Turkey's Myanmar policy
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
24 May 2013 Friday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 27 August 2012, Monday 4 0 0 0
ABDULLAH BOZKURT
a.bozkurt@todayszaman.com

Turkey's Myanmar policy

To argue that Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoğlu should not have gone to Myanmar at a time when bloodshed is occurring on our doorstep in neighboring Syria and innocent civilians are being slaughtered indiscriminately by regime forces on a daily basis does not make any sense from a holistic approach in foreign policy. The criticism in that regard does not constitute a criticism per se but rather a deliberate attempt from an ideological point of view to discredit the ruling Justice and Development Party (AK Party) government in general and the minister himself in particular. Even though I have my own fair share of criticism for this government on foreign policy issues, the Myanmar initiative must be praised and supported rather than lambasted.

The humanitarian crisis in Myanmar -- targeting the mostly Muslim minority -- has given Turkey an opening in its foreign policy that has been heavily dominated by the 17-month-long Syrian crisis. Turkey, a regional powerhouse with global clout in the G-20, must be able to engage in all parts of the world to be able to keep growing economically while accumulating the necessary political capital to advance its national interests. Though Ankara needs to prioritize its ambitions with respect to different regions of the world commensurate with its limited capacity, policy developers in the Turkish capital cannot remain indifferent to humanitarian crises in regions that seem as distant as in Myanmar.

Just as the engagement in Somalia last year with a visit by Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, who was the first Western leader to land in Mogadishu in 20 years, provided a success story for Turkish foreign policy and paved the way for opening new markets in sub-Saharan Africa, paying attention to the plight of Muslims in Myanmar will have similar results in the future. The fact that Davutoğlu and Emine Erdoğan, the prime minister's wife, visited the Rohingya Muslims in early August, staying at the Banduba refugee camp in the Myanmar coastal state of Rakhine, was the first instance of foreign aid being distributed to refugees in need in the region by a foreign nation.

Myanmar has a special significance for Turkey due to historical reasons that are not common knowledge, yet Turkey has not paid any attention to this East Asian nation for years. It was only in March of this year that Ankara opened an embassy in Myanmar's capital city Naypyidaw. In a conversation with a select group of reporters recently, Davutoğlu gave the full account of Turkey's Myanmar policy. He said he had given two specific instructions to Murat Yavuz Ateş when he appointed him to the post. Apart from improving bilateral relations in many areas as any diplomat should do in conducting his duty, the Turkish ambassador was asked to look into the fate of Turkish prisoners of war (POW) during World War I. The British took approximately 12,000 Turkish soldiers who were fighting on the Palestine, Egypt, Iraq and Syria fronts all the way to Myanmar so that they could not return to their homeland quickly or join in the fighting against the British.

It was a long and arduous voyage. They were all collected in Basra first and later transported to Karachi by ship. From there, the POWs headed to Calcutta by train, and from Calcutta they arrived in Rangoon. From Rangoon, they were brought to prisoner camps in Burma. Almost half of the Turkish POWs perished in these camps due to a lack of medical attention, malnutrition and other reasons. On March 26, 1916, Samuel G. Reat, the US consul in Rangoon, visited one of these camps at Thayetmyo, Burma, where a little over 3,500 Turkish POWs were kept. He reported back that there was an unusually high death rate at this camp. The Turkish ambassador in Naypyidaw is now busy discovering their burial grounds and trying to get the permission of Burmese officials to restore these graves and build a memorial for them. This would finally give closure to that sad chapter in our history while remembering the forgotten saga of our fallen heroes some 10,000 kilometers away.

Another special order given by Davutoğlu was that the ambassador must work hard to take care of the needs of Rohingya Muslims in Arakan province who have been victimized by Buddhist mobs supported by the state because of ethno-religious differences. According to the UN, Rohingyans are among the most persecuted people in the world. Arakan Muslims were among the few in India at the time who collected and sent donations to Turkey to help Turks during their War of Independence. It is now time to return that kindness. Turks already reciprocated to some extent to give relief to these people. Turkish government agencies as well as nongovernmental organizations have collected roughly TL 60 million (approximately $34 million) in cash aid for Rohingya Muslims in less than a month. The Kimse Yok Mu Association, a leading Turkish charity, which works in 71 countries, collected TL 7 million alone.

The Myanmar government's decision to grant permission for a Turkish delegation to visit the region and distribute aid to Arakan Muslims reflects Myanmar President Thein Sein's willingness to work with Turkey. With the exception of the United Nations, this was the first instance of foreign aid being distributed to refugees in need in the region by another nation. That opening in diplomacy should be capitalized on while paying due attention to the general problems the people of Myanmar face today. In other words, Turkish engagement should not be limited to Muslims in Burma.

