Is Turkey's EU membership declining in importance?
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
18 May 2013 Saturday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 11 December 2012, Tuesday 10 0 0 0
BÜLENT KENEŞ
b.kenes@todayszaman.com

Is Turkey's EU membership declining in importance?

It is very likely for Turkey's European Union membership bid to gain new steam with Greek Cypriots handing over the EU term presidency to Ireland on Jan. 1, 2013. That former French President Nicolas Sarkozy, known for his anti-Turkey stance, has been taken out of the equation is another factor that will provide additional steam to this process.

But, sadly enough, Turkey's EU membership is no longer received as enthusiastically by the Turkish public as it was in the past. Turkey's booming self-confidence, thanks to the country's good economic performance in recent years, it appears, has made a significant portion of the public feel no need for the EU membership process. But is this really the case? Do we no longer need the EU? I do not think so.

As a matter of fact, the main driving force behind Turkey's economic development is the sheer volume of its trade with EU member countries. Moreover, I believe Turkey's economic, political and social reform and renovation processes have been and are being undertaken with the enthusiasm and courage offered by its EU membership perspective. It is a historical reality that when the country's EU membership bid languishes, Turkey's determination and resolve to make reforms and tackle the critical issues wanes simultaneously. Unlike what some short-sighted leaders believe, just as the EU needs Turkey in order to boost its strategic and political potential, Turkey is in need of the EU membership, or at least the continuation of the membership process, in order to solve its problems and emerge as a peaceful, prosperous and stable country.

But it appears that a significant portion of Turkey's public does not agree with me. Surveys suggest they have lost their enthusiasm in this regard. The "Europe Perceptions" survey, recently conducted by Boğaziçi University's Center for European Studies reveals how Turkey's perceptions of the EU have radically changed since 2003. This survey unfortunately pinpoints an increasing alienation of the Turkish public from the EU bid and, in a sense, offers an explanation for why Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, known to change his policies depending on the results of the frequent opinion polls he sponsors, has for some time been refraining from making any reference to the EU membership process. This change in the popular perceptions, largely attributable to the detrimental effects of Sarkozy and German Chancellor Angela Merkel's collective efforts on the process, must be reverted. In this context, both political and social leaders in Turkey and European leaders have major responsibilities.

According to the above-mentioned survey, the rate of Turks who have positive perceptions of the EU has fallen from 69.3 percent in 2003 to 47.1 percent this year. The decline of the EU as a political union has also correlated with a negative impact on the popular perceptions of about Europe in general. The rate of Turkish citizens who consider Turkey as geographically part of Europe has decreased from 70 to 46 percent.

Despite the fact that Europe used to be perceived as a haven for freedoms -- even for religious life and rights -- 64 percent of Turkish citizens today nurture the concern that Turkey's EU membership may undermine religious values and spoil the youth's morality. This indicates an at least 10-percent increase from ten years ago. The rate of Turkish citizens who say, "EU membership will result in Turkey's partition” has risen from 41.8 percent in 2003 to 54 percent today. And those who believe Turkey will never become a member of the EU represent 32 percent of the people interviewed. Twenty-one percent, on the other hand, believe Turkey's membership will not occur during their lifetime. Furthermore, since 2003, the rate of the Turkish citizens who would say “yes” to a referendum for EU membership has dramatically declined from 74.4 percent to 51 percent. Although many Europeans fear Turks would flock to the EU if Turkey becomes a member, the survey finds only 14 percent of Turkish citizens plan to move to a European country in case of membership.

This picture invariably tells us one thing: both Turkey and the EU are on the brink of missing a historic chance. Despite the fact that Turkey's EU membership is capable of bridging the gap between the East and West, Islam and Christianity, Asia and Europe and the North and the South, the survey sadly unmasks the sociopolitical basis for this membership is diminishing. This decline in popular enthusiasm to join the EU, largely attributable to certain European leaders' lacking strategic vision and their insistence on furthering their personal short-term and populist interests, is paving the way for major damages, the price of which will be paid by future generations. These leaders who have smothered the enthusiasm mutually felt for Turkey's EU membership must quickly take some actions to re-ignite it. In particularly, France has this chance with President François Hollande at its helm, and whether it will make the best out of this opportunity is yet to be seen. I hope Germany quickly evolves into this position with or without Merkel.

