The Turkey-Iran proxy war
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
23 May 2013 Thursday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 12 August 2012, Sunday 4 0 0 0
GÖKHAN BACIK
g.bacik@todayszaman.com

The Turkey-Iran proxy war

The Turkish, or Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoğlu's, optimism on Iran ended after Hassan Firozabad, the Iranian chief of staff, criticized Ankara on Syria. However, Firozabad's criticism was not the only one. Various high level Iranian officials have done the same, particularly on the Syrian issue. It is a tough situation for Ankara, recalling Turkey's support of Iran on many other issues. It was not long ago that pro-government journalists in Ankara were poised to humiliate anyone who dared criticize Iran. Several journalists who tried were quickly condemned for being pro-Israeli. But today, Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan himself criticizes Iran. In a recent interview, Erdoğan declared that Iran is doing wrong.

Indeed, Syria is a vital issue for Iran. For Iranians, an attack on Syria is a direct attack on Iran. And the Iranians are not mistaken. There is a strong and growing inclination in the West that means to deliver Iran a more complex punch. The breakup of the Syrian regime will deprive Tehran of a historic and essential security footing for the survival of its regime. Iran believes that it is in a proxy war with its enemies in Syria. I should say that to a large extent, this is a correct interpretation by Iran. Some of the countries that are pushing for a regime change in Damascus may have other strategic objectives. There is persuasive evidence on display that Iran will be the new target after Syria. Put another way: toppling the Bashar al-Assad regime is a strategic, military and political prerequisite of an assault on Iran.

Turkey has elected itself to be a frontrunner in the campaign for a regime change in Syria. This is wrong in itself, even if the Assad regime does fall one day. Turkey should have devised a more fine-tuned tactic for balancing morality and reality. If you implement an erroneous strategy, you might end up helping your enemy. The rise of anti-Turkey Kurdish cities in northern Syria is perfect proof of this. Having weakened Assad, Turkey now realizes that, ironically, it has helped the PKK-linked groups to gain autonomy in Syria.

However, the critical factor for Iran is indeed not the Kurds. Turkey has become a frontrunner in a proxy war in Syria, and this is seen as a direct attack on Iran's survival. Tehran believes that Turkey is playing a key role in Syria. In fact, the Syrian case has almost become a Turkey-Iran proxy war. It is no secret that both sides are supporting their allies in Syria. Yet, what Turkey and Iran are doing in Syria is not the typical pattern of their historic bilateral relations since the 16th century. The Syrian case is unique and has the potential to change the historic Turkey-Iran configuration. The irony is that Turkey is doing this with a very pro-Iranian government. The lesson is very clear: If your material capacities are limited, you should keep a certain distance between yourself and the superpowers and their agendas. Otherwise, their backwash may easily splash on you in some directions that are quite different from the ones you intended.

The Turkey-Iran proxy war on Syria is contributing to the formation of a new Middle East. It is the Middle East of sects and ethnicities -- the Turks, the Kurds, the Jews, the Sunnis and the Shiites. In such a setting, there is no room for neutrality. Any such action is counterproductive. Sectarian and ethnic groups approach you either as an enemy or a friend. No one is interested in the neutral or meditating actor, Turkey's role of choice in the last decade. Worse, Turkey may face serious difficulties in reviving its former status of a mediator state among the regional actors.

