About Dersim while Dersim archives are being opened
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
19 June 2013 Wednesday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 10 May 2012, Thursday 5 0 0 0
ORHAN MİROĞLU
o.miroglu@todayszaman.com

About Dersim while Dersim archives are being opened

Within the last decade Turkish society underwent a serious reckoning and confrontation due to the 1915 deportation (Deportation of Armenians in 1915), the Kurdish problem, the wealth tax, the events of September (Sept. 6-7, 1955 İstanbul Pogrom) and the military coups.

This process is going on. As for the General Staff’s sending the archive regarding the events in Dersim in 1938 to a parliamentary research commission, it is a new and an important step.

The genie is out of the bottle. However, the subjects or victims of this confrontation have been carrying on with certain stances, which make no contribution to historical process of confrontation; and, at times, even obstructing the process.

The Kurds are experiencing the relief of blaming the state for all bad things that occurred in the past.

It is still very hard to mention both the involvement of the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) in violations and also people who were killed within the scope of executions within the PKK.

The words and evaluations of Halil Berktay about the Taksim Square Massacre of May 1, 1977, led to new indignation among leftist groups and communities.

The Alevi community’s political support for the Republican People’s Party (CHP) is still going on, and the fact that the CHP is still keeping silent although the issue of confrontation with Dersim was carried to Parliament hasn’t cause any kind of backlash among Alevi citizens.

This position of the aggrieved is generally explained with reference to the Stockholm Syndrome, and it isn’t hard to claim that that this syndrome will be affecting the Alevi community for many years. Kids born after the military operation in Dersim were named Kemal by the residents there.

The fact that in the aftermath of the military operation the residents of Dersim named their kids Kemal can’t be explained with reference to their admiration for Mustafa Kemal…

Maybe this fact might be explained with reference to the fear in their minds caused by the military operation. CHP leader Kılıçdaroğlu is an Alevi from Dersim, and the residents of Dersim allege that he is originally a member of a Kurdish tribe. But so far he has avoided confirming this claim. Kılıçdaroğlu considers what was done to his people and family as “an inevitable result of revolution” and recommends that his people forget about those incidents. He tells his people, “Let’s forget about it.” However, those incidents in the past are what made the existence of the contemporary CHP possible.

Dersim is where the CHP’s paradigm emerged. Therefore, neither Kılıçdaroğlu nor his party want a real confrontation with this paradigm because they know that the CHP would almost vanish if such a thing happened.

Today, a majority of CHP deputies still believe that the Dersim incident was a civilization project and a social engineering project. According to those deputies, the tragedy of the lost girls of Dersim, who were given to military officers after their heads were shaved, is nothing but a first step in a civilization and a modern life that started from scratch.

Since the 2000s, the process of change and democratization in Turkey has been determined via a new attitude and a new consideration about history and memory.

The policy restructured itself through this reckoning and confrontation, and it became quite renewed.

The intellectuals of the Islamic community adopted a very notable attitude in this issue. They have driven the policy of the Justice and Development Party (AK Party) onto the path of change and democracy.

Now while the AK Party is moving on the way that it knew, the main opposition party, the CHP, is trying to escape from this ominous past by staying on the path that it knew and never wanted to leave. In the course of the debate over Dersim and Sabiha Gökçe two years ago, I wrote that I wasn’t going to use that airport until its name was changed. Then all hell breaks loose!

Mrs. Sabiha is a woman who voluntarily went to Dersim and participated in the bombing operation as a pilot. This decision of mine was a radical one. However, none of the Alevis reacted. They not only avoided opposing the name of the airport but also our Kurdish ittihatçı (supporters of the Committee of Union and Progress) were the ones who made the greatest criticism of my decision.

To be honest, I reconsidered this decision of mine and decided it was useless and again started to use Sabiha Gökçen Airport to get to İstanbul.

Last week the federation of Alevi Associations protested in front of Sabiha Gökçen Airport with the same demand.

However, this isn’t enough. If we want this airport’s name to be changed, what we should do is not to use the planes arriving in and departing from this airport until its name is changed.

