|  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
May 28, 2012
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 28 February 2012, Tuesday 17 0 3 0
BÜLENT KENEŞ
b.kenes@todayszaman.com

Cold war in warm waters: East Mediterranean and Cyprus

The Arab Spring that started on December 17, 2010, and had the Arab world under its spell is also a Mediterranean Spring. Almost all of the countries where the Arab Spring demolished the existing dictatorial regimes and became successful at least with regard to its first stage are as Mediterranean as they are Arab.

I am referring to Tunisia, Egypt and Libya. Although the popular revolutions have not been completed successfully, even Syria can be considered within this context. On the other hand, Yemen and Bahrain, which are exhibiting popular movements inspired by the Arab Spring, are the exceptions. Nevertheless, it is impossible not to see the tremors in regional and global balances created by the Arab Spring, which continued successfully until tossed on the bloody Assad wall in Syria in March 2011.

Since their interests were not protected during the changes in Tunisia, Egypt and Libya, the countries that were the winners in the old system established an exaggerated roadblock in Syria. Russia, China and Iran are exerting their best efforts to ensure that the Syrian regime does not go as easily as the Tunisian, Egyptian and Libyan regimes, and even if it does not go at all, they see the Syrian regime as a precious friend and ally for themselves. These countries are warding off all international attempts to put the Assad regime in a tight corner, and they are offering it all sorts of solidarity, including supplying weapons and ammunition. A major transportation route for the friends of the Assad regime is the Eastern Mediterranean. Iranian warships passed through the Suez Canal after a hiatus of 32 years and traveled to the Eastern Mediterranean for the first time immediately after the Hosni Mubarak regime, which was known to be hostile to Iran, was destroyed. The start and exacerbation of the popular uprising in Syria has given Iran's interest in this region added vitality. In recent weeks, Iran has sent its warships once again to this region and made a show of power at the naval base in Tartus, Syria's port city. Of course, Iran was not the first country that staged a show of power. Russia's only aircraft carrier Admiral Kuznetsov had anchored at the same port for some time in what amounted to a show of solidarity with the Assad regime.

Apparently, the East Mediterranean constitutes one of the major fields where a new style cold war between the Eastern and Western blocs is being reshaped according to the conflicting interests in Syria. And in this way, it is not hard to find some countries that have a foot in both camps. As you know, Russia's commercial (particularly in the offshore banking sector that functions as a black money laundering mechanism) and military relations with the Greek Cypriots as well as its existing and refreshed ties with Syria are particularly striking. Although it is a member of the European Union, the Greek Cypriots are not complying with the military and political embargo the EU imposed on the Assad regime. Greek Cyprus forms a transit route for the weapons Russia sends to Syria. We know that Greek Cyprus recently allowed a Russian vessel carrying weapons to Syrian to use its territorial waters. God knows how many more unknown moves Greek Cyprus has undertaken for solidarity with Assad. What I really want to know is why the EU is silent or tolerant about the Greek Cypriots who publicly violate the EU's embargo. They should know that this weird silence creates serious doubts in the international community about their sincerity with regard to their embargo on the Assad regime.

The Eastern Mediterranean has turned not only into a sea where Russian and Iranian warships frequently sail for solidarity with Syria, but also to an area of serious geopolitical competition due to the extraordinary strategic relations Israel has developed with the Greek Cypriots. The strategic relations between Israel and the Greek Cypriots have gradually improved since the early 2000s, and they have evolved to allow the use by Israeli airplanes of the Greek Cypriots' airspace during military exercises. Furthermore, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu even asked the Greek Cypriot administration to permit Israel to establish a military base in Cyprus during his recent visit. Despite Turkey's opposition, Israel and Greek Cyprus continue to conduct joint oil and natural gas exploration projects in the Eastern Mediterranean, which further raises the existing tension in the region. Considering further the fact that the Greek Cypriots gave a military base in Baf (Paphos) to France, which openly competes with Turkey in the incident-laden region, we can safely assert that both the Eastern Mediterranean and Cyprus have acquired a refreshed strategic importance in the eyes of the actors in the region.

