From the September 1955 pogroms to a campaign against missionaries
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
26 May 2013 Sunday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 28 June 2012, Thursday 13 0 0 0
ORHAN KEMAL CENGİZ
o.cengiz@todayszaman.com

From the September 1955 pogroms to a campaign against missionaries

One of the most dangerous situations for the mind is being unable to make a distinction between fantasy and reality. This can work in two ways. You may treat a fantasy as if it is reality or you can listen to a shocking reality as though it’s a fable.

When it comes to paranoia about missionaries and Christians, we can see that our minds were paralyzed by both ways. Turkish society, media, politicians and so on treated a very stupid fantasy as if it was real for a long time. Our minds became a slave to this carefully created image of missionaries. We were looking for them everywhere: They had invaded Turkey, they were working to divide the country and they represented the fifth estate of Turkey’s external enemies. In the last couple of years, it became clear that this paranoia was created by the Turkish deep state in order to manipulate Turkish society into becoming more nationalist, to prepare the ground work for the ensuing murders of Christians and so on. With the Ergenekon investigation, we started to see the tip of the iceberg of this anti-Christian paranoia. With the second indictment in the Malatya massacre case, which is about the murder of three missionaries in 2007, some shocking details started to come out about how the paranoia surrounding them was created. In another country, these details would all have made headlines, whereas in Turkey they are ignored and treated like a kind of fantasy.

In this second indictment, we learned that this campaign against missionaries and Christians was led and orchestrated by a single center within the Turkish General Staff. This center is called the National Strategies and Operations Department (TUSHAD). TUSHAD was established within the framework of the Special Forces (Özel Kuvvetler), which is the continuation of Special Warfare Department (Özel Harp Dairesi).

Without knowing some history, these connections would not make any sense at all. The Special Warfare Department was implicated in many bloody provocations in Turkey in the past, including the pogroms of Sept. 6-7, 1955, targeting non-Muslims in İstanbul. One of the directors of this department, retired Gen. Sabri Yirmibeşoğlu, once said in an interview that the pogroms of 1955 “were an excellent operation carried out by Special Warfare and they achieved their goal.” Today, we have learned that a special branch, TUSHAD, was established in 1993 within the Turkish military by Hurşit Tolon, a four-star general and secretary-general of the General Staff at the time, to engage with Christians.

İlker Çınar, a staff member of this branch and a witness for the prosecutor, told the story of his activities within the framework of TUSHAD in great detail.

Çınar was first extensively educated about missionaries and intelligence at TUSHAD. Then he was sent to Mersin, where he infiltrated Christian community for the first time. He presented himself to the Christian community as a person doing some “soul-searching”. He was quickly accepted by the Christian community there and became a “member”. He started to distribute bibles. He engaged in quite intensive missionary activities throughout the whole Mediterranean region, while of course at the same time regularly sending all intelligence to TUSHAD through local gendarmerie agencies. His hard labor was appreciated by the Christian community and he was accepted to the Bible Academy in Ephesus. He received a diploma and became a pastor. He even changed his identity card to reflect his religion as Christian, of course with the permission of TUSHAD. He became one of the leading figures in his Christian community. His idea of opening a church in Mersin was accepted and he became the pastor of this church. In 2005, he received new instructions from TUSHAD ordering him to become Muslim again and to tell Turkish society about missionaries.

I clearly remember his first appearance on one of the popular TV channels. His whole head and face was covered with a paper bag first, but after a while he took off the paper bag and he said he is “not embarrassed.” It was such a theatrical show. Then he started to speak of how devilish the missionary people were. After this, he appeared on many national TV channels, one after another. He wrote books about missionaries. He attended conferences in every corner the country and became the symbol of the anti-missionary war. Now, he has told the prosecutors he did everything under the orders of TUSHAD, which arranged all contacts and other things for him.

I will continue with this subject in my next column.

