|  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
May 28, 2012
 
 
 
 
 
 

European Court of Human Rights orders Ankara to pay record compensation

Read Comment
18
11 January 2012 / TODAY'S ZAMAN, İSTANBUL
The European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) has ordered Turkey to pay more than 20 million euros in compensation after an allegation by 13 Cypriot nationals that the stationing of Turkish troops in the northern part of Cyprus following a 1974 intervention deprived them of their homes and properties.

Greek Cypriot Constantinos Lordos, together with 12 co-plaintiffs, filed a case with the ECtHR in 1990 after the Turkish military intervention blocked access to their properties in the district of Maras.

In its principal judgment, delivered on Nov. 2, 2010, the ECtHR ruled that the military activity had violated the right to “protection of property” of eight applicants and the right to “respect for private and family life” of a further seven.

In a judgment rendered on Jan. 10, 2012, the court awarded the applicants between 100,000 and 8,000,000 euros each for pecuniary and non-pecuniary damages, as well as a further 15,000 euros, to be shared between all applicants, for costs and expenses incurred during the process.

Following the outcome of the 2010 Demopoulos v. Turkey case, the ECtHR recognized the Immovable Property Commission, founded by the Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus (KKTC) as “an appropriate domestic body” for dealing with disputes and subsequently directed more than 1,400 cases to the commission. The court had previously ruled that decisions concerning compensation claims by Greek Cypriots that were made before the Demopoulos decision would be handled by the ECtHR. As a result, Lordos and Others v. Turkey will be the last case to be heard by the court.

As of Jan. 10, 2012, 2,801 applications have been lodged with the commission. Of these, 194 have been concluded through out-of-court settlements and seven through formal hearings. To date, the KKTC government has paid more than 77 million euros to applicants in compensation.

 
Read Comment
18
COMMENTS
Turkish Cypriots have as much of a right to ask for their properties back plus compensation. Some have done so in Cypriot courts and others have filed in The European Court Of Human Rights. I hope they are successful. Most however have relinquished their property rights to the Turkish Cypriot admini...
Sukuma
@Orhun: On 22 July 1989 a Cypriot national Mrs. Titina Loizidou filed an application against Turkey to the European Court of Human Rights. Mrs. Loizidou had been forced out of her home during Turkey's invasion of Cyprus in 1974 along with around 200,000 other Greek-Cypriots. During more than 20 year...
Alkis
Many thanks to all those comments which proved without shadow of a doubt that there are Human Rights for the Greek Cypriots and there are no Human Rights for the Turkish Cypriots no matter how much land they have lost or how many suffered and died in the hands of Greek Fascists. Irrespective of whic...
Ali
@Alkis. It has not taken 7 years for Turkey to comply. No compensation is due or payable until the legal process has fully run its course -- this is Turkey's right, even Italy does it. It has just finished and they will be paid. Trust me, almost every country pays once the process fully runs out bec...
Orhun
Evangelos Florakis naval base and Vasiliko power plant are both built on Turkish Cypriot land. Also, Baf and Larnaka airport build on partly Turkish Cypriot owned land. How much that will be when it comes to ECHR?
RebelJim
Ali, You say that you have land on the Greek side, but you have not recieved any compensation? When did you file your complaint and claim to the ECHR?
Sit on hands
"an allegation by 13 Cypriot nationals that the stationing of Turkish troops in the northern part of Cyprus following a 1974 intervention deprived them of their homes and properties"... allegedly I was 3 years old and the Turkish planes were bombing Pentadaktylos burning the forests around us. Alleg...
Kyproleon
DutchTurk. You have not understand anything obviously. One has courts to settle disputes. If you are of a certain opinion, feel free to submit a claim to the court. Today Turkey and other civilised countries are ruled by law.
Rule of law
@Ali - if you are an RoC citizen, then you have the ability for restitution through the Cypriot Courts in the Republic of Cyprus. That is why the ECHR does not get involved. If you choose not to be a RoC citizen then this is why there will be no compensation coming your way.
Mark
Turkey should not pay a penny unless the Greek Cypriots pay compensation for the civilian men, women and children they massacred ahead of the Turkish intervention on the Island!!! If Greek Cypriots want their properties, they should migrate to the Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus. Same for the T...
DutchTurk
Human Rights for Greek Cypriots who lost property in Turkish Controlled North Cyprus and NO Human Rights for Turkish Cypriots who lost property in the Greek controlled South Cyprus. And all you good people who commented think this is fair?
Ali
Can similar-to-European Court of Human Rights orders Israel to pay record compensation to Palestinian by ruling that the military activity had violated the right to “protection of property” of thousands applicants and the right to “respect for private and family life” of a further thousands?
Inke
I have land in the Greek controlled south Cyprus worth about 2 million which the Greeks have been using exclusively since 1974 and I have not received a penny. Who is going to compensate me and the other Turkish Cypriots whose lands and homes have been taken over by the Greeks in the south Cyprus si...
Ali
It took 7 years for Mrs Loizidou to receive the ruled compensation from Turkey. Turkey ignores the decisions held by the ECHR in a very arrogant way, and it takes sometimes more then 10 years to comply. I hope that Mr Erdogan's current government will show the appropriate respect and compliance with...
alkis
Why Turkey still keeps its troops in N.Cyprus anyway? Who needs them nowadays and who's going to attack Turkish Cypriots if these troops withdraw?
Rhetorical questions
The difference is that the ECtHR makes the judgement out of 0 understanding of property value in KKTC, if the existing cases reach the verdict of paying compensation the KKTC will probably make the verdict based on current property value (market value) some smaller compensation. Also I am pretty s...
Halis
It's a shame that it takes ECHR rulings to get Turkey to do the right things on Cyprus, but there it is. As for the IPC, they have settled less than one case for every 14 cases initiated, which shows that Turkey is not serious about providing monetary settlements for property damages to Greek Cyprio...
Christoph
The last section was interesting QUOTE "As of Jan. 10, 2012, 2,801 applications have been lodged with the commission. Of these, 194 have been concluded through out-of-court settlements and seven through formal hearings. To date, the KKTC government has paid more than 77 million euros to applicants i...
Did I understand this right?
Click here to read all user comments
Columnists
Weather
City>>
ISTANBUL
Today Tue Wed
15C°
21C°
15C°
22C°
16C°
22C°