About us | Advertising | Contact | Get Home Delivery | Archive
Mar 22, 2010 Homepage
News
Business
Interviews
Columnists
Op-Ed
Arts & Culture
Expat Zone
Features
Travel
Leisure
Life
Cartoons
Women
Health Briefs
Weird But True
Sports
Turkish Press Review
Today's think tanks
Turkey in Foreign Press

Columnists
İHSAN DAĞI i.dagi@todayszaman.com Columnists

The Kemalist model to resolve the Kurdish question


The suggestion has come from a veteran Kemalist, Professor Mümtaz Soysal, who is a columnist for the daily Cumhuriyet. In a commentary appearing in Cumhuriyet, Soysal argues that the “absolute solution” is to “exchange the Kurds of Turkey with the Turkmens of northern Iraq.”

Today's interactive toolbox
Bookmark and Share
Video Photo Audio
Send to print Send to my friend
Post your comments
Read comments
The sources of inspiration for this idea are obvious: the forced migration of the Armenians in 1915, which resulted in massacres, and the compulsory population exchange in 1923-1924 between the Turks and the Greeks, which left hundreds of thousands in pain, bitterness and poverty, all in the name of creating an ethnically homogenous nation-state. There were the kind of follow-up policies carried out in the 1930s, 1940s, 1950s and even 1960s that forced those ethnic and religious group to move out of Turkey.

The Kemalists now wish to expand their project of “ethnic cleansing” to include the Kurds of this country. Yet their problem is that this time -- thank God -- they do not have the power to dictate such an “absolute solution.” To be sure, the Kemalist model to solve the Kurdish question will remain “wishful thinking.” Yet it reveals the mindset that continues to prevail among the “contemporary” Kemalists.

Recognizing that they have lost the battle against the Kurds, whose ethnicity and identity were systematically denied by the state, the Kemalists now want to get rid of the Kurds. The presence of Kurds with a distinct ethnicity and identity goes against the Kemalist imagination of a homogenized nation ruled by the vanguard Kemalist elite at the top. The Kemalists also realize that a democratic solution to the Kurdish question will pave the way for a plural, democratic and decentralized polity that will put an end to the old authoritarian and controlled state system.

Thus instead of seeing Turkey transformed into a democratic and plural polity by recognizing Kurdish rights, they wish to get rid of the Kurds altogether -- exactly as they did in the past to the Armenians, the Greeks and the Jews.

Anyhow, we owe thanks to Professor Soysal, who revealed once more the fascist mindset of the Kemalists. One should not see him as a lunatic; he is a respectable representative of Kemalist thought and the Kemalist state tradition. His credentials are strong: an academic specializing in constitutional law, a longtime chief adviser to former Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus (KKTC) President Rauf Denktaş, a former minister of foreign affairs, a strong advocate of military intervention in politics and a columnist for the Cumhuriyet daily.

What is really funny is that once, in the 1970s, he even sat on the international board of Amnesty International. Can you imagine such a “human rights activist” that once worked for AI today suggesting “forced migration” of the Kurds out of Turkey?

Well, his current position illustrates the poverty of the Kemalists. Moreover, it proves how the country and its ordinary people progress faster and further than the Kemalists. Some 20 years ago, Turkey was among the top countries that AI had to deal with due to its poor human rights record. Turkish governments and the AI butted heads over human rights issues. The AI Turkey desk expert was even denied access to Turkey during those years.

Last week, the same AI held its world congress in Turkey, an event that amounted to a remarkable recognition of how Turkey has progressed in its human rights performance. But look at this poor Kemalist who used to be part of AI. How backward his ideas are. In this we see the poverty of Kemalists and their media outlets, which are full of hatred for anything and anybody that appears “different” to them.

The title of his article reads “The Absolute Solution.” Does that remind you of anything? Something that happened during World War II? Something carried out by the Nazis?

Look at the poverty of mind and imagination. Professor Soysal cannot think of anything but a racist and fascist method of ethnic cleansing. What he can think of is to forcibly expel Turkey's own citizens. Who are you? A reincarnation of Saddam Hussein or Radovan Karadzic?

24 August 2009, Monday
İHSAN DAĞI
Comments on this article

dimitris kipouros , Aug 24 2009 16:56, Monday
I have a sample of this kemalist idea of exchanges ; the muslim population of my mother's village in Western Macedonia w...
Metin , Aug 24 2009 16:26, Monday
I doubt Mr. Soysal is a genuine Turk.
Bulent Tekin , Aug 24 2009 15:08, Monday
Reading your article I concluded that you are not worthy of being a citizen of Turkiye. Maybe you should stop and think ...

Click to read the details of comments
   
Articles of Today
The ‘Armenian problem,’ intellectuals and politicians in Turkey
ŞAHİN ALPAY
Process (mis) management
YAVUZ BAYDAR
It’s good to know you’re in good hands
CHARLOTTE MCPHERSON
Can the AK Party change the Constitution?
İHSAN DAĞI
How to go for growth in Turkey
ASIM ERDİLEK
From zero problems to zero progress
ÖMER TAŞPINAR
Fraudulent activity regarding deeds -- Bodrum and other cities (1)
BERK ÇEKTİR
Reasons behind Erdoğan’s controversial statement
FATMA DİŞLİ ZIBAK

Other Articles of the Columnist

  The Kemalist model to resolve the Kurdish question
  The Kurdish initiative and Turkish opposition
  University degrees in overthrowing governments undemocratically
  Turkish state discussing the Kurdish solution
  Who should lead the ‘Kurdish solution’?
  The ‘holy alliance’ of the status quo
  Opposition party appeals to military, not people
  Is TÜSİAD still committed to democracy?
  Is the West supporting coup supporters?
  Can the islamic republic survive?
  The Turkish military: asset or liability?
  The poverty of the ‘white Turks’
  Islamization of population by the Kemalists
  Why is it the right time to solve the Kurdish question?
  The militarist right as an alternative to the AK Party
  Who is Demirel? Where is the center right?
  Appeasing the military by abandoning the EU
  Davutoğlu: Turkey’s new foreign policy chief
  What is Başbuğ trying to do?
  The Armenian question, Turkey and the US
Columnists
ABDULHAMİT BİLİCİ
ABDULLAH BOZKURT
ALİ BULAÇ
ALİ H. ASLAN
AMANDA PAUL
ANDREW FINKEL
ASIM ERDİLEK
AYŞE KARABAT
BEJAN MATUR
BERİL DEDEOĞLU
BERK ÇEKTİR
BÜLENT KENEŞ
BÜLENT KORUCU
CHARLOTTE MCPHERSON
DOĞU ERGİL
EKREM DUMANLI
EMRE USLU
ETYEN MAHÇUPYAN
FATMA DİŞLİ ZIBAK
FİKRET ERTAN
GÜRKAN ZENGİN
HASAN KANBOLAT
HÜSEYİN GÜLERCE
İBRAHİM KALIN
İBRAHİM ÖZTÜRK
İHSAN DAĞI
İHSAN YILMAZ
KATHY HAMILTON
KERİM BALCI
KLAUS JURGENS
LALE KEMAL
MEHMET KAMIŞ
MICHAEL KUSER
MUHAMMED ÇETİN
MÜMTAZER TÜRKÖNE
NICOLE POPE
ÖMER TAŞPINAR
ORHAN KEMAL CENGİZ
PAT YALE
ŞAHİN ALPAY
SELÇUK GÜLTAŞLI
SUAT KINIKLIOĞLU
YAVUZ BAYDAR