|  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
May 28, 2012
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 28 February 2012, Tuesday 37 0 3 0
LALE KEMAL
loglu@todayszaman.com

Time is running out for Cyprus talks

The eastern Mediterranean island of Cyprus is the last divided nation in Europe, with the Turkish Cypriots and the Greek Cypriots located in the north and south, respectively. The Greek Cypriot administration is recognized as the sole representative of the island by the United Nations, while it has been a full member of the European Union since May 2004. The Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus (KKTC), declared in 1983, is recognized only by Turkey.

Against this background, the UN has been continuing efforts, which I will describe as hopeless, to reunite the two communities under a federal Cypriot state based on the political equality of the two parties.

Unsurprisingly, the Greek Cypriot administration, which enjoys international recognition as a state, has long been dragging its feet to agree on a solution that will reunite the island based on political equality for both communities. The Greek Cypriot administration, instead, insists on a solution that will make the Turkish Cypriots its subordinates.

There are strong signs emerging at the moment that the current peace talks to reunite Cyprus will be the last ones and that if they fail, it may become inevitable for the Turkish Cypriot administration to draw a new roadmap to strengthen its existence as a state.

KKTC President Derviş Eroğlu spoke with a group of Turkish journalists he hosted last weekend at his residence in Lefkoşa, the Cypriot capital, which has been divided between the two communities, telling them that the Cyprus peace negotiations cannot continue for 100 years.

“If the talks fail this time, the Turkish Cypriots will decide their own future. July 1 marks the end of peace talks. I will tell my people at that time that we should stick to our state [KKTC]. And we will design policies to strengthen the existence of the state in the north,” he said firmly.

Eroğlu, however, fell short of telling the Turkish journalists what these policies would be.

Eroğlu referred to the start of a six-month-long EU term presidency of the Greek Cypriot administration when he said July 1 was the end of peace talks.

Turkey has already stated that it will freeze its relations with the EU if Greek Cypriots assume the term presidency in the absence of a resolution of the Cyprus dispute.

Since there are only four months left before the Greek Cypriot term presidency begins, it seems that it will take a miracle to find a solution to unify the island.

Kudret Özersay, the chief Turkish Cypriot negotiator in talks with the Greek Cypriots under the auspices of the UN, joined our lunch with Eroğlu and pointed out that efforts to reunite Cyprus have been continuing for 44 years now -- since 1968.

“The solution is an exception; it has never happened. But there exists a situation where the Cyprus question has not been resolved for 44 years,” he added.

If the current Cyprus peace talks collapse, there is nothing the Greek Cypriots will lose because they are the ones recognized internationally as the state in Cyprus.

The Turkish Cypriot administration draws a gloomy picture over the fate of the ongoing talks.

People in the streets of Lefkoşa, Gazimağusa (Famagusta) and in the resort town of Girne have long been frustrated over the uncertainty of their future status and because they have been suffering from EU and UN embargoes as a result. The repercussions from the long-lasting isolation can be read on the faces of the people with whom I talked -- hopelessness. They need to have a status to bring life to the northern section of the island.

Both the Greek and the Turkish Cypriots have been allowed to visit each other's territories. This also increases Turkish Cypriots' misery as they see how developed the southern Cypriot side is in comparison to the north.

From Girne, we, as a group of journalists, reached Gazimağusa on the eastern coast of Cyprus in the Turkish section after an hour-long drive. Adjacent to Gazimağusa is Maraş (Varosha), a ghost city closed to habitation since 1974. Once a famous resort town, the tall buildings visible from Gazimağusa have turned into ruins. Entry into the city requires obtaining permission from either the UN or from the Turkish military.

Maraş is kept closed and is to be handed over to the Greek Cypriots if there is a solution.

We asked KKTC President Eroğlu whether he can issue a permit for us to enter this ghost city. His answer was quite striking since he told us that Turkish military units issue the permits. Here you are -- the system of military tutelage is still at work in the northern half of Cyprus.

