Israel's right to self-defense!
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
22 May 2013 Wednesday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 15 November 2012, Thursday 29 0 0 0
BÜLENT KENEŞ
b.kenes@todayszaman.com

Israel's right to self-defense!

The world was once again left with the usual double-dealing attitude in the wake of the attack Israel launched into Gaza, indiscriminate of women or children. Like any nationalist politician who needs more support, the Benjamin Netanyahu-led Israeli government opts for addressing the chauvinist sentiments of the Israeli public in order to boost its popular backing in the country, and by doing so, it is playing with fire. Israel attacked the 1.7 million Gazan Palestinians who are already living under an Israeli occupation and blockade. The code name given to the attack was inspired by the following verse in the Torah, "By day the Lord went ahead of them in a pillar of cloud to guide them on their way and by night in a pillar of fire to give them light, so that they could travel by day or night." Despite the fact that the Netanyahu administration is so reckless as to give a religious identity to its recent brutal attack against Gazans by naming it "Pillar of Cloud," it still maintains the unconditional support it receives from the Western countries, to our dismay.

Israel and Western powers entertain a suspicious attitude toward Hamas. As you'll remember, when Hamas entered the democratically held elections in 2006, neither the US nor any other Western powers raised any objection. However, when it won the elections, Hamas became the target of pressure and attacks. Having assassinated Ahmed Jabari, the head of Hamas' armed wing, on Wednesday, Israel expanded the scope of its attacks, attacking Gaza from land, air and sea and killing everyone indiscriminately. As of yesterday morning, the number of casualties has risen to 11. And there were about 120 people wounded in the attacks. The dead include innocent infants, whose bodies were pierced with Israeli shells, including the 11-month-old Ahmad Mashrawi, who is son of BBC's Gaza reporter. Still, the statements by certain countries, including the US and Canada, in support of the Israeli attacks refer to right of self-defense of Israel, a country which has been officially implementing state-sponsored terrorism for more than 60 years in the region.

Turning a blind eye to Israeli's fanaticism in choosing a name for its massacre from its religious texts, Canadian Foreign Minister John Baird said that he lent support to Israel's efforts to resist those who threaten the peace and security of the region. "We support Israel's right to defend itself," said US State Department spokesman Mark Toner. Moreover, ignoring the fact that most of the people who died in the Israeli attacks were innocent Gazans who have the same right to self-defense as Israelis, Susan Rice, the US Permanent Representative to the United Nations (UN), who is expected to succeed Hillary Clinton as the US Secretary of State, announced the US's support for Israel's response to Hamas' attacks.

Speaking to Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Egyptian President Mohammed Morsi on the phone, US President Barack Obama, unfortunately, did nothing better, and parroted opinions similar to those of Toner and Rice. Obama and Rice's call on Israel to exert their best efforts to avoid civilian casualties may be meaningful, but they are unfortunately aware that this attitude refusing to acknowledge Palestinians' most basic right to life will be of no use in establishing peace in the region.

Here, I must note, every attack launched by anyone or for any purpose against civilians, either in Israel or in Palestine, is illegitimate and can be defined as terrorism. Just as it is impossible to defend the missiles Hamas militants send to Israeli-dominated territories without discriminating between civilian and military targets, it is equally inconceivable not to define the massacres Israel undertakes without discriminating between civilians and militants in Gaza -- a region which has already been turned into an outdoor prison by the Israeli death machine through years of blockade -- as state-sponsored terrorism. Both acts can hardly be defended by any sane person. Thus, both 11 Palestinians killed in the Israeli bombardment and three Israeli civilians who died in the house hit by a Hamas missile are victims of equally cruel attacks. Just as we are right to condemn the attacks Israel launches against Gaza with its F-16 warplanes, unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs), helicopters and assault boats, we find it equally unacceptable for Hamas to send dozens of missiles to civilian-inhabited regions in Israel, even if it is done out of the despair of being pushed into a corner.

Israeli military spokeswoman Lt. Col. Avital Leibovich's disclosure that the "Pillar of Cloud" attack is just the beginning of a more comprehensive operation, as well as Palestinian resistance groups who immediately gathered together to declared their determination for revenge, indicate that we are on the brink of a new crisis. In other words, we may start to nurture big worries about the inception of a new bloody process with an uncertain future in Palestine, similar to the one in Syria. This process, unfavorable to all parties, is undoubtedly of close concern to regional countries like Turkey and Egypt.