COMMENTS
Apology is a form of sincerety trap ,Traping the mind of those who may be concern that a correction is in the tube. This is seldom the case. All what is there is an undeniable crime been committed in Dersim ,and those who cmomitted it m and those who took over the functions of those who comitte...
Esfandyar
A lot of Muslim Kurds name their children Mohammad and Ali as well. Do you really think the Kurds saw the light through gentle persuasion and willingly embraced Islam without coercion? Surviving records show that the Kurdish population was decimated by Muslim Arabs in order to forcibly convert the K...
David
is there anyone in this country who HONESTLY believes that the Army did not 'clean out' the garbage bin they have been sitting on for the last decades to make it - at least more or less - comply with ideological realities ? I am flabbergasted that no one asks this question
tommy
Has anyone entertained the fact that the now factually accurate heritage of Mrs. Sabiha Gökçe as being Armenian had anything to do with her volunteering to bomb Dersim? After all, what a sweet revenge that must have been.
Yakov
How were the Armenians deported/ethnically cleansed from their 4000 years of homeland in 1915? By killing,rape,kidnapping of children.This is called Genocide
VTiger
Click here to read all user comments
Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
14 June 2013
Do the Gezi Park protesters subscribe to an ideology?
13 June 2013
Toward the Gezi Park referendum
7 June 2013
Turkey has great trouble with history
6 June 2013
Gezi Park
31 May 2013
Is an Assad-free solution possible?
30 May 2013
May 27 coup and democratic experience
24 May 2013
Kurds, settlement process and political attention
23 May 2013
Feb. 28 indictment a victory for democracy
17 May 2013
Disappointment in Hrant Dink case
16 May 2013
Son of al-Assad following in footsteps of father
12 May 2013
A life like everyone else has
9 May 2013
New era, new politics
3 May 2013
The Ottomans, the state system and today's reality
2 May 2013
A noteworthy hearing in Diyarbakır
26 April 2013
The PKK is withdrawing; neo-nationalists are gathering under a national umbrella
25 April 2013
Do Kurdish civil politicians think differently than those in Kandil?
19 April 2013
International actors and the peace process
18 April 2013
Is the CHP splitting?
12 April 2013
What did you give the PKK?
11 April 2013
Questions not asked to Umberto Eco
5 April 2013
It was politics that opened the way
4 April 2013
At home and in the world: wise people
29 March 2013
Hizmet movement to address Armenian issue
22 March 2013
Will the PKK bury its arms?
21 March 2013
Past crimes and prosecutor's opinion at Ergenekon trial
15 March 2013
Syriacs in Turkey and their rights
14 March 2013
Syriacs in Sweden
8 March 2013
Is the BDP the CHP of the Kurds?
7 March 2013
Does Öcalan have a vision for the future?
1 March 2013
Who leaked the minutes from the meeting with Öcalan?
28 February 2013
Feb. 28, Bediüzzaman Said Nursi and discrediting
22 February 2013
Paradigms of nationalism and prime minister's three speeches
15 February 2013
Will the peace talks fail?
14 February 2013
News from the PKK
8 February 2013
Don't say ‘You have a chance to become a Turk'; no one would believe you
7 February 2013
Dear Turks, your way is wrong
1 February 2013
Assad's Kurdish policy
31 January 2013
Isolation of the Syrian people
25 January 2013
A standard case of racism
24 January 2013
Right to court defense in one's mother tongue
18 January 2013
Following Mehmet Ali Birand
17 January 2013
Role of leaders in solution processes
11 January 2013
Peace-haters
10 January 2013
Who wants peace?
4 January 2013
What are the challenges of the new negotiations?
3 January 2013
The past and present of the Kurdish question
28 December 2012
Accounting for what occurred in Uludere
27 December 2012
In memory of Şerafettin Elçi
21 December 2012
Empathy
20 December 2012
Will rebellion be born of brutality and repression?
14 December 2012
Disinformation and a memory (2)
13 December 2012
Disinformation and a memory (1)
7 December 2012
Indecisive Maliki v. decisive Barzani
6 December 2012
In the eyes of a mother
30 November 2012
New status for Palestine
29 November 2012
Immunities
23 November 2012
Is there a crack in the CHP?
22 November 2012
While Sept. 12 is on trial
16 November 2012
Leyla Zana and Feleknas Uca
15 November 2012
A new era with Obama
9 November 2012
Feb. 28 and collective memory
8 November 2012
Unsettling witness in Ergenekon case
2 November 2012
The republic and peace
1 November 2012
Hunger strikes: 30 years ago, 30 years after
19 October 2012
When the EU fears its future
18 October 2012
The EU and the Nobel Peace Prize
12 October 2012
The Öcalan proposal and Feb. 28’s unfinished business
11 October 2012
Confronting Feb. 28
7 October 2012
Heading towards 2071: Turks and Kurds
4 October 2012
Assad’s new move
28 September 2012
Optional lessons
27 September 2012
Balyoz case
21 September 2012
CHP and Oslo process
20 September 2012
Bingöl: 20 years ago, 20 years later
14 September 2012
Common future
13 September 2012
Turks and Kurds
7 September 2012
‘Time for Justice'
6 September 2012
A ‘wise men’ formula and Turkey
2 September 2012
Psychological warfare and Kurdish issue (3)
31 August 2012
Psychological warfare and Kurdish issue (2)
30 August 2012
Psycholoical warfare and Kurdish issue (1)
24 August 2012
Sheikh Fethullah and Arameans
23 August 2012
The PKK
17 August 2012
The road to Kirkuk goes through Arbil
16 August 2012
‘Dersim is surrounded by four mountains’
10 August 2012
An untimely debate
9 August 2012
What do Kurds want?
3 August 2012
Davutoğlu’s visit to Arbil
2 August 2012
Whistling a Kurdish tune
27 July 2012
Is the real problem peshmergas sent from Arbil to Syria?
26 July 2012
Writers and readers
20 July 2012
Karayılan’s reply to call for cease-fire
19 July 2012
The powers that be
13 July 2012
Settling accounts with the past and political will
12 July 2012
Settling accounts with coups and the 3rd judicial package
6 July 2012
Does prime minister hold Moses’ staff?
5 July 2012
If the prime minister wills
28 June 2012
Nationalist envisagement and the Nationalist Movement Party
21 June 2012
Turkish nationalists and change
14 June 2012
Special courts
...
Bloggers