Mainland Turkey has taken considerable steps to bring the Turkish Armed Forces (TSK) under civilian democratic control, though it has a long way to go to fully end the system of military tutelage. But it is hard to say that this process has also been initiated in northern Cyprus.

During our travel from Lefkoşa, Girne and finally to Gazimağusa, we saw some of the many Turkish military garrisons. There are estimated to be around 30,000 to 60,000 Turkish troops deployed in the Turkish section of the island. Maintaining such a high number of Turkish troops there is quite costly for Turkey, and their number should definitely be reduced. This is because a future military conflict is highly unlikely on the island.

BÜLENT KENEŞ BÜLENT KENEŞ
What befell Niyazi-i Misri in the past is happening to Fethullah Gülen now
EKREM DUMANLI EKREM DUMANLI
When a call for fairness and reason finds acceptance
ŞAHİN ALPAY ŞAHİN ALPAY
Uludere, test case for democracy in Turkey
EMRE USLU EMRE USLU
Are the Kurds mentally divorced from Turkey?
GÖKHAN BACIK GÖKHAN BACIK
Erdoğan, Gül and Davutoğlu: the inner bargain on Turkish foreign policy
MARKAR ESAYAN MARKAR ESAYAN
Taking lessons from previous experiences with the military
YAVUZ BAYDAR YAVUZ BAYDAR
Qualm
ÖMER TAŞPINAR ÖMER TAŞPINAR
A new phase in Syria?
İHSAN DAĞI İHSAN DAĞI
Turkish foreign policy: Time for a re-evaluation
SEYFETTİN GÜRSEL SEYFETTİN GÜRSEL
Poor-friendly economic growth and the AK Party
CHARLOTTE MCPHERSON CHARLOTTE MCPHERSON
Missing women, missing opportunities
BERK ÇEKTİR BERK ÇEKTİR
Changes to incentives for investment in Turkey
MERVE BÜŞRA ÖZTÜRK MERVE BÜŞRA ÖZTÜRK
The 1960 coup: a final test for democracy
AMANDA PAUL AMANDA PAUL
Ukraine: a lost country
MÜMTAZER TÜRKÖNE MÜMTAZER TÜRKÖNE
The 52nd anniversary of May 27
COMMENTS
Good question, Mark. I've read the Annan plan and the various reports and I thought it might work, until that is, your killer question. Given the fact that the plan was worked out between Annan, Erdogan and the CIA, and given the universal agreement that it would have destroyed Cyprus, I'm now of th...
Baris
@Baris - did you read the international version of the Annan Plan or the Turkish version?
Mark
Mark, the 1977/79 agreements defined the framework of a solution based on a bizonal and bicommunal federal republic, which is what the Annan plan was. I disagree with you regarding it being another disaster waiting to happen. I believe that it was the best chance, the only chance in fact, the island...
Baris
A quick Cyprus history lesson by Dr Ihsan Ali (Google 'Dr Ihsan Ali', he was one of the original Turkish Cypriot leaders in the 1950s): Letter to Turkish Prime Minister, Suad Hayri Urguplu, 24/10/1965. Hon. Mr. Premier, In one of your recent statements you said that if the present state of affairs i...
Dr Ihsan Ali
@Ayse - do you make things up as you go along? Daily attacks on Turks in the RoC? @Baris - for once I was actually agreeing with some of your arguments until you suggested the Annan Plan was based on the federal agreements of 77/79, sadly the plan was not and was another disaster for Cyprus waiting ...
Mark
@DutchTurk - you live as a minority in the Netherlands, whats the problem with that?
Mark
As an original neutral on this subjectI have mixed with Greeks,Turks,TC,GC,
maxbarnes
This article is pointless. You do not even use the correct names for the towns and cities in the occupied areas. What is "Gazmagusa" or "Gurine"? The truth of the matter is that Turkey occupies the northern part of the Republic of Cyprus. This area was ethnically cleansed of the Hellenic
Ameriguy
Turkey's permanent and definite stall of its EU accession by the Republic of Cyprus and Greece, not to mention others, is anything but a "carrot on a stick" policy, which many Turks would like to believe. It is rather a most suitable and befitting retribution and or payback, similar to the permanenc...
Thessalonian
How likely it is for the Turkish Cypriots to live as a minority group on Cyprus, that likely it is for the Greeks to live as a minority when Greece will be a province of Turkey. Get used to it, NO minority, 2 state solution with more or less current borders. 2 languages 2 ethnicity 2 faiths = 2...
