16 April 2014, Wednesday
Today's Zaman

Hopes dim for normalization of Turkish-Armenian relations

7 May 2012, Monday /CELİL SAĞIR
As Armenians headed to the polls on Sunday, expectations were low that new life would be breathed into an unratified deal signed by the foreign ministers of Turkey and Armenia in 2009 to normalize relations.

Armenian officials and politicians accuse Turkey of holding the ratification process hostage through its insistence that Armenia must first agree to a solution to the long-standing Nagorno-Karabakh issue as a precondition for normalization.

Armenian Parliament head Samvel Nikoyan, who spoke to Turkish reporters who came to Armenia as part of the program sponsored by the Hrant Dink Foundation and the Heinrich Böll Stiftung Association accused Turkey’s policy of threatening the process, remarking: “We are seeing that any kind of provision, especially the precondition of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict, as devastating the process of talks. To move talks forward … it’s necessary that we vote on the protocols without preconditions.”

Galust Sahakyan, leader of the Republican Party of Armenia parliamentary faction, meanwhile, indicated that Armenian leaders had their own red lines that will take priority over the reconciliation pact, stating to the press, “For us, the Karabakh problem and the genocide issue are more important than a restart in relations with Turkey.”

Nonetheless, Sahakyan said he thinks of Turkey as the key to solving the region’s most pressing problems, saying of the protocol’s future: “We aren’t going to take any steps back. But if Turkey announces that it is withdrawing officially from the protocol, we will also do what’s necessary.”

Armenia’s third-largest expected winner at this year’s election, the Heritage Party, meanwhile, indicated that it was against the protocol, with party leader Raffi Hovannisian stating that it was necessary to restart the talks without preconditions. “If Turkey insists on preconditions, the Armenian side will have to develop a symmetric response.”

Nikoyan, commenting on the deadlock before the elections, said the disagreements still do not constitute a major rift between the two countries. “In a situation in which there are no official diplomatic relations and the border is closed, our communications are strong. At this moment commerce isn’t being supported, but we know there’s the potential for [re-establishing] trade. There are Turkish businessmen in Armenia, and Armenian businessmen in Turkey.”

Richard Giragosian of the Regional Studies Center also said the rift was less formidable than portrayed, noting, “I am optimistic about Armenian-Turkish normalization.”

Indicating that significant pressure exists to re-establish relations before the 100th anniversary of the Armenian massacres in 2015, Giragosian said, “It’s possible that some of the unofficial diplomatic ties will be made more official.” Giragosian believes that the Turkish Embassy in Tbilisi, Georgia, could be accredited by Yerevan or that relations could be formally established through the Swiss Embassy there. He also suggested that certain border gates could be opened. Such measures are not without cost, however, and Giragosian warns that they could meet heavy opposition in Azerbaijan.

Eurasia Partnership Foundation Country Director Gevorg Ter-Gabrielyan, meanwhile, speculated that the prospective relations change would be tied to changes in Armenia’s government. “The elections can in the medium run create new chances if the government changes and new and more energetic people come to power who are ready to engage more vocally in international organizations and thus induce Turkey to take some steps with regard to confidence-building measures,” he stated.

“I think the Turkish governments’ statements are sometimes too emotional, just like the Armenians, and more calm pragmatism is needed on both sides,” he added.

Turkish-Armenian relations also appear imperiled by Armenia’s continued appeal to territorial rights over territories possessed by Turkey. In the elections run-up, Nikoyan stated that for Armenia Mount Ararat must remain as one of the state’s symbols. Calls for recognition of the 1915 killings of Armenians as genocide also remain high on politicians’ priorities.

The coming 100th anniversary of that event is also likely to upset relations between the two countries, with analysts predicting that 2015 will see major demonstrations, especially among Turkey’s minority Armenian community.

Russia-Turkey balance

Turkey and Armenia’s renewed push to negotiate an opening of the border gates between the two countries might also be viewed in the framework of the latter’s close ties to Russia. According to Giragosian, Armenia remains “tied to a fundamental degree to Russia.” An Organization for Security and Co-Operation in Europe (OSCE) official, who asked not to be named, said Armenia should strive to be “small and transparent” in the future. “In foreign policy, they’re going to try to develop close relations with the EU and the West.” Ter-Gabrielyan agreed. “In the times to come, Russian interest is going to diminish even further because Armenia is getting closer and closer to Europe,” he commented.

Commenting on the possibility of starting Turkish-Armenian normalization process, Salpi Ghazarian, director of The Civilitas Foundation, based in Yerevan said “I dont know if it will. Because it is in Turkey’s hand”

To Wild Turkey! Before accusing Armenia of being Russia's puppet, let us first list all the countries to which Turkey is puppet: Israel, USA, Qatar, Saudi Arabia. As you see Armenia Wins one against Four.
Ararat Araratian
Armenia is Russia's puppet that lives on with their hand outs ..shame on those who are running the country mainly this guy that got elected again..he is a joke
No one associated with a soft line on Turkey will win the Armenian presidency ever again -- Armenia learned from the Ter Petrosyan years that Turkey is not interested in reconciliation, save for its use in avoiding condemnation in Congress.
Jack Kalpakian
Turkish specialty, ratify protocols and then put new conditions or not follow it through. Turkey has 134 such international protocols that have been signed with great political showmanship but with absolute zero results. Azerbaijan has too much clout with Turkey to expect anything else, perfect exam...
Saaten Maagar
Yes Turkey, get your troops out of Cyprus before any negotiations with the Greek side. This is what you are asking from the Armenians to do. Even Turks know that this is a joke but they have to bow to Mr. Aliev's demands or else he will charge them more for energy.
Uncle Billy
Click here to read all user comments
DIPLOMACY  Other Titles
‘Turkey will not remain silent over 'genocide resolution' if adopted’
Russia welcomes Turkey's assurances on observance of Montreux terms
Poland: NATO should send troops to east Europe, ignore Russia's objections
US looks to Turkey to uphold checks and balances
Dubai may be a hub for Turkey and Iran's illicit transactions
US House Speaker meets senior Turkish officials in Ankara
EU Minister Çavuşoğlu says Füle's comments on Turkey ‘balanced'
US Ambassador Ricciardone has talks with AK Party officials
Turkey's honorary consuls meet to discuss foreign policy
Iran to build cultural center in the heart of İstanbul
Loğoğlu: No Turkish institution in US works against Turkey
Erdoğan will further polarize Turkey as presidential election approaches
European Union concerned about rule of law in Turkey
Turkey seeks to restore dialogue with Serbia with FM's visit
Turkish Rights groups slam Egypt over execution ruling
Turkey to boost relations with Afghanistan, backing stability in post-election era
Erdoğan's political ambitions clash with Turkey's long-term interests
Critics say Turkey no longer state with rule of law with MİT bill
Turkey might export domestic political tension to diaspora
Turkey to face challenges amid rising Euroskepticism in EU
[Photo Story] Leaving the island, coming back home
FM Davutoğlu: Turkey won't allow violation of Montreux Convention
Military: Turkish jet fighters intercept Russian plane over Black Sea
Students enchant Turkish immigrants in Germany with poems of praise
Turkey's Davutoğlu in Mexico to attend MIKTA talks