COMMENTS
Every nation has it's clowns. Sadly my nation also has one young, probably uneducated, quite possibly from a poor family and young who has no real objectives in his life but to shame our people. That honor goes to "necati." Need I say more? A real Turk, just like our courageous journalists, will jum...
Mine Ozcelik Bagrationi
@necati, there is NOTHING funny about the pain, suffering, death and destruction inflicted upon the Empire's Armenian subjects. Just who are "They" who first started with ...? You should ask for "their" sources and references before you dismiss "their" claims! Your insensitivity is exceeded by your...
Aziz
..1,500,000 million were killed, 1 plus million were driven into the deserts of Syria and Iraq where they perished, and the rest exiled. That makes almost 3 million Armenians dead. Necati is the Thief that refuses to return the money stolen and (with interest) to the Armenians.
Mine Ozcelik Bagrationi
ermenians are like bank account with interest. They first started with 800.000 then, 1.000.000 and then 1.500.000 nowadays i read even 2.000.000. I am afraid soon will be 5.000.000 Ha Ha..funny people.
necati
@anastasia, thank you for your observations. He was not a dispassionate scientist, but a clearly moved human being. Today, most people would consider him prejudiced due to his generalization as you correctly point out. ...... History supports the British-born American patriot Thomas Paine when he pe...
Baran
BARAN I was an adolescent when i first read General Gordon's account. Being quite young, without having much critical thinking, i was horrified by his description,without further scrutiny. I happened to read it a second time while being a university student and then i was taken aback and stopped a...
anastasia
Lets not forget the Armenian Genocide of 1915 where 1,500,000 Armenians died.
Yakup
So much energy invested in perverse machinations, targeting a non-existent 'object'.At least, the pogroms of 1955 had a clear goal: expel the greek and other christian minorities from Turkey. But a handful of Protestants, how could they be perceived as a threat to the Turkish nation? Perverse, nat...
anastasia
Thank you for another informative column. Here is a tragic precedent in the words of the then American Consul General Mr George Horton based in Izmir: "I have often been impressed with the hopelessness of making people who have not been eyewitnesses, comprehend the dreadful character of the massacre...
Baran
..even though I do Not believe in a "god" or "gods," I would have rather see my people convert to Christianity than stay captive to a religion that has caused us nothing but continued headaches. Yes, some argue that we are "westernized," I see absolutely Nothing Westernized in Turkey today (that is ...
Mine Ozcelik bagrationi
Orhan? I want to be your best friend! AVRUPA!
YUSUF BABA-YESHUA BAR DAVID
Mr. Cengiz wrote, "... the pogroms of Sept. 6-7, 1955, targeting non-Muslims in Istanbul." Mr. Cengiz, even though I am in full agreement with what you have written on the subject matter at hand and in fact commend you for it, I feel compelled in pointing out that the previously mentioned pogroms we...
Thessalonian
Turks have to deal with 'fantasies' because they live in a permanent state of denial. Turkey has never engaged in orchestrated anti-Christian events according to most Turks. They have been instructed time and again in nationalist myths which deny any culpability in such events. When you live with an...
Christoph
Click here to read all user comments
Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
23 May 2013
Some citizens more equal than others
21 May 2013
Religious freedom problems in Turkey in 2012 and forever
16 May 2013
Who are the owners of places of worship in Turkey?
14 May 2013
How and why was the terrorist attack in Reyhanlı censored?
9 May 2013
The day after the PKK's withdrawal
7 May 2013
When will official reaction to 1915 change?
2 May 2013
Peace or democracy?
30 April 2013
Rumi, Buddha and remarks of Tokyo governor
25 April 2013
April 24 and Turkey's time tunnel
23 April 2013
An Armenian lady, Hrant and April 24
18 April 2013
Wise people's contribution to peace process
16 April 2013
What is wrong with Fazıl Say's punishment?
11 April 2013
How do Turkish laws produce terrorists?
9 April 2013
Truth and reconciliation commissions are necessary in Turkey
4 April 2013
What should wise people do for the peace process?
3 April 2013
Why can we not make fundamental improvements for non-Muslims?
28 March 2013
Murder of an Armenian Turkish soldier accidentally on purpose
26 March 2013
