How missionaries were linked to the PKK
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
19 June 2013 Wednesday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 06 September 2012, Thursday 27 0 0 0
ORHAN KEMAL CENGİZ
o.cengiz@todayszaman.com

How missionaries were linked to the PKK

It took three days for the court to read out the summary of the indictment in the Malatya massacre case. While listening to the whole indictment, many thoughts crossed my mind, and one particular question struck me profoundly: How on earth is wasmilitary doing their own work when they were involved in other things that had nothing to do with their work at all and they were spending so much energy on them?

Especially after the Ergenekon trials, it has become crystal clear that some units within the military were spending almost all of their efforts in monitoring society, waging psychological warfare against some segments of society, contacting the media, talking to businesspeople and doing several other things in order to maintain their hegemony over political and societal life in Turkey.

While listening to the second indictment of the Malatya massacre case, once again I was surprised by the amount of time that military personnel spend on activities that have nothing to do with their work.

From the indictment, we understand that the Malatya gendarmerie commander at the time and his men were monitoring a handful of missionaries in Malatya 24 hours a day. They were tapping their telephones, their man had infiltrated this tiny Christian group and the gendarmerie was also paying “informers” a lot of money to collect data about, let’s say, 15-20 Christians in Malatya. In Malatya and in other cities, the gendarmerie organized several meetings to show everyone how dangerous the missionaries’ activities were.

Apart from all the time which they spent to incite these murders, what they did after the murders was just mind boggling. They started to listen in on the telephone conversations of the victims’ families and some other people, including myself, one of the victims’ lawyers. We can see from the court file that they listened in on all of us with court orders based on, of course, false accusations. For example, they listened in on Turkish Christians by accusing them of being involved in “fundamentalist Islamist activities.” Apparently, the judges just approved of the gendarmerie’s “communication monitoring” request without looking at the names and accusations.

Again, we understood from the indictment that the gendarmerie spent an enormous amount of time creating false documents in order to create a false image about the missionaries and Christians. When the court case started four years ago, I wrote a couple of articles about the indictment and its attachments. There were 32 files attached to the indictment; 17 of them were related to missionary activities. These documents portrayed the slain Christians as criminals. When you looked at these files, you could easily form the impression that two gangs fought each other, and at the end, the Turkish nationalist gang killed the members of the Christian gang.

Today, with the second indictment, we learned that all these documents had been created by the gendarmerie and they had presented all these fake documents to the prosecutor to manipulate the case. These documents created imaginary links between the Christians and some clandestine networks. For example, there were many documents which “showed” that the missionaries were working with the members of the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK), that they were receiving orders from the CIA, and so on. Today, we learnt that all these fake documents had been carefully prepared during workshops held by gendarmerie officers. They spent a lot of time creating all this “evidence” against the missionaries. When you look at the work of the Malatya gendarmerie through this indictment and court file, you can see that most of the Malatya gendarmerie’s time in 2007 and 2008 was spent in the war against the missionaries.

Apparently they were conducting their “real tasks” in their free time. Just looking at this weird situation, you can understand what it meant to have military guardianship in Turkey.

I will continue sharing my observations about the case in following articles.

