Empathy, justice, humility
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
24 May 2013 Friday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 12 December 2012, Wednesday 4 0 0 0
CENGİZ AKTAR
c.aktar@todayszaman.com

Empathy, justice, humility

The terrible civil war raging throughout Turkey’s neighbor Syria does not just affect the Sunnis there. After all, we are talking about a civil war, meaning that everything there has come unhinged.

In Turkey, the official empathy is limited to the majority Sunni Syrians. And with the exception of a handful of civil society organizations, it is difficult to say that Turkish society in general seems very saddened by what is happening. At the same time, though, in addition to the Sunni Syrians who have been deeply affected by the civil war, there are also the Syrian Armenians, former citizens of Anatolia. These are people whose ancestors were kicked out of Anatolia. The grandchildren of those who survived the massacres live today in Syria, Lebanon and a few in Iraq. So don’t they deserve just as much sympathy as their Sunni compatriots? Especially in light of all that befell them a century ago.

At the start of the Syrian civil war, there was talk of Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoğlu raising the issue with Armenians in Turkey. True or not, couldn’t Turkey, so inept in facing up to its past with Armenians, reach out to extend just a bit of support to the grandchildren of the Anatolian Armenians? In fact, if only a miracle were to unfold and citizenship be re-granted to these people...

Vital test for the judiciary

The Turkish justice system is marked by the reflex to protect the state against the society and the citizen. It will be very difficult and lengthy to finally start looking out for the citizen. It was in fact with the military-inspired 1982 Constitution that our pro-state justice system reached its peak point. With the recent EU-inspired reforms, followed by the Sept. 12, 2010 referendum and the two latest justice bills, members of the judiciary have had a hasty series of new rules difficult for them to keep pace with.

But the problems of the judiciary do not end here. It now faces individuals who are becoming more and more vocal against the authorities much more than they ever used to be. And so the judiciary finds it increasingly difficult to ensure justice in the face of this democratic power with all of its various demands and criticisms.

Today the system produces a kind of justice in which individuals lined up before the courts are potentially guilty. And they are not just those who have committed political crimes, but any citizen.

Saddam Hussein and his mosques

The debate about the prime minister’s mosque projects reminds me how much hubris is a common human behavior. Saddam Hussein, who had no nothing to do with religion, suddenly got interested in religious topics after the war with Iran and the first Gulf War. Then the foundations of three gigantic mosques were laid in Iraq. Saddam did live to see the Umm al-Ma’arik, or Mother of All Battles, Mosque, but I do not think the second mosque, Ar-Rahman, has ever been finished. As for the third one, the Great Saddam Mosque, which was intended to be five times as large as the Umm al-Ma’arik, has fallen from the agenda. Actually, the building of the first mosque is in itself a legend. Its four outer minarets, each 43 meters high, came up against the 43 days of the “Desert Storm” battle of the US Army. As for the four 37-meter-high inner minarets, which are attached to the outer minarets, they celebrate the April 1937 birth month and year of the late dictator. And interestingly, they are built in the shape of Scud missiles aimed by Iraq at both the US and Israel. Some compare the shape of these minarets to a Kalashnikov rifle. What stylishness!

The mosque’s Quranic calligraphy was written by Abbas el-Bagdadi, using 28 liters of Saddam’s blood mixed with ink. Each of the 605 pages is protected in glass. As for the small pond outside the mosque, it is in the shape of the Arab world, with a tiny island in its corner made from blue mosaic stones in a copy of Saddam’s fingerprints. Let’s see what secrets will be enshrined in the prime minister’s mosques.

