Would the PKK lay down its arms?
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
19 June 2013 Wednesday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 10 June 2012, Sunday 14 0 0 0
EMRE USLU
e.uslu@todayszaman.com

Would the PKK lay down its arms?

Deputy Prime Minister Beşir Atalay made a statement a few days ago that the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) would lay down its arms. According to Atalay, negotiations with the PKK continue via Massoud Barzani and a tangible result is expected in the coming days.

Atalay added that Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan will reveal the details of the negotiations in the coming days.

In a normal country, such a statement from a deputy prime minister that Turkey has finally convinced the PKK to lay down its arms would produce a huge shock. This is not only breaking news for Turkey but breaking news for the rest of the world, too.

However, it is more than sad that no one has taken Atalay seriously. Perhaps there are two reasons for that. First, in recent years Atalay’s credibility has eroded so rapidly that no one trusts what he says anymore. Especially after Atalay’s terrible waste of the democratic initiative, neither Turks nor pro-PKK Kurds take him seriously.

Second, people do not believe that the PKK will lay down its arms. Given the fact that the PKK has declared many times that its aim is not to lay down arms but to return to the Kurdish region as security forces after possible peace negotiations, no one believes that the PKK would indeed end its violence. Therefore, Atalay’s statement does not make any sense.

If it is a fact that the PKK would not lay down its arms, why would Atalay need to manipulate people with such false rhetoric?

I think there are two reasons why he manipulates society. First, the Justice and Development (AKP) government, especially the group close to Atalay, has been pushing to change the law to abolish the special court that prosecutes organized crime and terror networks. This group has finally achieved its goal of abolishing this court, but there is strong resistance from AKP supporters. In order to ease the resistance against the AKP’s attempt to abolish the court, Atalay manipulates the facts and pumps false information into the public debate, hoping that the people would welcome any good news under the current circumstances. So with this kind of manipulation, Atalay believes that the AKP government would divert attention away from the issue of the special court to something positive, like a peaceful ending. Yet it was a failed attempt on behalf of Atalay that no one took him seriously.

The second reason why Atalay manipulates information is because he needs to prepare the public for possible negotiations with the PKK. Given that Atalay and his aids were the architects of the failed peace negotiation process, he insists that he will bring peace through negotiations. In a way, the peace negotiations are his only claim to success during his political career in the past 10 years. Thus it has become a matter of obsession for him and he uses every window of opportunity to promote his failed project. He insists that there is no other solution but his project.

All in all, because PKK leaders have denied his statement, there is no way that the PKK would lay down its arms. Atalay just manipulates people’s expectations for his own political ends and ambitions.

