A challenging process
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
18 May 2013 Saturday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 19 February 2013, Tuesday 0 0 0 0
BERİL DEDEOĞLU
b.dedeoglu@todayszaman.com

A challenging process

The general impression is that most people in Turkey agree with having negotiations with the Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK) to stop the bloodbath. People have really had enough of the ongoing armed conflict and they simply don't want more people to die. We ignore exactly what is being negotiated during these talks and, in fact, for the sake of the negotiations, we don't really need to know every tiny detail.

The public opinion is, at the moment, preoccupied with the composition of the team that will go to İmralı Island, where PKK leader Abdullah Öcalan is jailed. The problem is which members of the Peace and Democracy Party (BDP) will go there to meet him. The prime minister has said he will make the final decision and the BDP deputies are wondering why he is the one to make the decision.

As a matter of fact, it is not really important who will travel to İmralı because the messages Öcalan wants to transmit will be transmitted no matter who goes. However, the governing Justice and Development Party (AK Party) is worried about the public's reaction. It is already under heavy pressure from nationalist and Kemalist circles, who claim that talking to the terrorists is no less than treason. This pressure makes the government particularly worried about public opinion and perceptions of the negotiations and therefore it wants the most moderate and peaceful people from the BDP to remain at the forefront. The BDP, too, would prefer to send the most moderate among them. The leaders of the party have already declared that they hope this process will be a success and that they will not allow anyone to sabotage it.

There is no need to emphasize how this cease-fire is beneficial for the country. However, the process has just begun and the utmost caution is necessary to transform these talks into a genuine peace process.

A number of elections are scheduled for the next two years. The AK Party wants to win the local elections in cities with a Kurdish majority while the BDP is trying not to lose them. In the general elections, the AK Party wants to win enough seats to be able to modify the Constitution alone; while the BDP wants to win seats from the western regions of the country. All this, and I haven't even mentioned the presidential elections and the ongoing debate on the presidential system.

In this context, it is obvious that the bargain between the AK Party and the BDP cannot be limited only to the İmralı process. The two parties will have to talk about everything else as well and, after all, this is good for the sake of our democracy. However, if the two parties decide to look for a deal only about the presidential system or the outcome of the next presidential elections and they prefer not to talk about how to improve human rights and liberties, then it will be difficult to reach a genuine peace.

During an election campaign, given the tension that may arise from the political struggle, it may be hard to find compromises. Besides, some third parties may try by any and all means, including the use of violence, to prevent any agreement between the AK Party and the BDP. And, one mustn't think that these third parties are only in Turkey; one must never forget about international players.

The talks with Öcalan can only be successful with an agreement between the AK Party and the BDP, and this can only be possible if one of the two sides doesn't try to put pressure on the other. Given these circumstances, the fact that the prime minister has announced that he is against all kinds of nationalism is important. He has thus criticized both Turkish and Kurdish nationalists.

This process is a particularly sensitive one. For example, one mustn't suggest to those who feel Kurdish above all else that they should feel more pious. In other words, the bargain must have democracy at its core and it must help to improve the human rights, liberties and equality of all citizens.

Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
17 May 2013
A trial in Germany
14 May 2013
The Reyhanlı attack and Europe
10 May 2013
Sounds from Turkey
7 May 2013
Israel's attacks against Syria
3 May 2013
Turbulent politics
30 April 2013
Trusting the European Union
26 April 2013
The peace process and sabotage
23 April 2013
Terrorism, Chechens and beyond
19 April 2013
Turkey: the land of fear and suspicion
16 April 2013
The Middle East and terror
12 April 2013
Peace-building as a challenge
9 April 2013
The Egyptian case
5 April 2013
The United States is in a hurry
2 April 2013
Fires in Germany
29 March 2013
The peace process and the details
26 March 2013
Turkey-Israel: a new process
22 March 2013
Intervening in Syria
19 March 2013
Cyprus-Turkey: a new period?
15 March 2013
Dealing with technical issues
12 March 2013
Upcoming elections in Iran
8 March 2013
After Hugo Chavez
5 March 2013
The global dimension of the leak
1 March 2013
The PKK and global balances
26 February 2013
An actor's choice
22 February 2013
New initiatives on Syria
19 February 2013
A challenging process
15 February 2013
Explosion at the border
12 February 2013
Peace negotiations and global circumstances
8 February 2013
Turkey-EU: a new debate
5 February 2013
Attacking the US Embassy
1 February 2013
Africa: the new chessboard
29 January 2013
Discrimination
25 January 2013
David Cameron and the EU
22 January 2013
Two journalists
18 January 2013
Attacking a university
15 January 2013
France-Turkey: new problems?
11 January 2013
Negotiating with terrorists
4 January 2013
‘We are so different that nobody understands us'
1 January 2013
Turkey-EU: A proposal from Britain?
28 December 2012
The need for transparency
25 December 2012
Student movements
21 December 2012
Risk assessment
18 December 2012
The EU’s Irish presidency
14 December 2012
A new look at Greece
11 December 2012
A new law for universities
7 December 2012
A real risk for Turkey
4 December 2012
Turkey-France: A new period?
30 November 2012
Israel-Turkey: New communication channels
27 November 2012
The Patriot issue
23 November 2012
US and Russia should open a new page
20 November 2012
Israel, Gaza and beyond
16 November 2012
US’s Israel test
13 November 2012
Reforming the United Nations
9 November 2012
US presidential election
6 November 2012
The other aspect of US elections
2 November 2012
The Middle East and nuclear proliferation
30 October 2012
Celebrating the republic
23 October 2012
Dialogue with terrorists
21 October 2012
From crisis to cooperation
16 October 2012
Brainstorming about the Middle East and Nobel
12 October 2012
A festival in Houston
9 October 2012
Terror and Europe
5 October 2012
The prime minister’s speech
2 October 2012
Palestine’s future
28 September 2012
Another way to negotiate?
25 September 2012
Discussing Muslims
21 September 2012
The Middle East quartet
18 September 2012
A movie and a trap
14 September 2012
Time to resuscitate the EU process?
11 September 2012
The presidential race in the US
7 September 2012
War scenarios between Iran and Israel
4 September 2012
Reforming education
31 August 2012
Turkey’s Syria problem
28 August 2012
Forgetting about the EU and beyond
24 August 2012
The global rivalry enters a new phase
21 August 2012
PKK’s strategy based on hatred
17 August 2012
The Syrian civil war
14 August 2012
Kidnapping a deputy
10 August 2012
Iran and Turkey’s role in Syria
7 August 2012
More deaths, alas
3 August 2012
The foreign minister’s visit to Arbil
31 July 2012
Two pieces of news, one option
27 July 2012
Domestic and international politics
24 July 2012
Can Israel intervene in Syria?
20 July 2012
Bloody Wednesday and Syria
17 July 2012
Democracy, constitution and beyond
13 July 2012
Amnesty International’s report on China
10 July 2012
Visiting the patriarchate
6 July 2012
People, governments and Turkey
3 July 2012
The Erdoğan-Zana meeting
29 June 2012
Russia’s weight in the Syrian problem
26 June 2012
Change in eastern Mediterranean balances
22 June 2012
Those who try to bring the past back
19 June 2012
Maliki, Talabani and new problems
15 June 2012
A methodological problem with coup trials
12 June 2012
The new period in France
8 June 2012
The government-opposition summit
5 June 2012
Is there a risk of ‘going back’?
1 June 2012
The richness of plurality, impossibility of uniformity
29 May 2012
Individuals as pillars of democracy
...