Turkey weighs Syria options, proxy war not among them
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
20 May 2013 Monday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 29 June 2012, Friday 1 0 0 0
KLAUS JURGENS
klaus.jurgens@gmail.com

Turkey weighs Syria options, proxy war not among them

Sometimes what at first glance appears to be a one-off incident may well lead to an unwanted, lasting chain reaction. Last week’s deplorable downing of a manned Turkish reconnaissance plane by Syria is such a case. Verbal retaliation by the Turkish prime minister was an immediate must and the deployment of troops along the Syrian border another logical step. Yet what some hawkish circles apparently want -- Ankara going it alone vis-à-vis Damascus -- would be giving in to engagement in a proxy war in the name of others who neither can nor want to take serious action against Syria and would be like falling into a political trap of sorts.

Let me be more precise. A US-led initiative with boots on the ground before the presidential elections at the end of the year is highly unlikely. One or two single EU member states declaring war unilaterally would torpedo each and every effort at eventually creating a full-fledged Common Foreign and Security Policy that, until this very day, more often than not results in nothing more than simply adopting lengthy resolutions. Could NATO have become the third and only viable option to enter Syria, not as a US-led mission but supposedly as a broad coalition of NATO member states? Apparently not as of yet! Why? Syria is a different country than Libya, for example. Syria, although seemingly isolated, has at least on paper powerful external allies, if that is the right word. NATO would not simply be fighting President Bashar al-Assad’s troops but entering the treacherous waters of global conflict.

As much as I understand the anger in Ankara, first over the continuous bloodshed in a neighboring country that once was supposed to be an emerging economic and political friend, second over its concerns as to how many more thousands of Syrian civilians will flee to this country and where they will go from here, and third over its downed airplane, it would not merit a unilateral declaration of war.

Thus, assuming that the unilateral option is off the table despite the verbal retaliation which was all too understandable, Turkey must press its NATO allies and Washington and EU partner countries to come together and decide whether a joint effort is possible, desirable or not. Turkey going it alone would please all the hard-liners across the Atlantic, make Brussels’ political life so much easier and leave NATO not having to face the risk of being drawn into a lengthy war. Neither the population of Europe, America nor elsewhere would support that anyway. Turkey going it alone would please some Turkish neo-conservatives, too, who would have a field day arguing that a government that had promised its voters to establish a 21st-century civilian democracy would then resort to demonstrating its military might not just at home but abroad, too.

On the one hand, and initially unknowingly yet by now perhaps quite openly, President Assad has laid a trap for Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan. If Assad can no longer rescue his own position, what better than a neighboring leader becoming embroiled in the military action, too, thereby leading to a further loss of life on both sides? If Assad thinks he can no longer survive, why not set the entire region on fire next? Attention would be shifted to Turkey, away from only Damascus being seen as the bad boy responsible for innocent people losing their lives.

On the other hand, while Washington and Brussels having lent verbal support to Ankara after the downing of the plane is one thing, pushing Ankara to the edge to go it alone is altogether different and, above all else, totally wrong, if it ever comes to that scenario.

Ankara and the ruling Justice and Development Party (AK Party) government have modernized and democratized an entire country almost from A-Z in just under a decade. Let us hope that its foresightedness is not cut short by the conflict in neighboring Syria and, albeit understandable, that it never in a solo effort flexes its military muscles vis-à-vis Damascus. The Syrian conflict is a global issue; Ankara will be remembered as an eventual peace-broker if it manages to convey that message to its allies. Jointly, the time for action may come soon unless the democratic Syrian opposition in its transitional form manages to permanently turn things around at home, of course with external support, if demanded, yet full-blown military intervention must be a last resort.

Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
17 May 2013
Women's rights in Turkey seen by Lithuania
10 May 2013
Pseudo-Westerners' latest obsession: lipstick!
3 May 2013
A Spanish time bomb
26 April 2013
Have 500 EU nationals ‘gone missing' in Syria?
22 April 2013
April 23, 2013: relationship between state and children
19 April 2013
What is wrong with Turkish social democracy?
12 April 2013
Provocateurs deserve red cards
5 April 2013
Model to success story: towards peace in Turkey
29 March 2013
Cyprus' financial meltdown: signaling euro's demise, more?
22 March 2013
Five days amid Turkish civil society
15 March 2013
Obstacles for women finding employment
8 March 2013
Fire!
1 March 2013
Who in Syria's current regime has a Plan B?
22 February 2013
Promoting cultural heritage requires proactive site management
15 February 2013
One more chapter -- but where is the book?
8 February 2013
Does freedom of expression include promoting coups d'état?
3 February 2013
Costs, benefits of Turkey hosting 2020 Olympics
1 February 2013
Shanghai or Schuman roundabout
25 January 2013
United Kingdom out, Turkey in EU, by 2018?
18 January 2013
Six million loaves of bread!
11 January 2013
Economic, social inclusion key for post-PKK Turkey
4 January 2013
Of mice, men and Turkey's upcoming local elections
28 December 2012
Murder on Orange Blossom Street
21 December 2012
Shrinking numbers, nevertheless majority wants Turkey in EU
14 December 2012
Human rights in the Turkish Armed Forces
7 December 2012
Would Syria attack Turkey?
30 November 2012
Keep ‘Muhteşem Yüzyıl,’ ‘Seksenler,’ other soaps on air
29 November 2012
Turkey's generation democracy
23 November 2012
Having a disability is no criminal offense!
16 November 2012
Municipality boundaries redrawn:heading towards federalism?
9 November 2012
Turkey should not abandon its EU mission
2 November 2012
Could Ankara’s Republic Day scuffles have been avoided?
19 October 2012
Apolitical to pro-political: electability at 18
12 October 2012
Malala Yousafzai
5 October 2012
Turkey’s Syria policies didn’t fail, Syria’s own ‘policies’ did
28 September 2012
Turkish, Kurdish, Syriac, Arab: Mardin -- model for Turkey?
21 September 2012
Akçakale -- is Syrian violence spreading into Turkey?
14 September 2012
14 minutes of madness with a method
7 September 2012
Do you work for the CIA, too?
31 August 2012
A president’s health bulletin, conspiracy theories and reality
24 August 2012
‘I take the terrorist’: Tuesday afternoon at my local Internet café
21 August 2012
Static politics or sustainable progress -- has Turkey made its choice?
17 August 2012
Ecuador shows courage
10 August 2012
The AK Party and Kemalism
3 August 2012
And the next Turkish president is…
27 July 2012
Should governments tell parents how many children are best?
20 July 2012
Citizen-oriented, economy-friendly, EU-ready only options for CHP
13 July 2012
Citizenship and human rights education
6 July 2012
‘Faux liberalism’ versus the AK Party
5 July 2012
Greek elections take two: as the middle classes disappear…
29 June 2012
Turkey weighs Syria options, proxy war not among them
22 June 2012
A.B. Breivik: insane or calculating killing machine?
15 June 2012
Road safety cause for great concern
8 June 2012
Hard-line terrorists, soft sphere supporters: Terror can be overcome!
3 June 2012
Turkey’s parallel worlds: What makes society civil, civic?
1 June 2012
Revolution by social media: sustainable democracy by whom?
25 May 2012
Back to the ’80s
18 May 2012
May 19, 2012, rings in new era, almost
11 May 2012
If Turkey lacks press freedom, why is this column appearing?
4 May 2012
May 1: Defending workers’ rights or just another holiday?
27 April 2012
As the Turkish Spring turned into summer
22 April 2012
How much ICT do Turkish schools need?
20 April 2012
Attempting coups, not merely promoting tutelage, is the crime
13 April 2012
Turkey’s emerging climate change policies
6 April 2012
What future for the youth of the Arab Spring?
1 April 2012
Can Turkey be EU ready by 2015? Very possible!
30 March 2012
When Köşeköy had its 15 minutes of fame
23 March 2012
Turkish citizens want, deserve visa-free travel to EU
16 March 2012
New Turkish constitution could promote socially responsible entrepreneurs
9 March 2012
Haydarpaşa station: preservation versus modernity, compromise required
2 March 2012
‘Language for Peace’ improves (grassroots) Armenian-Turkish relations
24 February 2012
FATİH -- very welcome indeed!
21 February 2012
What makes Turkish mainstream conservatism so attractive?
17 February 2012
The MİT affair -- conspiracy theorists’ treasure trove
10 February 2012
9-19-9-6 or 53-22-11-7 or…
3 February 2012
Early Mondays and Fridays at our local primary school
27 January 2012
Navigating Ankara, deciphering Turkish politics
20 January 2012
A text message supposedly from Turkey’s main opposition party
13 January 2012
May 19, 2012 -- milestone in the making
6 January 2012
The difference between a Mars bar and overthrowing a government
30 December 2011
‘Happy to be in Turkey’
23 December 2011
France, early on May 7, 2012
16 December 2011
Unemployment statistics: more than number crunching!
9 December 2011
Euro-Group or no group -- Brussels’ summit impacts Ankara
2 December 2011
Dr. Saif al-Islam Gaddafi
25 November 2011
All eyes on İzmir and its 2020 EXPO bid
18 November 2011
Towards a non-conscript army?
11 November 2011
Turkey’s west-east gap
4 November 2011
Cyprus after Long Island: a milestone towards reunification
28 October 2011
Republic Day 2011: moment of unity, truth
24 October 2011
Earthquake, terrorism, civil uprisings: Which images are fit for publication?
21 October 2011
Colonel Gaddafi is dead, what next for Libya?
14 October 2011
What's wrong with international support for Turkey's future constitution?
7 October 2011
Roads not paved with gold, but double asphalt instead!
30 September 2011
Turkey's new constitution requires broad consensus
23 September 2011
Can MOBESE prevent inner-city terrorist attacks?
16 September 2011
And then there were three: London, Paris, Ankara
9 September 2011
Israeli, Turkish levels of self-criticism
2 September 2011
Back to school (nearly) -- spotlight on Turkey's education system
28 August 2011
[Racism, xenophobia, rise of populist movements]
Have mainstream political parties failed?
...