In a radical move, Turkey opts for co-development of long-range missiles
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
19 June 2013 Wednesday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 28 January 2013, Monday 4 0 0 0
LALE KEMAL
loglu@todayszaman.com

In a radical move, Turkey opts for co-development of long-range missiles

Despite high expectations, Turkey did not pick a winner in its six-year long-range air and missile defense systems (T-Loramids) project during a meeting on Jan. 3, held by the country's top decision making body on weapons procurement, headed by Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan.

Instead, Erdoğan used his influence in a decision for the co-development of the missiles in cooperation with one of the bidding companies in the T-Loramids program. I have to say that a decision to co-develop the missiles is a very aggressive policy, taking into consideration Turkey's existing relatively weak defense industry base. However, it does not mean that Turkey cannot co-develop a long-range missile in the long term and that the most important factor is to start somewhere instead of taking no action to this end.

Some critics have long been criticizing Turkey's plan to buy 12 long-range missile systems off the shelf at a cost of around $4 billion. Instead, those critics were urging Ankara to abandon the project on the grounds that it is expensive and that whenever Turkey needs such systems NATO -- of which it is a member -- has in all previous situations lent Turkey Patriot surface-to-air missile systems. This was the case lately when NATO began deploying Patriot missiles on Turkish soil to defend Turkey's territory against a possible anti-ballistic missile attack that may come from neighboring Syria, where the civil war has been continuing for almost two years now.

Hence, NATO has come to Turkey's assistance in bolstering the Turkish air defense against possible threats. However, some -- including many Turkish officers, distrust the alliance and have thus been advocating that Turkey acquire its own long-range missile systems.

The critical question that should be posed at this stage is: Who decides on the matters of Turkish weapons purchases? There is no parliamentary commission that is elaborating in depth over whether Turkey needs costly defense systems, for example, while it is unknown even to legislators what Turkey perceives as threats in order for it to buy the relevant weapons.

In the absence of an oversight on Turkish policies regarding the purchasing of weapons in particular and Turkish defense expenditures in general, neither by the parliament nor by the Court of Accounts, it becomes difficult to know exactly what kind of weapons Turkey needs and whether some of the weapons being purchased are really necessary or are being purchased arbitrarily resulting in the waste of our liras.

The lack of an oversight on Turkish weapons acquisition policies is as an important problem in meeting the transparency and good governance standards required in democracies.

In the meantime, however, the current government policies to strengthen the Turkish defense industry base have helped the domestic production of some of the weapons systems. This industry, for a long time, has been unable to produce even some nonessential technologies, thus being reliant on industries abroad for around 85 percent of their defense systems.

Turkey has now set a target of producing critical military technologies locally. Nevertheless, the financial resources earmarked for Research and Development (R&D) projects are a drop in the ocean to meet this ambitious goal. For example, $600 million is earmarked for R&D projects mainly in defense for the fiscal year 2013, which is not adequate enough to produce critical technologies. Adding to the problem is the current Turkish government's exaggerated approach and overconfidence as if Turkey has turned its defense industry base into a strong one to produce even critical technologies without foreign help.

For example, in the production of the Göktürk 2 satellite, Turkish decision makers claimed that it was 80 percent locally manufactured. The public was thus being deceived since considerable technical support was received from foreign suppliers in the production of this satellite which was put into orbit lately from China.

When the public is misled about Turkey's real strength in the defense industry, for example, they later become disillusioned and begin to inquire about the reasons behind the significant amount of resources allocated to the military yet Turkey does not have a strong defense industry base.

Now that Turkey has not picked a winner in its six-year missile acquisition project, the question is whether Ankara will be able to produce the long-range missiles that few nations have so far manufactured.

Turkey appears to have a strong will and the determination to co-develop long-range missiles. This will not only assist the creation of a stronger defense industry base in the long run but will also turn the lucrative weapons business into an asset for the economy instead of being a burden due to the earlier frequent direct purchases of weapons from abroad. Still, the problem of knowing which arms to buy in a transparent fashion has to be addressed.

