16 April 2014, Wednesday
Today's Zaman

US rights report criticizes Turkey’s judiciary, media freedom

Read Comment
25 May 2012, Friday / TODAYSZAMAN.COM
The US State Department's annual report on human rights described deficiencies in access to justice, government interference in the freedom of speech and of the press and inadequate protection of vulnerable populations as the most significant human rights problems in Turkey last year.

Chronicling developments in nearly 200 countries, the rights report said broad laws against terrorism and threats to the state, political pressure and inadequacies in the judicial system in Turkey limit access to justice, as do lengthy pretrial detentions and a lack of transparency in the prosecution of cases related to state security.

The European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) also ruled against Turkey in two separate cases regarding lengthy pre-trial detentions this week. The decision of the European court claimed that the length of pre- and post-trial detentions in Turkey in the case in question exceeded acceptable limits.

The Turkish government has embarked on the establishment of a commission to reduce nearly 3,000 cases filed with the ECtHR. Lengthy pre-trial detentions and the duration of trials constitute two primary complaints, pushing Turkey to seek alternative ways to clear cases outside of the Strasbourg-based court.

The rights report also said that the time lag between arrests and the presentation of indictments; leaks of information, evidence or statements; restricted defense access to evidence put forward by the prosecution; and the secrecy of the investigation orders also fueled concerns about the effectiveness of legal protections for suspects.

It noted that the close connection between prosecutors and judges gave the appearance of impropriety and unfairness in criminal cases, while the broad authority granted to prosecutors and judges contributed to an inconsistent and uncertain application of criminal law. It did, however, praise the government for adopting judicial reforms to speed up and improve judicial processes last year.

The State Department report also complained about the authorities' interference in freedom of speech and press, claiming that the penal code and anti-terrorism laws retain multiple articles that restrict press freedoms and public speech on politically and culturally sensitive topics.

The arrest and prosecution of journalists, writers and Kurdish intellectuals and political activists, coupled with condemnatory speeches by political leaders, had a chilling effect on freedom of expression, the report said, adding that politicians, including Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, have sued their critics for defamation at all levels.

It underlined that more than 100 journalists remained imprisoned at the year's end, with most charged under anti-terrorism laws or for connections to an illegal organization. Intellectuals, writers, journalists and media outlets increasingly reported practicing self-censorship to avoid prosecution, although the media continued to criticize government leaders and policies daily and in many cases adopted an adversarial role with respect to the government, it said. The report said the government and the courts limited access to a broad range of websites based on their content.

The report also blamed the authorities for failing to effectively protect vulnerable populations it described as women, children and lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) individuals, from societal abuse, discrimination and violence. Violence against women, the report warned, including honor killings and rape, remained a particularly significant problem. Child marriage persisted, it added.

Other significant human rights problems the report said were unlawful killings committed by security forces, which included a botched air strike in Uludere that killed 34 civilians mistaken for members of the Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK).

The document also reported that demonstrations in southeast Turkey and elsewhere related to the Kurdish issue, students' rights and activities of the Higher Education Board (YÖK) were marred by violence and that members of the security forces used excessive force. “Prisons were overcrowded. Law enforcement officials did not always provide detainees immediate access to an attorney,” it also said.

All laws in democratic countries are made to help growth of civilizations, brotherhood and co-operation. There are no superiors and inferiors. Superiority and respect is for the Lord of Adam, Jesus, Moses and Muhammad -- may peace be upon all of them. All those who accuse other nations must close do...
I wonder who would criticize American justice system and their corporate media which is influence by wall-street so much. Not 2 mention how they handled protest and cover the hold thing up.. By using cover up operation.
GENERAL SHERMAN Just fyi I am half Scot Irish and half native American with just a bit of french thrown in for good measure, so a few people back in the day decided to "make love" and not war. NO country or civilization is without crimes against others. Name one? ABDUL There are many kinds of re...
@ Genera Sherman: May I suggest that you stop reading all together because it seems that nothing you read makes any sense to you and nothing sinks in. Just stick to your babbling and LOLs.
Uncle Billy
Ramesh, what are you babbling about? Dear lord, their are hundreds of thousands (very possibly over a million) dead Afghans and Iraqis who would disagree with that assessment. Have you ever read transcripts by independent journalists of the conversations of US soldiers marching around the lands th...
Thessalonian, it is you who is in denial. Abdul Akbar made an astute observation and he is actually in error for not going deeper. "Western" and "civilization" don't belong together and the idea itself makes no sense becase it involves grouping together West European nations who, while being among...
Mr. Thessalonian is being correct. America and West countries never do anything against muslims or other religions. They support islam and muslims, and are always worrying about muslim peoples living in dictatorships like iraq,libya, syria and iran.
Mr. Abdul Akbar, you are indeed a denialist as well as an islamofascist who hates Western civilization. Yabanci below has correctly identified and pointed out your intentionally erroneous and flawed comparisons. Hope you will get over it soon as it will continue to pervert and skew your way of think...
I stopped reading after "US" and "rights report". It takes a lot of gall for a bunch of WASPs and Scotch-Irish to completely wipe out the Native Americans, rob their land entirely, and than compain to others 100 years later when a christian/kurdish terrrorist in another country gets a papercut.
Abdul, while I absolutely abhor the actions of religious intolerance you read of in newspapers, both US and around the world, there is a difference between the intolerant actions of individuals and the official positions of a state.
The US is criticizing others for religious intolerance. But its own citizens burns Quran and the US administration is silent about it? Who will ask the US and its civilized citizens to respect religions of others as well.
Abdul Akbar
Click here to read all user comments
DIPLOMACY  Other Titles
‘Turkey will not remain silent over 'genocide resolution' if adopted’
Russia welcomes Turkey's assurances on observance of Montreux terms
Poland: NATO should send troops to east Europe, ignore Russia's objections
US looks to Turkey to uphold checks and balances
Dubai may be a hub for Turkey and Iran's illicit transactions
US House Speaker meets senior Turkish officials in Ankara
EU Minister Çavuşoğlu says Füle's comments on Turkey ‘balanced'
US Ambassador Ricciardone has talks with AK Party officials
Turkey's honorary consuls meet to discuss foreign policy
Iran to build cultural center in the heart of İstanbul
Loğoğlu: No Turkish institution in US works against Turkey
Erdoğan will further polarize Turkey as presidential election approaches
European Union concerned about rule of law in Turkey
Turkey seeks to restore dialogue with Serbia with FM's visit
Turkish Rights groups slam Egypt over execution ruling
Turkey to boost relations with Afghanistan, backing stability in post-election era
Erdoğan's political ambitions clash with Turkey's long-term interests
Critics say Turkey no longer state with rule of law with MİT bill
Turkey might export domestic political tension to diaspora
Turkey to face challenges amid rising Euroskepticism in EU
[Photo Story] Leaving the island, coming back home
FM Davutoğlu: Turkey won't allow violation of Montreux Convention
Military: Turkish jet fighters intercept Russian plane over Black Sea
Students enchant Turkish immigrants in Germany with poems of praise
Turkey's Davutoğlu in Mexico to attend MIKTA talks