About us | Advertising | Contact | Get Home Delivery | Archive
Mar 20, 2010 Homepage
News
Business
Interviews
Columnists
Op-Ed
Arts & Culture
Expat Zone
Features
Travel
Leisure
Life
Cartoons
Women
Health Briefs
Weird But True
Sports
Turkish Press Review
Today's think tanks
Turkey in Foreign Press

Columnists
BÜLENT KENEŞ b.kenes@todayszaman.com Columnists

Did you know Atatürk is dead?


Turkey is one of the few countries where a cult of personality is still prevalent. On Nov. 10, it marked the 71st anniversary of the demise of its founder, Mustafa Kemal Atatürk, with countrywide mourning programs. In particular, sirens blared at 9:05 a.m. -- the time Atatürk died. This was reminiscent of enemy attacks and signaled that life in the country had stopped.

Today's interactive toolbox
Bookmark and Share
Video Photo Audio
Send to print Send to my friend
Post your comments
Read comments
Whether they liked it or not, everyone had to conform to this ritual of paying homage to Atatürk, which has nowadays become utterly dogmatic. The current archaic mentality that has created taboos out of Atatürk’s ideas, and his physical existence as well as his death is still able to conduct these Atatürk commemoration programs with the air of a totalitarian worship ritual despite democratic progress the country has made. I don’t know to what extent we are aware of it, but our country -- already rife with Atatürk statues which can hardly be regarded as having much aesthetic value -- is reduced to being one of the few despotic countries dominated by a leader fetishism such as North Korea, China and Cuba with these unusual ceremonies. No doubt there is a lot to be said on this subject, but in this article I would like to point you to a video that bothers me very much as the father of a 2.5-year-old girl.

I’d like you to sit down at your computer and go directly to YouTube. Search for “Atatürk öldü biliyor musun?” (Did you know Atatürk is dead?) in Turkish. Please attentively watch the heartrending video that lasts one minute and 36 seconds and which froze my blood. If you ask, “Why is this girl crying so grievously?” read on for the answer. As a service to our readers who do not speak Turkish, I would like to show you how the love for Atatürk -- which amounts to a cult of personality -- can be made into a great danger at the hands of Kemalist teachers who are ignorant of pedagogy and child psychology. I present the translation of this striking and alarming dialogue between a small girl at the age of 3 or 4 with her parents as she cried nonstop.

Little girl: Atatürk is dead? Did you know Atatürk is dead?

Mother: Who said that?

Little girl: My teacher.

Mother: Are you very upset, honey?

Little girl: Yes! He is dead.

Mother: Even so, honey, he left this country for us. Should we not thank him for this?

Little girl: But he is dead.

Mother: What difference does it make, honey?

Little girl: Atatürk died.

Mother: Who said that?

Little girl: My teacher.

Mother: What else did your teacher say?

Little girl: He did not say anything else. I cried, and I was very sad. Very sad... So sad... We cannot bring him back, yet...

Mother: We can still love him.

Little girl: No, he died! We cannot love him.

Father: How did you cry, honey?

Little girl: I was so sad. And I cried a lot. My friends cried, too.

I think this video of a poor little girl crying incessantly while talking to her parents -- posted on YouTube exactly one year ago, but which I only noticed on Nov. 10 of this year -- needs no comment.

I would really like to know whether the Turkish education system, which burdens little children with emotions so as to create psychological traumas in their small worlds, or her teacher, who caused this little student to enter into emotional shock, have any knowledge about pedagogy and child psychology.

I also wonder how our minister of education, a mother herself, and ministry officials reacted to this terrifying video. Were they only touched by this poor little girl’s reaction, as her parents were? Or did they launch an investigation into the teacher and the school where he worked for distorting the psychology of small children for the sake of the cult of personality?

Is this really what teachers understand when it comes to the love for Atatürk and the education of children? I am really curious about the answers to this.

13 November 2009, Friday
BÜLENT KENEŞ
Comments on this article

Zarathustra , Jan 02 2010 19:52, Saturday
“Dear Mr. Bülent, I followed your advice to open You Tube but recieved following message: The decision no 2008/402 ...
Tuba , Nov 14 2009 01:23, Saturday
@Schubert If you put Hitler and Ataturk in the same category,sorry but you know nothing about history. If that girl had...
Yaygır Özgür , Nov 13 2009 16:19, Friday
Mr. Keneş, ı admit that turkish education system is not the best but ı'd like to know if your disappointment is about th...

Click to read the details of comments
   
Articles of Today
The ‘genocide’ problem: states, parliaments and people
BERİL DEDEOĞLU
Greek Cypriots blocking Turkey’s judicial reform
ABDULHAMİT BİLİCİ
Opportunity for judicial reform
MÜMTAZER TÜRKÖNE
Who is who?
CHARLOTTE MCPHERSON
Either the state or a raven’s carcass
MEHMET KAMIŞ
Let it play out for everyone’s sake
ABDULLAH BOZKURT
‘Model partner’ or ‘genocide offender’?
GÜRKAN ZENGİN
Can (Turkish) soccer hooliganism be stopped?
KLAUS JURGENS
A small package but a big step for democracy
FATMA DİŞLİ ZIBAK

Other Articles of the Columnist

  Did you know Atatürk is dead?
  That’s what we need transparency for
  What would Özal do?
  We all need an army we can trust
  Between the walls
  Turkey enters northern Iraq
  To-do list for the military conspiracy
  Pinocchios in uniform
  A color-blind Tanzanian
  Turkey faces the tragedies of its past
  Farewell to arms
  Is Turkey really overestimating its role?
  Price paid freedom of the press
  Iraq is even closer now
  Where is the world going with climate change?
  Why shouldn’t Samsun do what Samsoe has achieved?
  To what extent are we ready for another revolution?
  Fascism on the minaret
  Lessons on politics from Turkey to Karamanlis
  We are one less without you and the children of others
Columnists
ABDULHAMİT BİLİCİ
ABDULLAH BOZKURT
ALİ BULAÇ
ALİ H. ASLAN
AMANDA PAUL
ANDREW FINKEL
ASIM ERDİLEK
AYŞE KARABAT
BEJAN MATUR
BERİL DEDEOĞLU
BERK ÇEKTİR
BÜLENT KENEŞ
BÜLENT KORUCU
CHARLOTTE MCPHERSON
DOĞU ERGİL
EKREM DUMANLI
EMRE USLU
ETYEN MAHÇUPYAN
FATMA DİŞLİ ZIBAK
FİKRET ERTAN
GÜRKAN ZENGİN
HASAN KANBOLAT
HÜSEYİN GÜLERCE
İBRAHİM KALIN
İBRAHİM ÖZTÜRK
İHSAN DAĞI
İHSAN YILMAZ
KATHY HAMILTON
KERİM BALCI
KLAUS JURGENS
LALE KEMAL
MEHMET KAMIŞ
MICHAEL KUSER
MUHAMMED ÇETİN
MÜMTAZER TÜRKÖNE
NICOLE POPE
ÖMER TAŞPINAR
ORHAN KEMAL CENGİZ
PAT YALE
ŞAHİN ALPAY
SELÇUK GÜLTAŞLI
SUAT KINIKLIOĞLU
YAVUZ BAYDAR