Sarkozy, Socialist contender vow to pursue genocide bill despite veto
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
24 May 2013 Friday
 
 
 
 
 
 

Sarkozy, Socialist contender vow to pursue genocide bill despite veto

Read Comment
18
Nicolas Sarkozy, France's President and UMP party candidate in the French 2012 presidential election, reacts after his speech at a political rally in Montpellier on Feb. 28, 2012. (Photo: Reuters)
29 February 2012 / TODAYSZAMAN.COM WITH REUTERS
French President Nicolas Sarkozy and socialist presidential hopeful Francois Hollande have both promised to pursue a new bill that would penalize the denial of allegations of Armenian genocide by Ottoman Turks in 1915 after a previous bill was struck down for being unconstitutional.

Sarkozy already reportedly asked his government on Tuesday to draft a new version of the law. The French Constitutional Council ruled on Tuesday that the law, which had soured relations between Paris and Ankara, ran against the principles of freedom of expression written into France's founding documents.

“The President of the Republic considers that [genocide] denial is intolerable and must therefore be punished,” his office wrote in a statement. “He has asked the government to prepare a new draft taking into account the decision of the Constitutional Council.”

According to the French media, his socialist rival, Hollande, also said he promises to bring the bill back onto the agenda if he is elected president. Noting that drafting a new bill is currently difficult as presidential elections approach, he added, however, that he is determined to keep his promises and draft a new bill if elected.

Stating that Armenians in France expect the approval of such a bill, Hollande also said Turkey should not think of the bill as targeting it.

Armenia, backed by many historians and Parliaments in several countries, says about 1.5 million Armenians were killed in what is now eastern Turkey during World War I in a deliberate policy of genocide ordered by the Ottoman government. The Ottoman Empire dissolved after the end of the war, but successive Turkish governments and the vast majority of Turks take the charge of genocide as a direct insult to their national pride. Ankara argues that there was a heavy loss of life on both sides during fighting in the area.

In Ankara, Turkish President Abdullah Gül told reporters on Wednesday that French Constitutional Council’s decision regarding the genocide-denial bill “rescued France” and its prestige.

Turkey’s main opposition Republican People’s Party (CHP) leader Kemal Kılıçdaroğlu said in Ankara that the council corrected what he said “coup to French history.”

“We have witnessed rule of law, ethic values in France. ... [Constitutional Council] did what it was supposed to do,” Kılıçdaroğlu told reporters on Wednesday.

          

 
COMMENTS
Senol. Just for your information. The law in France is not about RECOGNITION (that has been done by many countries), but it is about a law which makes it illegal to deny it. So it is a different issue. France has previously made a similar law against denying the holocaust (which also Germany and oth...
Get it right
100 years have past and the Armenians are still looking for war to win. They have been loosers and always will remain loosers. Say France recognises it, you need more Armenian lobbies around the world to change anything. Your not the Jewish Lobby who might accomplish such a task, even they will find...
Senol
To pro-Armenian Posters We are not buying your cheap arguments unless you lodge a case at the International court of Justice and get a verdict in your favour. But I very much doubt that you have the to to that as you must have done it by now. Keep your dream and your delusional world busy congratul...
satrap
Whatever the agenda Sarkozy is pursuing, it is a sad fact that both pro-genocide and anti-genocide believers are against free speech. Illegal to deny in France, illegal to admit in Turkiye!
The Prisoner
Just some questions: Is the denial of the Aghet forbidden in Armenia? Is admitting the genocide forbitten in Turkey? Do the Turks pay american universities to teach the denial of the genocide or are Armenians the ones investing money for the truth to come out... and you want to tell me that 11 Milli...
Akritas
Raffi and Djoghk - I am happy to debate with both of you on this matter. Please send me emails on acar1sin@hotmail.com with your arguments and I will reply. Thanks for your time.
Sinan
I think it is hilarious reading all the Pro-Armenian posts up here. I strongly recommend you people should look at facts and stop pin pointing to books made by your incompetent, lying Armenian historians. Firstly, all these 'Genocide' ideas are accepted because Armenian LOBBYING groups push ahead to...
Sinan
People around the world read and investigate History, the more the Armenian issue is discussed the more Turkey's name gets stained, maybe the Turkish government should act before Turkey's name is tarnished to a point that can be very hard to clean.
Raffi
Turkey has to face her ugly past. There is no use denying something that happened in 1915. The Armenian Genocide is a historical fact. The quicker the Turks realise that the better. Only good can come out of this recognition ,then some things can move on but until then there will always be injustice...
Djoghk
France has already recognized the Armenian Genocide long time ago, who cares what a Turk thinks or says. The Turkish history books are all full of lies so it is not very important what people who have grown up listening to lies will say the wrong things, just like Dersim, eventually the truth will p...
Saaten Maagar
Turks won one battle, but sooner or later they will lose the WAR of denialism.
George
"Today under French law there are two types of victims and two types of descendants of victims ... Some are protected from revisionist acts and some are not, and I think this is a serious double standard," Boyer said.
VTiger
Poor Harutyunyam...
Ali
They say in my country(Albania): When a mule insists it is a horse there is nothing and nobody changing it's mind.Can Sarkozy change his mind? I "think" so.Poor France for the leader she has.
adnan
Why does not Armenia and the Armenian diaspora sit down with the Turks and open their archives and then calmly look into the facts that history has left behind the tragic events of 1915. Sarkozy is an opportunist like Hollande the leader of the Socialist party. They do not care for France's national...
A. Khan
If Sarkozy genuinely respected the Armenian 'genocide' farce he would not be making it a political tool to win Armenian votes for the upcoming elections. Now he's trying to convince Armenian's that, although the last bill violated his own countries constitition, he's still going to somehow water it ...
Metin
Denying the Armenian Genocide will cost Turkey more than recognizing it..........poor Turkey :)))
Samvel Z. Harutyunyan
Sarko's ego is sad; grieving. His baby, the so called 'genocide bill' is dead. Will he be able to resurrect it before the elections???
Ali
Click here to read all user comments
Diplomacy  Other Titles
...