In particular, Egypt, which, like Turkey, tries to save Hamas from Iran's pro-violence influence, sees the most recent attacks as targeting itself as much as they target Palestinians. In this context, Morsi's political adviser Mohammed Saif Al-Dawla's statement that "Israel assassinated Ahmad Jabari physically and Morsi spiritually" is considerably meaningful. Egypt's tendency to perceive the Israeli attack as a move designed to undermine the Egyptian revolution and Morsi's popularity unfortunately implies that the hellfire sparked by Israel has the potential to grow.

In such a setting, Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan's trip to Egypt on Saturday, scheduled months ago and viewed as having great importance, has acquired additional significance. Erdoğan will fly to Cairo, accompanied by several ministers of his Cabinet, where he will take part in a high-level joint cabinet meeting with Egyptian officials, and his statements there about Israel's inhuman attacks as well as the dosage of his criticisms may trigger new dynamics in the Middle East.

The Israeli attacks relate to the Syrian crisis as well. At a time when the Syrian opposition, having acquired a more representative structure, is demanding more support and attention from the world, Netanyahu attacked Gaza to draw the world's attention from the massacres in Syria to Palestine, thus doing a great favor to the bloodthirsty Assad regime. This can be described as one murderer's coming to the rescue of another. In any case, we can safely assert that with Israel's attack on Gaza on the evening of Nov. 14, the Middle East's already complicated and uncertain status has become more complicated and more uncertain. With every innocent person killed in Israeli attacks, the hopes for a peaceful and stable Middle East become dimmer.