COMMENTS
But what about the humantarian side of sotry , the inisant people and children are dying every day by Assad forcses .. Who or What will stop these massacars
Ali
Somehow Turkey's intellegensia is un-necessarily critical of its Syria policy. Had Turkey shown some leadership and vision and moved in troops in areas that were later vacated by Bashar for PKK, the Kurd question would not have arisen. Foreign policy crafted by drawing room analysts has already crea...
Naveed Ahmad
Excellent piece! I think the real bottom line here is this article shows the world is a far more complex entity than most people truly understand. So, people should generally not be as sure of themselves regarding geopolitics as they tend to be.
Bryan Christiansen
Turkey's difficult predicament began unfolding first when it hubristicly came to believe that it could dominate the Middle East and finally when it followed this with a decision to position itself as the enemy of Israel and the ally of Hamas. These decision lost Ankara the support of old friends and...
Yavuz
Click here to read all user comments
Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
19 May 2013
Syria: Is a transitional government possible?
12 May 2013
Bombing Turkey: What next?
5 May 2013
Autonomy and Turkish foreign policy
28 April 2013
Why is the West still sleeping through the Syrian crisis?
21 April 2013
Why is the post-Cold War world still trauma-prone?
14 April 2013
State collapse in Middle East and its consequences
7 April 2013
What does a ‘successful negotiation' mean?
31 March 2013
Upcoming Kurdish dilemma: identity or economy?
24 March 2013
Negotiating with the PKK and the Syrian aspect
17 March 2013
A new method of intervention in Syria: Is it possible?
10 March 2013
Turkey: An infiltrated society
3 March 2013
Negotiations with the PKK: Some technical suggestions
24 February 2013
Turkey's DDR
17 February 2013
Who will finance Egypt?
10 February 2013
Explaining Assad's survival
3 February 2013
The unwanted truth: the Muslim enemies of Islam
27 January 2013
Trading with Iran
20 January 2013
What do the Syrian refugees tell us?
13 January 2013
A tribute to Hillary Clinton
6 January 2013
The invisible factor in the Arab revolutions: energy
30 December 2012
Is there hope for Cyprus?
23 December 2012
Iran's Plan B in Syria
16 December 2012
Qatar's Golden Age
9 December 2012
Need for Ottomanism at home
2 December 2012
Newton and foreign policy
25 November 2012
Many winners in the cease-fire: My thanks go to…
18 November 2012
Israel disturbs equilibrium, puts Egypt at risk
11 November 2012
Obama's global blank check
4 November 2012
How to rescue the Syrian opposition?
28 October 2012
Ankara and Washington: What is the problem?
21 October 2012
Ankara's call for cease-fire: A new strategy?
14 October 2012
The Syrian revolution that is not ending
7 October 2012
Turkey-Syria: What next?
30 September 2012
Will Turkey change its position on Iran?
23 September 2012
Waiting for Obama: Ankara's expectations
16 September 2012
Wise men sleep, ignorance reigns
9 September 2012
Northern Syria and Turkey: Need for small ideas
2 September 2012
Apology: How? When?
26 August 2012
Turkey's cancer
12 August 2012
The Turkey-Iran proxy war
5 August 2012
The value of the Barzani card
29 July 2012
The Kurdish nation
22 July 2012
Is a genuine Alawite state possible?
15 July 2012
Who benefits from Arab Spring's economy?
8 July 2012
Assadism in Turkey and the poverty of conservative intellectuals
1 July 2012
Turkey’s Not-To-Do List on Syria
24 June 2012
Turkey and the secular Arabs
17 June 2012
The invisible front
10 June 2012
The Arab mind, the Turkish mind
3 June 2012
Is Turkey exhausted?
27 May 2012
Erdoğan, Gül and Davutoğlu: the inner bargain on Turkish foreign policy
20 May 2012
The air wars in the Middle East and Turkey
13 May 2012
Annan destroys Syria
6 May 2012
Turkey and the US: alliance with no essentials?
29 April 2012
Return of medievalism in Middle East
22 April 2012
The political geography of the Kurds
15 April 2012
Turkey needs a plan B
8 April 2012
The new Kurdish order
1 April 2012
The Ikhwan’s historic responsibility
25 March 2012
The Syrian revolution in Turkish foreign policy
18 March 2012
Buffer zone in Syria and Turkey
11 March 2012
The patriarch is ecumenical
4 March 2012
The Arab Spring and the Turks: three views
26 February 2012
The Iranian lobby in Turkey
19 February 2012
Did Turkey misfire in Syrian crisis?
12 February 2012
Partition of Syria among the Great Powers: The solution?
5 February 2012
Iran's suicide
29 January 2012
Turkey and Iran: Neither enemies nor friends
22 January 2012
Maliki against Turkey
15 January 2012
The US and Turkish democracy
8 January 2012
Is the Sunni-Shiite split a myth?
1 January 2012
Turkey's limits
25 December 2011
Turkey and France: Hitting true and false notes
18 December 2011
Turkey and the Shiite Muslims
11 December 2011
Turkey reads the EU incorrectly
4 December 2011
After one year: Quo vadis?
27 November 2011
The Arab Spring versus China?
20 November 2011
The Obama Doctrine, NATO and Turkey
13 November 2011
Islamic politics and ‘secular’ problems in the Arab world
30 October 2011
Promise of Islamic politics
23 October 2011
The canon of foreign interventions
16 October 2011
Vying for Syria: Will the Cold War really end this time?
9 October 2011
Taming the Arab Spring
2 October 2011
Putin's Russia: somewhere between socialism and capitalism
25 September 2011
The Turco-American duet in the Middle East
18 September 2011
Egypt's moment
11 September 2011
Deconstructing Israel
9 September 2011
Major concerns over Turkey’s new strategy with Israel
4 September 2011
The Arab Spring and its losers
28 August 2011
After spring, the summer
...