Davutoğlu's visit to both minority Muslim camps as well as the ones belonging to Myanmar's majority Buddhists who were displaced because of conflict was a strong signal to the Myanmar government that Turkey is keen to foster ties with all the people of Myanmar. While distributing aid to a Buddhist camp, Davutoğlu's message that Turkey would like to see Muslims and Buddhists living together in peace resonated well among Myanmar government elites. Turkish engagement in a way may even help the Burmese government stabilize this restive region with further development and investment projects. With a booming economy, Turkey can extend further foreign direct investment in Burma, a move that would certainly be welcomed by Burmese elites to counterbalance growing Chinese influence over the Burmese national economy.

What is more, developing friendly ties with Turkey may contribute to President Sein's attempts for further reforms in the economy and democratization steps following decades of repressive military rule. Sein told Davutoğlu during his visit that Myanmar would also open an embassy in Turkey as soon as possible, adding that relations between the two countries would be developed by this move. Cozying up with Turkey may help the Burmese government remove some of the pressure brought to bear by the UN and 57-member Organization of Islamic Cooperation (OIC), the largest intergovernmental organization after the UN. Turkey has major clout in the OIC, which is headed by Turkish diplomat Ekmeleddin İhsanoğlu, who had spearheaded efforts in establishing a committee to monitor developments in the Arakan region.

The real solution to the problem of the Rohingya Muslims in particular or Buddhists in general in Myanmar is not extending charity or providing relief efforts. These may be necessary for the transitional period during which those in need must be taken care of. But the real effort must be spent on increasing trade and investment in Myanmar with special emphasis on less developed regions such as Arakan province. Generating jobs and increasing welfare in Myanmar will also reduce the number of refugees ending up in Turkish territory as a destination or as a transit country in search of a better life. Turkey must be able to engage with the Burmese government in collective diplomatic talks by bringing neighboring countries as well as regional powers into the mix. The Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN), with which Turkey signed a deal on accession to this organization's Treaty of Amity and Cooperation (TAC) on July 2010, may be a perfect platform in which to raise these issues.