DutchTurk
Lale, What an excellent article. It is one of th eonly honest assesments of the situation and circumstances faced by the Turkish Cypriots. You honestly outline the economic difficulties, political impotence, and Turkish military dominance that exists in the north. This is in drastic contrast to the ...
Breakfast of Consequences
AlexyFlemming: It is well known among Turkish Cypriots that the TMT (Turkish Cypriot Terrorists) were killing and beating up Turkish Cypriots who were against war and partition in Cyprus. So Dr Ihsan Ali was telling the truth in his letters to the UN Secretary General and to the Turkish Prime Minist...
Dr Ihsan Ali
Baris, you are right about the UK. Google 'UK murky role in Cyprus crisis' to read the BBC News article about the UK's role in dividing Cyprus and its people.
Dr Ihsan Ali
Turkish Cypriots left the Government in 1963. Turkish Prime Minister Inonu ordered the Turkish Cypriots to return to the Cyprus Government. However, Dr Kucuk was Vice-president of the Republic of Cyprus from 1960 to 1973 when he was replaced by Rauf Denktash. Rauf Denktash was Vice-President of th...
Dr Ihsan Ali
@Baran, your comment is empty groundless and has no meaning. TURKISH CYPRIOTS LIVE UNDER INTERNATIONAL SANCTIONS AND KURDS DON'T. TURKISH CYPRIOTS HAVE NO POLITICAL PARTY IN THE CYPRUS REPUBLIC. KURDS HAVE ONE IN THE REPUBLIC OF TURKEY. Please show me a draft or constitution drawn up by the UN that ...
LEVENT
Dr. Ihsan Ali is a Greek Cypriot spy among Turkish Cypriots. He helped Greek Cypriots to steal the "Republic of Cyprus" title from Turkish Cypriots. * Proofs of Dr. Ihsan Ali's Traitorness via United Nations Documents (S/5831 page4 and S/5914). (S/5831 Page4): Dr. İhsan Ali (to UNFICYP head Gene...
Alexy Flemming
30 000-60 000 troops. Imagine if we instead could reallocate such an enormous amount of people and use them for something in Turkey. If we for example could add 60 000 teachers to our school or 60 000 doctors to our hospitals. Or 60 000 people building roads or houses for people in need.
What to do
It was Mr. Denktash who openly sabotaged and bluntly rejected any deal provided by the UN, EU or ay other international institution between 1955 and 2004. Only in 2004 when Denktash wasn't president anymore the population voted yes for reunification. A little late? That Turkey wants to erase Mr. Den...
Johan
Yes, the Cypriot Turks are pessimistic about their status and about the talks. They keep demonstrating against the imposed, hostile Cypriot Turkish leadership, with no results.
george avgeris
The Turkish Cypriots should accept that as a minority they have no special rights, but equal rights to participate in the democratic processes of the Republic of Cyprus. Their aspirations can be achieved only by removing the shackles of the Turkish (Anatolian) mentality which is entrenched in the Tu...
Diogenes
The current Cyprus problem physically started in the early 1950s, before the ROC was even conceived. All sides, UK included, did their bit to ensure that the two peoples didn't stand a chance to live as equal citizens in one country. The violent events starting in 1963 was also the start of the sepa...
Baris
Turkish Cypriots were subject to genocide by Greek and Greek Cypriot terrorists. Unlike Armeian lies that fabricate a fictitious so-called "armenian genocide", there are real documents by the illegal terrorist Greek Cypriot regime (Akritas and Ifestos) that plan in painstaking detail how to annihi...
Ayten Aksoy
I ask again where is the morality of denying Kurdish citizens of Turkey the very same rights, freedoms and political status that Turks so belligerently demand for a handful of Turkish Cypriots? Or should that be a handful of Turks on the island of Cyprus?
Baran
What exactly is the solution Turkey envsions that Cyprus is dragging its feet for? Asking Cyprus to acceot Turkish troops on the island can hardly be considered a "solution". Asking Cyprus to accept the "guarantees" of a foreign government so that it can invade, rape and pillage freely is not a futu...