In this context, the message the Nobel Committee sent to the EU about Turkey's significance during the Nobel Prize ceremony must be harkened by everyone. As he was extending the Nobel Peace Prize to the EU leaders, the head of the Nobel Committee, Thorbjørn Jagland, underlined that Turkey is crucial to peace in the Middle East and across the world. Although the original text of his speech did not include it, Jagland inserted several sentences into his speech to stress the importance of the developments in Turkey for world peace. It is extremely significant that this message was given at a ceremony attended by Merkel, Hollande, leaders of all EU member countries excluding the UK, President of the European Council Herman van Rompuy, President of the European Commission Jose Manuel Barroso and European Parliament President Martin Schulz.

Jagland, who is also the secretary-general of the Council of Europe, stressed that the aim of EU membership had provided Turkey a guideline for reform. Stressing that reforms have strengthened Turkey's democracy, Jagland said success in the process was very important for both the Middle East and the world as a whole. “After the new government, headed by the [Justice and Development Party] AKP, won a clear parliamentary majority, the aim of EU membership provided a guideline for the process of reform in Turkey. There can be no doubt that this has contributed to strengthening the development of democracy there. This benefits Europe, but success in this respect is also important to developments in the Middle East, and therefore also for world peace,” said Jagland.

It is our hope that certain EU member countries and leaders that have prevented the opening of about half of 35 chapters Turkey should have been opened as part of its membership negotiations with the EU will lend an ear to this call for the sake of the regional and world peace.

 

