Why is Jordan special for Turkey?
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
19 May 2013 Sunday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 25 February 2013, Monday 13 0 0 0
ABDULLAH BOZKURT
a.bozkurt@todayszaman.com

Why is Jordan special for Turkey?

Turkey and Jordan are two countries in the Middle East that were unlucky in terms of vast oil and gas reserves. That may be a blessing in disguise, however, as both economies have had to rely on developing human potential via entrepreneurship, innovative skills and educational investment in order to grow in a turbulent region. Good stewardship is required as well for the leadership teams of both countries to navigate the troubled waters often stirred up by the waves of sectarian rifts, extremism and territorial issues. Both Turkey and Jordan long for the settlement of the Palestinian-Israeli problem and the successful conclusion of the Arab Spring revolutions. They fear the looming threat of a region-wide Shiite-Sunni confrontation simply because they have a vested interest in stability to continue trading and to keep the price of energy and food staples in check.

Unlike Turkey, which has a growing economy with robust macroeconomic indicators and a well-functioning democracy, Jordan has recently been challenged by economic difficulties from rising food and energy prices as well as demands for political reform on the home front. That makes it even more important for Turkey to link up strongly with Jordan to maintain peace in what has proved to be an island of stability in a tough environment. Jordan is a small Arab state but offers great opportunities for Turkey, one of the three non-Arab countries in the Middle East in addition to Iran and Israel.

Why makes Jordan so special to Turkey? Well, first of all, both Turkey and Jordan share common concerns over Iranian expansionism in the Middle East, which has successfully exploited Shiite ideology and the Palestine problem to advance Persian national interests. The mullah regime has hijacked issues that are deemed very sensitive to Muslim communities across the region without offering anything substantial on the constructive resolution of any of these issues. Ankara and Amman have a stake in seeing Iran put a stop to the proxy battles that it has been waging to destabilize countries.

Secondly, the two-year-long Syrian crisis has really been testing both countries with a number of problems that are not so easy to tackle. In contrast to other countries, both Turkey and Jordan have received hundreds of thousands of Syrian refugees who fled the violence in the Arab country. The number is expected to climb further, costing the economies of both countries. But more importantly, as the Syrian crisis is lingering longer than originally anticipated, the social fabric of both countries, especially in areas bordering Syria, is increasingly exposed to security risks, unsettling the fault lines in the respective societies. It is not surprising to see that both Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan and Jordan's King Abdullah II have huge disdain for US President Barack Obama at the moment because they feel that the US shied away from its regional responsibility and abandoned its allies in the region to handle the Syrian crisis alone.

Thirdly, both Turkey and Jordan, sharing borders with Iraq, are interested in seeing a stable Iraq free of sectarian strife. As the Iraqi economy is reeling from years of occupation and civil war, both Turkey and Jordan have helped the Iraqi government rebuild the country's infrastructure while supplying much-needed goods through their territories. King Abdullah II was the first Arab leader to pay a visit to Baghdad in 2008, followed by Erdoğan a year later. However Iraqi Shiite Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki's sharp turn towards sectarian policies after the last elections have marginalized the country's Sunni and Kurdish groups as well as Shiites who are not aligned with the pro-Iranian policies of Maliki. This was met with great concern by both Ankara and Amman.

Fourthly, the impact of moderation in Turkish and Jordanian societies in the Middle East is immensely important as a bulwark against the spread of fanaticism and radicalism that exploit the religious sensitivities of the people. Turkey has proven to be successful in bringing its own model by emphasizing the centuries-long tradition of a spiritual Sufi interpretation of Islam. Since this experience emphasizes that Muslims should focus on improving themselves with an inner-oriented approach, this stands in contrast with the radical Wahhabi/Salafi ideology which most Turks greatly loathe.

Jordan's rulers, coming from a prominent Arab Muslim dynasty called the Hashemites, who were the protectors of the holy sites of Mecca and Medina until the Wahhabis captured Western Arabia in the early 20th century, are the traditional enemies of Wahhabis. If the Hashemites still ruled these places, we would probably not have witnessed the destruction of the rich Islamic and Turkish cultural heritage in and around these holy sites. A significant portion of Jordanian society has a huge dislike for Wahhabis/Salafis as well. It is no wonder that al-Qaeda and other terrorist organizations do not like Turkey and Jordan, the two Muslim countries that have good relations with the West and a working relationship with Israel, albeit bumpy at times. Jordanian intelligence services have considerable experience in cracking down on al-Qaeda cells and can really help Turkey improve its capacity in fighting against these groups in places where Turkey has invested a lot in, from Africa to Central Asia.

Turkey may return the favor by spending some of the political capital it has earned in recent years with the Muslim Brotherhood, whose branches in Jordan pose some challenges for the authorities there. It is no doubt that the Muslim Brotherhood elements in Jordan have been emboldened by the political developments in Egypt and the civil war in Syria. The question remains whether the Muslim Brotherhood in Jordan will subscribe to moderation and show a willingness to compromise. The Egyptian experience raises many question marks in the minds of many in the Middle East.

