American mothers
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
24 May 2013 Friday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 13 May 2012, Sunday 3 0 0 0
ARZU KAYA URANLI
auranli@todayszaman.com

American mothers

“All that I am, or hope to be, I owe to my angel mother” said the 16th president of the United States, Abraham Lincoln.

There are a lot of similar quotes to assure us how important a mother’s role is in her child’s life as the first educator who loves her child unconditionally more than anything else.

Being a mother is a life-long commitment in which the mother has to sacrifice her personhood but is enriched spiritually at the same time. As a mother you have a challenging full-time job with no vacation or retirement. Even the idea of having a child changes the potential mother’s life. When you decide to be a mother you always have to think twice, once for yourself and once for your child. Actually, it wasn’t hard for me to understand the meaning of the hadith of the Prophet Muhammad that says, “Paradise lies under the feet of your mother,” from the very first days of my first pregnancy when I started thinking of my baby.

Two months ago, I went to a fundraising event in New York with the first lady Michelle Obama. When it was time for her to give her speech, she started by describing herself first and foremost as a mother of two, even though she is a president’s wife and a very successful lawyer. Her strong speech was mostly about the importance of the family and the role of the woman in it. Basically, she was claiming that a mother’s role is crucial in a family. In order to have a strong society, we should have a strong family structure, and to maintain that, the government should support women in every aspect of life.

Then a month ago, when Democratic strategist Hilary Rosen mocked Ann Romney, the wife of Republican presumptive presidential candidate Mitt Romney, who has raised five sons, on CNN’s Anderson Cooper 360 for having “never worked a day in her life,” a bipartisan firestorm broke out in the US.

Even though some feminists supported Rosen’s idea, her comments were mainly criticized. Even President Barack Obama became involved in the argument, saying there was “no tougher job than being a mom.” Michelle Obama tweeted, “Every mother works hard, and every woman deserves to be respected.” Eventually, Rosen ended up issuing an apology.

Because I became a mother in the US and had the aim of helping my children not feel like immigrants in the US and tourists in Turkey, I find myself alternating between the values of both cultures when raising my children. Sometimes my Turkish friends label me as “an Americanized mother” and sometimes my American friends say I am so Turkish! I don’t mind those jokes as long as I can keep my children peaceful, happy and healthy. I believe both sides have pros and cons, and why shouldn’t I take advantage of both sets of values for the sake of my children?

Yes, being a working mother is exhausting. You have to juggle everything to keep your career and your happy family life in balance. There is always guilt inside you, either while you are at work thinking of your children or when you are with your children worrying about many uncompleted work tasks. Thus, some women give up on their career like Mrs. Romney. However, I love American mothers because many of them fight religiously to earn their right not to give up the joy of motherhood and their career at the same time. There are plenty of active nonprofit women’s organizations for individuals who recognize the significant role of motherhood in the US.

I should also say that I love some of the mothering skills of some American mothers, too. I hope Turkish mothers won’t be mad at me but we Turkish mothers smother our children when we try to mother them. If you go to any kid’s party, you can easily spot the Turkish mothers who are chasing their children, trying to feed them with a spoon or give them a piece of food! Yet American mothers don’t treat their children as princes and princesses. They treat them as individuals. They don’t baby their children but start talking to them as if they are grown up even in the very first days of their lives.

Children take on responsibilities much earlier. They learn to say four magical words -- “thank you,” “please” and “sorry” -- and they are able to use those words naturally from a very early age. In pre-k, a regular American kid would know that carrying their own backpack is their responsibility, not their mother’s. Children start to make their beds, they learn to pick up and clean their plates after meals and they help their parents with the house chores. Basically, they learn to take care of themselves and to become self-sufficient and independent while they are very young. Thus, they start their adulthood more prepared and better equipped.

Some of you might think it’s annoying to classify mothers as Turkish and American. We can also describe them as Eastern and Western mothers and yes, I am talking about stereotypes and there are always some exceptions on both sides.

I wish you all a happy Mother’s Day!

COMMENTS
BILGI I have actually often remarked on how these "smothered" children actually grow up to be members of productive society. Some do..but not all. MSURANLI You are spot on! As and American, I have often been chastised by my Turkish family, when I have taken the "independent" trac with my son. I...
Me
mothers often trample paradise to dust. fathers are totally ignored, they are just man, with urges and no feelings standing by indifferently everytime babies pop out of their women.
mother of pearl
There is nothing more annoying than the idea that the difference between American and Turkish mothering is the difference between raising independent children and smothered children. This column's viewpoint sounds too much like the ridiculous anthropology expats engage in, usually as they grasp for ...
Bilgi
Click here to read all user comments
Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
19 May 2013
A goodwill ambassador’s new mission
12 May 2013
Wake-up calls for societies of the 21st century
5 May 2013
Humanity needs a touch of magical interfaith dialogue
28 April 2013
Every day is Earth Day
21 April 2013
Aftermath of Boston Marathon explosion
14 April 2013
Farewell, ‘Iron Lady’
7 April 2013
Must the women of the Middle East fight for their rights at the expense of their faith?
31 March 2013
Happy birthday to a double-digit girl and a new ‘women’s revolution’
24 March 2013
We must end rape culture: lessons from Steubenville
17 March 2013
A bridge from the US to the Turkic world
10 March 2013
What has changed in a year for women in Turkey
3 March 2013
You are what you wear
24 February 2013
American-style vacation
17 February 2013
‘Zero Dark Thirty’
10 February 2013
‘Strike, shine, dance’
3 February 2013
Lost in İstanbul
27 January 2013
Women in combat
20 January 2013
What is your dream?
13 January 2013
Really, is marijuana use OK?
6 January 2013
We can stop rape
30 December 2012
A new you in the new year
23 December 2012
2012 for the US children
16 December 2012
America is discussing: Is today’s youth a lost generation?
9 December 2012
Changing the world before it ends
2 December 2012
Sweet dreams
25 November 2012
Thank you!
18 November 2012
Women and children first
11 November 2012
Taming of the shrew Sandy
4 November 2012
Peace in the world
21 October 2012
What women want
14 October 2012
Education… Education… Education…
7 October 2012
Who will fall this fall?
30 September 2012
US election 2012: Obama vs. Romney
23 September 2012
With US election around the corner, is the wild wild (Middle) East key?
16 September 2012
America’s acceptance and renewal
9 September 2012
A true philosophical problem: suicide
2 September 2012
Highlights from the summer of 2012
26 August 2012
Sweet talks
19 August 2012
Farewell to a month of thanksgiving and hello to a holiday
12 August 2012
Where is Islamophobia heading in the US?
5 August 2012
Headscarf 2012
29 July 2012
Killing death
22 July 2012
Seven paragraphs in memory of a highly effective person
15 July 2012
Are we losing our integrity in social media?
8 July 2012
The paradox of dying lonely and living in solitude
1 July 2012
Let’s talk the talk, walk the walk for Syrian children
24 June 2012
Finding a job
17 June 2012
Fathers and daughters
10 June 2012
Can American women determine the election?
3 June 2012
Pro-choice or pro-life
27 May 2012
On Memorial Day a few words to make your day memorable
20 May 2012
Don’t judge a book by its cover, but how about a magazine?
13 May 2012
American mothers
6 May 2012
Women in Turkey
29 April 2012
April showers bring May flowers
22 April 2012
Every day is Earth Day
15 April 2012
I speak, therefore I am
8 April 2012
Talking to children about adult topics
1 April 2012
Let’s rid the present of prejudice to save the future
25 March 2012
Enough is enough for Syrian children
18 March 2012
4+4+4: educational relegation or championship!
...