Returning to normalcy
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
22 May 2013 Wednesday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 27 August 2012, Monday 6 0 0 0
LALE KEMAL
loglu@todayszaman.com

Returning to normalcy

Turkey is a country where an abnormal state mentality is usually perceived as normal. For example, military coups can still be regarded as normal mainly among the so-called intellectuals who believe that democracy is something that appointed bureaucrats can impose from the top and that there is no place for the voice of the people to be heard in this bizarre concept that cannot be described as democracy.

This abnormal mental behavior is the result of frequent military coups staged and memorandums issued by the military between 1960 and 2007 on various grounds indicating that the nation's militant secular character is in danger. The Turkish Armed Forces (TSK) did not necessarily stage military coups just because they perceived that the secular state was in danger posed by what it believed to be Islamic fundamentalism. In 1960, the military staged a coup using the deepening economic crisis as a pretext to intervene that culminated with the hanging of three politicians, including then-Prime Minister Adnan Menderes.

In 1980, the military junta staged another bloody coup on the grounds that the then coalition government was unable to halt violence among leftist and rightist university students. In 1997, the then coalition government was forced to resign by a military junta with the support of its civilian extensions. The Feb. 28, 1997 military intervention, described by its architects as a postmodern coup, was staged on the grounds that the senior partner of the coalition government was accused of pursuing policies to replace the secular state system with one based on religious laws.

In 2007, the TSK issued a memorandum and posted it on its website, warning the current ruling Justice and Development Party (AK Party) against electing Abdullah Gül as president because his wife wore a headscarf. Gül was elected president by the Parliament established after early elections the same year despite the military's e-memo.

The presidential post has historically been important for the military-led militant secularists to harden some of the reformist laws passed by Parliament to go into effect. Some political parties helped and are still helping the military to prevent Parliament from adopting laws that will improve democratic standards.

But the election of Gül as president in 2007 turned the calculations of the supporters of the status quo upside down. This was because a president having Islamic roots and with a wife wearing a headscarf became president for the first time in Turkish republican history. It is worth noting that Gül, as a former prime minister and a foreign minister from the AK Party, played a significant role in bringing Turkey closer to the democratic standards of the European Union. On the contrary, the TSK and its civilian supporters do not hide their distaste for democratic reforms.

The then TSK top commandership did not hide its displeasure toward President Gül and his headscarved wife by treating both disrespectfully on several occasions.

For the TSK to stage a military coup in retaliation for a Parliament that elected Gül as president was no longer easy thanks to various earlier military reforms that curbed the military's power in politics. In addition, over 250 retired and active officers, including around 68 active generals, are in jail over charges of triggering an armed action to unseat the current government. This legal action also deterred coup lovers from taking military action to interrupt the political process once again.

Against this background, for the first time Turkey will be celebrating Aug. 30, Victory Day, at the presidential palace instead of a military site.

The TSK used to host receptions every year at a military housing complex in Ankara on the occasion of Victory Day as if this important day belonged to the TSK alone.

Those media members subjected to the military's accreditation ban simply because they had criticized the TSK were not invited to the military-organized Victory Day celebrations.

On one occasion, President Gül, breaking the military's monopoly on Victory Day celebrations, hosted an Aug. 30, Victory Day, reception as an alternative to the one the military held on the same day and at the same time.

However, such abnormal military behavior began changing under Gen. Necdet Özel, chief of General Staff, a commander respectful of civilian authority. Özel and his service commanders, for the first time since the AK Party came to power in November 2002, attended this year's April 23, National Sovereignty Day, celebrations held in Parliament. Previous TSK commanders attended neither the April 23 celebrations in Parliament nor those hosted by Gül on the occasion of Oct. 29, the day the Turkish Republic was established in 1923, on the grounds that some of the wives of ruling party members wore headscarves and that generals did not want to shake hands with them.

It was abnormal for the TSK to hold receptions on Victory Days rather than the country's president. It was also abnormal for the military to protest receptions held to celebrate significant national days such as Oct. 29, Republic Day.