Kyproleon
Again I read comments below which are a repeat of the Ergenekon propaganda myths (found on extremist Ergenekon websites) about Turkish Cypriots "thrown out of the government", "Turkish Cypriots were victims of genocide", etc. Google 'Dr Ihsan Ali' - who was one of the original Turkish Cypriot lead...
Dr Ihsan Ali
There are strong signs emerging at the moment that the current peace talks to reunite Cyprus will be the last one and let's hope it is. Why are we so naive to think that the Greek Cypriots are going to share Cyprus in a peaceful manor. For years they have shown there venom and we still don't get the...
LEVENT
If Eroglu wants a 'solution', he should stop making proposals which are outside the agreed UN's negotiating framework for Cyprus. You can't demand progress on a 'solution' and at the same time withdraw from positions which have been previously agreed between Talat/Christofias... It's in the inte...
Elias E
'KKTC' can try and raise it's status, nobody really cares. But without a settlement which is agreeable to the Greek Cypriots Turkey will NEVER accede into the EU. On that item let there be no confusion!
Esteban
Time is running out for Turkey, not for Cyprus. If the Turks think stalling on these talks will elevate their side they coudln't be more wrong. Illegal invasion and Ethnic Cleansing was wrong in 1974 and it's wrong today-perhaps even more so. Turkey has painted itself into a corner on Cyprus and the...
Christoph
@Lale Kemal, you make it sound like it's the  end of the world for the Turkish Cypriots. Ok the Greek Cypriots are going take a rotating EU presidency, so-what! who cares, they never where are partners and never will be, so it makes no difference. The EU is a Christian club and the reason the Greeks...
LEVENT
Your article is bothe naive, biased, un-educated, like most turkish journalists, why wait to return varosha? Why constantly play the blame game? like eroglu and all mainstream political parties. Sunni islam is being forced down the TC throats, demographic pressure is being cranked up by Turkey whils...
jahitty
I don't think the GCs want to make the TCs their subordinates. They just want to see them as equal citizens of the Republic of Cyprus who are a minority, and this is the root of the problem. TC politicians say that TRNC cannot survive without Turkey, So how can something be a state that cannot survi...
Elias
Ever since Turkish Cypriots where booted out from the Cyprus republic the Greek Cypriots have never had it so good. They have become ignorant selfish and very raciest against Turks in general. But one must ask themselfs a question,  if a country is handed to you on a plate, would you want to share i...
LEVENT
The status quo in the internationally recognized, and militarily occupied by Turkey, national entity of the Republic of Cyprus will not change until Turkey decides to fully comply with all UN issued resolutions. As far as the authority of the Turkish Cypriots on their native lands is concerned, Erog...
Thessalonian
Almost daily, we hear of new violent attacks or cases of discrimination of Turks on the Greek side. There was no "military conflict" in 1963 either but that didn't stop the criminal Greek Cypriot terrorist state from devising an implementing a policy of genocidal assaults on Turkish Cypriots (Akrita...
Ayse
The framework of the so-called "negotiations" are unbalanced since 1977 and are a threat to the existence of Turkish Cypriot people and their right of self-governance. They also threaent the security of an independent TRNC. A so-called "united cyprus" is artificial construction and never existed in...
Erkan
Realistically, the only questions left now are under what conditions and within what border will a Turkish entity be legalized within the international system. The most viable solution is land-for-recognition. The TRNC should be shrunk to 18 percent of the whole island, reflecting pre-invasion dem...
Jack Kalpakian
Click here to read all user comments
Weather
City>>
ISTANBUL
Today Tue Wed
15C°
21C°
15C°
22C°
16C°
22C°