17 April 2014, Thursday
Today's Zaman

Erdoğan says rating agencies make decisions based on rumors

Read Comment
11 May 2012, Friday /GAMZE GÜL
Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan said on Friday that credit agencies such as Standard & Poor's (S&P) make their ratings decisions based on rumors and called on economists to question the credibility of these agencies.

Speaking to participants at the seventh meeting of the Investment Advisory Council for Turkey (YDK) at the Prime Ministry's Dolmabahçe office in İstanbul, Erdoğan went on to criticize S&P for its decision to change its outlook on Turkey from positive to stable, saying the credit rating agency did not even visit Turkey prior to making the revision. “Credit rating agencies are either not visiting Turkey or issuing their ratings based on rumors. We'll continue on our way, without paying any attention to these unfair rating decisions,” Erdoğan said.

Erdoğan stated that Turkey is an economically strong and fast-growing country and that there must be other reasons behind S&P's rating revision. Noting that Turkey attracted $119.5 billion in foreign investment between 2006 and 2008, he said, “Turkey has even outpaced the historic figures between 2006 and 2008. Employment has increased by 3.5 million people in the last two years. We will continue on our way with controlled economic management."

Recalling that experts have also criticized S&P for its decision, Erdoğan called on economists to seriously discuss the motives of the rating agencies and question their credibility. He said, “Do not blame me for criticizing because as we have been working hard towards achieving our goals, facing such a downgrade is not acceptable and we won't tolerate such a move. It is natural for us to look for the decision's ulterior motives,” adding, “The S&P rating will certainly result in a change of our approach toward the agency.”

Erdoğan stressed that the government will continue to work hard to make progress by disregarding the smear campaign against Turkey and carry on building the country to make it one of the top 10 economies of world by 2023. “We have been actively working to better the investment environment in Turkey by making reforms and holding investment advisory councils which have been greatly contributing to our progress. Our government takes the suggestions of these meetings very seriously and works hard toward their implementation.”

Erdoğan also said some of the companies there are present at the meeting have already moved their regional offices to İstanbul, and stressed that İstanbul has become a center where many important international firms conduct operations. He stated, “We will continue our efforts to make İstanbul an international financial center and a regional oversight center.”

Speaking to Today's Zaman, President and CEO of General Electric Healthcare John Dineen said that the decision of the ratings agency is not concerning for his company, explaining, “Our interest in Turkey is driven by local demand and as long as the government continues to support health care and energy fields, our interest will remain.” Noting that Turkey's health care sector has been growing more than any other country in the world and accessibility to health care is world class, he stated, “The presence of great doctors, good public and private hospitals as well as increase in specialty hospitals demonstrate [Turkey's] potential; however, there are needs for high-technology products and we are looking to serve those needs as well as creating local manufacturing opportunities. In addition, policies implemented by the government have contributed majorly to this progress.” He also commented, “Investments in health care and energy fields up to this date have been successful and we have actively been in dialogue with the government. GE's future investments include the health care sector and locomotive production for the transportation sector.”

At the YDK meeting International Monetary Fund (IMF) head Christine Lagarde and World Bank head Sri Mulyani Indrawati were present. It was Lagarde's first visit to Turkey since her appointment. Also present at the meeting were Coca-Cola Company CEO Muhtar Kent, CEO of Vodafone Group PLC Vittorio Colao, the Turkish Union of Chambers and Commodity Exchanges (TOBB) President Rifat Hisarcıklıoğlu, Turkish Industrialists and Businessmen's Association (TÜSİAD) President Ümit Boyner and Turkish Exporters Union (TİM) President Mehmet Büyükekşi.

Economy Minister Zafer Çağlayan informed the press after the meeting that 19 people had given speeches on their views of the general economic issues as well as the investment environment in Turkey, highlighting possible opportunities in the country. “In the second session, agreements were made for a joint declaration to be announced at a later time.”

Çağlayan stated that many companies had expressed plans to invest in Turkey, and some had announced that they will transfer their logistical operations to Turkey. He said: “With the contribution of an incentives package, Turkey is expected to attract more investments than it has before, especially in the chemicals sector. Additionally, textile giants like Zara and Mango will make major investments in southeastern Turkey, particularly in the province of Muş. In the next 15 days, we will share the details of these upcoming investments.”

7Hills-Assuming you actually did use to work for a ratings agency (this is the internet, who can tell?), one wonders if that was before 2008 when the rating agencies rubberstamped all the fictitious 'credit instruments' that triggered this latest on-going recession. Of course I am sure that all of t...
Chester Bushey
All of world finance runs this way--on rumor and herd-following. Have none of the commenters heard of any of the the bubbles of the last 30 years? As a national leader, it is part of Erdogan's job to spin the rumors and steer the herd as best he can. The shocking thing would be if this article is co...
Chester Bushey
@ Yaacov The two honourable "leaders" seem to be on a competition who is the more ridiculous. The West is having a good laugh!
Inflation 11.5%,official unemployment 11.5% unofficial unemployment 30%,current account deficit increased 45% to $6.1 since February.Is this a bright economy?
This Prime Minister just cannot accept anything that does not stroke his over inflated ego. What a comical character. From the one who gives his opinions freely, he should learn to accept what others say.
I used to work for a ratings agency. there is no rumour or gossip involved in country risk analysis. A number of quantitative indicators, models and comps linked to policy are looked at. Just like growth companies can stretch their debt ratins from time to time, so can growth countries. Argentina an...
Erdogan is becoming an embarassment, by politicising every event. He has a bigger mouth than Davutoglu, even.
Erdogan is right. Turkey is on the right path in terms of growth and prosperity.
Osman Emir
The hideous man just never knows when to shAt Up, LOL.
PM Erdogan is absolutely correct in his response to S
Perhaps The Sultan 'doth protest too much'! No smoke without fire as they say.
The Prisoner
Why is it unheard of for someone else to base something on "rumor"? The majority of Turks base the majority of their life decisions on rumor and gossip. How many Turks still believe that Bush blew up the WTCenter for his own purposes? The evidence against this is that people do NOT keep secrets a...
He can't get over it, can he? Nobody arund makes such a fuss as the honourable PM, it is extremely embarassing!
He says "We'll continue on our way, without paying any attention to these unfair rating decisions,” I think he has paid more attention than any other PM in the world. The problem with comments like these are that a)it signals panic, b) makes us look overly "macho" and hostile and aggressive c) signa...
Not good
Click here to read all user comments
BUSINESS  Other Titles
Galatasaray to pay $35 mln in tax penalty
Twitter: No current deal to open office in Turkey
Ankara says Russia's South Stream pipeline could run to Turkey
Turkish central bank meeting eyed for signs of political meddling
Turkish cement firms eye assets after Holcim-Lafarge merger
CHP raises issue of irregularity in loans for Sabah-ATV sale
TUSKON key in trade with Turkey, top Russian group says
Number of job seekers hits 10-year high
Gül attends event of group labeled ‘traitors' by Erdoğan
'Banning social media disaster for any government's global image'
Pakistan publishes list to embarrass tax cheats into paying up
Turkish schools help to enhance trade relations with Africa
Unemployment rate sees decrease year-on-year in Jan
Pegasus Airlines to start flights to Bahrain
Installment payments down 16 pct since credit card regulation implemented
Euro zone's trade surplus widens on rising exports in February
Doğan Holding merges with publishing group
Turkey's Koç: We will concentrate our energy on investments
EU lawmakers complete financial system overhaul
Egypt limits air conditioning in mosques as power shortages worsen