18 April 2014, Friday
Today's Zaman

Why the Kurdish issue is not similar to the issue of Albanians in Kosovo
by Erdoan A. Shipoli*

Read Comment
14 August 2012, Tuesday /
Firstly, let me make it clear from the beginning that it is not my aim to discuss here whether there is a Kurdish issue in Turkey, or whether the approach of the Turkish government/state towards the Kurds living in Turkey is right or wrong.

What pushed me to write this article is the vast literature of analysts arguing the similarities between the Albanians and the Kurds, or better to say the fight that the Albanians fought during the 1990s in Kosovo and the fight that the Kurds have been fighting in Turkey for more than 30 years. The solution of the Albanian question in Kosovo came after the intervention of the Western powers in 1999, and these analysts argue that there is a double standard as to why the Western powers do not intervene on behalf of the Kurds in Turkey. These analysts are of various categories, from heavyweights like Noam Chomsky to analysts of a lighter category, in my level. In fact what they miss is not something new, but is something that we see very often among the international relations analysts, those who analyze countries like Kosovo, Turkey, Bosnia and other countries in the Middle East and Africa from Washington, D.C., New York, London or Paris. For me it doesn’t seem right to analyze, or compare, a situation without being in the field, speaking to people, knowing the language and being directly engaged.

Let me again repeat that it is not my aim to be an advocate of Turkey, or any other state or group. My aim is to put forward the differences between the Kurds in Turkey and the Albanians in Kosovo. These differences, I think, make the issue of the Kurds and the issue of the Albanians fundamentally different.

I understand when people compare and find many similarities between Kosovo and Bosnia, as they are many similarities, starting from a popular support of the fighting from the people, and continuing with others. Nevertheless, arguing on the similarities between the issue of Albanians in Kosovo, or Yugoslavia, and the Kurds in Turkey is not so relevant, for the following reasons:

1. The formation of the PKK and the KLA

The Kosovo Liberation Army (KLA) was formed and was operating in a self-defense. It did not have an ideology other then freedom for its oppressed people. Formed in the mountains of the villages where its members were from, the KLA had no important heavy arms, rather rifles and arms from the villagers. Unlike the KLA, the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) was firstly established as a Marxist organization, then later came to espouse an ethnic ideology. The PKK organizes offensives against security forces’ stations and imports heavy arms from different countries.

2. The popular support for the PKK and the KLA

When I first came to Turkey in 2004, five years after the war had finished in Kosovo, I wanted to understand the Kurdish issue in Turkey. Firstly, coming out of a freedom war, I was sympathizing with the Kurds’ quests for their rights in Turkey as I want all the people to have their rights and freedoms. But when I started digging into the issue more I found out the differences. When the war started in Kosovo and the KLA was formed in the mountains, the whole Albanian population supported them. I must remind you that the Albanian population in Kosovo is majority Muslim but the war in Kosovo and the KLA had nothing to do with religious affiliations. The KLA saw the same support from the Albanian Muslims and Christians; in fact that was never a question discussed.

After I came to Turkey I understood that the Kurdish population living in Turkey does not support the PKK. In fact only a small number of people supports the PKK and finds its acts righteous. This is understood when speaking to people and friends in closed conversations, and publically. Even though they were prosecuted for doing so, no Albanians were hiding their public support for the KLA, including intellectuals, artists, civil servants and all others. Although some analysts might argue that the Kurdish people cannot publically support the PKK, in eight years I have met many Kurdish friends who are against the acts of the PKK, and you can see that many Kurds condemn the acts of the PKK and its existence, including Kurdish intellectuals, civil servants, artists and others.

3. The violation of the rights and liberties

Why the KLA was formed is because the 10-year pacifist struggle to resolve the Albanian issue in Kosovo did not show any particular result and the Serbian forces increased their violation of the Albanians’ human rights. The Albanians tried to resolve their issue by political means, peacefully, for more then 10 years, under the leadership of Ibrahim Rugova. The Albanians were kicked out of their jobs in 1993, and they were forced to leave Kosovo, as asylum seekers in Europe mostly, but also other places in the world. The Albanian intellectuals were prosecuted; the only Albanian university, the University of Pristina, was closed; and many Albanian high schools were also closed. With the formation of the political movement in 1989, and then the KLA, what the Albanians requested were their constitutional rights under the 1974 constitution of Yugoslavia. They were requesting the return of the rights they had up until 1989, revoked by Slobodan Milosevic’s regime.