COMMENTS
Kurds should not negotiate with an opressive regime of Turkey the same way Libya and syrian revolution refuse to negotiate with their opressive regime..Kurds should fight to gain their rights and establish their state as Turks did after their defeat in the first world war.
dario
Mr. Genis, I have absolutely No problem with a rational man, who argues using common sense and provides proof. However, when You start talking using Hatred, then it shows Your mental capacity to comprehend, analyze and argue a point. You represent the Good people of Turkey, however, You have Always ...
Mine Ozcelik bagrationi
Thank you Mineyan Hanım for your "polite" words. TO ALL HERE: Dont let ermenians here using nice humanistic words fool you. They are mostly wolves in a sheep's wear. To see their real face, hatred, rudeness, anti-Turkism, racism, fascism just have a look in their media.
necati
You don't have to thank me, Preston. We are all human beings and that's what matters above all else. We must honestly try and understand our mistakes, correct them, and build bridges with others around us. You and Mine have already done that, and I appreciate that very much.
Baris
Thank you Baris. You are, just like my wife and millions of other good, honest and truthful Turks, a light in the dark tunnel, you give us hope to mend fences with our Turkish brothers and sisters. You Always talk the truth, and that shows you are a person of highest integrity and were raised, just ...
Preston Bagrationi
Wow... what amazing hatred being shown to these harmless Christians. But I know its what Jesus fortold for his followers. Part of the cost of knowing God is being hated without reason in this life. "The time is coming when anyone who kills you will think they are offering a service to God. They wi...
Aslan
The chinese people support kurds' struggle to free their land from erdogan and his genocidal thugs
chineseperson
Memnun, do you have proof for the allegation against OKC? Don't try to slander one of our most beloved journalists. Just because he is writing the truth as it is, you don't have to pile false accusations about our Turkish brother. You have the proof? Then produce the proof.I don't want to see my Tur...
Mine Ozcelik Bagrationi
TO ALL HERE: This uneducated boy, calling himself 'necati," has been trying and desperately, if I may add here, to portray us all Turks, as shameless uneducated nomads...well, he himself "necati" is. Any Turk here or on any other forum, who portrays All Turks in a negative way, will hear from me. Th...
Mine Ozcelik Bagrationi
Just a comment regarding missionaries. Many years ago I worked, traveling the Navajo Reservation (U.S) with a Navajo interpreter. Once he commented, "I have never known a white man to give away anything worth while. Why do they (missionaries) try so hard to give their religion away?"
J.Lee Bonham
Mine,I admire your guts.
VTiger
VEry sad reading because in Turkey nothing is as it appears even when you view the evidence with your own eyes! There is so much finger point and I do believe that the truth rarely rises to the top these days. MEAT You backward mentality is showing once again. We, of all faiths, should be able to...
Me
Missionary work is not illegal in Turkey. On the contrary, article 115 of the Turkish penal code specifically allows people to freely express and spread their religious, political, social and philosophical beliefs. People who are trying to justify the shameful and barbaric act in Malatya, on the gro...
Baris
@ Meat: "Therefore any missionary work that seeks to spread religion other than Islam to Muslims should be banned." Unfortunately your statement is totally unacceptable. It contradicts not only Turkish law, but also the Human Rights Declaration which Turkey has accepted. @ Necati: You could do the w...
Matteo
@Cengiz: If any of these three murdered people (one a father of three children) had committed any crime, the police and the courts would have been responsible to follow up on it. Nothing of this sort happened. Why? Obviously they did not commit any crime; their only "crime" was to be a Christian liv...
erol
Western Missionary workers where very active during the Ottoman State working with their governments with the aim to cause rifts between Muslims. This is a proven fact. Therefore any missionary work that seeks to spread religion other than Islam to Muslims should be banned.
Meat
According the anti-Turkish Islamophobic conservative newspaper Telegraph in England, they admitted that the German Protestant Church (the church of these missionaries) was aiding the PKK in the 1980's. Orhan Kemal Cengiz was proven to be taking money from said group in the 1980's.
Memnun
Necati. Can you please provide a reliable source for your claim below.
ccp
It is very clear and proved that so-called missionaries especially ermenians are hand to hand with terrorist pkk.One who do not see this is either blind or have some agenda.
necati
Sad reading.
Red Tail
Sad reading.
Red Tail
The blind hatred directed by these military officers against innocent missionaries is utterly appalling. As if a handful of Christian missionaries were any threat to Turkey! But, what is really dissapointing was the support the military got from the media in labelling missionaries as threats to Turk...
Christoph
It makes you wonder-- how well was the gendarmerie actually doing its proper work? I think we can guess the answer.
katherine
Your article has one big and obvious flaw. You have not provided proof that the information in the documents were "faked" and you have not demonstrated with facts how you came to that conclusion. It seems how easily you have forgotten how so-called "christian" groups in Europe and Greece were openly...
Cengiz
Nothing against our military, all generations of Ozcelik's served our nation with honor and dignity. However, the role of our military is to safeguard the safety of our motherland and it's borders, and Not to spy on Christians. What is the reason for harassing the Christians. Are we better than Chri...
Mine Ozcelik Bagrationi
