16 April 2014, Wednesday
Today's Zaman

Facing Muslim stereotypes in New York City
by Richard Peres*

27 May 2012, Sunday /RICHARD PERES*
What I love most about New York City is its intense diversity, and its being a place where hundreds of languages are spoken and every nationality and faith is represented. So it was no surprise that the taxi driver that recently took us from Manhattan to JFK airport was from Benin, a poor yet democratic West African country.

The driver was initially silent and reserved, until he found out that we were from Turkey, at which point he suddenly got friendlier and blurted out, “I am also Muslim, and 99 percent of the taxi drivers in New York City are also Muslim.” Could that be true? A few days earlier, another taxi driver had told us, as he brought us to our hotel and other patrons tried to enter the cab, “Tell them that I cannot take them, I am going to pray.” Was this a coincidence? I thought for a moment that I had not left İstanbul.

My curiosity peeked, I found out that more than 90 percent of New York's 44,000 taxi drivers are immigrants mostly from South Asia, particularly Bangladesh, Pakistan and India, followed by Haiti, Egypt and the former Soviet Union. Indeed, it seems quite likely that a majority of NYC's cab drivers are Muslim, though not 99 percent.

NYPD surveillance of Muslims

In fact, last November it was revealed that the New York City Police Department (NYPD) with the help of an ex-CIA officer was carrying out a systematic surveillance program on Muslims in the New York City area and, in particular, targeted taxi drivers, including every Pakistani and Moroccan taxi driver registered with the NYC Taxi and Limousine Commission. The NYPD was even spying on Muslims outside of New York City, in the states of New York, New Jersey, Connecticut and Pennsylvania.

Last January it was further revealed that the NYPD was showing an anti-Muslim documentary called “The Third Jihad” to 1,500 officers during police training in 2010. One police officer, who was repeatedly shown the film in training, said: “It was so ridiculously one-sided. It just made Muslims look like the enemy. It was straight propaganda." According to NY television station WPIX, “The movie, produced by the non-profit Clarion Group, suggests even moderate Muslim groups can't be trusted -- as it presents violent imagery and fiery rhetoric from radical Islamists who want to annihilate the Western way of life.” NYPD Police Commissioner Raymond Kelly has since apologized for the film being shown, while the surveillance program was denounced by several members of congress and civil liberties groups, including the New York Taxi Workers Alliance, led by a charismatic Indian-American leader, Bhairavi Desai.

The loss of thinking

So how is it exactly that people can make such erroneous conclusions about others and be so prejudiced? After all, more than 2000 years ago, Socrates, Plato and his student Aristotle helped us learn to think rationally and objectively. One method was the syllogism, which consists of two declarative statements and a conclusion. Syllogisms help people think logically and avoid making errors in judgment when premises are untrue or links have not been established between them. For example: (1) all cats are black; (2) you have a cat, therefore, (3) your cat is black. As noted by author John Hirst, the argument is valid but the conclusion is not correct because the first premise is not true.

While in New York I had dinner with some old friends and the notion that people can no longer think once again surfaced. One of them volunteered that he thought that “Islam causes extremism” and wanted our views on the matter. A colleague of mine, a political scientist, answered unequivocally: “No. Politics causes extremism, not Islam.” My friend seemed unconvinced. I looked at him, a lawyer no less, in dismay and wondered what it would take to change his mind. Perhaps he needed to talk to some taxi drivers -- or at least one -- in the city that he and I both loved. It's unlikely that he would ever live in a Muslim country and discover just how absurd his fears were.

No nation is immune to making such sweeping, incorrect generalizations. In America, one of the most notorious examples was the shipping of Japanese-Americans to concentration camps after the attack on Pearl Harbor on Dec. 7, 1942. Many of the families of these unfortunate people had sons serving in the US military and dying for the same government that locked them up. They were unfairly dealt crushing blows to their lives, and most lost all their property. President Franklin D. Roosevelt ended the camps when it became necessary to secure votes for his re-election in 1944. Fifty years later the official apologies came.

Ground Zero

Before leaving New York ,we visited the 9/11 memorial at the site of the World Trade Center buildings, which was built on the two footprints of the destroyed towers. It is an overwhelmingly sad place, where gray waterfalls flow into what seems like an infinite pit in the center of each memorial, the names of the victims engraved on its borders. Those names are, like the citizens of New York, incomparably diverse in nationality and ethnicity -- it's obvious as soon as you start reading them. And, yes, dozens of Muslims were also its victims.

I remember indelibly the agony of that time because I lived in nearby New Jersey and saw the burning ruins for days, then visited the site a few weeks later. Hundreds of posters of missing people hung on the fence of nearby St. Paul's church, seeking answers that were never found, for the bodies were turned to dust.

It is a monumental loss of logic that also made Islam and Muslims the victims on that fateful day almost 11 years ago.

*Richard Peres is a writer and journalist living in İstanbul.

In needs of better SYLLOGISIMS , yes there are some pre caussionery measures taken by terorrised police department, but it is only spotty .Mayor office is packed by Nuslems , and further more mostly young Persian Shiah. Elsewhere in Government Dept. some are deputy commisioner ,some are di...
Concern about Islam has risen in the US because after 9/11, dozens of planned attacks have been uncovered, moslem preachers have become more visible and vocal in their hae speech, thousands of illegal immiagrants have flooded he US as axi drivers and gas sation attendants, etc.There was a time Isla...
If I were to believe that Islam leads to extremism so Muslims must be monitored closely and mosques harbor extremists; I should also think that Christianity leads to extremism so they need to be monitored closely because they are all racists, churches harbor extremists, and hate immigrants (just lik...
This is a great article. The last sentence is so true. It is sad that we live in a society going backwards on racism. We need to move forward and learn to love each other. Asalaamu Alaycum
Scott Nassery
Click here to read all user comments
OP-ED  Other Titles
Taming the China Bears
Why did France decide not to touch French religious schools abroad?
by Emre Demir*
Europe's deepening muddle
by Ashoka Mody*
Taming the China Bears
by Yu Yongding*
Turkey's great losses
by Birol Başkan*
Chernobyl factor in the Ukraine Crisis
by Bennett Ramberg*
AK Party-Hizmet clash a blessing for world Muslims
by Doğa Sacit*
The West's financial arsenal
by Harold James*
Five reasons why Crimea cannot be compared with Kosovo
by Hajrudin Somun*
Transitioning from a global actor Turkey to a ‘national' Turkey
by Murat Aksoy*
Losing Interest
by Barry Eichengreen*
Europe after Ukraine
by Zaki Laidi*
How was Obama's red line crossed?
byAydoğan Vatandaş*
Syria and Turkey: Casus belli, civil war and politics
by Robert Olson*
The Grand Global Health Convergence
byGavin Yamey and Helen Saxenian*
Gurus and governors
byShashi Tharoor*
Putin's calculus
byJoseph S. Nye*
Muhammad Qutb: One of the two qutbs
by Ali Bulaç*
Europe's bogus banking union
byPhilippe Legrain*
Cold War Comforts
byIan Buruma*