The Eastern Mediterranean has turned into an area of competition among global powers due to the developments in the areas surrounding it, and it has shifted toward become a platform for friction between Turkey and Israel because of the already tense Turkish-Israeli relations. Following the deterioration of its ties with Turkey, particularly after it killed nine Turkish citizens aboard the vessel Mavi Marmara, Israel moved closer to Greece and Greek Cyprus. Israel uses the Greek airspace in its military exercises, and Russia is seeking to boost its clout in the same region largely using Greece and Greek Cyprus, which are EU members, and these developments send alarming signals to everyone concerned about these odd international alliances.

To sum up this complicated picture in the Eastern Mediterranean where we can expect increased tension, we can say the following: (1) Turkey, which has more than 40,000 troops in Cyprus, the Greek Cypriots, Greece and largely the EU are in an ever-increasing competition in the Eastern Mediterranean. (2) France, which has always been seeking to increase its influence in the entire Mediterranean as well as in Mesopotamia and Levant countries, is in a serious competition with Turkey over the Eastern Mediterranean. (3) Israel is getting closer to Greece and Greek Cyprus as it is shying away from Turkey, and it is giving the impression that it is establishing a sort of Israeli-Orthodox alliance because of its special ties with these countries with which Russia is also very friendly. (4) Iran does not want to lose Syria, to which it attaches a great importance as regards its regional domination and Shiite expansion goals and with which it has maintained an uninterrupted alliance for 32 years, and just like Russia, it seeks to make its presence felt by setting sail to the Eastern Mediterranean. This naturally worries Israel as it does not want Iran to be a threat closer to its shores, which in turn adds a contentious Israel-Iran dimension to the competition over the Eastern Mediterranean.

I know all this may sound complicated or intricate, but there is more: While it competes with Iran, Israel also has interests that overlap with those of Iran as it pursues similar policies with Russia and Greek Cyprus, which side with Iran concerning Syria and the Eastern Mediterranean. In other words, although it may appear to be in conflict with the countries of the Eastern block that have been reshaped based on the developments in Syria over the Eastern Mediterranean, it is in serious cooperation with some of these countries. Thus, the Eastern Mediterranean has become the locus of a multi-sided and dangerous geopolitical competition in the wake of the Arab Spring developments, and its strategic value in world politics is on the rise. Therefore, the strategic value of Cyprus for the parties to this issue has increased many times more compared to 10 years ago. Although many won't like to hear it, it would be more realistic to assert in the light of these developments that it is now more unlikely that a solution to the Cyprus issue will be found.

