Turks and Kurds: Yearning for a new republic?
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
25 May 2013 Saturday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 19 September 2012, Wednesday 17 0 0 0
SUAT KINIKLIOĞLU
s.kiniklioglu@todayszaman.com

Turks and Kurds: Yearning for a new republic?

Months of Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK) terrorism have tired this country. The human and material losses of the fight against the PKK continue to take their toll on our social fabric.

We should beware of provocative acts from all sides that want to ignite communal violence. Thanks to the wisdom of most Kurds and Turks there is still adequate desire to live together in this country. The PKK is trying hard to break the psychological bond between the two peoples, but it is not working. That said, the daily violence also reminds us that the Kurdish issue is still not settled.

What do the Kurds want? The answer is simple. They want to become normal citizens of this country. They do not want any privileges granted to them. They want equal citizenship rights enshrined in the constitution. In other words they want a new republic -- a republic where they are also a founding element. They are beyond the squabbles of whether three hours of elective Kurdish courses would suffice or not. They want to live together on equal terms.

The general perception among the Kurds is that this country's conservatives obtained their rights from the authoritarian/Kemalist state. They acknowledge that the Justice and Development Party (AK Party) was successful in suppressing the deep state and Ergenekon mentality to a level where some sort of civilian democracy prevailed. That said, they feel that the AK Party government is not willing to grant them their natural rights as equal citizens and thus view the democratization process begun in 2002 as incomplete. This is important as it has created considerable frustration and disappointment among the Kurds. They feel that the Kurdish opening in 2009-2010 was badly managed and had no strategic vision of what the end result should be.

The Peace and Democracy Party (BDP) has very much discredited itself as a credible actor on the issue. The recent violent process and statements made by some BDP members have opened deep scars in the Turkish psyche. In the region there is also a new development as Hizbullah is forming a new party. This is likely to complicate the regional setting even further. Friends who know the region well tell me that such a party could pose a challenge to both the BDP and the AK Party.

There is by now wide consensus that the PKK issue and the Kurdish issue are two different sets of issues. Even the most benign and liberal Kurdish thinkers acknowledge that there has to be a military response to the physical threat the PKK poses. Certain parts of the PKK obviously have developed client relationships that are motivated by a set of diverse regional political and economic interests. Given the large reserves of oil and gas in Iraq, the regional game in the name of the Kurds is increasingly becoming part of a great game about energy resources. The sheer predictions for energy reserves in Iraq as well as our considerable dependency on energy imports will necessitate a more energy-related discourse on the Kurds.

The fundamental question remains: How can we institute a workable democratic order where we can live together? Such a strategy should have two simultaneous dimensions. First, a strong and robust specialized anti-terror capacity must be formed within the armed forces. This force should have an offensive strategy rather than a defensive one and should haunt the terror cells wherever they are. We should take the fight to the PKK -- not wait for them to strike at Turkish targets. That said, a simultaneous opening in the form of a new constitution should proceed. Here, a coalition between Turkey's conservatives, Kurds and liberal/democrats should be the fundamental base supporting it. This is easier said than done. But this is exactly where the AK Party has a historic opportunity. The leadership and political majority the AK Party enjoys are crucial in furthering such a process. Turks and Kurds will live together when they are on an equal footing and see themselves as founding elements of a new republic. What began in 2002 must continue now.

