Is Turkey getting too close to the Syrian fire?
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
19 May 2013 Sunday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 21 August 2012, Tuesday 3 0 0 0
JOOST LAGENDIJK
J.lagendijk@todayszaman.com

Is Turkey getting too close to the Syrian fire?

On Monday, Stratfor, an influential but also controversial global intelligence company, distributed an article about the implications of an expanded Turkish role in Syria. According to the report, Ankara for weeks has been preparing the public for more Turkish involvement in the conflict that is ripping apart its southern neighbor. The Stratfor analyst warns that more Turkish action inside Syria could trigger a backlash from Syria and Iran. One option for Damascus and Tehran would be to use their good contacts with the Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK) and stimulate the Kurdish terrorists to intensify their attacks on targets in Turkey.

Later that same day, a car bomb killed nine people, including three children, in Gaziantep, close to Turkey's border with Syria. The PKK quickly announced that they had nothing to do with the explosion. That is no final proof of their innocence because in similar situations in the past it turned out that autonomous PKK-affiliated groups like the Kurdistan Freedom Falcons (TAK) were responsible. It does indicate that the PKK does not want to be associated with the killings that took place during Bayram, or the holiday that marks the end of Ramadan, a holy month for Muslims. So far nobody has claimed responsibility for the attack and if there is any kind of Syrian or Iranian involvement, probably no one ever will.

Did Stratfor have prior knowledge of the Gaziantep bombing? Of course not. Their article underlined certain potential consequences of Turkey's strong support for the Syrian opposition and its intentions to step up its efforts. Others have made the link before. Stratfor may, however, be correct in its analysis of a heightened risk for Turkey as the civil war in Syria drags on.

In that respect, it is interesting to see what will happen with Turkey's call on the United Nations to create a safe or buffer zone within Syria to accommodate a growing number of refugees. According to Turkey's foreign minister, Ahmet Davutoğlu, Turkey is already hosting almost 70,000 Syrians and will run out of space if that number surpasses 100,000.

The idea of buffer zones inside Syria is not a new one. Turkey has been pushing for them for months. In the spring reports were published claiming that Turkey had already discreetly started preparations for such a zone, sending 500 specialized soldiers to the region to look at possible options. A few days ago Davutoğlu again discussed the issue with his US colleague, Hillary Clinton, when she visited İstanbul to coordinate Turkish-American initiatives in Syria. After the meeting, US Ambassador to Turkey Francis Ricciardone called for some caution as he stressed that there are still serious legal and practical obstacles. It was not clear, though, whether the ambassador was referring to the idea of buffer zones or to a no-fly zone, an issue that was also discussed.

Whatever the official statements, the reality on the ground appears to be already much messier. In July, Deborah Amos, an American journalist, reported on the NPR website about a refugee camp on the Turkish-Syrian border and quoted a Syrian rebel who was moving easily between Syria and Turkey: “Actually we have a buffer zone now. I mean, it's not declared by the Turkish government. People transport arms freely. The Turks are closing their eyes. We bring our wounded people here; we go back and forth and nobody bothers us at all.”

Other media reports seem to confirm the existence of a large area along the Turkish-Syrian border, most of it on Turkish soil, where people, aid and weapons move into Syria without the Turkish authorities interfering and, maybe even more important, without the Syrians trying to prevent such a free flow. It is a clear indication that most of the border areas are no longer controlled by Damascus. Of course, this is more of a gray zone than an officially declared buffer zone on Syrian soil, the request put forward by Davutoğlu.

Looking at the well-known Russian and Chinese position on territorial integrity, it looks highly unlikely that the UN Security Council will react positively to Turkey's suggestion.

Ankara must be fully aware of this, so the question arises: What will Turkey do next? Muddle on with a de facto open border that allows the Syrian opposition to move freely but puts the burden of the refugees solely on Turkish shoulders? Or ask for American and European assistance in occupying Syrian lands to spread the costs and risks of new refugee flows, knowing that doing so could further trigger the wrath of both Syria and Iran with all the far-reaching and unpleasant consequences that might entail?

