Tragedy in Western Thrace
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
25 May 2013 Saturday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 16 October 2012, Tuesday 16 0 0 0
HÜSEYİN GÜLERCE
h.gulerce@todayszaman.com

Tragedy in Western Thrace

Last Sunday, a meeting was held under the sponsorship and auspices of Burhanetting Hakgüder, chair of the Western Thrace Turks Solidarity Association, to address problems of Turkish journalists in Western Thrace and issues of the Turkish minority there. The meeting was attended by 80 journalists from Turkey and Western Thrace, as well as Justice and Development Party (AK Party) Edirne deputy Mehmet Müezzinoğlu and Republican People's Party (CHP) Edirne deputy Kemal Değirmendereli.

As with Cyprus, the rights, issues and freedoms of the Turks of Western Thrace represent a national cause for us. But unfortunately, the media and the public remain indifferent to this cause. Hearing the Turkish journalists from Western Thrace, it sounded as if they worked in a totalitarian regime rather than an EU member state. Democracy was restored to Greece after the junta administration of the '60s and '70s, at a time when democracy was considered a luxury for the Turks. But, interestingly, the Turkish minority are treated like stepsons of the country, despite the EU being aware of the situation in Greece.

Turkish journalists are not allowed to become members of media associations in Greece. They have become targets of a campaign of intimidation; they are fined large amounts of between 150,000 and 250,000 euros for transgressions, while in reality the fines should never exceed 6,000 euros. Let me give you an example of this pressure and intimidation: the Millet daily is not allowed to register its name. Why? Its name resembles that of the Milliyet daily in Turkey. Businesspeople, as well as institutions and corporations, including the Ziraat Bank and Turkish Airlines, are unable to advertise in these papers.

The problems of the Turkish minority in Western Thrace are even graver than the problems experienced by the media. Besides, the economic crisis has exacerbated the problems of racism and Islamophobia in Greece, as it has in Europe in general. The 150,000 Turkish-Muslim people in the country have been the victims of racist assaults. They also have to deal with threats from the far-right and racist Golden Dawn Party.

The greatest problem is the denial of the Turkish identity. The Greek government does not allow the establishment of any institution or association bearing a title that includes “Turk” in Western Thrace. The second most important problem is education. The Turkish minority has established its own schools; but cannot offer elementary or secondary education. The Greek government has reserved a 0.5 percent quota in universities for the minority since 1998, but young people who have not received a good education fail to perform well at Greek universities. Those who study in Turkey face qualification problems and issues of recognition of their diplomas. Turkish preschool institutions are also rare, with 7,000 out of 12,000 children having to attend Greek institutions.

The Greek government does not recognize the elected muftis, despite the Treaty of Lausanne; it appoints its own muftis. There are also serious problems in the Turkish foundations; the Turkish minority in Western Thrace is not permitted to elect the managers of its foundations. The foundations face constant taxes levied by the government.

Another problem concerns Article 19 of the citizenship law, which victimizes Turkish citizens. Under it, a person of non-Greek ethnicity who leaves Greece without the intention of returning can lose their Greek nationality. According to the European Commission against Racism and Intolerance (ECRI), there are 60,000 Turkish people who have been victimized by this article. ECRI notes that affected people must be readmitted as Greek citizens.

Another problem, in the heart of the EU, is the prevention of the election of Turks to office. Independent candidates must pass the three percent threshold for election, which means gaining the support of 200,000 voters. However, the number of voters in the minority is around 150,000. In other words, Turkish candidates are virtually barred from election as independent deputies. They must become members of Greek parties, and even taking this into consideration hold only three seats.

The EU treats the Turkish minority in Greece like its stepsons. We have to resolve the issue of Western Thrace through EU institutions. The issue has to become a leading one in the EU's enforcement of basic human rights and freedoms.

Let me add a note: What is the reason for the current regulation under which college students from Western Thrace have to study with foreigner status in Turkey?