Unlike the Albanians in Kosovo, the Kurds in Turkey did not have a political party, prior to the formation of the PKK, that could resolve the issue of the rights of the Kurdish minority in a peaceful manner. The political force of the Kurds, which I argue that does not represent all the Kurds, was formed after the initial formation of the PKK. In fact the PKK was firstly established as a Marxist and socialist organization, and only afterwards did it leave its revolutionary ideology to be transformed into an ethnic organization. Although I don’t omit the wrong policies of Turkish governments at different times towards its population in southeastern Turkey in general and the Kurdish population in particular, the main difference between them and the Albanians in Kosovo is that the Kurds did not have any particular right revoked recently, as was the case in Kosovo. The Albanians in Kosovo’s capital, Pristina, were kicked out of their jobs just for being Albanian, whereas I don’t recall reading or hearing anywhere that a civil servant was kicked out of his job in Ankara or İstanbul just for being a Kurd. I think that there should be a Kurdish University in Turkey, where all the subjects and departments are taught in Kurdish, but nevertheless such a university did not exist prior to the advent of the PKK, or the Kurdish issue, only to be revoked by the Turkish authorities, as was the case with the University of Pristina. No constitution, like the 1974 Yugoslavian constitution, had given autonomic rights to the Kurds in Turkey that were abolished later. It is different to ask for your rights, although they might be legitimate, for the first time, versus asking for rights that existed prior to their abolishment.

In fact what the Albanian political movement, and then the KLA, wanted were the rights that were violated by the Serbs, including the right to life, as the Serbians were killing the Albanians in their homes. They wanted their jobs, their university, and other things that were taken away by the Milosevic regime. So, it was a self-defense movement. Only after did they start to ask for the autonomy in Yugoslavia, but with the continuous rejection by the Serbian government and the start of the war, when more then a million Kosovar Albanians were forced to leave Kosovo, massacres and genocide happened, ethnic cleansing took place and the NATO forces started the first-ever humanitarian mission, independence was inevitable and in fact that is what happened.

Another very important difference between the KLA and the PKK is that the KLA did not strike at any civilian during the war. The KLA did not attack the civilian population and rarely struck first against the Serbian forces. The KLA was mostly a defense organization answering the strikes of the Serbian forces against the Albanian population. The operations of the PKK, on the other hand, are mainly strikes against bases of the Turkish military. But the PKK also targets civilians, including terrorist strikes in İstanbul and elsewhere, including ones using suicide bombers, ones against civilians and planned assassinations. So, the PKK is more of an offensive organization. It is a well-known and common complaint of the people living in southeastern Turkey that the PKK runs a racket that hurts the people of the region, closes their shops and even takes their children to fight for it, and this, I think, decreases the support of the Kurds towards the PKK.

If we sum up the fundamental differences between the Albanian question in Kosovo and the Kurdish question in Turkey, we can name several key points. There are the distinct foundations of the PKK and the KLA, in which the PKK was founded as a Marxist-socialist organization and only afterwards transformed to an ethnic organization. The Kurdish party was also formed only after the guerilla organization was formed. The KLA, on the other hand, was the result of a 10-year peaceful political struggle, as a last resort of self-defense. Secondly, and for me this is the most important point, not all of the Kurds in Turkey support the PKK, the political party that supposedly represents the Kurds in Turkey. We can see this in the large number of the Kurdish citizens who voted for the Justice and Development Party (AKP) government. In Kosovo, on the other hand, all the Albanians, despite their political, religious or ideological differences, supported the formation and the actions of the KLA, publically. Thirdly, the Kosovar Albanians wanted back what was recently taken away from them. Although I support the arguments that Turkey should give more rights to its Kurdish citizens, like education in the mother tongue, the Kurds have never had these rights before, and they were not taken from them. Finally, the PKK targets civilians, and most of their operations are offensive operations, whereas the KLA did not strike any civilians, and most of their operations were of a defensive nature, defending the civilian population in the villages. This, I think, is the main element that makes the PKK a terrorist organization, and the KLA a freedom-fighting organization. During the war in Kosovo the KLA detonated no bomb in a city, and there was no operation towards any civilian group, Serbian or otherwise.