COMMENTS
I use to admire Erdogan and Turkey once upon a time. Now I see both as puppets of their western masters who do their bidding by bringing bloodshed and insecurity to the region. They support terrorism in Syria, and when the government of Syria fights back they get condemned for it. However, when T...
African
Thanks for the bully Erdogan, Turkey got too close to Syria even before the fire started. So Erdogan wanted the adoration of Arabs and moved away from the West, very smart huh Erdogan? You isolated
Jaime
The wreth of the Siryan and Iranian regims is already there. They pushed and supported PKK to start with a strong terror ampain. Even more dangerous is the forming of the PKK controled zone in the north east of Syria. It started. Turkey has to react. A thing that will speed up the end of the war is ...
Haled
Click here to read all user comments
Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
19 May 2013
Kılıçdaroğlu: a foot full of bullets
14 May 2013
Turkey's anti-Americanism in a state of flux
12 May 2013
Soft power is no power
7 May 2013
The eternal Turk
5 May 2013
To drink or not to drink
30 April 2013
Lessons for Turkey from the Syrian conflict
28 April 2013
What is Turkey’s plan for April 24, 2015?
23 April 2013
An EU success story -- finally
21 April 2013
Syria’s agony of death
16 April 2013
On the Muslim Question
14 April 2013
Unproven speculations and legitimate questions
9 April 2013
Better protection in Turkey for foreigners in need
7 April 2013
Wise persons, foolish party
2 April 2013
How to deal with a German Europe?
31 March 2013
‘The Turks are coming!’
27 March 2013
Turkey's ambiguity on Europe
24 March 2013
The desperate Cypriot hunt for 6 billion euros
19 March 2013
Yunus and the extremists
17 March 2013
The arms race in Syria
12 March 2013
Are Turks anti-Semites?
10 March 2013
Foster children and eternal migrants
5 March 2013
A politician's dream and a banker's nightmare
3 March 2013
Arab Islamists and the Turkish model
26 February 2013
Arming the Syrian rebels
24 February 2013
Constitutional opportunism
19 February 2013
What next for Kosovo?
17 February 2013
Poisonous tactics
12 February 2013
Why visit a sick general?
10 February 2013
Stop sulking on the sidelines
5 February 2013
Forget about the 50 years myth
3 February 2013
Ambiguous royal feelings
29 January 2013
Erdoğanology
27 January 2013
Cameron has a point -- and a problem
22 January 2013
Sneijder: top or flop?
20 January 2013
Mehmet Ali Birand in a class of his own
15 January 2013
One extra condition
13 January 2013
Is Erdoğan pushing his luck?
8 January 2013
Turkey-EU relations slowly warming up (2)
6 January 2013
Turkey-EU relations slowly warming up (1)
1 January 2013
My 2013 wish and fear list
30 December 2012
Turkey beyond clichés
25 December 2012
Digital addiction
23 December 2012
Why Turks open their own discos
18 December 2012
How to stop soldier suicides?
16 December 2012
EU: more powers but no clear vision
9 December 2012
Are all Turks Kemalists?
4 December 2012
How not to make a new constitution
3 December 2012
How not to make a new constitution
2 December 2012
Turkey should stop refusing help
27 November 2012
Turkey's Patriot games
25 November 2012
Does Morsi’s rise mean Erdoğan’s fall?
20 November 2012
An alternative EU membership
18 November 2012
Dutch-Turkish relations after the party is over
13 November 2012
Arguments against the death penalty
11 November 2012
To date or not to date
6 November 2012
Which EU to join?
4 November 2012
Most US states don’t swing
30 October 2012
Öcalan should call off the hunger strikes
28 October 2012
A blow to Turkey's soft power
23 October 2012
Turkey should not do what Turks want on Syria
21 October 2012
Overcoming Eurocentrism
16 October 2012
Does the EU deserve the Nobel Peace Prize?
14 October 2012
Turkish conservatism 2.0
9 October 2012
Don’t blame the doctor
7 October 2012
Engin Çeber and the end of impunity
2 October 2012
European dream not over yet
30 September 2012
Fighting hate speech instead of blasphemy
25 September 2012
It happened
23 September 2012
In the making: the Kosovar national football team
18 September 2012
Organized provocations
11 September 2012
Stepping back from the abyss
9 September 2012
Dutch populism and its limits
4 September 2012
Turkey could beat the Netherlands
2 September 2012
Evaluating the AKP
28 August 2012
Europe in for a rough autumn ride
26 August 2012
Iran’s dirty fingerprints
21 August 2012
Is Turkey getting too close to the Syrian fire?
19 August 2012
The optimism of Serdar Gözübüyük
14 August 2012
Olympic lessons for İstanbul
12 August 2012
Can Greece change?
7 August 2012
Pride and prejudice
5 August 2012
Don’t give up on politics in Syria
31 July 2012
The perverse effects of tax evasion (2)
29 July 2012
The perverse effects of tax evasion (1)
24 July 2012
Bashar al-Assad and the 5 percent rule
22 July 2012
The EU can’t deal with an inside job
17 July 2012
Breaking: Another brick in the visa wall removed
15 July 2012
Will Putin listen to Erdoğan?
10 July 2012
Geert Wilders: Islamophobe turned Europhobe
8 July 2012
Bad customs and good habits
3 July 2012
And the winner is…
1 July 2012
Büşra Ersanlı and the Turkish paradox
26 June 2012
From prison to presidency
24 June 2012
Turkey not out of the woods on visa yet
19 June 2012
The Turkeyfication of Egypt
17 June 2012
Judicial coup in Egypt
12 June 2012
The Greek dilemma
10 June 2012
Now we’re talking
5 June 2012
Will Germany have the upper hand?
3 June 2012
Irresponsible polarization on abortion
...