Not surprisingly, it was only the main opposition Republican People's Party (CHP) that boycotted this year's April 23 celebrations held in Parliament, protesting -- though implicitly -- the attendance of women with headscarves.

Turkey continues breaking taboos, but they are not at a desired level because military reforms to bring the TSK under full civilian control have long been halted. It is still a small but positive step that Turkey is leaving behind an abnormal situation that can be described as a state within a state by bringing historic day celebrations to normal standards.

COMMENTS
Syler2, Nope! The world's largest and most densely populated open-ait prison is in "southeast Turkey" or Kurdistan, not in Palestine. The Palestinians are free to use their mother tongue, Arabic, without any restrictions in education, trade and commerce, judicial proceedings and broadcasting whereas...
Baran
@Syler2, please don't take my word for it ...... just go to Reporters Without Borders website and look at the 2012 Press Freedom Index. There you will see that Palestinians enjoy greater press freedom than citizens of Turkey by a whopping 15 notches! Or just Google it. As you know nothing about me,...
David
David, stop lying. P. alestinians enjoy more press freedom? LOL, please. Who are you kidding. The P. alestinians live in the world's largest open-air prison. Don't even joke about your lowly people occupying Turkiye. It wouldn't happen even if the US was doing the fighting for you (as they alw...
Syler2
I just wonder if the concept of democracy and freedom of expression are fully understood or accepted in Turkey? Is it not amazing that the Palestinians under Israeli occupation enjoy much more press freedom than citizens of Turkey? Turks will have greater press freedom should Israel ever occupy Tur...
David
If Turkish Government is powerful(like now), Turkey will have more democratic regime. Opposition political parties also must be powerful.
democracy
Mostly because people have somewhat established lifestyle and do not want to be hunted or jailed. It's wise enough to stay away from "trouble".
life practices
Click here to read all user comments
Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
22 May 2013
Reyhanlı attack & rethinking Turkish democracy
20 May 2013
Syrian crisis carries risk of killing Erdoğan's political calculations
15 May 2013
Will the Syrian tragedy be Turkey's, too?
13 May 2013
Who will benefit from shortened military service?
8 May 2013
What will be the next move?
6 May 2013
Turkey's mishandling of the JSF
1 May 2013
Bureaucratic war over democratic oversight
29 April 2013
Presidential system and authoritarianism
24 April 2013
Erdoğan will obtain presidential powers
22 April 2013
Peace process and reduction of military power
17 April 2013
Turkish-Israeli military ties will not resume soon
15 April 2013
Al-Nusra's growing influence prompts frequent Turkey visits by Kerry
10 April 2013
Military-government covert deal doomed to fail
8 April 2013
National strategy lacking in Turkish peace process
3 April 2013
Why this stubbornness to kill transparency?
1 April 2013
Government push for unrealistic demands risks peace process
27 March 2013
Military response to solution process is an open question
25 March 2013
Turkish-Israeli reconciliation to help thwart regional threats
20 March 2013
PKK disarmament will come later
18 March 2013
Shortcomings in judicial reform to slow peace process
13 March 2013
Favoritism poisons ethical values in Turkey
11 March 2013
Peace process and presidential system
6 March 2013
PKK's European wing weighs in on peace process
4 March 2013
Where does the military stand in the peace process?
27 February 2013
Achieving peace also requires open debate on state mistakes
25 February 2013
Uludere and making peace
20 February 2013
Decentralization is critical in Kurdish peace process
18 February 2013
Alternative to current peace process is catastrophe
13 February 2013
Turkish military's morale from a historic perspective (2)
11 February 2013
Turkish military's morale from a historic perspective (1)
6 February 2013
Is Turkey seeking to revive pan-Turkism?
4 February 2013