If they spend this much time doing their real jobs then young conscripts may not die in PKK ambushes of unprotected barracks, or in exploding arsenals. Pathetic!
Baris
Brilliant. Orhan's piece exposes a microcosm of the Deep State at work- everywhere, not least in the education of Turkey's youth. Actually, we could drop the 'deep' bit and just charge the State with crimes against all its citizens: GUILTY.
Rudolphus
Click here to read all user comments
Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
18 June 2013
How did an international conspiracy manipulate Gezi Park events?
13 June 2013
Democracy at stake
11 June 2013
How Erdoğan sees all this
6 June 2013
What did prime minister's hometown tell us?
4 June 2013
Can the damage Erdoğan caused be repaired?
31 May 2013
Alevis' feeling of otherness deepens
28 May 2013
‘Satanic Verses,' Fazıl Say and Sevan Nişanyan
23 May 2013
Some citizens more equal than others
21 May 2013
Religious freedom problems in Turkey in 2012 and forever
16 May 2013
Who are the owners of places of worship in Turkey?
14 May 2013
How and why was the terrorist attack in Reyhanlı censored?
9 May 2013
The day after the PKK's withdrawal
7 May 2013
When will official reaction to 1915 change?
2 May 2013
Peace or democracy?
30 April 2013
Rumi, Buddha and remarks of Tokyo governor
25 April 2013
April 24 and Turkey's time tunnel
23 April 2013
An Armenian lady, Hrant and April 24
18 April 2013
Wise people's contribution to peace process
16 April 2013
What is wrong with Fazıl Say's punishment?
11 April 2013
How do Turkish laws produce terrorists?
9 April 2013
Truth and reconciliation commissions are necessary in Turkey
4 April 2013
What should wise people do for the peace process?
3 April 2013
Why can we not make fundamental improvements for non-Muslims?
28 March 2013
Murder of an Armenian Turkish soldier accidentally on purpose
26 March 2013
What is Turkey's roadmap for the Kurdish question?
21 March 2013
Real injustice in Ergenekon and Balyoz cases
19 March 2013
What did the Hasan Cemal case show us?
14 March 2013
Turkey, Israel and jujitsu lessons
12 March 2013
Secrecy in the investigation of attacks on Armenian women
7 March 2013
The peace process and freedom of the press
5 March 2013
Does an Armenian murderer eliminate the hate crimes presumption?
28 February 2013
Culture of lynching: dealing with hate crimes
26 February 2013
Öcalan's letters
21 February 2013
Turkey in mirror of European Court of Human Rights
19 February 2013
Victory and defeat
12 February 2013
What is wrong and right in criticisms against American ambassador
7 February 2013
Turkey's judiciary problem
5 February 2013
Hrant and Talat Pasha
31 January 2013
Genocide through the eyes of a child
29 January 2013
The Halki Theological School and the SCO
28 January 2013
‘I wish I wasn't Armenian'
22 January 2013
Why were the lawyers arrested?
17 January 2013
Is the Hrant Dink murder being resolved?
15 January 2013
Aren't the murders of Armenian women hate crimes?
10 January 2013
Atrocities in Syria committed by all sides
8 January 2013
A country of speed readers
7 January 2013
How can we achieve peace?
1 January 2013
The prime minister’s lawsuits will backfire
27 December 2012
Uludere massacre one year later
25 December 2012
Why was the commemoration for the Maraş massacre banned?
20 December 2012
How the Uludere massacre alienated Kurds from Turkey
18 December 2012
What can propaganda achieve?
13 December 2012
Praising Hrant Dink's murder
11 December 2012
Special Warfare and Christians
6 December 2012
Hrant, embarrassment, a disaster
4 December 2012
Déjà vu -- removing immunity of Kurdish MPs?
29 November 2012
Revealing too much: info belonging to Armenian groups online
28 November 2012
Turkey and Germany’s past atrocities
22 November 2012
Can Germany be a model for Turkey in confrontation with past atrocities?
20 November 2012
Hunger strikers did not die, but handicapped for life
15 November 2012
İstanbul and Constantinople
8 November 2012
Polar bears, Bedouins and poor Turkish politics
6 November 2012
Hunger strikes and a vicious circle
1 November 2012
1915: heroes and murderers
30 October 2012
The price of no criticism for the government
23 October 2012
Do not interfere with Kemalists’ mourning
18 October 2012
Armenians and a Turk in a Lebanese restaurant
16 October 2012
Restorative guilt and the Kurdish question
12 October 2012
Linking women’s stories in Turkey and Armenia
11 October 2012
1915 and terrorists on mountains
4 October 2012
The price for denial of the events of 1915
2 October 2012
How can Turkey bring an end to violence in Kurdish question
27 September 2012
Why are they so successful in seeing problematic aspects in coup cases?
20 September 2012
How Alevi victims became criminal offenders
18 September 2012
Islamophobia and hate speech in Turkey
13 September 2012
Criticizing Israel and insulting the Prophet
11 September 2012
Owen, Cemal and 1915
6 September 2012
How missionaries were linked to the PKK
4 September 2012
Will justice be served in Malatya massacre case?
30 August 2012
Campaign against violence
28 August 2012
Has the dispossessing of non-Muslims ended?
23 August 2012
Was Atatürk an Armenian?
21 August 2012
Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar!
16 August 2012
Zero tolerance for freedom of expression
14 August 2012
PKK, kidnapping and absolute impunity for the PKK
9 August 2012
Is there any ‘legal' place of worship for Alevis in Turkey?
7 August 2012
The government as an advocate of military coups
19 July 2012
The future of the deep state
17 July 2012
One basketball for all non-Muslims
12 July 2012
How was a monastery robbed in Turkey?
10 July 2012
Halki Seminary, cemevi in Parliament
3 July 2012
Who ordered the murder of Christians?
28 June 2012
From the September 1955 pogroms to a campaign against missionaries
26 June 2012
Recognizing the victimhood of the slain Christians
21 June 2012
What does the PKK really want?
19 June 2012
Prison SOS
14 June 2012
Let’s send all Kurds to prison
12 June 2012
From stone throwing children to child soldiers
7 June 2012
What do Islamist feminists say about abortion?
5 June 2012
Nationalists, muslims and the Kurdish question
...
Bloggers