COMMENTS
Well ! It seems like you folks didn't find my comment to post appropriate , simply because I described Anadolu as kilikia , So from now on I will not waist my time and energy to comment on a lot of these articles , or even read them. Regards
Vartan
Great and level headed article, with a twist of tragicomic at the end. True, until the judiciary are able to protect society Turkey will never grow up. You are innocent until guilty in a democratic society. This is the fundamental mindset that has to change soon.
Agnes
Mr. Aktar ! It is indeed very considerate of you to talk about the dire situation the Syrian Armenian community is facing these days . I my relatives are stuck in there homes in Aleppo for over two weeks now , and only have been going out for a few minutes to buy food while risking sniper fire and ...
Vartan
For us Gavur, we cannot expect "Empathy, Justice and Humility" from Turkey. Given both the past and the present, the main focus must be on transactional relations defined by realpolitik. If Turkey wants a relief from Armenian lobbying which costs it about 200 million a year, it needs to begin payi...
Jack Kalpakian
Click here to read all user comments
Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
22 May 2013
Nuclear (un)consciousness
15 May 2013
Europe Week: legitimacy crisis versus bright spots
8 May 2013
Last constitution of ancient Turkey
1 May 2013
What was April 24?
24 April 2013
Economy and waste
17 April 2013
Realpolitik and the new ethic
10 April 2013
Towards regionalization?
3 April 2013
Negotiation time for AK Party
27 March 2013
Israel and its apology
20 March 2013
What if we simply call it the ‘democratization process'?
13 March 2013
European Charter of Local Self-Government revisited
6 March 2013
An alarming act against nature conservation
27 February 2013
Allowing time for the constitution
20 February 2013
Regional policy
13 February 2013
Shànghǎi Hézuò Zǔzhī
6 February 2013
Labor unions and job security
30 January 2013
The Touareg
23 January 2013
Parliamentary inquiry commission on military coups and memorandums
16 January 2013
Conflict resolution
9 January 2013
A time tunnel to 2013
2 January 2013
Presidential system, not Constitution, on agenda
26 December 2012
Concentration of powers
19 December 2012
Brotherhood by homeland
12 December 2012
Empathy, justice, humility
5 December 2012
Environmental notes
28 November 2012
New functions for metropolitan municipalities
21 November 2012
Urban hardship
14 November 2012
‘We are alive; we survived’
7 November 2012
Debating GMOs
31 October 2012
Turkey’s place in a multi-speed Europe
24 October 2012
This time the EU has lingered on the agenda
17 October 2012
Europe’s peace
10 October 2012
Turkish military’s unending public legitimacy
3 October 2012
Solutions to conflicts will make agenda sooner or later
26 September 2012
Loyalty, voice and exit
19 September 2012
Any ideas about the meaning of war?
12 September 2012
Local refugee policy
5 September 2012
Foretastes from our new models
29 August 2012
National matrix
22 August 2012
Online freedom of expression
1 August 2012
Disarmament and art
25 July 2012
Inclusive and exclusive foreign policies
18 July 2012
Syriacs are full Turkish citizens
11 July 2012
What about a second time zone?
4 July 2012
Beating our history
27 June 2012
Inclusion of Kurdish language in education system
20 June 2012
Unattended Cyprus issue
13 June 2012
Development at any cost
6 June 2012
Anatolia’s recovery from amnesia
30 May 2012
A positive agenda
23 May 2012
Rather a systemic crisis
16 May 2012
This presidential system would lead Turkey to autocracy
9 May 2012
Turkish-French relations after Sarkozy
2 May 2012
France’s election
25 April 2012
After denial
18 April 2012
Time to settle all accounts with the military mentality
11 April 2012
The new investment incentive package
4 April 2012
Playing amongst ourselves
28 March 2012
Syrian refugees and the state of asylum policy
21 March 2012
Accidents and deaths in workplace are not destiny
14 March 2012
New constitution should be brought back to the agenda
7 March 2012
Turkey’s Armenian policy subcontracted to Azerbaijan?
29 February 2012
Ceausescus never die; neither do Bashars!
22 February 2012
Taksim Square and the Black Sea Highway
15 February 2012
New Arab actors versus fresh Cold War
8 February 2012
A new phase in demilitarization
1 February 2012
Consultation
25 January 2012
Dealing with national causes
18 January 2012
We shall keep on talking like Hrant
11 January 2012
Law of armed conflict
4 January 2012
2012: a difficult year that should motivate us
28 December 2011
Balance sheet after ‘Boyer Act’
21 December 2011
Saving the day by selling the future
14 December 2011
We are all in the same boat
7 December 2011
Russian restoration Act II
30 November 2011
Eurocynicism
23 November 2011
Recommence the speech where it ended
16 November 2011
Human development and Turkey’s rankings
9 November 2011
Yugoslavia 20 years ago
2 November 2011
Towards the multilateral conference on Cyprus
26 October 2011
Annotated agenda
19 October 2011
‘Kosovoization'?
12 October 2011
The week of the report
5 October 2011
‘You don’t make peace with your friends, do you?’
28 September 2011
Eastern Mediterranean fossil fuels: a lose-lose-lose scenario
...