Turkish-US conflicts are at tactical level
30 January 2013
Society necessitates the emergence of a new democratic movement
28 January 2013
In a radical move, Turkey opts for co-development of long-range missiles
23 January 2013
US delivers democracy message to Turkey
21 January 2013
Kurdish issue haunts CHP
15 January 2013
What will happen if China suffers from famine?
9 January 2013
'I can make everything' policy will weaken defense industry
7 January 2013
Yet another process to beat terror
2 January 2013
Getting rid of a state of siege mood
31 December 2012
Beginning new year with good news for transparency
28 December 2012
Invitation crisis implicates PM
26 December 2012
Grave violation of soldier rights
24 December 2012
Turkey's unclear direction raises concerns
20 December 2012
Russia should cooperate if it wants to protect post-Assad interests in Syria
17 December 2012
Why was Taraf important?
13 December 2012
Why has the Turkish commander received a medal?
10 December 2012
Why didn't Russia ask for the return of seized military equipment from Turkey?
5 December 2012
Immunity debate demonstrates Turkey's Kurdish deadlock
3 December 2012
Scrutiny over defense industry activities
26 November 2012
Turkish nationalism prone to exploitation
21 November 2012
Turkish Parliament surprised me
19 November 2012
End of hunger strikes may revive peace talks
14 November 2012
Is Turkey seeking a 19th-century constitutional monarchy?
12 November 2012
In Turkey causes of incidents are left in the dark
7 November 2012
Göktürk satellite project recalls reform in defense industry
5 November 2012
Hunger strike opens a new page in Kurdish question
1 November 2012
Curiosity surrounds Babacan's replacement
29 October 2012
Turkey's security-centric approach and its repercussions
24 October 2012
Turkey's choice: modernity over democracy
22 October 2012
Erdoğan is hedging his bets
17 October 2012
Turkey should not criticize, it is doing poorly
15 October 2012
Turkey should make efforts to diffuse tension with Syria
11 October 2012
Transparency will beat corruption
9 October 2012
Civilian protection and state transparency
3 October 2012
Nations run out of ideas on Syria as FSA runs out of ammunition
1 October 2012
Another Oslo cannot come out from this speech
26 September 2012
New party scenarios are discussed in Ankara
24 September 2012
Future coups or coup plans will freeze Turkey's NATO membership
19 September 2012
War to gain psychological superiority
17 September 2012
Dealing with arms in post-Assad period
12 September 2012
One step forward, two steps back
10 September 2012
Transparency and accountability are key for democracy
29 August 2012
Alarm bells do not ring despite danger on its way
27 August 2012
Returning to normalcy
22 August 2012
A nation that can't finish the war
15 August 2012
Why media becomes vulnerable
13 August 2012
Turkey's gamble on Syria
8 August 2012
Rethinking Kurdish question as Burkay talks
6 August 2012
What is YAŞ?
1 August 2012
Between paranoia and reality
30 July 2012
Indifference to police misconduct
26 July 2012
Critical questions not asked in F-4 downing
23 July 2012
Turkey’s difficult times as Syrian conflict intensifies
18 July 2012
Is the CHP the same old story, same old song?
16 July 2012
Turkey played all cards in Syrian conflict
11 July 2012
Transparency will shed light on jet downing
9 July 2012
Helping Kurds explore avenues other than guns
4 July 2012
Turkish media deceives public over strength of locally developed arms
2 July 2012
Government is taken hostage by Huntington’s theory
20 June 2012
Gül to return to politics on his own terms
18 June 2012
Turkey should beat fear to thwart extreme Kurdish demands
13 June 2012
AK Party faces risk of losing popular support
11 June 2012
Restrictions on human rights poison positive Turkish climate
6 June 2012
‘New CHP’ undergoes critical test on Kurdish issue
4 June 2012
Why is Turkey in reform fatigue?
30 May 2012
I liked the AK Party because it was reformist
28 May 2012
Turkey presses for arms but not a Kurdish solution
23 May 2012
Who is in the driver’s seat in Turkey?
21 May 2012
Carelessness in target selection results in killing of 34 civilians
...