|  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
May 28, 2012
 
 
 
 
 
 

Auster responds to Erdoğan, says free speech exists in Israel

Read Comment
25
US author Paul Auster poses for a photograph before an interview in Stockholm on May 10, 2011. (Photo: Reuters)
2 February 2012 / TODAYSZAMAN.COM,
Renowned American author Paul Auster, who elicited an angry reaction from Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan after saying he refuses to travel to Turkey due to the high number of imprisoned journalists, has responded to Erdoğan's criticism of him for travelling to Israel, saying freedom of speech does exist in the Jewish state.

“Whatever the Prime Minister might think about the state of Israel, the fact is that free speech exists there and no writers or journalists are in jail,” he said on Wednesday. “According to the latest numbers gathered by International PEN, there are nearly 100 writers imprisoned in Turkey, not to speak of independent publishers such as Ragıp Zarakolu, whose case is being closely watched by PEN Centers around the world. All countries are flawed and beset by myriad problems, Mr. Prime Minister, including my United States, including your Turkey, and it is my firm conviction that in order to improve conditions in our countries, in every country, the freedom to speak and publish without censorship or the threat of imprisonment is a sacred right for all men and women.”

The war of words between Erdoğan and Auster kicked off after the Turkish prime minister commented on an interview the US novelist gave to a Turkish daily. “I refuse to come to Turkey because of imprisoned journalists and writers. How many are jailed now? Over 100?”Auster had said during the interview.

“American writer Paul Auster recently gave an interview to a Turkish daily. He said he refuses to travel to Turkey since he finds Turkey anti-democratic. He said he would not travel to Turkey because of jailed journalists. He said he also refuses to go to China. As if we need you! What difference would it make if you came or not? Would Turkey lose prestige?” Erdoğan said on Wednesday during a meeting of his Justice and Development Party (AK Party).

“This writer paid his most recent visit to Israel in 2010, as if Israel is a democratic, secular country where human rights are limitless. What an ignorant man you are. Israel is a religious state. Isn't Israel shelling Gaza?” Erdoğan had added.

 

 
Read Comment
25
COMMENTS
Dear Senol, very impressive.
Zahra Niknafs
Breaking news: Quote "Swedish MPs have applied to the Nobel Peace Committee to nominate jailed publisher Ragıp Zarakolu for the peace prize, daily Radikal reported today. The MPs said Zarakolu was a symbol for the freedom of press, as well as a defender of human rights. The application further menti...
migo
Can Zaman's editorial staff get over the Auster guy and use this space for some other news. We know where this guy comes from. I read it yesterday in Haaretz which described him as a jewish writer.
A. Khan
"Isn't Israel shelling Gaza?" asks Turkey's Prime Minister. Indeed it is, and much of the world deplores it! But what, might I ask, does this have to do with confirming or denying that there is free speech in Israel? Turkey's international image would be well-served by delegating foreign policy stat...
Bruce Humes
THIS REFERS TO HIS COMMENTS ABOUT CHINA,THE COUNTRY WHICH HE DOES NOT TRAVEL, THEY WONT LET YOU A PAID WRITER TO ENTER IN THEIR COUNTRY,YOU SHOULD TELL YOUR FINANCERS THAT, AMERICAN DOMESTIC LAWS CANNOT BE FORCED TO OTHER COUNTRIES, AMERICA IS DUAL PARTY SEMI AUTHORITARIAN REGIEME BOTH PARTIES FUNDE...
majid
Auster is a Jewish American author. Mr Impartial, I think not.Tell me how many Jewish journalist or writers who will not support Israel. As for his comparison to Israel, the fact that Israel is proclaimed a Jewish state, means there is hardly anyone else left who is not a Jew to be allowed to critis...
Senol
Whats the point of having freedom of speech or press if all the Journalists in Israel or the US write the same crap. Freedom is not the issue, who controls what is printed is, this is in Israel and in the USA. There is no freedom if reporters are put limits from their bossess, is it? On the other po...
Senol
LOL, who?
GeneralSherman
LOL, who?
GeneralSherman
Erodgan is jealous of what the Jews have accomplished in little Israel, plain
aha
Paul Auster's chutzpah is breath taking. If he visits Turkey, the honour would be his and not vice versa. Conversely, if he does not visit Turkey, then the LOSS would be his and NOT Turkey's. So I am sorry Paul Aster, your travelling arrangements are of no real consequence to Turkey. Feel free to do...
AbuBintain
Only selective free speech exists in Israel. You are biased Paul Auster. Please do not insult our intelligence.
AbuBintain
Would Obama care if a Turkish journalist said that he or she would not visit the US? Probably not. So why does Mr. Erdogan worry about what Auster says? Turkey is a great country, with a magnificent past and, as is becoming clearer by the day, a wonderful future. She does not need the approval of Au...
Shams
Maybe there is freedom of speech in Israel.Why do not you tell Israelis they are killers(bad ones) killing children and elderly? Print it in Jerusalem Post please. First of all the turkish PM did not say there is no freedom of speech in Israel to start with.He clearly stated that Israel is not a sec...
adnan
The true igonorance is of Mr. Erdogan who never miosses an opportunity to bash Israel. If this leader were to read any newspaper of Israel, he would understand what a true democratic state is like. It is one where if the religious are gaining too much control, the secular, who represent the majority...
michael wollman
The Name Mordechai Vanunu may not have been rung Mr PA's bell. In my view His excellency should let the deputies be engaged in the War Of Words.
ZN
Mr. Auster has dressed-down Erdogan in expert style. PM Erdogan has no defense for throwing journalists in prison. None.
Yaacov
Journalist, Generals and even Nobel Laureates and chained for just speaking out against the societal wrongs going on in the land where freedom is supposed to abide. The Kurds are Turkish citizens yet, they cannot even speak their own language boldly in public. They attacked and murdered without the ...
Chuks
Auster lives in a world of his own. Appears he never reads Israeli newspapers. Wonder how he managed to become a literary figure in America. Had never heard his name before coming across these columns. The PM should ignore a person like him. There are many other literary figures in America who know ...
A. Khan
auster has no idea what he talks about and why those journalists are in prison - and the prime minister is intimidating, threatening and scolding - nothing new in the world so - where is my cup of tea ?
tommy
Israel is shelling Gaza.. Mr. Erdogan, as usual, I am glad to see that you are very concerned about the Palestinians. by the way, when was the last time that Israel fired at Gazan civilians (January 2009), and when was the last time that Gazans fired at Israeli civilians (yesterday)?
Amit Brin
It's amazing how erogant and ignorant PM Erdogan can be. Muslim Arab MP's, journalists and writers can say almost everything they want in Israel. Religious muslims work and serve in every aspect of Israeli life. They can volunteer to the army and thousands of mslim Cherkes
Omer
@ DaniC Right! But only according civil law and not according criminal law and certainly not accompanied by being detained! If the politician can proof the issue there is usually a penalty or an apology, nothing more. Same all voer the Western world. Turks should definitely read more Israeli papers...
migo
Louis XIV: L'Etat, c'est moi. Erdoğan: Devlet, benim. In Israel criticizing the government is part of the democratic process. Members of the government can always seek justice by suing journalists and newspapers for slander and libel.
DaniC
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia: Biography - Auster was born in Newark, New Jersey,[4] to Jewish middle class parents of Polish descent, Samuel and Queenie Auster. He grew up in South Orange, New Jersey[5] and graduated from Columbia High School in adjoining Maplewood.[6] After gradu...
Ali
Click here to read all user comments
Columnists
Weather
City>>
ISTANBUL
Today Tue Wed
15C°
21C°
15C°
22C°
16C°
22C°