Two-tier war in Syria
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
20 May 2013 Monday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 24 July 2012, Tuesday 2 0 0 0
DOĞU ERGİL
d.ergil@todayszaman.com

Two-tier war in Syria

One of the components of Syria’s population is the Kurds. It would be wrong to say that they are united, and that the Kurdish political parties have similar agendas; different factions have taken disparate stances vis-à-vis the ongoing conflict in the country.

There are two main currents among the Syrian Kurds that have come close to causing confrontation amongst them: On one side groups related to the Free Syrian Army (FSA), and on the other the People’s Defense Committees (TEV-DEM), which are affiliated with the Democratic Union Party (PYD), the Syrian extension of the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK), born and fighting for autonomy in Turkey.

Indeed, the TEV-DEM has often attempted to suppress anti-Bashar al-Assad demonstrations and Kurdish activists siding with the opposition. The PKK and its scion in Syria, the PYD, are trying to achieve self-rule in the Kurdish northern region. That is why the PYD does not want to alienate the Assad government in these dire times. The FSA has delivered a few retaliatory punches to TEV-DEM militias. The two parties are in uneasy cohabitation, with no mechanism for arbitration. In fact, when conflict peaked last month among Syrian Kurdish political parties, Massoud Barzani, president of the Iraqi Kurdistan Regional Government (KRG), had to intervene. The PYD has accused other Kurdish political parties of being the stooges of Turkey, and its support for the incumbent Syrian government infuriates Syrian National Council (SNC) affiliates.

The major problem with the Kurdish parties, which demand equality and the civic rights of which they have been deprived, is that the SNC is too Arab and wants to retain the country’s Arab character in the event of the fall of the Assad government. Not all Kurds trust the SNC and its evident Arab nationalism. That is why some Kurds feel close to the PYD: because of its uncompromising Kurdish character. Its temporary tactical alliance with the Assad government is not much heeded as PYD supporters believe that the party, with the backing of the PKK, will sooner or later deliver “Syrian Kurdistan.”

In fact, the PYD has built up muscle to fulfill its stated aims. It has 4,500 highly trained armed militia in the Kandil Mountains, the hideout of the PKK and the organizations it controls and guides in neighboring countries.

While there is a rift between the Kurdish factions in Syria concerning the place of the theoretical Kurdish state with or without the Assad regime, there is also conflict as to who will rule over the Kurds. Both conflicts will unravel as the process of regime change evolves. However, the “advent” of the Kurds and their visibility as a political actor annoys some Arabs, particularly the tribal Arabs in regions populated by Kurds.

Given the fact that the PKK has a strong claim as the leader of the Syrian Kurds (as is the case in Turkey and Iran), and that it is an armed organization, adding weight to this claim, internal fighting in Syria is likely to continue, even after the downfall of the Assad regime.

Arab tribes being supported and armed by Arab nationalists may lead to bloody clashes between local Arab tribes and the Kurdish people. Turkey may lend support to anti-PKK elements, further complicating the scene.

Another area of difficulty is the use of Syria as a pawn in broader attempts to bring down the Shiite theocracy in Iran. The downfall of the Syrian Alawite government will also mean the empowerment of the Sunni majority. The main reason why some want the Iran-affiliated Syrian Alawite regime to be brought down is to balance Iraq against Iran and diminish Syria’s influence on Lebanon through Hezbollah. Now what Syria has done in the past -- namely, sending militants (especially jihadists) to Lebanon and Iraq -- is reversed. Saudi Arabia is said to be using the same channels to send militants to Syria.

How this mess, this ideologically driven warfare extending from Lebanon to Iran, will be resolved, and what kind of political landscape will result, is very unclear. How Turkey will chart its course in this unknown territory, gathering more power for itself than it already has, is another vital question.

Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
20 May 2013
Syria in the eye of the beholder
19 May 2013
Syria between a rock and a hard place
14 May 2013
Syria exploding
12 May 2013
Awakening
7 May 2013
Iraq in turmoil (1)
5 May 2013
Questions and sincerity
30 April 2013
Poisonous questions
28 April 2013
Pride and Prejudice
23 April 2013
Scenes from Central Anatolia
21 April 2013
Official vs. Civic
16 April 2013
Iraqi Turkmens
14 April 2013
Oh Kurd (2)
9 April 2013
Oh Kurd (1)
7 April 2013
Oh Turk, (2)
2 April 2013
Oh Turk,
31 March 2013
Syria and Kurds
26 March 2013
Israel's apology
24 March 2013
Time to celebrate
19 March 2013
Meltdown
17 March 2013
A new phase in globalization
12 March 2013
A day for women
10 March 2013
EU membership: realities and aspirations
5 March 2013
The leak and the aftermath
3 March 2013
Where to tap?
26 February 2013
Syrian stalemate and the tragedy of inaction
24 February 2013
Presidency and the ‘grand peace’ offer
19 February 2013
Hope and caution
17 February 2013
Political perceptions
12 February 2013
Europe vs. Asia; elite vs. public
10 February 2013
Scenarios in the Syrian conflict
5 February 2013
Assessment of political and economic trends
3 February 2013
From Brussels to Shanghai
29 January 2013
Egypt and Iran
27 January 2013
‘Open Networks, Closed Regimes’
22 January 2013
Kurdish landscape is bustling
20 January 2013
Dividends of peace
15 January 2013
Peace with the dragon
13 January 2013
Dangers ahead
8 January 2013
Changes and challenges to understanding the Kurdish problem
6 January 2013
New year, new constitution?
1 January 2013
The 8 most interesting things we learned in 2012
30 December 2012
A 2012 account of Turkish foreign policy
25 December 2012
Interesting developments
23 December 2012
Iraqi prospects in Kurdish parentheses
18 December 2012
Turkey’s popularity in the Middle East
16 December 2012
Civil war in words and deeds
11 December 2012
Suicides in the army
9 December 2012
The pro-coup makeup in our DNA
4 December 2012
The secret army
2 December 2012
Violence against women
27 November 2012
The Kurdish house
25 November 2012
After the hunger strikes
20 November 2012
Is this a war?
18 November 2012
Life is a mirror: You get what you give
13 November 2012
Remembering and contemplating Atatürk
11 November 2012
Ending hunger strikes and political folly
6 November 2012
Elections and US foreign policy debate
23 October 2012
A slightly different competition
21 October 2012
Syria tough test for goals of ex-Ottomans
16 October 2012
Strategic depth (1)
9 October 2012
On war
7 October 2012
Another name for Syria: uncertainty
2 October 2012
Regional dynamics at play at the AKP congress
30 September 2012
The AKP congress
25 September 2012
Turkey, Israel and Egypt
23 September 2012
Systemic flaws
18 September 2012
On extremism
16 September 2012
Shadow boxing
11 September 2012
Tenacity of Syrian regime
9 September 2012
Questions and prejudices
4 September 2012
The Syrian enigma
2 September 2012
A bold new world?
28 August 2012
Here we stand?
26 August 2012
Questioning the Kurdish question
21 August 2012
US elections frivolous games
19 August 2012
One more time
14 August 2012
Syrian challenges
12 August 2012
Turkey’s Kurdish imbroglio as seen from outside
7 August 2012
Brotherhood?
5 August 2012
Syria unfolding
31 July 2012
Syria and Turkey: a friendship that went astray
29 July 2012
Whither goes the regime change in Syria
24 July 2012
Two-tier war in Syria
22 July 2012
Living with the hegemon
17 July 2012
Differing official rhetoric and common problems
15 July 2012
Turkey in the Syrian ‘problem’
10 July 2012
Strangers in their own land
8 July 2012
Russia and Israel on Syria
3 July 2012
The princess and the phoenix
1 July 2012
Reciprocity
26 June 2012
An intricate strategy
24 June 2012
Egypt’s hijacked spring
19 June 2012
Hopeful developments
17 June 2012
Dynamics of the Syrian conflict
12 June 2012
Kurdish issue redux
10 June 2012
The other world
5 June 2012
The abortion debate and beyond
3 June 2012
Conquest and discovery
29 May 2012
NATO’S near future
27 May 2012
Qualities of power
...