COMMENTS
RebelJim - which version of the Annan Plan did you read? I dont think you have actually read it at all judging by your statement.
Mark
Turkey and Europe ? hmmmmmm.Like Black and white , Fire and water , ... Continue your attempts.Maybe they let you in in 3013.:P
Soren
Ditto Rebel, I agree. If Turkey did not use her guarantor state rights to intervene, the Greeks would wipe the Turks off Cyprus in 1974. They still would do, the moment Turkish military left Cyprus! Greeks massacred thousands of civilian Turks in Cyprus within weeks! I know Turkish Cypriot friends w...
Zach S
Turkey remains in violation of UN Resolution 550 over it's illegal Cyprus occupation. Until that's addressed there is no reason to be optimistic about EU accession. The EU doesn't want members who violate international law.
Joachim Weiskopf
James Shawcross@ Well known for his Anti Turkish views. It was Greeks who rejected Annan plan. Plan was going to reunified Cyprus, remove Turkish troops, and allow 100.000 Greeks Cypriots to return to TRNC.
RebelJim
As you mentioned in the article, Turkey and the EU are on the brink of missing a historic chance. Very good summary of the story. You are right. I don't think AKP is (seems) caring much about the membership. But the history says the other way. Ottoman looked at to the west all the time whenever they...
Alp
Hey James buddy. Turkey doesn't care about EU membership. We will not take orders from anyone! No one in the EU gives a damn about Greek concerns right now.
Eric Turk
Turkey has always known that Europeans have been sceptical for Turkish membership, and yet Turkey continued to insist on candidature for membership with pressure from the US.
O.Goldman
As long as the Turkish army occupies northern Cyprus in defiance of UN resolutions and international law there is zero chance that Turkey can join the EU. Cyprus needs to be reunified as a democratic sovereign state, the current partition fully dismantled and the occupying Turkish troops to leave th...
James Shawcross
The most important thing we can obtain from EU is support to improve ourselves, which in turn will not only make Turkey a better country for the Turks, but also support our companies and economy. So what we can improve with the support from EU are areas such as: Corruption, Human rights, womens' rig...
bobek
Click here to read all user comments
Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
14 May 2013
Mr. Erdoğan goes to Washington
12 May 2013
Do we know this language? To what extent?
9 May 2013
Religious and sectarian wars in the Middle East
7 May 2013
5 years ago, 40 years after
30 April 2013
Concrete civilization
25 April 2013
The way to cope with radicalism, extremism
23 April 2013
Can Turkey overcome its bad luck in EU membership process?
21 April 2013
Fear of radicalism in Syria: the self-fulfilling prophecy
18 April 2013
Why is the GYV statement on press freedom significant?
16 April 2013
Role of NGOs in democratization, demilitarization, conflict resolution (2)
14 April 2013
Role of NGOs in democratization, demilitarization, conflict resolution (1)
11 April 2013
Turkey and Azerbaijan on converging paths
2 April 2013
Choreography of the settlement process
28 March 2013
Germany running the neo-Nazi and racist gauntlet
26 March 2013
The New Middle East
21 March 2013
Glad tidings for a colorful spring, and concerns
19 March 2013
Borders and limits
14 March 2013
The effect of ‘soft power' on Turkey's rapid development
10 March 2013
There is no Kurdish issue in Turkey!
7 March 2013
What's the situation in the talks with the PKK?
5 March 2013
Öcalan invests in the post-İmralı era
22 January 2013
What does the aborted attack against the İzmit church tell us?
20 January 2013
İshak Alaton's letter to TÜSİAD
17 January 2013
Theses on PKK members assassinated in Paris
15 January 2013
World's most famous Turkish brand: Today's Zaman
10 January 2013
Risks facing İmralı process
8 January 2013
But which PKK?
6 January 2013
Hope and caution necessary in talks with PKK
3 January 2013
Not funny in the least!
1 January 2013
Demirel, psychological warfare and media
30 December 2012
Assessment of a year
27 December 2012
Cyprus under siege: analysis
25 December 2012
Cyprus under siege: predictions
23 December 2012
Cyprus under siege: observations
20 December 2012
Yearning for unchecked and unbalanced power
16 December 2012
Ergenekon alive and operational
11 December 2012
Is Turkey's EU membership declining in importance?
9 December 2012
Alienation of Turkey's Kurds
6 December 2012
Egypt, Morsi and democracy
2 December 2012
The coup commission's praiseworthy performance
29 November 2012
'Not enough, but yes' to elimination of school uniforms
27 November 2012
History, art and power
22 November 2012
The other side of the coin: Hamas
20 November 2012
Israeli aggression and 'new circumstances in the Mideast'
18 November 2012
Israel's right to kill!
15 November 2012
Israel's right to self-defense!
13 November 2012
A massacre that is becoming ordinary in the insensitive eyes of the world
11 November 2012
Turkey's place: the East or the West?
8 November 2012
‘Can Turkey shoulder the responsibility of being a model country?'
6 November 2012
The choice of the US people and the world
4 November 2012
Rising Anatolia
30 October 2012
Through patience, it seems, our republic is evolving into a democracy
11 October 2012
Why are we angry at our EU snapshot?
9 October 2012
Civilian supervision of military a must, but how to do it?
4 October 2012
We must stop seeing Azerbaijan purely as a source of oil and natural gas
2 October 2012
Has Turkey already abandoned its EU vision?
30 September 2012
AKP congress and R2P from Davutoğlu's perspective
27 September 2012
Who is the real hero that stopped the Balyoz coup?
25 September 2012
Quo vadis Turkey?
23 September 2012
Balyoz verdict and the future of coup culture
20 September 2012
Democracy, tolerance and forbearance
18 September 2012
The prep courses debate and Erdoğan's real intentions
16 September 2012
Muhammad, Jesus and Moses are our revered values
13 September 2012
Is it freedom of expression or a hate crime?
6 September 2012
I have good news for newspapers!
4 September 2012
Speaking out in hard times
30 August 2012
Media's 'Kony's and child abuse
28 August 2012
Can Morsi's historic Iran visit be seen as a sign of a shift of axis?
9 August 2012
Cold War with Iran
5 August 2012
Has the coup threat been averted yet?
2 August 2012
Ibn Khaldun’s lessons on politics for leaders
31 July 2012
Nizam al-Mülk’s advice for today’s leaders
29 July 2012
Afghanistanization risk in Syria
26 July 2012
Islam, Islamic and Islamism
24 July 2012
Arakan: a big massacre witnessed by the insensitive world
22 July 2012
When will Ankara change its thesis about the downed F-4?
19 July 2012
‘Assad struck at the heart’
15 July 2012
Rule of the executive
12 July 2012
All Muslims, like Turks, don’t see contradiction between democracy and Islam
10 July 2012
Turks prioritize economy or democracy?
5 July 2012
Is Iran's nuclear program peaceful?
1 July 2012
Clutching at straws with Syria
28 June 2012
One correct and one wrong move
24 June 2012
Turkish-Syrian tension and Abant platform
21 June 2012
Kurds’ PKK issue
19 June 2012
The PKK issue must be settled once and for all
17 June 2012
Syrian deadlock’s blow to Egypt
14 June 2012
A rift between the Hizmet movement and the AKP?
12 June 2012
First year of AKP’s third term
5 June 2012
Focus is on serving humanity, not only promoting Turkish
3 June 2012
Those who are not part of the solution to the Syrian crisis are part of the problem
31 May 2012
PM gives glad tidings to subversive generals!
29 May 2012
Red suitcase, honorable commander(s) and others
27 May 2012
What befell Niyazi-i Misri in the past is happening to Fethullah Gülen now
22 May 2012
The role of civil society in Turkey's democratization
20 May 2012
If democracy had ever come, it wouldn't have gone away!
15 May 2012
How has resource-low South Korea ended up the world’s 13th-largest economy?
13 May 2012
Yes to presidential system if...
10 May 2012
Erdoğan, military coups and public opinion
8 May 2012
New realities coming out of ballot boxes
...