17 April 2014, Thursday
Today's Zaman

Kerim Balcı’s book recounts Jerusalem as Turks’ lost heritage

Read Comment
27 May 2012, Sunday /LAMIYA ADILGIZI
Kerim Balcı, editor-in-chief of the Turkish Review, and Aykut İnce, a prominent photographer, have come together to lend their names to a newly published album of historical photographs of Jerusalem aiming to showcase forgotten parts of the city and prevent further erosion of its history.

Describing the book as a story drawn from real life, Balcı told Sunday’s Zaman that the project started five years ago when he and İnce arrived in Jerusalem with a team to make a documentary about Jerusalem, one of the oldest cities in the world, holy to all three Abrahamic religions. Gaining access to sacred sites, some closed to the public for the past 30 years by Israel -- such as the minarets of the al-Aqsa Mosque -- and photographing them brought lost stories to life, stories essential to the value of the heritage sites.

Hoping to restore neglected parts of Jerusalem’s history, particularly from the time of Turkish rule, Balcı believes the book will serve to bring the two nations together, as it was in years gone by, in the time of the Ottoman Empire and before.

What were you aiming for with this book about Jerusalem? Why did you pick Jerusalem instead of another city? How will the book resonate with the Turkish society and Turkish speaking communities?

Firstly, I did not specifically set out to create this book, it just came to life. I spent more than seven years in Jerusalem and during that time I was a guide for Turkish tourists in Jerusalem. Of course, being a guide required me to know a lot about Jerusalem and I subsequently became interested in its history and culture. So I decided to research Jerusalem’s history. The one thing that seemed to be left out of the history books was the fact that over the course of its 4,000-year history, Jerusalem had been ruled by Turks for nearly 1,000 years since A.D. 832 -- with the exception of 150 years during the Crusades -- until 100 years ago, when the British and then the Israelis administered the city. So before coming to Anatolia, the Seljuks first established their Turkish state in Jerusalem. However, this was not widely depicted in either Turkish history books or tourist guides, so I decided to research this gap of knowledge. I was interested in the contributions of the Turks -- the Seljuks, the Abbasids, the Ottomans, etc. -- to Jerusalem. While researching I encountered a huge treasure trove of information. I discovered that almost all of the major buildings in Jerusalem today were built during the period of Turkish rule, except for maybe Masjid Qubbat As-Sakhrah, which was constructed by the order of the Umayyads.

This book is a product of all my research, although my research is still uncompleted. I believe that it is necessary to depict the real history of Jerusalem firstly to the Turkish nation, and later to the whole world. We have gotten to know Jerusalem and Palestine as territories under occupation for years, not knowing that Jerusalem was a heritage of our fathers. We should know that we were once living there and our grandfathers died there fighting for Jerusalem. This gap in recognition resulted in a decline of support for Jerusalem and replacing it with rhetorical passion against the city.

In fact, Jerusalem is a city that has left a mark on our history. The main question is whether we view this part of our historical heritage just as it is, or through a radical, anti-establishment discourse. Unfortunately we have done the latter, and our current issues with Jerusalem are a result of opposition against the secular order in the country and not because of protection of our heritage. As a matter of fact, Jerusalem is not a religious issue, but part of our heritage. Jerusalem is not an issue of occupied territories but an issue of occupied history. It is an issue of forgotten history. It is an issue of necessity because there are traces of our history that are still alive in Jerusalem. It is an issue of necessity because a Turk going to Jerusalem should feel at home. I do believe that this book will fill in the gap of the forgotten 1,000 years of Jerusalem’s history. I hope that the reader going through the pages of the album will be made aware of the history of those lost years of Jerusalem.

During your seven years in Jerusalem, what did the stones of the city of Jerusalem teach you? What was the most powerful of these lessons?

For me Jerusalem is a city where place and time merge. Before traveling to Jerusalem I believed that the history of humanity followed a sequence independent of the physical world. However, in Jerusalem I began to understand that time is another dimension of location. The city will teach you this only if you know the language of the stones. There is an archeological park to the south of the al-Aqsa Mosque in Jerusalem which has been the site of continuous occupation due to its geostrategic position. In the past the city’s location was secure and strategically important due to its proximity to water, and therefore each time the city was razed throughout history it was not relocated but rather rebuilt. That is why you find the 25-staired remains of a city in the archeological park, but you must recognize it to understand it. An unknowing person wandering in the park would never notice it, they would see only a big pile of stones, but a well-informed person has the opportunity to see 4,000 years of history built layer upon layer in these stones. In fact, while walking on or around the stones one is following the passage from one historical period to another. The sense of time in this place relates only to Jerusalem. It may be that neither clouds nor trees reflect the passage of time, but the olive trees in the garden bear witness to 1,000 to 1,500 years of history; they remind us of the Prophet Jesus and the last three days of his life.