COMMENTS
Right for self-defense! Only Israelis must have that right. Poor Palestinians have nothing, not even a simple right!
David
Good job Mr. Kenes, you hit the nail in the head.
Khaled
Hamas is not a terrorist organisation, Hamas is part of Turkey proxies in the Middle East, isn't it ?
Ben Yacob
When Israel left Gaza, several years back, the Palestinians were left to their own devices in their small yet free enclave. Instead of devoting their energies to economic growth and building an oasis of stability and peaceful security, something dozens of countries had offered help in doing, they h...
Abu Khalil
@ ANJA Turks are a race of Sakhtakars ,some people confuse them for been a nation of Hypocrats ,they are wrong
Esfandyar
Blaming Shia Iran is very typical for sectarian pseudo-Sunni Wahhabi and AKP/Muslim Fraternity outlets. Shia Muslim Arabs of South Lebanon only retaliated after Israeli aggression in 2006. The Sunni movement of Hamas is different. Israel has a right to defend itself against illegal rockets. Iran is ...
Abu Piet
Hamas has launched 5000 rockets at Israel. Does the columnist think that it is such a minor detail that he does not even have to mention it? Well, then look at how Mr Erdogan calls for Nato support after ONE rocket from Syria. Here we are talking about double standards galore.
Rocket
Wow! Such words of wisdom coming from a Turkish columnist is mind blowing! Perhaps Israel should apply the Turkish solution. Israel should annex Gaza, outlaw Arabic and Arab culture, force Palestinian children to cry out every school day "One Jew is worth the world!" and "Happy is he who says he is ...
Aziz
it is iran causing trouble again! as this writer has indicated, iran's influence is making hamas violent. if we want to solve this problem we have to strike at the source, which is iran.
jeevan
How funny "Israel's right to self-defense" sounds!
Cem
@senol: I think you remember the pictures of beheaded PKK members in the newspapers. Glad to hear how civilized Turkey really is. And don't tell me Turkey would not hit Karaylan in the same way - if they could ... That is the main difference between Turkey and Israel here.
anja
Can hardly wait for Erdogan's forthcoming visit to Egypt. We wait with bated breath for his biased comments: again own foot in the mouth, another own goal,lots of lost "friends"and further isolation! With a prime minister like Erdogan, Israel has its greatest friend. But the Turks can't see it!
Haydar
I don't think Israel's attack on Gaza has anything to do with Syria.They just lost their patience with all those rockets and missiles fired against them from Gaza day by day.Every country would react in the same way, in case she faced such a continous provocation.Hamas has a Chapter where she mentio...
Chris Athens
Are you also so sarcastic
arc
Let those who blindly defend Israel's atrocities as act of self defence know that this is a bloody investment in upcoming election by hawkish Netanyahu and his circle. W do not want any suffering on Israelis and palestinians. This is time for the ordinary Israelis to force their government for acc...
James
great article. keep your spirit up and do not let Murdock school of though destroy your independent thinking
James
I wish the author to taste living under rockets for years and years (around 1000/year) from a terrorist entity. Then will see how he will refer to such a reality. Turkey's administration chosen to embrace islamic terrorism. Hamas is considered a terrorist organization by EU, US, Canada and other co...
theo
Kenes: Where's your soft and/or hard power? Why don't you Turks put your money where your mouth is and go it alone? But you won't because, as usual, you want other states to pay the bill.
Shena
I just have ONE question for you Mr. writer of this article, if Hamas didn't start the fire, would you be writing this idiotic biased article? You talked about references from the Torah, LMAO, like you make no reference to the Koran, do you not know what reference Hamas has used from the Koran in th...
Jaime
@Robert, your missing two key points, Turkey does not assasinate PKK leaders in Turkey or in Europe, yet alone in populated areas with Airplane bombings and rockets. The other, we havn't imprizoned them as a result they are not desperate to do what they no other mean to deliver.
Senol
It gotta be from the book of Joshua 6:1-20 and Exodus 13:21. Again this saga between those two nations is from the Ages = Ismael and Isaac.
wr
The reporter described the situation very dramatically because instead to wright the truth and beeng inpopular he choosed to go with the stream. Hamas is a political and military organisation with ideology of wipe Israel from the map. They declared very clearly that they will newer recognise the rig...
kzeev
It is time for Islamic world to move forward, leaving the West behind.
Asif Reyaz
What would Turkey's response be if hundreds of rockets were raining down on its cities on a daily basis. What a one sided article to say the least. Israel is fully justified in defending its citizens and returning fire to a world renowned terror organization called Hamas.
Robert
Get accustomed to hear the facts which being covered for decades. When end comes a bright new beginning starts. This is the pure truth and there are hearts to beat for thrutfullness.
Facts hurt
Very well articulated, Thank0You
Osmanli
It seems the author forgets on purpose that Hamas denies Israel's right of existence and is officially considered a terror organisation by the US, Canada, the EU, Japan and a host of other democracies...
erol
What can Mr. Erdogan say that he did not say before? His hateful words towards Israel and his enmity towards Jews are well-known throughout the region. Whereas all the Western states and NATO members expressed their sympathy with Israel, it is only Turkey that stands out as supportive of terrorist H...
Israeli