BÜLENT KENEŞ BÜLENT KENEŞ
What befell Niyazi-i Misri in the past is happening to Fethullah Gülen now
EKREM DUMANLI EKREM DUMANLI
When a call for fairness and reason finds acceptance
ŞAHİN ALPAY ŞAHİN ALPAY
Uludere, test case for democracy in Turkey
EMRE USLU EMRE USLU
Are the Kurds mentally divorced from Turkey?
GÖKHAN BACIK GÖKHAN BACIK
Erdoğan, Gül and Davutoğlu: the inner bargain on Turkish foreign policy
MARKAR ESAYAN MARKAR ESAYAN
Taking lessons from previous experiences with the military
YAVUZ BAYDAR YAVUZ BAYDAR
Qualm
ÖMER TAŞPINAR ÖMER TAŞPINAR
A new phase in Syria?
İHSAN DAĞI İHSAN DAĞI
Turkish foreign policy: Time for a re-evaluation
SEYFETTİN GÜRSEL SEYFETTİN GÜRSEL
Poor-friendly economic growth and the AK Party
CHARLOTTE MCPHERSON CHARLOTTE MCPHERSON
Missing women, missing opportunities
BERK ÇEKTİR BERK ÇEKTİR
Changes to incentives for investment in Turkey
MERVE BÜŞRA ÖZTÜRK MERVE BÜŞRA ÖZTÜRK
The 1960 coup: a final test for democracy
AMANDA PAUL AMANDA PAUL
Ukraine: a lost country
MÜMTAZER TÜRKÖNE MÜMTAZER TÜRKÖNE
The 52nd anniversary of May 27
COMMENTS
how stupid to lose loyal israel...for the sake of arabs who betrayed to ottomans...
necati
@Levent - you are surviving on UK taxpayers handouts, whats the difference?
Mark
I find it an omission that you do not mention oil.
tehlikeli yabanci
GR...Just to put matters right, After 5 thousand years of history and you are surviving on German cash handouts. Please ask yourself who really is useless.
LEVENT
Had Turkey known in 1974 what is known today she would’ve conducted a very different “peace operation”… one that removed the useless Turkish Cypriots! :)
GR
I?m glad Turks bleat on about ?Greek Cyprus? and Greek this and Greek that, because nobody else in the world who reads your articles realizes you?re criticizing Cyprus instead of Greece! Thanks! :)
GR
Although one could see the article as realistic through Turkish eyes, the author is somewhat ill-informed. There is no French base in Paphos, or in Cyprus. Moreover, in the spirit of cooperation and being good neighbours everyone in the region get along just fine, except Turkey. Shouldn't ...
Pontius
this article is very misleading. 1. the writer relate to security issues and economic issues as if they are the same. considering the Iran atomic race, Israel showed it can snub the US and shake hands with Saudi Arabia. 2. the Turkish behavior over the Marmara is nothing but childish. the same about...
musa
It is written MMMMMMM "Considering further the fact that the Greek Cypriots gave a military base in Baf (Paphos) to France, which openly competes with Turkey in the incident-laden region" MMMMMM What exactlh does that mean? Competing for what?
Competition
The solution to the Cyprus problem has never been likely, so the issue is not whether it is unlikely, as Bulent Kenes concludes, but whether the Cypriots, Turks and Greeks, will use force against each other again. By nature they are not a war like people. On the contrary! But they have grandiose i...
alper ali riza
Nothing is finished until its down and out! I think the Greek Cypriots will start somekind of confrontation with Turkey hoping Turkey dose something stupid. If things go pearshape then Turkey will take care of things in a appropriate way. If its war then so-be-it Won't be the first, neither the last...
LEVENT
Mr Kenes is conveniently forgeting in his analysis the fact of previous confiscation by ROC of explosive shipment to Syria.You know, the one that exloded last summer in Mari, causing many deaths of innocent personell and a major drawback in economy.This fact makes the scenery even more complicated....
Chris Athens
Turkey should build its air power to match any threat in the region or face dissaster.Isreal has the largest and most modern air force in the region.
Mehmet
The only ones who have heartburn with the current state of affairs in the eastern med is Turkey. Everybody else is getting along just fine and improving bilateral relations. The reason for this is Turkey's leaders want to dominate that region and issue edicts to other nations as to what they can do ...
Christoph
It must be scary to be a Turk now Mr.Kenes. You put the cart in front of the horse though when you talk about the Cyprus problem and the Arab spring. Turkey created the Cyprus problem or kept it going so long by mistake because the Turkish policy was " No solution is a solution ". It was wrong, very...
Elias
Mr. Kenes wrote, "although many won't like to hear it, it would be more realistic to assert in the light of these developments that it is now more unlikely that a solution to the Cyprus issue will be found." At the same time, although many won't like to hear it, it would be equally realistic to asse...
Thessalonian
A very good analysis. It is refreshing to see that the triumphalism about Turkey's supposed unstoppable rise in the region, which was previously promoted by this writer, has all but vanished from this analysis. Ankara's policies in the last few years indeed raised its regional profile, but it gained...
Israeli
Click here to read all user comments
Weather
City>>
ISTANBUL
Today Tue Wed
15C°
21C°
15C°
22C°
16C°
22C°