COMMENTS
Baran, I take the time and check my evidence before posting. I try not to post "pseudo-evidence". Sorry but not convinced about your forced conscription argument. Yes, military service is compulsory, but how many Kurds have been taken in by the police? And if they are in against their will, why don'...
Baris
Baris, I am sorry if I have wrongfully called you an apologist due to the pseudo-evidence you present in your comments. For the sake of brevity, I will address your concerns in different comments. Firstly, yes Turkish police and gendarmes will round up any young male citizen of Turkey -Turk, Kurd, A...
Baran
Baris, thirdly you speak of the fact that many Kurds voted for AK Party and you are right –for the wrong reasons. As usual, the devil is in the details where all cards are stacked against the Kurdish citizens to deprive them of freedom and equality! BDP did NOT contest the election because its lead...
Baran
Baris, secondly you often mention village guards -Kurds recruited by Turkish state to fight the PKK, just the way Ottoman Sultans did. In the 1980’s, Turkish state agents approached Kurdish village, tribal and religious leaders with a very compelling message: “Remember Dersim, remember Zilan and do...
Baran
Baran, of course the Kurds deserve freedom and equality but there's no need for guns for that. I have often criticised Turkey for its policy towards the Kurds. Until you criticise the PKK for their terror, such as the suicide bomber Nazli Gorer, the bombs in Gungoren and Kumrular, the 4 Girls in Sii...
Baris
Baris, as an apologist for Turkish state terror and intimidation, you are simply unwilling to see the wood for the trees -and vice versa! Kurdish citizens yearn for freedom and equality. They have the same aspirations as Turkish citizens do. Turkish state is determined to deprive the Kurds of freedo...
Baran
Thank you, Sid, for telling it like it is! Sadly, many Turks write but cannot read comments like yours.
Aziz
Religion alone cannot be the only uniting force in such complicated affairs as state building and co-existence of different nations in the same borders. There are many other factors of historical and cultural character that tend not to unite but, on the contrary, divide the neighboring peoples with ...
pinecone
"Methinks, the yearning is for TWO separate and equal republics! ... Through peaceful and democratic means, of course.". Yes Baran, just like the peaceful and democratic means of your "heroic freedom fighters". You are the biggest apologist for the terrorist PKK, and then you talk about peaceful and...
Baris
Turkey should grant the same rights demanded for Turkish Cypriots to Kurds. ie.federal state and rotating presidency. A bizonal,bicommunal federation of Turkey with defined borders for the two states and live side by side in peace.This is what they demand in Cyprus.
Sid
Methinks, the yearning is for TWO separate and equal republics! ... Through peaceful and democratic means, of course. Your preaching of more systematic and better organized violence against citizens starved of freedom and equality is foolish. It is only in the best interest of those profiteering fro...
Baran
And the is :The Islamic republic of ANATOL .Is the name...
Esfandyar
I am also a kurdish-turk and I totally agree with Yavuz. Well written Yavuz!
Osman F
Methinks, the yearning is for TWO separate and equal republics! ... Through peaceful and democratic means, of course. Your preaching of more systematic and better organized violence against citizens starved of freedom and equality is foolish. It is only in the best interest of those profiteering fro...
Baran
thanks for the article, as a matter of fact, that's what we want
idris
I like the article as you give a good insight. The Kurds in Turkey certainly feel that when the republic was formed it was not inclusive. Before anything else--just as you state-- the Kurdish rights should become explicitely enshrined in the Turkish constitution. Now some of the conservatives might ...
Shwan Hawezi
well said. as a kurdish turk myself i dont want separation from turkey because its my religion that ties me to turks and my nation. our religion is the unity factor. but if one side refuses to give another equal rights and it looks like they're placing nationalism before muslimhood. then dont expect...
yavuz
Click here to read all user comments
Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
22 May 2013
Syria after Erdoğan's Washington trip