Having thrown a $2 billion lifeline to the battered Egyptian economy, Turkey may channel some of its influence on the Brotherhood through President Mohammed Morsi. Ankara has also cultivated some ties with Hamas in recent years in an effort to drive a wedge between Hamas and Iran. It has strong relations with the Syrian Muslim Brotherhood. To what extent Turkey can exert influence, if any, on the Jordanian Brotherhood through these external channels is an open question. But Ankara may very well try to deliver some results on behalf of King Abdullah II.

How the Muslim Brotherhood will shape the policies in the region in general and in Jordan in particular is the main concern in the king's mind at the moment. In an interview with Turkish Policy Quarterly academic journal in March 2012, King Abdullah said that the people in the Arab Spring countries are more concerned that the values of moderation, respect for liberties and pluralism be upheld than they are with supporting any particular political party. If it is any indication, the endorsement given by Ankara to the Jordanian parliamentary elections held on Jan. 23 despite the decision by the Brotherhood to boycott them must be read as Ankara's support of the king. The Turkish Ministry of Foreign Affairs' statement underlining the importance of economic and political reform in Jordan is perfectly in line with the king's position.

The fifth point in bilateral relations touches on economic cooperation between Turkey and Jordan, which has important regional ramifications. Since both governments signed a free trade agreement while scrapping visa requirements at the same time in December 2009, trade ties have flourished. Trade volume between the two countries stood at $838 million in 2012, an increase of 53 percent over 2011's figure, which was $549 million.

Jordanians see Turkey as a success story in economic growth and want to replicate the Turkish experience. For Turkey, Jordan is important for the diversification of its trade routes. Jordan's Port of Aqaba, the second-largest container port on the Red Sea, may be an important hub for Turkey to gain access to markets in Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) countries as well as other markets through the Indian Ocean using this route.

Lastly, there are a significant number of Circassian communities in both countries, and many officials in public administration on both sides, especially in the military and security fields, are Circassian. They are loyal and hardworking people with a keen interest in maintaining their cultural heritage. This can serve as a common social link between the two countries.

All in all, Jordan is an important Arab country that has always maintained good relations with Turkey. Ankara should invest political, economic and social capital to protect this island of stability in the Middle East. King Abdullah's upcoming visit to Turkey in March should be utilized to turn what seem to be excellent ideas of cooperation into concrete action plans.

