About us | Advertising | Contact | Get Home Delivery | Archive
Mar 22, 2010 Homepage
News
Business
Interviews
Columnists
Op-Ed
Arts & Culture
Expat Zone
Features
Travel
Leisure
Life
Cartoons
Women
Health Briefs
Weird But True
Sports
Turkish Press Review
Today's think tanks
Turkey in Foreign Press

Columnists
ANDREW FINKEL a.finkel@todayszaman.com Columnists

Mahinur, Neda and the politics of appeasement


Sections of the Turkish press were right to applaud the mature way in which Mahinur Özdemir, a third-generation Belgian of Turkish descent, was welcomed by her new peers as she swore a constitutional oath of allegiance before the Brussels Regional Parliament.

Today's interactive toolbox
Bookmark and Share
Video Photo Audio
Send to print Send to my friend
Post your comments
Read comments

Ms. Özdemir is the “benjamine”-- the youngest member of the local assembly -- and many of her compatriots have easily decided that her bright smile and simple eloquence, plus a commitment to fighting for the rights of her fellow residents in the ethnically mixed neighborhood of Schaerbeek, matter so much more than the headscarf she wears out of religious conviction. Her election from the Centre démocrate humaniste (the former Christian Democrats) is representative of the changing face of European politics and one more step in the battle against prejudice and for the acceptance of cultural diversity. Ms. Özdemir is not the first ethnic Turk in the Brussels Regional Parliament. She joins the talented Emir Kır, 31, a minister from the Socialist Party (PS) who is the son of a coalminer who immigrated to Belgium in the 1960s. Not everyone, of course, is greeting her selection with enthusiasm, and it seems probable she will remain a mildly controversial figure both in Belgian politics, but also in Turkey where politicians of both sexes are expected to show their pates.

At the very least, her life lies ahead of her.

It might seem over-ingenious to compare the treatment afforded Ms. Özdemir to the fate of Neda Agha Soltan, even though the two women were both 26 years old. Ms. Soltan, as the world now knows, was gunned down on the fringes of the demonstrations against what the political opposition in Iran says were shamelessly rigged presidential elections. She was, by all accounts, more interested in becoming a tour guide than a politician, and her excursions took her earlier this year to Turkey, where she met her fiancé. A smiling photograph of Ms. Soltan (without the headscarf she was obliged by law to wear in public) has become a potent symbol of the moral failure of the society in which she was raised. Her death has touched everyone, according to Martin Fletcher, writing in The Times, “everyone except the rulers of her own country, who did their level best to suppress it.” Her family was even made to remove the black ribbons of mourning from the outside of their house.

It is somewhat shameful that those newspapers in Turkey so eager to praise Ms. Özdemir's success have been equally conscientious in trying to avoid any graveside eulogies for Ms. Solton. It was embarrassing to read a report in our sister paper Zaman dismissing her death as a sort of cheap martyrdom because it claimed she was shot not as a demonstrator, but merely as an innocent bystander. “The legend quickly crumbles,” the Turkish headline ran.

I have already complained in this column that Turkey skates on thin ice when it expects other countries to register concern for its own struggle to preserve democracy and yet shows little interest in empathizing with the struggle for democracy in its region. There was a fairly striking example of this in a recent interview that the Turkish foreign minister, Ahmet Davutoğlu, gave to Der Spiegel magazine. Barack Obama, like many European nations, has admitted the counterproductive folly of trying to interfere in a country where his nation's past conduct is deeply resented. His policy has been to talk to Tehran about its nuclear enrichment program, not threaten. Professor Davutoğlu is clearly determined not to isolate Tehran -- and this is sensible, but he appears to have adopted a limbo dancer's posture of bending backwards. Mr. Obama is resisting a political constituency that wants him to take a harder line. Professor Davutoğlu and his government appear to be riding a tide that equates the “green protest” in Iran to the anti-Justice and Development Party (AK Party) “Republican Rallies” in Turkish cities. There emerged “very different interpretations of results after the election,” the foreign minister told his interviewers. “I think that we should take this as a sign that the political process in Iran is very healthy,” he said.

I am not entirely sure that Ms. Solton's family shares this same high opinion. It is one thing not to interfere. It is another to pretend to like what you see.

25 June 2009, Thursday
ANDREW FINKEL
Comments on this article

suleyman polatcan , Jun 26 2009 00:40, Friday
that we are progressing as mentally tell always ourselves but we open and close the same door and we are afraid of diff...
memet , Jun 25 2009 13:23, Thursday
as you know Turkey had tried to help Saddam...

Click to read the details of comments
   
Articles of Today
The ‘Armenian problem,’ intellectuals and politicians in Turkey
ŞAHİN ALPAY
Process (mis) management
YAVUZ BAYDAR
It’s good to know you’re in good hands
CHARLOTTE MCPHERSON
Can the AK Party change the Constitution?
İHSAN DAĞI
How to go for growth in Turkey
ASIM ERDİLEK
From zero problems to zero progress
ÖMER TAŞPINAR
Fraudulent activity regarding deeds -- Bodrum and other cities (1)
BERK ÇEKTİR
Reasons behind Erdoğan’s controversial statement
FATMA DİŞLİ ZIBAK

Other Articles of the Columnist

  Mahinur, Neda and the politics of appeasement
  Turkey, the viper, the stone and Iran
  A question of balance
  Iran, Turkey and the defense of democracy
  Clean Tricks Department
  Taking tea with Mr. Türk
  Back to the future in Europe
  D-Day at the polls in Europe
  Coming home
  Turkey in Washington
  Broken-arm-in-sleeve syndrome
  ‘In jail with Nazım Hikmet’
  Where were you on Aug. 21, 1968?
  The role of cynicism in democracy
  Getting higher education to lift its game
  Pigheaded
  Joanne Greenwood
  Restoring urgency to the European agenda
  Lord of the swings
  Allah and Alem
Columnists
ABDULHAMİT BİLİCİ
ABDULLAH BOZKURT
ALİ BULAÇ
ALİ H. ASLAN
AMANDA PAUL
ANDREW FINKEL
ASIM ERDİLEK
AYŞE KARABAT
BEJAN MATUR
BERİL DEDEOĞLU
BERK ÇEKTİR
BÜLENT KENEŞ
BÜLENT KORUCU
CHARLOTTE MCPHERSON
DOĞU ERGİL
EKREM DUMANLI
EMRE USLU
ETYEN MAHÇUPYAN
FATMA DİŞLİ ZIBAK
FİKRET ERTAN
GÜRKAN ZENGİN
HASAN KANBOLAT
HÜSEYİN GÜLERCE
İBRAHİM KALIN
İBRAHİM ÖZTÜRK
İHSAN DAĞI
İHSAN YILMAZ
KATHY HAMILTON
KERİM BALCI
KLAUS JURGENS
LALE KEMAL
MEHMET KAMIŞ
MICHAEL KUSER
MUHAMMED ÇETİN
MÜMTAZER TÜRKÖNE
NICOLE POPE
ÖMER TAŞPINAR
ORHAN KEMAL CENGİZ
PAT YALE
ŞAHİN ALPAY
SELÇUK GÜLTAŞLI
SUAT KINIKLIOĞLU
YAVUZ BAYDAR