Islamist Zaman's hatred of Israel is not new, but this combination of lies and conspiracy theories is much lower than even the standard of enmity usually displayed in the newspaper (the Turkish version is much worse). The Hizmet movement always claim that they are not Islamists, but their publicatio...
Yavuz
Click here to read all user comments
Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
19 May 2013
We make peace with ourselves as we integrate with the world
14 May 2013
Mr. Erdoğan goes to Washington
12 May 2013
Do we know this language? To what extent?
9 May 2013
Religious and sectarian wars in the Middle East
7 May 2013
5 years ago, 40 years after
30 April 2013
Concrete civilization
25 April 2013
The way to cope with radicalism, extremism
23 April 2013
Can Turkey overcome its bad luck in EU membership process?
21 April 2013
Fear of radicalism in Syria: the self-fulfilling prophecy
18 April 2013
Why is the GYV statement on press freedom significant?
16 April 2013
Role of NGOs in democratization, demilitarization, conflict resolution (2)
14 April 2013
Role of NGOs in democratization, demilitarization, conflict resolution (1)
11 April 2013
Turkey and Azerbaijan on converging paths
2 April 2013
Choreography of the settlement process
28 March 2013
Germany running the neo-Nazi and racist gauntlet
26 March 2013
The New Middle East
21 March 2013
Glad tidings for a colorful spring, and concerns
19 March 2013
Borders and limits
14 March 2013
The effect of ‘soft power' on Turkey's rapid development
10 March 2013
There is no Kurdish issue in Turkey!
7 March 2013
What's the situation in the talks with the PKK?
5 March 2013
Öcalan invests in the post-İmralı era
22 January 2013
What does the aborted attack against the İzmit church tell us?
20 January 2013
İshak Alaton's letter to TÜSİAD
17 January 2013
Theses on PKK members assassinated in Paris
15 January 2013
World's most famous Turkish brand: Today's Zaman
10 January 2013
Risks facing İmralı process
8 January 2013
But which PKK?
6 January 2013
Hope and caution necessary in talks with PKK
3 January 2013
Not funny in the least!
1 January 2013
Demirel, psychological warfare and media
30 December 2012
Assessment of a year
27 December 2012
Cyprus under siege: analysis
25 December 2012
Cyprus under siege: predictions
23 December 2012
Cyprus under siege: observations
20 December 2012
Yearning for unchecked and unbalanced power
16 December 2012
Ergenekon alive and operational
11 December 2012
Is Turkey's EU membership declining in importance?
9 December 2012
Alienation of Turkey's Kurds
6 December 2012
Egypt, Morsi and democracy
2 December 2012
The coup commission's praiseworthy performance
29 November 2012
'Not enough, but yes' to elimination of school uniforms
27 November 2012
History, art and power
22 November 2012
The other side of the coin: Hamas
20 November 2012
Israeli aggression and 'new circumstances in the Mideast'
18 November 2012
Israel's right to kill!
15 November 2012
Israel's right to self-defense!
13 November 2012
A massacre that is becoming ordinary in the insensitive eyes of the world
11 November 2012
Turkey's place: the East or the West?
8 November 2012
‘Can Turkey shoulder the responsibility of being a model country?'
6 November 2012
The choice of the US people and the world
4 November 2012
Rising Anatolia
30 October 2012
Through patience, it seems, our republic is evolving into a democracy
11 October 2012
Why are we angry at our EU snapshot?
9 October 2012
Civilian supervision of military a must, but how to do it?
4 October 2012
We must stop seeing Azerbaijan purely as a source of oil and natural gas
2 October 2012
Has Turkey already abandoned its EU vision?
30 September 2012
AKP congress and R2P from Davutoğlu's perspective
27 September 2012
Who is the real hero that stopped the Balyoz coup?
25 September 2012
Quo vadis Turkey?
23 September 2012
Balyoz verdict and the future of coup culture
20 September 2012
Democracy, tolerance and forbearance
18 September 2012
The prep courses debate and Erdoğan's real intentions
16 September 2012
Muhammad, Jesus and Moses are our revered values
13 September 2012
Is it freedom of expression or a hate crime?
6 September 2012
I have good news for newspapers!
4 September 2012
Speaking out in hard times
30 August 2012
Media's 'Kony's and child abuse
28 August 2012
Can Morsi's historic Iran visit be seen as a sign of a shift of axis?
9 August 2012
Cold War with Iran
5 August 2012
Has the coup threat been averted yet?
2 August 2012
Ibn Khaldun’s lessons on politics for leaders
31 July 2012
Nizam al-Mülk’s advice for today’s leaders
29 July 2012
Afghanistanization risk in Syria
26 July 2012
Islam, Islamic and Islamism
24 July 2012
Arakan: a big massacre witnessed by the insensitive world
22 July 2012
When will Ankara change its thesis about the downed F-4?
19 July 2012
‘Assad struck at the heart’
15 July 2012
Rule of the executive
12 July 2012
All Muslims, like Turks, don’t see contradiction between democracy and Islam
10 July 2012
Turks prioritize economy or democracy?
5 July 2012
Is Iran's nuclear program peaceful?
1 July 2012
Clutching at straws with Syria
28 June 2012
One correct and one wrong move
24 June 2012
Turkish-Syrian tension and Abant platform
21 June 2012
Kurds’ PKK issue
19 June 2012
The PKK issue must be settled once and for all
17 June 2012
Syrian deadlock’s blow to Egypt
14 June 2012
A rift between the Hizmet movement and the AKP?
12 June 2012
First year of AKP’s third term
5 June 2012
Focus is on serving humanity, not only promoting Turkish
3 June 2012
Those who are not part of the solution to the Syrian crisis are part of the problem
31 May 2012
PM gives glad tidings to subversive generals!
29 May 2012
Red suitcase, honorable commander(s) and others
27 May 2012
What befell Niyazi-i Misri in the past is happening to Fethullah Gülen now
22 May 2012
The role of civil society in Turkey's democratization
20 May 2012
If democracy had ever come, it wouldn't have gone away!
15 May 2012
How has resource-low South Korea ended up the world’s 13th-largest economy?
13 May 2012
Yes to presidential system if...
10 May 2012
Erdoğan, military coups and public opinion
...