You say in your book that a solution that would work for the majority of both Israelis and Palestinians seems complex and that the problem would probably go on until the “Second coming of Christ.” You then say although it is difficult, one should still attempt to come up with a solution. How can this book be a hope for a solution? How can we settle the conflict from your point of view?

Any piece written about Jerusalem in Turkey typically starts off by criticizing Israel. Even if the issue deserves criticism, by starting out this way, one boxes oneself into a paradigm that appears to be reactionary. This paradigm is a colorless one that produces no solution to the problem. Although no Israeli would say that they have read a study conducted by a Turk, I publicized this book on Jewish websites when it was published. The Israelis knew that I was not searching for mistakes of the past, but rather was displaying the spectacular heritage of their history. My book tells the story of daily life of Jews, Christians, Muslims and secular people living together in peace during the period of the Ottomans.

I do believe that the album will boost readers’ hope for a solution. As a Muslim, of course I am hopeful, as Islam and Muslim prayers as a whole always reflect hope. However, if we look at the issue in terms of present conditions, the reality is that Palestinians want to regard Jerusalem as a capital of their independent state. The Jews are already controlling Jerusalem and at the moment they are in a position to announce it as their eternal capital. The situation reminds me of two men who fell in love with a lady and are constantly fighting over her. You cannot divide this lady into two -- Jerusalem cannot be divided. However, we need a miracle if we are to have a settlement, a settlement where both sides could say that this lady [Jerusalem] is mine. The fact is, she will belong to neither of them, which is why only a miracle in the form of the “Second coming of Christ” could settle this longstanding conflict.

My solution of a settlement is in the title of the book -- “Jerusalem, the Holy Capital.” I am not underlining the holiness of the city, as a matter of fact the word Jerusalem already means holiness, but I am trying say that Jerusalem is a capital of both sides. Jerusalem cannot be the eternal capital of Israel, not the prospective capital for Palestinians. Jerusalem should be for all humanity, and should be the city that all Abrahamic religions view as their capital. Even if you leave out the content of the book, the title of my book provides a resolution to the problem.

You conclude your book with the phrase, “For our part what we should do right now is to complete the Jewish traditional prayer of ‘Next year in Jerusalem’ and say amen in order to bring peace to Jerusalem.” However, as a Muslim you would most probably say amen for the favor of Muslims. In that case, how will peace and tranquility come to Jerusalem?

The traditional Jewish prayer of “Next year in Jerusalem” means to bring happiness to Jerusalem in the coming year. However, I want to say amen to the prayer of recognizing Jerusalem as a holy capital. Of course Jews pray for the welfare of their city, that they might live peacefully. No Jew prays, “Next year in Jerusalem may there be fighting,” as no Jew living in Jerusalem prays for conflict. They will of course desire peace and tranquility. Unfortunately, however, until now in the minds of most Jews there has been a presumption that it is impossible to live in peace with Arabs, Muslims or Palestinians. They believe that they will live in peace only after they are rid of Muslim Palestinians. In fact, if they rid themselves of this presumption they will live in peace.

Basically I see peace in Palestine and in Jerusalem not as a change in circumstances followed by a change in mindset but as a change in mindset reflected in changing circumstances. Yes, the reality of a history marred by continuous occupation is unpleasant. The conditions of the occupation are becoming critical, and the basis of this escalation is the paranoid belief that Israelis cannot coexist with Palestinians. The same paranoia is being reflected collaterally on the Palestinian side as well. They are also attached to the idea that “these Israelis will never treat us fairly,” and to the belief that they will never regain their territories. The current conditions, the shared history, may in fact justify the paranoia of both sides, but if the future is built on the awfulness of the present, we will construct a far more awful future. One should learn how to start from zero, and that zero point is the holy capital, the name I gave to the book.

This is not all I want to say. Many sensible people in both Israel and Palestine say that Jerusalem is a city of God and should be given to God. It is strange that people are fighting each other due to Jerusalem being a city of God. However, I remain hopeful, and that is why I call for a Jerusalem accessible to all the people of the world, where people of different religions will live in peace, and later this change will be reflected in the physical world.