15 May 2013
The Syria file
8 May 2013
The ‘cementization' of Turkish cities
24 April 2013
The Tsarnaev brothers, terror and Chechnya
10 April 2013
Longing for the reasonable
3 April 2013
Entertaining the Kurdish card
27 March 2013
New Atlanticism, Russia and Turkey
13 March 2013
Turkey in the Middle East: an assessment
7 March 2013
Can Turkey's conservatives consolidate Turkish democracy?
22 February 2013
What will be left of Syria?
13 February 2013
Twitter and politics
6 February 2013
Munich, Turkey and European security
30 January 2013
What is Turkey's yardstick?
23 January 2013
European security and Turkey
17 January 2013
Turkey and Russia in an evolving region
9 January 2013
And winter came…
2 January 2013
Presidential system blues
26 December 2012
2012: Divisions exacerbated – democracy not consolidated
19 December 2012
Is Turkey a Middle Eastern country?
13 December 2012
Sobering experiences in Europe
5 December 2012
Turkey in Brussels
28 November 2012
The Turkey talk in Washington
21 November 2012
Halifax, Washington and Turkey-US relations
14 November 2012
Turkey, US and the new Syrian opposition
7 November 2012
Barack back to office, Turkey back to tension
31 October 2012
The US presidential election and Turkey
24 October 2012
Letters from the Black Sea
18 October 2012
Diets, obesity and the utilization of the EU
11 October 2012
Turkey's foreign policy identity
3 October 2012
The convention and the party
26 September 2012
The Arab Awakening: Phase II
19 September 2012
Turks and Kurds: Yearning for a new republic?
12 September 2012
Turkey needs urgent defense reform
5 September 2012
US inaction in Syria has a cost
29 August 2012
Kürecik
22 August 2012
We are at war with Syria
15 August 2012
The Syrian uprising is reconfiguring the region
8 August 2012
Sobering on Iran
1 August 2012
In defense of Davutoğlu
25 July 2012
Political culture
18 July 2012
Turkish politics gearing up for 2014
11 July 2012
How Syria divided Turkey’s conservatives
4 July 2012
The Syrian imbroglio
20 June 2012
Turkey’s Kurdish issue: Yet again we fail
13 June 2012
The Balkans, Turkey and Europe
6 June 2012
Turkey and Europe: Time for an amicable divorce?
30 May 2012
Are liberal politics possible?
23 May 2012
Qatar
16 May 2012
Back to a barbarian age
9 May 2012
Putin 2.0
2 May 2012
Spring and the historic process of revolution
20 April 2012
Politics without opposition
18 April 2012
Traumatized we stand
13 April 2012
The vagaries of exploiting foreign policy
11 April 2012
What is about to happen in Syria?
6 April 2012
Turkey’s Iran issue: The end of Turkish romanticism
4 April 2012
Russia’s ‘principled stance’ in Syria
30 March 2012
Turkey and the US in no one's world
28 March 2012
Turkey as a global swing state?
23 March 2012
Nothing new on the eastern front
21 March 2012
Our security and NATO
16 March 2012
America
14 March 2012
Letter from Sea Island, Georgia
7 March 2012
Syria’s barbarians must be stopped
7 March 2012
Syria's barbarians must be stopped
2 March 2012
The neighborhood: policies, priorities and power
29 February 2012
The Armenian file
24 February 2012
The Syrian struggle and Tunis
22 February 2012
Trauma, renewal and the demand for more change
17 February 2012
What to read?
15 February 2012
Winter of uncertainties
10 February 2012
Turkey's media
8 February 2012
Munich, Moscow, Damascus
2 February 2012
Beyond the stage
27 January 2012
Where is the Polish ambassador?
25 January 2012
Letter from Garmisch
20 January 2012
Winter of discontent
18 January 2012
Disgrace
13 January 2012
Why we need to act on Syria
11 January 2012
It is time for Turkish leadership on Syria
4 January 2012
A strategy for 2012
1 January 2012
A column without a heading
28 December 2011
A wish list for 2012
23 December 2011
What else is new in Russia?
21 December 2011
1915 is back
14 December 2011
The rise of democracy
9 December 2011
Match-rigging, football and politics
7 December 2011
Changing perceptions in the Middle East
2 December 2011
Turkey needs a normal opposition
30 November 2011
Russia's losing battles
25 November 2011
The Arab Awakening: an attempt at stocktaking
23 November 2011
Responsibility to protect
18 November 2011
What to do with Syria
16 November 2011
Grace
11 November 2011
The republic
9 November 2011
Ankara will need to tread with care
4 November 2011
İstanbul Forum
2 November 2011
Li Beirut
28 October 2011
Ennahda and political Islam
26 October 2011
The politics of the quake
...