Israeli gas deal tied to resolution of Mavi Marmara dispute
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
24 May 2013 Friday
 
 
 
 
 
 

Israeli gas deal tied to resolution of Mavi Marmara dispute

Read Comment
26
Energy and Natural Resources Minister Taner Yıldız speaking at a meeting in Antalya where discussions on oil and natural gas exploitation took place on Sunday. (Photo: Today's Zaman)
11 March 2012 /İLYAS KOÇ
Energy and Natural Resources Minister Taner Yıldız has said Turkey can facilitate the transportation of natural gas Greek Cyprus and Israel are currently working to extract in the eastern Mediterranean to northwestern markets only if and when Israel agrees to Turkey's demands regarding the killing of eight of its citizens together with a US citizen of Turkish origin onboard an aid ship two years ago.

“All the feasibility studies conducted are now pointing to Turkey [as the most suitable transportation route]. If we did not have the Mavi Marmara issue with Israel, there could have been many joint projects between us -- and the transportation of natural gas [from the eastern Mediterranean to Europe] would be at the top of the list of those projects. And that would have been only right to do. Yet that natural gas pipeline is not worthy of nine lives we lost,” he said on Sunday, speaking to reporters in the southern province of Antalya.

Faced with resistance when trying to intercept it, Israeli naval commandos killed eight Turks as well as 19-year old Furkan Doğan, a US citizen of Turkish ethnicity, onboard the Gaza-bound Mavi Marmara aid ship in international waters on May 31, 2010. The Turkish government and people have been infuriated with the operation and its deadly result, but Israel refused to apologize for it, perceiving it as an insult to its national pride. It also did not agree to pay compensation to the families of the victims. Turkey has accordingly imposed sanctions on Israel, expelling the Israeli ambassador and suspending military agreements with the Middle Eastern country.

“There is only one way to transport this natural gas. The seabed of the Mediterranean is not ideal for a pipeline. Turkey, on the other hand, has a pipeline infrastructure. Why should it not be used for that purpose? Should we receive an offer, we can speak of such a partnership only when the political foundation is strengthened for it. Energy cannot carry the burden of politics,” Yıldız said.

Teaming up with the Greek Cypriots and Israelis, the American Noble Energy company is leading natural gas exploration efforts in the eastern Mediterranean. It estimates that there are more than 25 trillion cubic meters in Israeli waters and up to 230 billion cubic meters in Cypriot waters to the west. Ankara, however, adamantly opposes any Greek Cypriot oil and gas search that denies Turkish Cypriots, who have a separate government in the north of the island that is recognized only by Turkey, what it contends is a rightful claim to any revenue made from the sale of the gas. It also dismisses a Greek Cypriot-Israeli deal demarcating their maritime borders as null and void. In response, it recently signed an agreement with the Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus (KKTC) to explore for oil and natural gas in the region.

Cyprus was split into an internationally recognized Greek-speaking south and a Turkish-speaking north in 1974 after Turkey militarily intervened to protect the lives of Turks on the island following a coup attempt by supporters of union with Greece.

