EU Minister Bağış slams German court's decision on circumcision
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
19 June 2013 Wednesday
 
 
 
 
 
 

EU Minister Bağış slams German court's decision on circumcision

Read Comment
19
Turkish EU Affairs Minister Egemen Bağış speaking at a meeting titled “Communication with Turkey: Turkey's image and EU Membership” at Germany's Economy and Technology Ministry office in Berlin on Wednesday. (Photo: AA)
27 June 2012 /TODAYSZAMAN.COM WITH WIRES
Turkish EU Affairs Minister Egemen Bağış has criticized a German court ruling stating that circumcising young boys constitutes assault.

Speaking to the press at a meeting titled “Communication with Turkey: Turkey's image and EU Membership” at Germany's Economy and Technology Ministry office in Berlin, Bağış said it is a completely ignorant act to say circumcision is a crime against one's health.

A German court recently ruled that circumcising young boys on religious grounds amounts to bodily harm even if the boy's parents consent to the procedure. The case in question involved a doctor accused of carrying out a circumcision on a 4-year-old that resulted in medical complications. However, the doctor was acquitted and prosecutors said they won't appeal.

Bağış said the court's decision was not acceptable and that circumcision is a religious issue that should not even be discussed in courts. “This is an issue of religious freedom. If German judges require any information on this topic, we are ready to provide them with help on this topic,” he added.

The president of Germany's Central Council of Jews, Dieter Graumann, called the ruling “unprecedented and insensitive,” urging the country's parliament to clarify the legal situation “to protect religious freedom against attacks.”

Muslims also practices circumcision of young boys, and some parents request circumcision for health rather than religious reasons. The state court's ruling has created a tricky legal situation for doctors who perform the procedure on parents' orders.

 
COMMENTS
@Christoph, do you like to know more about this topic? Get this, Jesus was circumcised on the 8-th day. And stop talking non-sense! It was, it's a sign of covenent between man and higher power in accordance with the Torah. It's a matter of choice. Christoph you have no right to say anything when fac...
defer
Happen to live abroad,where if you don't do it in the first few days of the newborns live, you won't find a MD to perform it. So the youngest son travel to Turkey and no problem. Even was videotaped(he is now embarrass to watch it and declared "no one watches anymore"!). By the way,even Abraham did ...
defer
The Koran does not even say that you should circumcise. There is no health benefit. This is a myth that circumcising societies say so that they don't look like ridiculous fools for cutting their own penises.
Deniz
Metin, my ancestors were in Anatolia 2000 years before the first Seljuk Turk arrived. I have as much right to comment here as anybody and certainly more than you. If you don't like it, leave. The back side of your head is your best side anyway.
Christoph
Don't worry, modern Germany is a slave state of israel and the US. They won't do anything.
GeneralSherman
An egg on the face of neo-Nazis and Aegean Ethiopians. They thought that by doing this they could antagonize the Turkish-German minority but they forgot about their Jewish masters. "Oh, wait..."
GeneralSherman
Now it is official, Mr. Bağış admits knowing more about circumcision than EU affairs. Shouldn't one stick to a topic that one knows?
Saaten Maagar
I am sure that the German judges are at a loss, do not know what to do and eagerly are waiting for information to be provided by Mr. Bağış to function properly, specially on circumcision.
Uncle Billy
What is wrong with the way God created our bodies? Why do parents think that they have the right to cut off certain parts of the childs body, the child which was given to them as gift by God?
Fearless
@Christoph - I was not knowing paupers can also laugh. Disaster is EU and not Bagis
Just Think
Christoph, if you are a European conservative, your comment only shows how far away you and your likes have strayed from decency and how deep you are mired in depravity. if we speak against homosexuality, you find that funny. If we speak against abortion, you find that amusing. If we speak against s...
Appalled
kapitop. It is called development........I guess people like you like to stick to all sorts of niceties such as female circumcision as well?
Redford
Circumcision is an invasion and mutilation of the body, the body created by the supreme creator, God given as many believe,whether you believe in God or not. Circumcision is an act of violence and destruction in effect-however well intentioned in terms of religious belief-whether performed apon male...
Rudolfus
There is lots of room in Muslim lands, so why not live where you can practice all your traditions without interference? You wanna have 4 wives, no problem, go to Saudi.
keith
Christoph, you don't have life. Why don't you go and look after your own country and politicians before you come out of jelousy and comment on ours. You're not welcome. Get lost.
Metin
Wonky Germans. This isn't an issue in the US.
GeneralSherman
Whe always hear around for example the Ergenecon that AKP has faith in an independent court system and its interpretation of the laws. But does that not also mean that we should respect other countries legal systems and democratic laws?
We SP
What next ? Burying the dead is environmental hazard,therefore cremate(burn) ? EU has gone back to their pagan roots !
kapitop
The unqualified disaster as Turkey's minister opens his mouth again. They are laughing in Brussels, you can count on that.
Christoph
Click here to read all user comments
Diplomacy  Other Titles
...
Bloggers