Kurdish state or PKK state?
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
22 May 2013 Wednesday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 02 August 2012, Thursday 3 0 0 0
MERVE BÜŞRA ÖZTÜRK
b.ozturk@todayszaman.com

Kurdish state or PKK state?

Legitimate concerns were raised in Turkey after the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) and its affiliate in Syria, the Democratic Union Party (PYD), seized control of Syrian towns along the Turkish border. The Turkish authorities are worried that the PKK is using the current crisis in Syria to expand the area from which it can attack Turkey. However, columnists mainly argue that a distinction between an administration that might be established by Syrian Kurds and one that might be established by the PYD should be made and, bearing this distinction in mind, Turkey should respect the former and may object only to the latter.

Sedat Laçiner from the Star daily focuses on the roots and identity of the Syrian Kurds, who number between 1.5 million and 2 million people. He says the majority of Syrian Kurds migrated from Turkey to Syria in and after 1920. The Damascus administration regarded these Kurds as “foreign elements” and had concerns about their presence in the country. However, Syrian Kurds have become a very Arab-like people. Most of them are Sunni and live in the northeast, where there are borders with Turkey and Iraq. What is a matter of concern for Turkey, Laçiner says, is that Syrian Kurds are a continuation of the Kurds in Turkey, but they are constantly fed misinformation about Turkey. But despite all this, Turkey should not confuse demands that stem from terrorism with demands stemming from ethnicity. Objecting to a demand for autonomy just because Kurds are the ones demanding it is neither reasonable nor fair. After all, it is their right to demand autonomy, but as long as they get the state’s approval and respect other ethnic groups.

In his article “Are we against a Kurdish state or a KCK state,” Bugün’s Gültekin Avcı asks: Are the PKK and its affiliated Kurdistan Communities Union (KCK) terrorist organizations? Have these two organizations been killing our innocent people, soldiers, security officers and teachers for years? Do these two constitute threats to Turkey’s unity and peace? If “yes” is the answer to all, then we are supposed to be against a probable state that the KCK or PKK intend to establish inside or outside of our country, because any state they establish will produce further terrorism in Turkey. But from a liberal perspective, Kurds who are not from the KCK have the right to establish an administration in northern Syria. This, however, is not the case here, and those Kurds in northern Syria are not unrelated to the PKK or KCK, Avcı says.