COMMENTS
The champions of the rights of Turks within Greece had better be advised not to cite the Treaty of Lausanne. That treaty contained obligations on both Greece and Turkey. Turkey violated each and every one of its obligations under said treaty. If anyone wants to cite the Treaty of Lausanne then th...
Kelly
The Turkish Muslims of Western Thrace were allowed to stay in their ancestral lands, whereas the 155,000 Greeks of Istanbul/Constantinople were violently expelled in 1929 and the 1955 Istanbul pogrom against Greeks, Armenians and Jewish citizens of the Cumhüriyeti. Turks in Greece have full rights a...
Abu Piet
The Greeks left Imvros, Tenedos and Istanbul fearing for lives whilst their rights were rapidly being stripped from them. They fled to a country, Greece, which offered them refuge. This country was alien to them, they were after all Turkish citizens. If these so called Turkish minorites, the vast ...
Mark
Then there are some who without any shame or consciousness advocate placing the Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus (TRNC) and the Turkish Cypriot people under a Greek rule through a mythical "united cyprus" or "federation" or "confederation".
Semra
Dear HÜSEYİN, I see you are very concerned about minority rights. This is very good. Please answer the following questions: 1. Does Tturkey provide its own Kurdish minority wich is around 20 million the same rights as the Greeks give the Turks of Thrace? The answer is NO The Turks of Thrace can g...
jimmy
Then there are some people who without any shame advocate placing Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus (TRNC) and the Turkish Cypriot people under a Greek rule through mythical so-called "united cyprus" or "federation/confederation".
Semra
Yes, the treatment of Turks- Greek citizens- of Thrace is an absolute disgrace, and has long been the case. The EU has turned a blind eye to it for decades. The reason for this sly, spiteful oppression is ongoing 'revenge' for the suffering and expulsion of Greeks from Asia Minor, a dreadful crime i...
Rudolphus
Come on Turkey go
VTiger
Mr. Gulerce, while acknowledging some of the difficulty, rather than tragedy, the Muslim minority (not entirely Turkish) of Eastern Thrace (from a Greek geographical perspective that is) has been facing, it should suffice to say that they will never encounter the nearly genocidal pogrom the Greek po...
Thessalonian
Turkish people in Thrace have lived there without prejudice they even have a Muslim Greek citizen representative in parliament. The Turkish Consulate there is funding extremism to keep the Turkish speaking populations divided against the Greeks. They are even allowed to Celebrate Turkish Independenc...
jima
What a load of rubbish, Turkish state propaganda. The muslim mninorities in Greece have all the rights attributed to them as every other Greek citizen, if they feel hard done by, get out, cross the Evros and go and live in Turkey if they want to be Turks. You cannot state that Turks can be Turks i...
Mark
You refer to the Treaty of Lausanne and a parallelism with Cyprus.The said treaty refers to Greek muslims in Greece and Turkish Christians in Turkey.So,there are no minorities there.The Orthodox Patriarch is a Turkish citizen. Most of your article is based on the assumption that there is a Turkish m...
Sid
Right.Not a single word about the state and status of Christians in Turkey who are often forced to leave the country.
pinecone
Stop trying to export Turkey's internal problems to Greece. Anyone with any common sense can clearly see this is strictly a propaganda piece, filled with inaccuracies, that was designed for domestic consumption in order to foment anger and create issues where there aren't any.
Paul
@dimitrios. I am part Greek. And I open my mouth and say that Greeks are hypocritical and do not know how to treat their minorities, including Turks. We have grown a nation of incompetent, Government dependent and unproductive citizens. We lost Constantinople 559 years ago. Let it go. If we are goin...
Orhun
The real tragedy and violation of treaty happen in Constantinopole and isles of Imvros and Tenedos. That"s why you have no moral right even to open your mouth. When somebody compare cases, the conclusion is that there is paradise for muslims in Western Thrace. The problems of muslims in Thrace are ...
dimitrios macedon
Click here to read all user comments
Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
9 May 2013
Responses to concerns and worries
7 May 2013
Inevitable direction: Plan C
30 April 2013
Process of caution and vigilance
4 April 2013
What will the wise men do?
28 March 2013
Let's try peace, shall we?
26 March 2013
Wise men board a must?
19 March 2013
New Ergenekon scenarios
14 March 2013