COMMENTS
We should build the 'air defense rocket system' ourselves. Yes there needs to be transparency. This government is attacking the problems of our previous weak industrial manufacturing. We need to address our lack of semiconductor microchip manufacturing Lale. I haven't seen you write an article o...
Eric
Pakistan? Are you crazy? Development at stone age level spiced up with religious radicals? Not a partner for the modern Turkey, thank you very much! We still have some dignity.
Nope
I totally agree with these comments about collaborating with Pakistan for defense and civilian purposes. Turkey can save billions as Pakistan is relatively a cost-effective option.
Pakistan
The public is eager to know whey Turkey is not cooperating with a very potential country Pakistan to develop long range missile for Turkey. similarly Turkey can acquire a civilian nuclear technology from Pakistan to establish a nuclear power plant in Turkey. Erdogan seems too much busy that he is no...
A potential country!
Click here to read all user comments
Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
17 June 2013
Gendarmerie in Gezi Park, what is next?
12 June 2013
Democracy and Uludere
10 June 2013
A new democratic movement may be in the offing
5 June 2013
Not the deep state but the streets pushing Erdoğan to change
3 June 2013
Turkish government commits suicide
30 May 2013
Turkey regressing, risks losing earlier achievements
27 May 2013
No luxury for stalling tactics if peace is to move forward
22 May 2013
Reyhanlı attack & rethinking Turkish democracy
20 May 2013
Syrian crisis carries risk of killing Erdoğan's political calculations
15 May 2013
Will the Syrian tragedy be Turkey's, too?
13 May 2013
Who will benefit from shortened military service?
8 May 2013
What will be the next move?
6 May 2013
Turkey's mishandling of the JSF
1 May 2013
Bureaucratic war over democratic oversight
29 April 2013
Presidential system and authoritarianism
24 April 2013
Erdoğan will obtain presidential powers
22 April 2013
Peace process and reduction of military power
17 April 2013
Turkish-Israeli military ties will not resume soon
15 April 2013
Al-Nusra's growing influence prompts frequent Turkey visits by Kerry
10 April 2013
Military-government covert deal doomed to fail
8 April 2013
National strategy lacking in Turkish peace process
3 April 2013
Why this stubbornness to kill transparency?
1 April 2013
Government push for unrealistic demands risks peace process
27 March 2013
Military response to solution process is an open question
25 March 2013
Turkish-Israeli reconciliation to help thwart regional threats
20 March 2013
PKK disarmament will come later
18 March 2013
Shortcomings in judicial reform to slow peace process
13 March 2013
Favoritism poisons ethical values in Turkey
11 March 2013
Peace process and presidential system
6 March 2013
PKK's European wing weighs in on peace process
4 March 2013
Where does the military stand in the peace process?
27 February 2013
Achieving peace also requires open debate on state mistakes
25 February 2013
Uludere and making peace
20 February 2013
Decentralization is critical in Kurdish peace process
18 February 2013
Alternative to current peace process is catastrophe
13 February 2013
Turkish military's morale from a historic perspective (2)
11 February 2013
Turkish military's morale from a historic perspective (1)
6 February 2013
Is Turkey seeking to revive pan-Turkism?
4 February 2013
Turkish-US conflicts are at tactical level
30 January 2013
Society necessitates the emergence of a new democratic movement
28 January 2013
In a radical move, Turkey opts for co-development of long-range missiles
23 January 2013
US delivers democracy message to Turkey
21 January 2013
Kurdish issue haunts CHP
15 January 2013
What will happen if China suffers from famine?
9 January 2013
'I can make everything' policy will weaken defense industry
7 January 2013
Yet another process to beat terror
2 January 2013
Getting rid of a state of siege mood
31 December 2012
Beginning new year with good news for transparency
28 December 2012
Invitation crisis implicates PM
26 December 2012
Grave violation of soldier rights
24 December 2012
Turkey's unclear direction raises concerns
20 December 2012
Russia should cooperate if it wants to protect post-Assad interests in Syria
17 December 2012
Why was Taraf important?
13 December 2012
Why has the Turkish commander received a medal?
10 December 2012
Why didn't Russia ask for the return of seized military equipment from Turkey?
5 December 2012
Immunity debate demonstrates Turkey's Kurdish deadlock
3 December 2012
Scrutiny over defense industry activities
26 November 2012
Turkish nationalism prone to exploitation
21 November 2012
Turkish Parliament surprised me
19 November 2012
End of hunger strikes may revive peace talks
14 November 2012
Is Turkey seeking a 19th-century constitutional monarchy?
12 November 2012
In Turkey causes of incidents are left in the dark
7 November 2012
Göktürk satellite project recalls reform in defense industry
5 November 2012
Hunger strike opens a new page in Kurdish question
1 November 2012
Curiosity surrounds Babacan's replacement
29 October 2012
Turkey's security-centric approach and its repercussions
24 October 2012
Turkey's choice: modernity over democracy
22 October 2012
Erdoğan is hedging his bets
17 October 2012
Turkey should not criticize, it is doing poorly
15 October 2012
Turkey should make efforts to diffuse tension with Syria
11 October 2012
Transparency will beat corruption
9 October 2012
Civilian protection and state transparency
3 October 2012
Nations run out of ideas on Syria as FSA runs out of ammunition
1 October 2012
Another Oslo cannot come out from this speech
26 September 2012
New party scenarios are discussed in Ankara
24 September 2012
Future coups or coup plans will freeze Turkey's NATO membership
19 September 2012
War to gain psychological superiority
17 September 2012
Dealing with arms in post-Assad period
12 September 2012
One step forward, two steps back
10 September 2012
Transparency and accountability are key for democracy
29 August 2012
Alarm bells do not ring despite danger on its way
27 August 2012
Returning to normalcy
22 August 2012
A nation that can't finish the war
15 August 2012
Why media becomes vulnerable
13 August 2012
Turkey's gamble on Syria
8 August 2012
Rethinking Kurdish question as Burkay talks
6 August 2012
What is YAŞ?
1 August 2012
Between paranoia and reality
30 July 2012
Indifference to police misconduct
26 July 2012
Critical questions not asked in F-4 downing
23 July 2012
Turkey’s difficult times as Syrian conflict intensifies
18 July 2012
Is the CHP the same old story, same old song?
16 July 2012
Turkey played all cards in Syrian conflict
11 July 2012
Transparency will shed light on jet downing
9 July 2012
Helping Kurds explore avenues other than guns
4 July 2012
Turkish media deceives public over strength of locally developed arms
2 July 2012
Government is taken hostage by Huntington’s theory
20 June 2012
Gül to return to politics on his own terms
18 June 2012
Turkey should beat fear to thwart extreme Kurdish demands
13 June 2012
AK Party faces risk of losing popular support
...
Bloggers