COMMENTS
PKK try to achieve Kurdish demand of autonomy by force since Turk state decided to jail elected Kurdish Members of Turkish parliament who peacefully asked for autonomy of Kurdistan.
dario
first of all my friends there are well more than 4 million Kurds in Syria and no they have not "become arab like" I can understand in way that turkey has concerns but why should turkey be against an autonomous Kurdistan in Syria?? why is that it always turkey assumes the worst from Kurds? I just do...
Kurd
Avci should be asking more pertinent and meaningful questions! Was Kurdistan divided, partitioned and annexed to the neighboring countries by the infamous Sykes-Picot agreement in the best interests of Anglo-French imperialists? Yes. Did Turkish dictator Mustafa Kemal collaborate with the imperialis...
David
Click here to read all user comments
Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
22 May 2013
AK Party’s Plans B and C for constitution
21 May 2013
Alarm bells for CHP
20 May 2013
What did Turkey get from the Obama meeting?
17 May 2013
CHP's steady inconsistency
16 May 2013
Syria and terrorism
15 May 2013
Media ban was wrong move
14 May 2013
Intended message behind Reyhanlı blasts
13 May 2013
Reyhanlı blast
12 May 2013
CHP's fall
10 May 2013
Overcoming constitution dilemma
9 May 2013
PKK's choice
8 May 2013
Withdrawal begins
7 May 2013
For better democracy
6 May 2013
The core of settlement
3 May 2013
May Day failure
2 May 2013
Return of May Day riot
1 May 2013
Cooperation against settlement
30 April 2013
Reactions to the wise
29 April 2013
Turkey's social agreement project
28 April 2013
Expectations from the next stage in the process
26 April 2013
Withdrawal not a tactic but a strategy
25 April 2013
First stage of the settlement process
24 April 2013
Impartiality of the state, tragic events of 1915
23 April 2013
Why do they object to the settlement initiative?
22 April 2013
Kılıçdaroğlu's Pyrrhic victory
21 April 2013
Wise people's journey
19 April 2013
Nationalists' defeat of reformists within CHP
18 April 2013
Peace and democracy
17 April 2013
Suggestion of new method for constitution
16 April 2013
Another black stain on judiciary
15 April 2013
Reasons behind Kandil's reluctance
11 April 2013
Bahçeli’s attempt at provocation
10 April 2013
Right of resistance
9 April 2013
War of propaganda in Ergenekon trial
8 April 2013
Peace through grassroots mobility
5 April 2013
Turkey's opposition, an obstacle to settlement?
4 April 2013
More or less of a Turk?
3 April 2013
First peace, then democracy
2 April 2013
How should the PKK retreat?
1 April 2013
Including PKK in sphere of law
31 March 2013
New constitution embracing all ethnicities
29 March 2013
Controversial statement on citizenship
28 March 2013
Questions over the process of withdrawal
27 March 2013
Democracy for everyone, not only Kurds
26 March 2013
Diplomatic thaw with Israel
25 March 2013
Apology is product of Zeitgeist
22 March 2013
This Nevruz heralds peaceful springs
21 March 2013
Terror companies sharing PKK's clients
20 March 2013
Lack of support will be reflected at the ballot box
19 March 2013
Conflict between pessimists, optimists
18 March 2013
Drawing lessons from others' experiences
17 March 2013
Peace process a test for CHP?
15 March 2013
Will there be a price for laying down weapons?
14 March 2013
First token of good intentions
13 March 2013
Opposition's lack of maturity
12 March 2013
A democratization project
11 March 2013
Demands no longer enforced by arms
8 March 2013
Calls for action before truly celebrating Women's Day
7 March 2013
Risks of too much transparency
6 March 2013
Road to peace always thorny
5 March 2013
What is good journalism?
4 March 2013
Is it a provocation-proof process?
3 March 2013
Challenges of the peace process
1 March 2013
More sabotage, more calls for caution
28 February 2013
Too early for a sigh of relief
27 February 2013
Öcalan's failure in communication
26 February 2013
Test for Öcalan's authority
25 February 2013
Possible roadmap of peace process
22 February 2013
Presidential system under today's circumstances
21 February 2013
Violent protests in the Black Sea region
20 February 2013
Violent protests aimed at creating ‘Turkish issue'
19 February 2013
The dilemma of the new constitution
18 February 2013
Crucial balance of optimism and realism
15 February 2013
Error and essence of coup trials
14 February 2013
CHP torn between nationalists, peace initiative supporters
13 February 2013
Little known about deadly blast, many worries
12 February 2013
Political consensus on a new constitution
11 February 2013
Speculation over Erdoğan's visit
10 February 2013
EU, SCO no viable alternatives
8 February 2013
A sign of judicial activism
7 February 2013
The EU's challenges
6 February 2013
Turkey's pursuit of int'l cooperation
5 February 2013
Challenging steps of peace strategy
4 February 2013
Political test awaits Turkey
3 February 2013
More than an anti-American attack
1 February 2013
Vision Shanghai Five offers
31 January 2013
Güler's remark core of Kurdish issue
30 January 2013
The CHP's problems swept under the carpet
29 January 2013
Different stances in Mali and Syria
28 January 2013
Turning towards the East
25 January 2013
The CHP in contradiction with its leftist image
24 January 2013
Shadow cast over peace plans
23 January 2013
Paris killings get even more complicated
22 January 2013
Not Kurdish problem, democracy problem
21 January 2013
Good signs
20 January 2013
Turkey's struggle against its phobias
18 January 2013
First test on the long road to peace
17 January 2013
Six answers to ‘Why now'
16 January 2013
Language needed for peace
15 January 2013
Syria's possible role in the Paris killings
...