*Erdoan Shipoli is a research assistant at Fatih University in Istanbul, and the co-director of the İstanbul Leadership Institute. He can be followed on twitter @erdoan

Very shallow analysis. The author does not seem to understand the basics of history. Whatever happened to the universal human rights such as the right to self determination. The author seems to think that the Albanians and Turks deserve human dignity but the Kurds, well the Kurds are different?
I have to say that Kurdish people in Turkey (and elsewhere) have my full support to have a substantial cultural autonomy. Moreover, Turkey should go further and promote cultural and ethnic values of Kurds. however, Turkey cannot be compared to what Milosevic's regime conducted in Kosovo with ethnic ...
As a Kurd from Iran, I might agree with your illustration of the differences between KLA and PKK; however, I don't see any differences between Kosovan and Kurds in Turkey and else where in the region who merely want their right to self-determination, period! My humble take of your approach in this ...
KLA NOT Marxist or based on anything but wanting to help oppressed Albanians? THE WASHINGTON TIMES, May 5, 1999 Continuing Western doubts about the ideology and the fighting tactics of the Kosovar guerrilla uprising have relegated the (KLA) to a minor supporting role for NATO...Western officials sa...
Julia Gorin
Nice parallel, mashallah. It would be useful to add the geo-politic component of both conflicts into the picture, too. Furthermore, although I do agree that KLA and PPK are not similar, it would be interesting to look at the whole issue form the perspective of what could Kurds (not only PPK), both...
Erdoan, how can you be so woefully uninformed about the KLA's origins? The KLA "did not have an ideology other then freedom for its oppressed people"?? "UNLIKE the KLA, the PKK was firstly established as a Marxist organization"?? Did you miss the part where the KLA started out as a purely criminal o...
It is all pathetic. When Mr Davutoglu released a statement that: ''Turkey will recognize the autonomous Kurdistan region of Syria'' he should look at the turkish kurdistan too. Soon, Turkey will rip the fruits of its foreign catastrophic Policy.
Mehmet Albania
Dear Erdoğan ; Here , I DO NOT AGREE with what you mentioned above saying : or better to say the fight that the Albanians fought during the 1990s in Kosovo and the fight that the Kurds have been fighting in Turkey for more than 30 years. These PKK Have never been Freedom Fighters so You cncider them...
Unfortunately PKK doesn't terrorize with guns but also with words. The sooner we realize this the better. We shouldn't allow terrorism speech in the name of free speech because Americans want it. Would Americans support terrorism if blacks in US would want a separate state? I don't think so.
Yes, the Kurdish issue is not similar to the issue of Albanians in Kosovo. If Kurds in Turkey will have same rights which Kosovars have within Yugoslavia-Serbia, then PKK will be an ordinary political party and no reason will exist to continue fighting. If you have "besa", you have to recognise this...
dimitrios macedon
Just like the PKK, the KLA also targeted both soldiery and citizenry. The KLA also killed Albanians, let alone Serbs, who were pro-regime. Also, when there were the first elections, the KLA candidates did not win. How can the author cite universal popular support for the KLA? The biggest difference...
Great article, PKK is a terrorist organization. Comparing it to KLA is an insult for us Albanians.
Using the points made here, the PKK sounds a lot like Hamas, using heavy weapons (rockets
Your support for the KLA obvoiusly stems from the fact that they are Muslim Albanians. Kosovo is rightfully Serbian. Albanians have no right to Kosovo as they are immigrants in that land. You sir, are a hypocrite and a liar. Biji Kurdistan!
This article can only be publishing in Turkish media otherwise will be a joke anywhere else; The Kurdish people do not support PKK? How? Do you remember what happen to Hrant dink when he spook do you really believe any Kurdish person can publically support PKK? How about the mujahidin that Turkey co...
Click here to read all user comments
OP-ED  Other Titles
An advocacy of dunces
by David Ropeik*
Global warming's upside-down narrative
by Bjorn Lomborg*
Thank God we do not live in the land of a dictator
by Tamer Çetin*
The end of the two-state solution
by Mohammed Ayoob*
In an unequal world, we need inclusive growth
Taming the China Bears
by Yu Yongding*
The High-Tech, High-Touch Economy
by Adair Turner*
Why did France decide not to touch French religious schools abroad?
by Emre Demir*
Europe's deepening muddle
by Ashoka Mody*
Taming the China Bears
by Yu Yongding*
Turkey's great losses
by Birol Başkan*
Chernobyl factor in the Ukraine Crisis
by Bennett Ramberg*
AK Party-Hizmet clash a blessing for world Muslims
by Doğa Sacit*
The West's financial arsenal
by Harold James*
Five reasons why Crimea cannot be compared with Kosovo
by Hajrudin Somun*
Transitioning from a global actor Turkey to a ‘national' Turkey
by Murat Aksoy*
Losing Interest
by Barry Eichengreen*
Europe after Ukraine
by Zaki Laidi*
How was Obama's red line crossed?
byAydoğan Vatandaş*
Syria and Turkey: Casus belli, civil war and politics
by Robert Olson*