About us | Advertising | Contact | Get Home Delivery | Archive
Mar 20, 2010 Homepage
News
Business
Interviews
Columnists
Op-Ed
Arts & Culture
Expat Zone
Features
Travel
Leisure
Life
Cartoons
Women
Health Briefs
Weird But True
Sports
Turkish Press Review
Today's think tanks
Turkey in Foreign Press

Columnists
ANDREW FINKEL a.finkel@todayszaman.com Columnists

Shrugging your soldiers


It is not just boy scouts who are expected to be prepared. A nation demands a high degree of readiness from its armed forces. Their job is to foresee the unforeseeable, to second guess the unpredictable and to have a contingency plan waiting in the drawer.

Today's interactive toolbox
Bookmark and Share
Video Photo Audio
Send to print Send to my friend
Post your comments
Read comments
Of course, what is mildly unusual in the Turkish case, and what has been occupying the front pages day after day, is that the military has extended its brief to anticipating threats from its own elected politicians. It has established, so it would appear, a dedicated agency whose lone purpose has been to devise ever more ingenious strategies to replace the democratically formed government with one of their own choice.

There is a great deal of smoke surrounding the details of this plot. There are any number of questions which demand answers -- who authorized the Action Plan to Fight Reactionaryism, how near did it come to being implemented, who authorized it and who can be relied upon (the civilian or military court) for investigating these issues. It is the duty of the press not to speculate but to press that investigation forward. However, with the exception of the Taraf newspaper (again, punching above its weight), this is not really being done. Indeed much of the press coverage has been speculation about Taraf itself -- how it got the story and whether it timed the publication of the story to distract from other issues. However entertaining this may be, it is something of a distraction from the main event which is that parts of the Turkish military still see the world through the optic of a cheap airport thriller and feel that somehow, in this day and age, it can pull the rug out from beneath the civilian government.

If this seems bizarre, it is stranger still that this attitude is not unique. Consider the following quotation which invites the reader to “imagine a bloodless coup to restore and defend the Constitution through an interim administration that would do the serious business of governing and defending the nation.” The author goes on to confess that while it would not be practicable to lead the president and Cabinet away in leg-irons, they could be reduced to figure heads while the real decision making could go on behind the scenes. It is not from yet another document leaked to Taraf but a column in the American hard right news portal, Newsmax. “Skilled, military-trained nation-builders would replace accountability-challenged, radical-left commissars,” writes John L. Perry, conjuring up his own political nirvana where US President Barack Obama’s powers would be limited to the odd ceremonial speech. “Unthinkable?” he has the graciousness to ask, before inviting his readers to engage in a bit of lateral thinking to what he calls “the Obama problem.” Urgency is of the essence. “Just don’t shrug and say, ‘We can always worry about that later’,” he warns.

This incitement to treason attracted a fair amount of adverse comment from the “accountability-challenged” members of the US Fourth Estate who still cling to the quaint notion of a democratic process and the rule of law. Sensing it had gone too far, Newsmax removed the article from its Web site (although its electronic shadow lingers on http://mediamatters.org/blog/200909290042 ). Wishing for a military take-over is one thing. Threatening a coup is something else altogether. The Newsmax hissy-fit contrasts with the far more earnest e-memorandum issued by Turkey’s General Staff in April 2007, which advised Turkey’s politicians against not so much shrugging their shoulders as shrugging their soldiers by electing as president the current incumbent whose patriotism, they implied, was in doubt.

What seems shocking in the American context -- that the American right can have such visceral hatred toward an elected president that they would countenance anything a hair’s breadth short of a military coup to see him removed -- once seemed business as usual in Turkey. Now what comes as shocking is not that the military tried to undermine the civilian government, but that anyone finds it unusual. It was only two years ago that the military posted its warning. Now it is the military itself that is being warned.

01 November 2009, Sunday
ANDREW FINKEL
   
Articles of Today
The ‘genocide’ problem: states, parliaments and people
BERİL DEDEOĞLU
Greek Cypriots blocking Turkey’s judicial reform
ABDULHAMİT BİLİCİ
Opportunity for judicial reform
MÜMTAZER TÜRKÖNE
Who is who?
CHARLOTTE MCPHERSON
Either the state or a raven’s carcass
MEHMET KAMIŞ
Let it play out for everyone’s sake
ABDULLAH BOZKURT
‘Model partner’ or ‘genocide offender’?
GÜRKAN ZENGİN
Can (Turkish) soccer hooliganism be stopped?
KLAUS JURGENS
A small package but a big step for democracy
FATMA DİŞLİ ZIBAK

Other Articles of the Columnist

  Shrugging your soldiers
  A nation grows up
  Nuclear gossip
  Question time
  The journey home
  Envelope, please
  Cinema, before our eyes
  New friends
  A time to keep silent and a time to speak
  The not-so-good old days
  Changing the IMF’s spots
  If the shoe fits, throw it
  The IMF, the crisis and what is to be done
  Did Germany vote for Turkey?
  The nation’s heirloom
  The great conspiracy
  Yüksel Arslan
  Some of the news fit to print
  Bodynapping and the Kurdish problem
  The hard rains are already beginning to fall
Columnists
ABDULHAMİT BİLİCİ
ABDULLAH BOZKURT
ALİ BULAÇ
ALİ H. ASLAN
AMANDA PAUL
ANDREW FINKEL
ASIM ERDİLEK
AYŞE KARABAT
BEJAN MATUR
BERİL DEDEOĞLU
BERK ÇEKTİR
BÜLENT KENEŞ
BÜLENT KORUCU
CHARLOTTE MCPHERSON
DOĞU ERGİL
EKREM DUMANLI
EMRE USLU
ETYEN MAHÇUPYAN
FATMA DİŞLİ ZIBAK
FİKRET ERTAN
GÜRKAN ZENGİN
HASAN KANBOLAT
HÜSEYİN GÜLERCE
İBRAHİM KALIN
İBRAHİM ÖZTÜRK
İHSAN DAĞI
İHSAN YILMAZ
KATHY HAMILTON
KERİM BALCI
KLAUS JURGENS
LALE KEMAL
MEHMET KAMIŞ
MICHAEL KUSER
MUHAMMED ÇETİN
MÜMTAZER TÜRKÖNE
NICOLE POPE
ÖMER TAŞPINAR
ORHAN KEMAL CENGİZ
PAT YALE
ŞAHİN ALPAY
SELÇUK GÜLTAŞLI
SUAT KINIKLIOĞLU
YAVUZ BAYDAR