COMMENTS
dario, it was never a political organization. This is because it was invented by Soviet Russian agents with the goal of destabilizing Turkiye. LOL, Turkiye planned a "kurdish genocide"? That's interesting. So your suggesting that Turkiey planned on erasing say 7 million people without the intern...
GeneralSherman
Dario, you're making outrageous and unsubstantiated claims again. You say "...and planned a kurdish genocide similar to armenian one". Utter rubbish! Where's your proof? I could just as easily claim that PKK took up arms to commit a genocide on the Turks, if I had no scruples. Truth is, many groups ...
Baris
PKK was a political organisation in 1970s but took arm when the coup leaders took power in 1980s and planned a kurdish genocide similar to armenian one. PKK who paid heavy price for defending Kurds, which is why seen by kurdish people as heros. when Turks stop arresting peaceful kurdish activists an...
dario
David, you say PKK is the only insurance policy for Kurdish citizens of Turkeys. Not so. PKK has directly killed thousands of Kurds and are hindering the democratisation of Turkey which would give equal rights to the Kurds. Some insurance policy! You are also on record for saying that you abhor viol...
Baris
solution, then you're just as clueless as he is.
GeneralSherman
All4Untruth, no, actually it would be the first demonstration that they have any brain cells in their lives.
GeneralSherman
David, who are you kidding? Tell that to the more than 30,000 dead PKK terrorists who have been sent to hell. LOL, whether or not a few thousand kurds carry out sporadic terrorist attacks against teachers, doctors, or policemen, it makes no difference? "insurance policy"? Nope, more like Soviet ...
GeneralSherman
Shorasha Ne, actually you already have. Technically, you never took up arms to begin with when you consider that most kurds don't want anything to do with the PKK. You have no mother land. The only one occupying anything are the kurds who are from India by way of Iran and Iraq. None of you were ...
GeneralSherman
@david ı am totally agree with you..
solution
Kurds throughout history have never accepted to lay down arms, the knife is a part of the Kurdish traditional dress, The Sultan Abdul Hamid II understood that and uses them in Hamidiyeh Regiments and in fact he was the most beloved Sultan by the Kurds. The CUP tried to disarm them at the begenning ...
Araratian
Nice analysis again from Mr. Eslu.
Burak Turkmen
It would be very foolish, if PKK laid down its arms!
All4Truth
That's what politicians and columnists like you do, just manipulate people's expectations for their own good and ambitions, my boy! You are doing the same thing. PKK leadership would be quite foolish to lay down its arms as they are the only insurance policy Kurdish citizens of Turkey have got. Did ...
David
are you out of your mind or what. we kurds will not let pkk to lay down its arm. in kurdish ur army is ur morals so how in earth would pkk let down its arms and our mother land still accupied by Turkey.
Shorasha Ne
Click here to read all user comments
Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
16 June 2013
Is Erdoğan a dictator?
14 June 2013
Erdoğan's world: fear and fantasy
12 June 2013
MİT in breach of law
7 June 2013
How Erdoğan sees the protests in Turkey
5 June 2013
The one-man show has ended
2 June 2013
Understanding people's anger at Tayyip Erdoğan
31 May 2013
How MİT manipulated the media: the case of Reyhanlı
29 May 2013
Turkish media and MİT
26 May 2013
Intelligence wars
24 May 2013
Do Kurdish-Turkish marriages prevent division?
22 May 2013
Syrian crisis, Ankara crisis
19 May 2013
What did Erdoğan gain from Washington?
17 May 2013
Can we Turkify Turkish intelligence?
15 May 2013
Security weakness
10 May 2013
Why is the CHP so important for the AKP?
8 May 2013
Time for urban battle in Kurdish cities
5 May 2013
Is the MHP on the rise?
3 May 2013
Will Turkey agree to international intervention in Syria?
1 May 2013
The coming election period and the settlement process
26 April 2013
What did Karayılan ask?
24 April 2013
The PKK's new strategy: acts of civil disobedience
21 April 2013
Kurdish nationalism on the rise
19 April 2013
Freedom of Press in Turkey
17 April 2013
Skeptics and optimists
12 April 2013
Hizbullah-PKK clashes
10 April 2013
Plan B for peace
7 April 2013
Questions for wise men committee
5 April 2013
The role of the wise-man committee
3 April 2013
New moves in the solution process
31 March 2013
Finding solutions (2)
29 March 2013
Finding solutions
24 March 2013
How is peace with the PKK being made?
22 March 2013
What is in Öcalan's message
20 March 2013
Ergenekon's bomb message
17 March 2013
Something fishy going on?
15 March 2013
The Turkish flag at Nevruz celebrations?
13 March 2013
Let PKK hostages be ambassadors for peace
10 March 2013
Who will lose?
8 March 2013
Why is Erdoğan so furious?
6 March 2013
Why were the İmralı minutes leaked?
3 March 2013
Abdullah Öcalan: ‘a man of peace'
1 March 2013
MİT targets us
27 February 2013
Erdoğan and Öcalan took the right steps, but...
24 February 2013
What to make of the visit to Öcalan?
22 February 2013
What is happening in the CHP?
20 February 2013
The BDP's Black Sea trip and the violent protests
17 February 2013
Would the PKK suicide attack again?
15 February 2013
Erdoğan's new friends: generals
13 February 2013
Where is the solution process heading?
10 February 2013
Erdoğan's new enemy: the EU
6 February 2013
An open letter to the American ambassador to Turkey
3 February 2013
Causes behind DHKP/C shock among diplomats
1 February 2013
Paris killings' impact on negotiation process
30 January 2013
Ömer Güney was a courier
27 January 2013
Erdoğan considering Shanghai Five
25 January 2013
Is the PKK exhausted?
23 January 2013
Forecasting politics in 2013
20 January 2013
Abdullah Öcalan benefits from peace process
18 January 2013
Discussing the peace process
16 January 2013
Would the PKK agree with the government?
13 January 2013
Killing in Paris
9 January 2013
Sledgehammer verdicts: Professor Rodrik 'deserves' Nobel Prize
6 January 2013
PKK perspective on laying down arms
2 January 2013
Can the PKK lay down its arms?
30 December 2012
Yet again Öcalan-MİT meeting
28 December 2012
Disgusting
23 December 2012
The Patriot missiles and politics
21 December 2012
Bülent Arınç and the Kurdish portfolio
19 December 2012
Kurdish politics without Talabani
16 December 2012
Taraf, democracy and freedom of the press
14 December 2012
Washington, Syria and al-Qaeda
12 December 2012
Give that medal to Öcalan and the Oslo trumpeters!
7 December 2012
A Kurdish faction within the AKP?
5 December 2012
Bring EU process back to Turkish politics
2 December 2012
Putin's visit: What to do with him?
25 November 2012
The return of Erdoğan?
23 November 2012
Kenan Evren's confession and the Sledgehammer coup
21 November 2012
Hunger strike act: the return of Abdullah Öcalan
18 November 2012
Is Turkish-Kurdish peace on the horizon?
16 November 2012
Déjà vu
14 November 2012
Erdoğan’s way
11 November 2012
Was the chopper crash in Siirt an accident or a conspiracy?
9 November 2012
How does Öcalan think? What does he want?
7 November 2012
Obama: a Thanksgiving gift to the world
4 November 2012
PKK is winning
2 November 2012
Who recorded the Oslo meetings?
31 October 2012
Is Öcalan the right actor to solve the Kurdish problem?
28 October 2012
The Öcalan theater
24 October 2012
A storm looming after Eid
21 October 2012
Erdoğan's grave mistake
17 October 2012
The state was on the verge of shelling its own people
14 October 2012
Erdoğan's fear
10 October 2012
Political implications of Diyarbakır police chief’s statements
8 October 2012
AKP’s election strategy: 50 percent threshold
5 October 2012
What is wrong with our Syrian policy?
30 September 2012
10 years in power: the AKP as ‘perception changer'
28 September 2012
‘Peace' season has arrived once more
26 September 2012
The untold tragedies of PKK parents
23 September 2012
After the Sledgehammer trial: the defendants' strategy
20 September 2012
Where is Turkey heading?
...
Bloggers