COMMENTS
@Yusuf, who are the "The Gulf club"?
treble
The regional alignment as far as King Abdalla II is concerned is rather Turkey, Qatar, New Egypt and Gaza tearing down the order of things so painstakingly maintained by The Gulf Club plus Jordan, Morocco and the PA, the latter three as financial wards of the club in exchange for their security se...
Yusuf
Jordan is so special to Turkey because it takes in more refugees that would otherwise drain the Turkish resources.
Mark
You need to grammar and spell check your post.
KarayOfCrimea
@R.Wells, last time i checked, was said i'm not an Arab(with respect to Arabs). How did you come up with "Turkey and Jordan are two arab,,,"?,who told you, that Turks are Arabs? = Wrong. Makes me tremble, when Turkey is compared with even Jordan.
treble
@Observer and what is problem if traffic is going through Israel? It is being good for peace. I am sure Mr. Bozkurt is supporting traffic through Israel.
Ramesh
abdullah bozkurt is an excellent and fearless writer. he is not afraid to support israel against iran and other muslim entities. the international community should support more writers like him in the muslim world.
jeevan
Ever since the relations soured between Turkey and Syria and Turkey and Iraq, most of the traffic between Turkey and Jordan is passing through Israeli ports and Israeli airspace. Just sayin'...
Observer
Turkey and Jordan are two arab successs stories.
R.Wells
Soon Turkish khayrollahs ,Abdullahs ,Saadullah ,Hamdullah Shukrullahs , will gets Iranian weapons too,only more up to date ...
Abu Jassem
Abdi Buzi , I'm sure you have had a bad memory with an Iranian when you were a kid :D
Soren
Yes Ramesh, US should stop sending weapons to Isreal if we want peace.
Osman
Iran is sending weapons to Palestinians and Hezbollah so they can fight against Israel. In last Gaza war Hamas was firing Iranian Fajr rockets into Israel causing lots of damage. If we are wanting peace then it is essential to be putting a stop to this transfer of weapons.
Ramesh
Click here to read all user comments
Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
17 May 2013
EU's stake in Turkey's judicial council
13 May 2013
What to expect from Obama-Erdoğan meeting
10 May 2013
How Turkey's deputy PM saved the Israeli-Turkish deal
6 May 2013
ECtHR, freedom of assembly and May Day in Turkey
3 May 2013
Get out of jail free card for bid-rigging in Turkey
29 April 2013
PKK's venomous mouthpiece targets US, Gülen
26 April 2013
Iran's clandestine operations in Turkey
22 April 2013
Turkey deserves 2020 Olympics Games
19 April 2013
Concerns over Turkey's new petroleum law
15 April 2013
French socialist's unfair report on Turkey
12 April 2013
Turkey should tread carefully on Palestine issue
8 April 2013
US-Russian deal to impact Turkey's role in Central Asia
5 April 2013
Legal woes for Turkish energy firms in Iraq
1 April 2013
Turkish railways and EU
29 March 2013
Turkey, Cyprus and ENI fallout
25 March 2013
Apology and Middle East politics
22 March 2013
Terrorism toll on Turkey
18 March 2013
Turkey, world trade and top WTO post
15 March 2013
UNHCR's Guterres on the Syrian refugee crisis
11 March 2013
Why Sweden is going strategic with Turkey
8 March 2013
Competition as Turkey goes nuclear
4 March 2013
Zionism debated by Turkey, US and Israel
1 March 2013
Energy plays in Turkey's ties with US and Iraq
25 February 2013
Why is Jordan special for Turkey?
22 February 2013
Iran plays al-Qaeda figure to pit Turkey against US
18 February 2013
Violence and freedom of expression in Turkey
15 February 2013
France courts better ties with Turkey
11 February 2013
US Ambassador Ricciardone's blunder
8 February 2013
Why is Turkey sending its navy to Somalia?
4 February 2013
US response to embassy attack
1 February 2013
Engaging in Africa without challenging others
21 January 2013
Steps to align Turkey with ECtHR
18 January 2013
Whistleblower reveals foreign policy blunders in Turkey
14 January 2013
Turkey and hydrocarbons in Iraq
11 January 2013
The PKK bookkeeper and cover-up
7 January 2013
Turkey's security deals with partner nations
4 January 2013
DPG's challenge to secret US-Iran talks on Afghanistan
31 December 2012
US secret talks with Iran over Afghanistan
28 December 2012
New tool to promote trade
24 December 2012
Sudan and South Sudan: indispensable partners for Turkey
21 December 2012
Failure of new constitution in Turkey
17 December 2012
Turkey tightens vise on tax havens
14 December 2012
Turkey to help secure Af-Pak border
10 December 2012
Turkey, Hungary should do more
7 December 2012
Last act for Assad
3 December 2012
Turkey's golden story with Iran
30 November 2012
Connecting Turks and Emiratis
26 November 2012
Israel's legal woes in Palestine
23 November 2012
Turkey's new plan on Cyprus property disputes
19 November 2012
Turkey should arm the opposition in Syria
16 November 2012
Turkey's high hopes for Africa
12 November 2012
Turkey, Brunei offer promising partnership
9 November 2012
Turkey slacking on combating terrorism financing
5 November 2012
Fouling up press freedom in Turkey
2 November 2012
Rapprochement with Israel unlikely
29 October 2012
Phone call that disrupted Turkey's ties with Iraq
22 October 2012
Future of Afghanistan and Turkey's role
18 October 2012
De-coupling fears for Turkey-Russia ties over Syria
15 October 2012
Iran to turn ECO into paper organization
12 October 2012
The pro-war lobby rallies in Turkey
8 October 2012
EU ‘regress report' 2012
5 October 2012
New mandate needed for diplomats, not military
1 October 2012
Elections and a swelling budget in Turkey
28 September 2012
Convention speech and Erdoğan's dream
24 September 2012
Iran prime culprit for slashed hajj quotas
21 September 2012
Role of Iran and Syria in THKP/C terrorism against Turkey
17 September 2012
Early warning for Muslim bashing
14 September 2012
Campaign to repatriate stolen Turkish artifacts
9 September 2012
Iran's terror and trade war against Turkey
7 September 2012
Turkey hails Egypt's comeback
3 September 2012
Turkey's management of Syrian refugee crisis
31 August 2012
Germany playing dangerous game with Muslims
27 August 2012
Turkey's Myanmar policy
24 August 2012
Prosecuting Syrians in Turkish courts
17 August 2012
Wait on Syria, push for Kandil
13 August 2012
New page in Syria
10 August 2012
Countering Iran's threat
6 August 2012
Iran Spring and Turkey
3 August 2012
Turkey to shape Syrian army in post-Assad era
30 July 2012
The new CHP vigor for Turkish politics
27 July 2012
Turkey's play with Syrian Kurds
6 July 2012
Scorecard for Turkey's AK Party since election victory
2 July 2012
Turkey and Arab anxiety
29 June 2012
Iran, Syria to target Turkish troops in Lebanon
25 June 2012
Is Turkey itching for war with Syria?
22 June 2012
Sledgehammer case and ECtHR
18 June 2012
EU presidency of Greek Cyprus: Coming of age or falling from grace
15 June 2012
Neutered Ombudsman Law
11 June 2012
Profiling Erdoğan through the eyes of a confidant
8 June 2012
Whistleblowers and secret recordings in Turkey
4 June 2012
Cost of Syrian crisis to Turkish economy
1 June 2012
THY and union zealots
28 May 2012
The legacy of the Mexican presidency of the G-20
25 May 2012
Turkey and Mexico: Distant yet so close
21 May 2012
İşbank and the CHP
18 May 2012
Erbakan's legacy and gas deal with Iran
14 May 2012
EU-Turkey fundamentals: How strong are they?
11 May 2012
Germany must come clean on neo-Nazi murders
7 May 2012
Davutoğlu's record on parliamentary queries
4 May 2012
Turkish concern over specter of Alawite state in Syria
...