Unemployment can be headache for government
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
21 May 2013 Tuesday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 18 October 2012, Thursday 0 0 0 0
SEYFETTİN GÜRSEL
s.gursel@todayszaman.com

Unemployment can be headache for government

Labor market statistics for July revealed on Monday by the Turkish Statistics Institute (TurkStat) point to a turning point in the unemployment rate, which has been in decline since the economy's strong recovery in the aftermath of the crisis in 2009. The seasonally adjusted unemployment rate rose from 8.9 percent in June to 9.1 percent in July in line with a decrease of 0.4 percent in employment -- within a month employment has declined by 102,000 people, adding 48,000 to the ranks of the unemployed. If the labor force had not been decreased slightly, the unemployment increase would have been even stronger.

On the side of the government, the reaction to what must be considered a major event was either silence or diversion. We heard nothing from Deputy Prime Minister Ali Babacan, in charge of economic affairs, while Economy Minister Zafer Çağlayan preferred to remind us of the yearly drop in unemployment, from 9.1 percent July 2011 to 8.4 percent in July of this year. This is, admittedly, an irrefutable fact, but it is at the same time a useless fact. Indeed, it is quite normal that employment had shown growth during the last year given the fact that Turkish economy was expanding, albeit at a slower rate. So, the decrease in the unemployment rate in July compared to last year is not surprising at all. The problem is that the yearly approach is unable to inform us on what is currently happening in the Turkish labor market. As such, we have to look closely to the seasonally adjusted figures -- since both employment and the labor force are subject to strong seasonal fluctuations in Turkey -- if we would like to understand the current changes in unemployment.

As I noted above, these seasonally adjusted figures show an increase in unemployment. Having said that, is it possible to conclude that the rate of unemployment has reached its height? I do not think so. This is my opinion, but I am required, of course, to provide support for it as well. During the first half of this year, the gross domestic product (GDP) growth rate declined to 3 percent. The estimations for the third quarter indicate an even slower rate prospect. These days, a growth rate near 3 percent is considered miraculous in Europe, but for Turkey this is rather bad news. This degree of growth is not sufficient to create enough jobs in order to absorb the regular rise of the labor force. Indeed, the trend for the labor force's yearly increase is between 500,000 and 600,000 people. On the other hand, the GDP growth necessary to create that many jobs is estimated at around 5 percent, or at the least 4 percent, assuming that the capacity of such growth to create jobs is at its highest.

Obviously Turkey's economy is not growing this fast today, but could it reach these levels in the coming years? Let me point out that this is exactly what the last Medium-term Economic Program (OVP), the government's official roadmap for the economy, assumes. Sustained growth in the Turkish economy, as I have explained many times in this column, depends on two basic factors: A solid improvement in the competitiveness of Turkish industries and an increase in domestic savings. Both of these factors require difficult structural reforms, such as more flexibility in the labor market, lower energy costs, a tough attack on tax evasion, perseverance on budget discipline and, last but not least, a decrease in inflation.

Actual debate on how to encourage domestic demand in order to boost growth is in vain. Growth in the Turkish economy can no longer continue to rely on the domestic demand exclusively, for the simple reason that the current account deficit, albeit narrowed to 7.5 percent of GDP thanks to a decrease in domestic demand, has hit the brakes at an unsustainable level. Despite this fact, exports must carry on at a higher rate than imports, as they did last year, in order to have more balanced growth. This cannot be achieved without a quick implementation of all the structural reforms I mentioned above.

Here emerges the political dilemma. Next October, Turkey will have three successive elections within less than two years in the order of the local, presidential and then general election. For any democratically elected government, elections are not suitable moments for implementing reforms, which imply winners but also plenty of losers -- many of which may be supporters of the incumbent. In that case we can expect that the government will be squeezed between the unpopularity of a rising unemployment and the anger that structural reforms risks provoking. If I had to decide, I would opt for the reforms -- if, of course, I believe that the rise in unemployment is unavoidable.

Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
20 May 2013
A European socialist view of the CHP
17 May 2013
Employment increases despite low growth
13 May 2013
Working women and the headscarf
10 May 2013
Interesting questions on Turkish economy
6 May 2013
‘Eurozone is on the brink of collapse'
3 May 2013
Amalgams should be avoided
29 April 2013
Structural features of unemployment
26 April 2013
Peace process going well but not the economy
22 April 2013
Material deprivation among children
19 April 2013
Limits of monetary policy
15 April 2013
The gas of the east Mediterranean
12 April 2013
A modest revival in sight
8 April 2013
Working children
5 April 2013
Central bank facing trade-offs
1 April 2013
Hard landing is confirmed
29 March 2013
A surprising upgrade
25 March 2013
An outcome fraught with consequences
22 March 2013
Peace dividends
18 March 2013
Are the brakes burning?
15 March 2013
Unemployment is still on a rising trend
11 March 2013
Something is being plotted over Cyprus
8 March 2013
Huge regional disparities in unemployment
4 March 2013
Is education a panacea?
1 March 2013
Productivity or employment
25 February 2013
Neither working nor studying
22 February 2013
‘Women hold up half the sky' -- Mao Zedong
18 February 2013
Female employment, as well as unemployment, greatly increased
15 February 2013
More children will not solve aging population problem
11 February 2013
Worries on economic growth
8 February 2013
Once again on the presidential debate
4 February 2013
Fears of ageing population
1 February 2013
The ideal but difficult mix for the Turkish economy
28 January 2013
Uncertainty regarding EU membership is increasing
25 January 2013
‘Informality' in the Turkish labor market
21 January 2013
Bid for regional power could be realized through peace
18 January 2013
Too little growth, too much employment
14 January 2013
Undesirable tradeoff
11 January 2013
Erdem Başçı, central banker of the year
7 January 2013
How bad is it going in Europe?
4 January 2013
Pro-coup mindset waiting for AK Party's failure in economics
31 December 2012
Two scenarios for the Turkish economy in 2013
28 December 2012
The year of rebalancing
24 December 2012
‘Confusing' policies of the Turkish Central Bank
21 December 2012
Turkish schools abroad: a global phenomenon
17 December 2012
Unemployment up as expected
14 December 2012
Kurdistan oil: a strategic shift
11 December 2012
Growth: Lower than expected
6 December 2012
Debt crisis as seen from Greece
3 December 2012
OECD is rather optimistic on the Turkish economy
30 November 2012
Greece's ‘dark period' not over yet
26 November 2012
European turmoil's and the Turkish accession
22 November 2012
Why can't credit rating agencies agree?
19 November 2012
Too much focus on presidential election is dangerous
16 November 2012
Two bad, one good news item
12 November 2012
Income inequality in Turkey
9 November 2012
Upgrading Turkey
5 November 2012
Depreciation is hardly a tool for competitiveness
1 November 2012
AK Party decade from a historical perspective
29 October 2012
World Savings Day
24 October 2012
Reshaping EU presents new opportunity for Turkey
22 October 2012
Housing prices in Turkey
18 October 2012
Unemployment can be headache for government
15 October 2012
Turkey-EU relations need new perspective
11 October 2012
Is the new roadmap credible?
8 October 2012
The risk Syria poses to the Turkish economy
4 October 2012
AK Party's 2023 vision
1 October 2012
Not much room to maneuver
27 September 2012
Electoral system reform
24 September 2012
Looking for the right policy mıx
16 September 2012
Poverty in Turkey
10 September 2012
Second quarter confirms worries about low growth
3 September 2012
BRICS a challenge to the supremacy of the West
27 August 2012
Turkish bourgeoisie according to Orhan Pamuk
12 August 2012
Severance pay reform
5 August 2012
Demographic dynamics, aging populations and Turkey
31 July 2012
Republican People's Party has no economic strategy
22 July 2012
Long term growth perspectives for Turkey
15 July 2012
Austerity policies in jeopardy
8 July 2012
The unpleasant low growth perspective
1 July 2012
Dangers on Turkey's road to becoming a real regional power
24 June 2012
The European deadlock
17 June 2012
Babacan is decided on fiscal discipline
10 June 2012
A revolutionary program for Greece
3 June 2012
Sluggish growth and AK Party rule
27 May 2012
Pro-poor economic growth and the AK Party
20 May 2012
What should we do with a president elected by a general vote?
13 May 2012
Open letter to French President Hollande
6 May 2012
Is Standard & Poor's so wrong?
29 April 2012
On employment and labor market reforms
22 April 2012
Economic background of military coups
15 April 2012
Signs of a slowdown
8 April 2012
Investment incentives arrived at right moment
1 April 2012
Fiscal devaluation for Turkey
25 March 2012
Fiscal devaluation instead of an exit from euro
18 March 2012
The worrying savings gap
11 March 2012
Women: Too few are working, too much violence against them
4 March 2012
Sisyphus and the Danaids
26 February 2012
A masked debate on education
19 February 2012
Exports will be the key for a soft landing
...