 
COMMENTS
Turkey has chosen to downgrade the relations with Israel, not the other way around. What does Erdogan expect that soldiers should not defend themselves from violence? Your so called "moderate government" will never be accepted into the EU, because of your government's Islamic character.
VV
I will not buy from bully Erdogan's government even a pair of used shoelace.
theo
No No NO apology to Turkey. the Turkish Government has created this problem they will have to bite the bullet. the Turks now realized how they shut themselves in the foot, and how important Israel is to them. so I say to hell with Turkey.
Moshe
I'm confused, who has asked Turkey for anything? You're dreaming if you believe any country on this planet trusts Turkey. Not even Arabs can stand you; Turkey is a bully and it knows the EU will never want it to join. As someone below commented, Turkey is a *** indeed ***. Turkey is the biggest lose...
tamam
Mr Yildiz nobody asked you for facilitating or transporting hydrocarbons found in the EEZ of Israel and Cyprus.
paul
And why should Israel agree to such a thing? They don't need Turkey to facilitate distribution, they'll just look to Greece or another Balkan country.
Surely you jest
As a secular Turk i want Turkey to cut all ties with dishonest hyena state israel. Secular, islamist, communist or nationalist no Turk trusts israel anymore. So also the few people in the israeli embassy should be given 24 hours to leave Turkey. Wish iran, syria, lebanon and israel a good time soon....
DutchTurk
@ Hasan the advantage of the non-Turkish people is that they can see things clearer and with less preoccupations than those whose thoughts are fogged by super-nationalist feelings. If you want to get a Turkish opinon as well, go to the Turkish language media. Oh sorry, I forgot! No freedom of expre...
migo
My Israeli friends, my Jewish friends, enjoy the moment while you can, because middle east is changing, and very soon most of the middle eastern nations will become nuclear nations, including Turkey, Iran, Egypt, Saudis,maybe even more nobody can stop progress, if not now, but it will happen, maximu...
asim
I see that just non Turkish people commented here, so I think I have to say something about your comments. Turkey has the rights to do whatever it wants as a country, it is been a long time that the Turkish government was ruled from western powers. Why is Israel depending on Turkey anyway, find anot...
Hasan
I just came back from Turkey and the sad thing is that almost every educated and civil person in Turkey is very concerned about the impossible political decision and behaviour of Erdogasn, they all call him "Sultan". They told me that his supporters are mostly the more uneducated and simple masses a...
migo
Of course you did not print my two very appropriate comments on this article, for fear to anger the administration.
Orly
"Should we receive an offer" he realy think that Israel can count on Turkey.....it better to use all the gas for Israel for many years this is a whay to be indeapendet in energy.
"Erdogan Friend"
Mr. Erdogan, by vilifying Israel is just another Middle Eastern leader, who unfortunately gets intoxicated from the tune of ?The Arab Street?, just to achieve an imaginary and fleeting victory. Even though no physical harm was done to Israel, trust in Turkey, will not return now or in future, and h...
Kelly -
Who asked Turkey to 'facilitate the transfer'? Israel didn't. Cyprus didn't. Turkey is sticking it's nose into a bilateral relationship between Israel and Republic of Cyprus. Mind your own business, Mr. Yildiz.
Yaacov
and the other shoe drops
jmbaum
haha, it sounds as though turkey wants piece of the pie, but you ain't gonna get any because of your foolish and false pride and that is what it's all about, you don't care at all about the 9 violent people who hit the Israeli soldiers and met their deaths, you care justs about an apology from a cou...
fowzia
Greek Cyprus is a member of the EU, and the EU would support it .The 9 killed on the Marmara went to assist the Palestinian version of the PKK. What would Turkey do if Israeli "peace activists" would launch an aid mission to the PKK???
Israeli
Neither Israel nor Europe trust Turkey to carry Israeli or Greek Cypriot gas to market. Sooo, the pipeline will be buil;t undersea. Not ideal. But doable. Perhaps Turkey can carry Iranian gas instead, since it is not respecting the UN embargo.....
bill
Turkey's got a lot of hutzpah dictating terms to Israel and Cyprus! They should tell Turkey they'd consider using their pipelines only IF: 1) Turkey removes all its troops and illegal settlers from occupied northern Cyprus, and allows for a true reunification of the island, and 2) Turkey apologizes ...
Paul
Stop trying the apology, recognize first your own mistakes ! Every single day before the flotilla departure Israel demanded from Turkish governmaent to stop the provocation. The answer was - it's private mission ! So let it be the private issue after the mission failed, do not demand the official st...
Yuri
I sincerely hope the Israeli Governement will not even consider the option of using Turkey to market their gas, as it is not a friendly country any longer. You do not make deals and depend on your enemy.With their bullying attitude, Turkey will lose all their friends in the west, and will not make ...
Orly
Turkey has proven that it cannot be trusted with any agreement, and Israel will not transport its gas through an unstable radical Islamist regime in Turkey. Why should want to do that anyway? They will only be held hostage to some other stupid Turkish demand in the future. The Marvi Marmara "victims...
Joe
Unfortunately, this is an insincere argument. After the 'Mavi Marmara' confrontation I and many other Israelis were supportive of Israeli apology and payment of compensation. But once Mr. Erdogan also demanded to dictate Israel's policy on Gaza, Turkey became a sponsor of the Islamist Hamas, and ant...
Israeli
Turkey's demand to link the unfortunate Marmara incident to the transportation of Gas to Cyprus confirms once again that it has turned to a totalitarian regime without sensible judgement. The current administration only knows how to use "mano forte". Turkey certainly does not belong in the Europea...
Orly
Even if Israel agreed to an "apology, it would not agree to lifting the Gaza blockade, as even now terrory groups in Gaza are sending more and more powerful rockets deeper and deeper into Israel. Given Turkeys support for Hamas, agreeing to the use of Turkish pipelines would be like giving Turkey a ...
rich
Click here to read all user comments
Business  Other Titles
...