COMMENTS
Great to see Turkey taking the lead to reduce human suffering world wide.
kapitop
You are right in your comments. Many people were touched by the video in which Amine Urdugan cries seeing the pain of Victims in Myanmar. May Allah reward. Aameen.
Siddeeque India
BRAVO TURKEY! Being a Muslim from Mauritius, Turkey has always been in our hearts. Our grandfathers wore Turkish Fezs', Muslims in Mauritius collected large amounts of money and donated jewellery for the Turkish war efforts during the turbulent early years of the early 20th century. The name of the ...
Melt
As the distinguished commentator has noted ASEAN is perhaps the best platform to tackle the issue of moslems in Burma. Nevertheless Turkey should be commended for the efforts it has taken to solve this issue in a forthright manner. Moslems where ever they are should not be taken for granted and trea...
anonymous
Click here to read all user comments
Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
20 May 2013
Iran exploiting Shiites and destroying Iraq
17 May 2013
EU's stake in Turkey's judicial council
13 May 2013
What to expect from Obama-Erdoğan meeting
10 May 2013
How Turkey's deputy PM saved the Israeli-Turkish deal
6 May 2013
ECtHR, freedom of assembly and May Day in Turkey
3 May 2013
Get out of jail free card for bid-rigging in Turkey
29 April 2013
PKK's venomous mouthpiece targets US, Gülen
26 April 2013
Iran's clandestine operations in Turkey
22 April 2013
Turkey deserves 2020 Olympics Games
19 April 2013
Concerns over Turkey's new petroleum law
15 April 2013
French socialist's unfair report on Turkey
12 April 2013
Turkey should tread carefully on Palestine issue
8 April 2013
US-Russian deal to impact Turkey's role in Central Asia
5 April 2013
Legal woes for Turkish energy firms in Iraq
1 April 2013
Turkish railways and EU
29 March 2013
Turkey, Cyprus and ENI fallout
25 March 2013
Apology and Middle East politics
22 March 2013
Terrorism toll on Turkey
18 March 2013
Turkey, world trade and top WTO post
15 March 2013
UNHCR's Guterres on the Syrian refugee crisis
11 March 2013
Why Sweden is going strategic with Turkey
8 March 2013
Competition as Turkey goes nuclear
4 March 2013
Zionism debated by Turkey, US and Israel
1 March 2013
Energy plays in Turkey's ties with US and Iraq
25 February 2013
Why is Jordan special for Turkey?
22 February 2013
Iran plays al-Qaeda figure to pit Turkey against US
18 February 2013
Violence and freedom of expression in Turkey
15 February 2013
France courts better ties with Turkey
11 February 2013
US Ambassador Ricciardone's blunder
8 February 2013
Why is Turkey sending its navy to Somalia?
4 February 2013
US response to embassy attack
1 February 2013
Engaging in Africa without challenging others
21 January 2013
Steps to align Turkey with ECtHR
18 January 2013
Whistleblower reveals foreign policy blunders in Turkey
14 January 2013
Turkey and hydrocarbons in Iraq
11 January 2013
The PKK bookkeeper and cover-up
7 January 2013
Turkey's security deals with partner nations
4 January 2013
DPG's challenge to secret US-Iran talks on Afghanistan
31 December 2012
US secret talks with Iran over Afghanistan
28 December 2012
New tool to promote trade
24 December 2012
Sudan and South Sudan: indispensable partners for Turkey
21 December 2012
Failure of new constitution in Turkey
17 December 2012
Turkey tightens vise on tax havens
14 December 2012
Turkey to help secure Af-Pak border
10 December 2012
Turkey, Hungary should do more
7 December 2012
Last act for Assad
3 December 2012
Turkey's golden story with Iran
30 November 2012
Connecting Turks and Emiratis
26 November 2012
Israel's legal woes in Palestine
23 November 2012
Turkey's new plan on Cyprus property disputes
19 November 2012
Turkey should arm the opposition in Syria
16 November 2012
Turkey's high hopes for Africa
12 November 2012
Turkey, Brunei offer promising partnership
9 November 2012
Turkey slacking on combating terrorism financing
5 November 2012
Fouling up press freedom in Turkey
2 November 2012
Rapprochement with Israel unlikely
29 October 2012
Phone call that disrupted Turkey's ties with Iraq
22 October 2012
Future of Afghanistan and Turkey's role
18 October 2012
De-coupling fears for Turkey-Russia ties over Syria
15 October 2012
Iran to turn ECO into paper organization
12 October 2012
The pro-war lobby rallies in Turkey
8 October 2012
EU ‘regress report' 2012
5 October 2012
New mandate needed for diplomats, not military
1 October 2012
Elections and a swelling budget in Turkey
28 September 2012
Convention speech and Erdoğan's dream
24 September 2012
Iran prime culprit for slashed hajj quotas
21 September 2012
Role of Iran and Syria in THKP/C terrorism against Turkey
17 September 2012
Early warning for Muslim bashing
14 September 2012
Campaign to repatriate stolen Turkish artifacts
9 September 2012
Iran's terror and trade war against Turkey
7 September 2012
Turkey hails Egypt's comeback
3 September 2012
Turkey's management of Syrian refugee crisis
31 August 2012
Germany playing dangerous game with Muslims
27 August 2012
Turkey's Myanmar policy
24 August 2012
Prosecuting Syrians in Turkish courts
17 August 2012
Wait on Syria, push for Kandil
13 August 2012
New page in Syria
10 August 2012
Countering Iran's threat
6 August 2012
Iran Spring and Turkey
3 August 2012
Turkey to shape Syrian army in post-Assad era
30 July 2012
The new CHP vigor for Turkish politics
27 July 2012
Turkey's play with Syrian Kurds
6 July 2012
Scorecard for Turkey's AK Party since election victory
2 July 2012
Turkey and Arab anxiety
29 June 2012
Iran, Syria to target Turkish troops in Lebanon
25 June 2012
Is Turkey itching for war with Syria?
22 June 2012
Sledgehammer case and ECtHR
18 June 2012
EU presidency of Greek Cyprus: Coming of age or falling from grace
15 June 2012
Neutered Ombudsman Law
11 June 2012
Profiling Erdoğan through the eyes of a confidant
8 June 2012
Whistleblowers and secret recordings in Turkey
4 June 2012
Cost of Syrian crisis to Turkish economy
1 June 2012
THY and union zealots
28 May 2012
The legacy of the Mexican presidency of the G-20
25 May 2012
Turkey and Mexico: Distant yet so close
21 May 2012
İşbank and the CHP
18 May 2012
Erbakan's legacy and gas deal with Iran
14 May 2012
EU-Turkey fundamentals: How strong are they?
11 May 2012
Germany must come clean on neo-Nazi murders
7 May 2012
Davutoğlu's record on parliamentary queries
...