Headscarved penguin
12 March 2013
What happens to the AK Party if Öcalan is released?
7 March 2013
Brainstorming on the leaked minutes
5 March 2013
What will be the result of the negotiations?
28 February 2013
Games begin to muddy process
26 February 2013
What if they don't listen to Öcalan?
21 February 2013
I am a nationalist
19 February 2013
What's happening in Sinop, Samsun?
15 February 2013
Is the prime minister being political or sincere?
12 February 2013
Prime minister's visit to Saygun
5 February 2013
Dialogue is not a jacket
1 February 2013
Presidential system on the horizon
30 January 2013
Shock waves not restricted to the CHP
11 January 2013
Paris assassinations and the İmralı processes
14 December 2012
A Muslim society no impediment to democracy
2 December 2012
Ergenekon is just the means…
20 November 2012
Gaza’s heavenly children
15 November 2012
Private university prep courses, opposition and TOBB
4 November 2012
Is it solely about Erdoğan and Gül?
23 October 2012
Does this mean there will be no new constitution?
19 October 2012
Do new things really happen in Ankara?
16 October 2012
Tragedy in Western Thrace
11 October 2012
On terrorism and crying
10 October 2012
Possibility of war, Iran and NATO
25 September 2012
The whole point is to get rid of the AK Party
21 September 2012
Will terrorism end? And other questions
19 September 2012
Traces of assassinations: from Özal to Erdoğan
14 September 2012
Which button was hit in Libya?
12 September 2012
TSK statements shed light on the truth
30 August 2012
Aug. 30, Ergenekon and our army
15 August 2012
Was Aygün really kidnapped by the PKK?
10 August 2012
You should ask the PKK
7 August 2012
A new era in government-TSK relations
31 July 2012
New foreign policy in new Turkey
26 July 2012
Strategic depth and romanticism
19 July 2012
Conservatism: What we were; what have we become?
17 July 2012
HAS Party merger and beyond
12 July 2012
How was our jet downed, really?
10 July 2012
Release of deputies under detention
5 July 2012
They will not be able to make football an arena for enmity
3 July 2012
What really happened with specially authorized courts?
28 June 2012
Do it, but listen first
26 June 2012
Syria trap
21 June 2012
Before entering Kandil
19 June 2012
Hopes for peace and Dağlıca attack
7 June 2012
The situation is now clear, but …
5 June 2012
Democracy, not ‘The community,’ will be undermined
31 May 2012
New trap for the AK Party?
29 May 2012
Things that dark sunglasses hide
24 May 2012
Uludere in all its urgency…
22 May 2012
Why do we need to ride on the EU bid wave?
15 May 2012
Is a semi-presidential system on the horizon?
8 May 2012
Good news from Prophet’s Way
3 May 2012
A Silivri trap for the AK Party?
1 May 2012
Trucks in Taksim and Susurluk
26 April 2012
No, you won’t be able to destroy and eliminate it
19 April 2012
The real reason behind Feb. 28
17 April 2012
The season for birds to sing…
15 April 2012
‘What, İbrahim, can be bad about this?’
10 April 2012
Could there be an army that has its officers killed?
5 April 2012
A Sept. 12 coup for Ergenekon supporters…
3 April 2012
Quran, the AK Party and the MHP
29 March 2012
Beware: it is a plot within a plot
27 March 2012
The closure of Özgür Gündem
22 March 2012
Why does Evren still think so?
20 March 2012
My eyes are set on shores far more alluring than your polemics
13 March 2012
ÇEV, Interpol, Sabancı murder…
6 March 2012
The new constitution has a bold owner
28 February 2012
Feb. 28 from a different angle
23 February 2012
Why is there such interest in ‘Fetih 1453’?
16 February 2012
Those who infiltrate the state
15 February 2012
Sabotage: government-Gülen movement relations
9 February 2012
MİT, the judiciary and the new constitution
7 February 2012
Islamic faction and democracy
2 February 2012
Don't treat TSK and junta as the same
26 January 2012
Diyarbakır skulls are proof of our sorrows
24 January 2012
As the mystery on the east of the Euphrates is resolved
17 January 2012
Thank you, Vice Adm. Sağdıç
12 January 2012
Greatest trick of pro-Ergenekon figures
10 January 2012
Saving Başbuğ…
5 January 2012
Why was the Uludere plot devised?
3 January 2012
Who devised the Uludere plot?
27 December 2011
Ergenekon, Sledgehammer, Sivas, Maraş…
22 December 2011
Is it possible to cover up the Ergenekon case?
20 December 2011
Will a new constitution be written?
15 December 2011
Is it really all that great that we are not yet in the EU?
13 December 2011
Letter from Van...
8 December 2011
The AK Party's match-fixing test
6 December 2011
The Sunnis' responsibility on the Alevi issue
1 December 2011
What do the Alevis want?
29 November 2011
Why the Alevis just cannot give up on the CHP?
22 November 2011
Dersim and the derailment of tutelage
17 November 2011
Ergenekon case rattles PKK
...