It was Turks that expelled the crusaders from Jerusalem, and it was the Sublime Ottoman Empire that protected the Arab lands, including Jerusalem, from imperialists for four hundred years. The collapse of the Sublime Empire was bad for the Turks, but it was catastrophic for the Arabs. Arab lands, un...
Ferhat B, you call me a "Turk-Islam sentezci". I will ask for your proof for that, and if you can’t supply it, I will continue to believe in your arguments being based on speculations. I will also ask you to inform me what percentage of the Turks are Turk-Islam sentezci. Turks in Central Asia do no...
@Baris, 2- Ottomans and Seljuks did not have nationalism in mind and they definitely were not "Turk-Islam sentezci"s like you and Kerim Balci are. 1- Turks in Central Asia actually look and speak like the Mongolians. (I don't want to get into that but "Turks" in Turkey are mostly muslim Greeks, Arme...
Ferhat B.
Ferhat B, what are you talking about? What have the Native Americans, Swedish, Japanese and many others got to do with it? Why don't you stick to the issue at hand? Turks and Mongols are different races. They look and talk differently. This is particularly true for the Turks who populate the ME and ...
@Baris It's very interesting to see how you Turks claim that Native Americans, Swedish, Japanese and many others are all Turks while denying your ties to the Mongolians?
Ferhat B
Osmanli was never a democratically elected representative of Turkish nation or any nation at all. No nation under its rule including Turks democratically supported Osmanli system of oppression. The Turkish subjects under Osmanli boots were forced to be the poorest, totally ignorant and with no influ...
adam orman
Johan, I think you might want to check you 1085 date re. Jerusalem and Seljuks. Interesting that you mention Mongols, who were not Turks, killing the population but ignore the Crusaders killing the Muslims and Jews in 1099.
Without comment a word from the brilliant Burak Bekdil, which says it all and show the opinion of the esteemed PM
Thanks for definition Ben Yakob. Ottoman Empire in Jerusalem 1517–1917 Large-scale renovation was undertaken of the Dome of the Rock during the reign of Mahmud II in 1817. Adjacent to the Dome of the Rock, the Ottomans built the free-standing Dome of the Prophet in 1620.
@Ferhab B, lol, but you're totally right, some Turks are really full of it. Also, considering all the years this journalist claims that he lived in Jerusalem, not impressed with his knowledge of history in the least. What will his next book be about, the Ottoman's rule in Hungary and their heritage ...
Bloody nonsens: Abbasids were Arabic, their language was Arabic and Armenean. Nothing to do with Turkish. The first thing the Sjesluk Turks did in 1085 when they entered the city was put most synagogues on fire triggering the first crusade. The Mongol killed most 0f the population in 1258!! The anc...
One correction.Jerusalem was not ruled by the Turks for nearly 1,000 years. Only in 1517, Jerusalem and environs fell to the Ottoman Turks, who generally remained in control until 1917. The most important Ottoman contribution was rebuilding of magnificent walls around the Old City.
Ben Yacob
This is a magnificent effort which should be heartily applauded. I stayed in Jerusalem for just thirty days, yet I enjoyed every minute of it. Moslem holy places are safe and sound and well kept and protected. What impressed me more was the Tomb of David in a dilapidated unused mosque covered with I...
Ahmed m Ibrahim
For those of you who are not acquainted with the "Turk-Islam sentezci"s yet: This interview is not meant to be hilarious. Such a book probably exists. If they get strong enough they will probably try to expel both Jews and Arabs from Jerusalem, so that they can wave the Turkish flag over their "lost...
Ferhat B
Click here to read all user comments
NATIONAL  Other Titles
Turkish ruling party wants Erdoğan presidential bid
Turkey to hold further talks with Twitter
PM avoids suing critics of corruption out of fear ‘truth may come out'
AK Party deputies pass MİT law article-by-article despite warnings
Ministerial bureaucrats purged after being profiled by MİT
Chief ombudsman laments low implementation of KDK recommendations
Purges in police force leading to higher crime rate
AK Party government punishing reassigned police officers
Commemorations for former President Özal, supporter of Turkish schools abroad
Gag order on case file in Yazıcıoğlu's death lifted
Legal complaint issued over Mazhar Bağlı’s hate speech
'Banning social media disaster for any government's global image'
Armenian Akdamar church restoration nears completion
Turkey's Gül says candidacy in presidential election not yet settled
Nana Zeyini dies at age of 120
92,000 die of cancer each year in Turkey
Four-year-old dies after being found with slit throat, wrist
Report: Naval command allegedly profiles personnel
Ruling AK Party to determine presidential candidate toward end of May
Probe launched into Afyonkarahisar explosion on suspicion of terrorism
American journalism school offers free online training in Turkish
Erdoğan threatens judges, prosecutors in party group speech
Opposition leaders say PM turning Turkey into intelligence state
Opposition CHP leader likens Erdoğan to Hitler, Mussolini
Nearly 90 police officials purged in southeast Turkey