What is Turkey's roadmap for the Kurdish question?
21 March 2013
Real injustice in Ergenekon and Balyoz cases
19 March 2013
What did the Hasan Cemal case show us?
14 March 2013
Turkey, Israel and jujitsu lessons
12 March 2013
Secrecy in the investigation of attacks on Armenian women
7 March 2013
The peace process and freedom of the press
5 March 2013
Does an Armenian murderer eliminate the hate crimes presumption?
28 February 2013
Culture of lynching: dealing with hate crimes
26 February 2013
Öcalan's letters
21 February 2013
Turkey in mirror of European Court of Human Rights
19 February 2013
Victory and defeat
12 February 2013
What is wrong and right in criticisms against American ambassador
7 February 2013
Turkey's judiciary problem
5 February 2013
Hrant and Talat Pasha
31 January 2013
Genocide through the eyes of a child
29 January 2013
The Halki Theological School and the SCO
28 January 2013
‘I wish I wasn't Armenian'
22 January 2013
Why were the lawyers arrested?
17 January 2013
Is the Hrant Dink murder being resolved?
15 January 2013
Aren't the murders of Armenian women hate crimes?
10 January 2013
Atrocities in Syria committed by all sides
8 January 2013
A country of speed readers
7 January 2013
How can we achieve peace?
1 January 2013
The prime minister’s lawsuits will backfire
27 December 2012
Uludere massacre one year later
25 December 2012
Why was the commemoration for the Maraş massacre banned?
20 December 2012
How the Uludere massacre alienated Kurds from Turkey
18 December 2012
What can propaganda achieve?
13 December 2012
Praising Hrant Dink's murder
11 December 2012
Special Warfare and Christians
6 December 2012
Hrant, embarrassment, a disaster
4 December 2012
Déjà vu -- removing immunity of Kurdish MPs?
29 November 2012
Revealing too much: info belonging to Armenian groups online
28 November 2012
Turkey and Germany’s past atrocities
22 November 2012
Can Germany be a model for Turkey in confrontation with past atrocities?
20 November 2012
Hunger strikers did not die, but handicapped for life
15 November 2012
İstanbul and Constantinople
8 November 2012
Polar bears, Bedouins and poor Turkish politics
6 November 2012
Hunger strikes and a vicious circle
1 November 2012
1915: heroes and murderers
30 October 2012
The price of no criticism for the government
23 October 2012
Do not interfere with Kemalists’ mourning
18 October 2012
Armenians and a Turk in a Lebanese restaurant
16 October 2012
Restorative guilt and the Kurdish question
12 October 2012
Linking women’s stories in Turkey and Armenia
11 October 2012
1915 and terrorists on mountains
4 October 2012
The price for denial of the events of 1915
2 October 2012
How can Turkey bring an end to violence in Kurdish question
27 September 2012
Why are they so successful in seeing problematic aspects in coup cases?
20 September 2012
How Alevi victims became criminal offenders
18 September 2012
Islamophobia and hate speech in Turkey
13 September 2012
Criticizing Israel and insulting the Prophet
11 September 2012
Owen, Cemal and 1915
6 September 2012
How missionaries were linked to the PKK
4 September 2012
Will justice be served in Malatya massacre case?
30 August 2012
Campaign against violence
28 August 2012
Has the dispossessing of non-Muslims ended?
23 August 2012
Was Atatürk an Armenian?
21 August 2012
Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar!
16 August 2012
Zero tolerance for freedom of expression
14 August 2012
PKK, kidnapping and absolute impunity for the PKK
9 August 2012
Is there any ‘legal' place of worship for Alevis in Turkey?
7 August 2012
The government as an advocate of military coups
19 July 2012
The future of the deep state
17 July 2012
One basketball for all non-Muslims
12 July 2012
How was a monastery robbed in Turkey?
10 July 2012
Halki Seminary, cemevi in Parliament
3 July 2012
Who ordered the murder of Christians?
28 June 2012
From the September 1955 pogroms to a campaign against missionaries
26 June 2012
Recognizing the victimhood of the slain Christians
21 June 2012
What does the PKK really want?
19 June 2012
Prison SOS
14 June 2012
Let’s send all Kurds to prison
12 June 2012
From stone throwing children to child soldiers
7 June 2012
What do Islamist feminists say about abortion?
5 June 2012
Nationalists, muslims and the Kurdish question
3 June 2012
How did abortion come to our agenda?
29 May 2012
Some things never change
24 May 2012
Turkey through Amnesty International’s eyes
22 May 2012
Mr. Öcalan!
17 May 2012
Greek radio, Greek properties
15 May 2012
Arameans’ return and state policies
10 May 2012
Fabricated evidence in Sledgehammer case and the ECtHR
...