The Turkish-Iraqi battle of words
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
20 May 2013 Monday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 25 April 2012, Wednesday 3 0 0 0
KERİM BALCI
k.balci@todayszaman.com

The Turkish-Iraqi battle of words

It is no longer a secret that Turkey has problems with the current Iraqi government. The most recent statement to this effect comes from Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki, who said Turkey is becoming an enemy state in the region, obviously referring to Turkey's red carpet treatment of both Iraq's Vice President Tariq al-Hashimi, who is already regarded as a fugitive in his native capital, and Kurdistan Regional Government (KRG) leader Massoud Barzani, who has become a major oppositional figure in Iraq by claiming that the Maliki government was turning more dictatorial each and every day.

Maliki's anti-Turkish sentiments are not new. He has accused Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan of sectarian interference in Iraqi internal affairs and has even gone as far as threatening Turkey with retaliation, hinting that Turkey too had internal sectarian issues to deal with. Maliki's explanation for Turkey's alleged sectarian interference is Erdoğan's “illusion of regional hegemony.”

The political scene is seen completely differently from Ankara. From here it seems that due to Maliki's sectarian policies Iraq is disintegrating. For the last 10 years, the questions asked in Ankara regarding a Kurdish declaration of independence from Baghdad have been “Why?” and “How do we avoid this?” Today, the questions are “When?” and “How can this be done with Kirkuk?”

Quite opposed to Maliki's claim of sectarian interference, Turkey has advocated continued integration in Iraq and regarded Kirkuk's control by the central authority of Baghdad, despite the historical and demographic rights of the northern Kurdish and Turkmen tribes in the city, as a key to this territorial integrity. At the cost of angering its natural allies in the region, Turkey lobbied against the Kirkuk referendums that would probably bind the fate of the oil-rich city to the KRG.

It is true that Turkey played its cards openly during the last elections and gave clear support to the secular al-Iraqiya List headed by former Prime Minister Ayad Allawi. Al-Iraqiya was a pre-election coalition of Sunni, Shiite, Turkmen and non-sectarian elements of Iraqi society. Its political identity was defined as “secularism, non-sectarianism, Iraqi nationalism and Arab nationalism.” Al-Iraqiya, which was also joined by Hashimi's Renewal List, lost the elections, and one by one all the leaders of the political parties who joined the coalition started to pay for their decision to unite against al-Maliki. This is sectarian politics. Supporting al-Iraqiya may be called “interference” but not “sectarianism.”

What will happen now?

Turkey is not a remote transatlantic country when it comes to having a stake in the future of Iraq. Any power vacuum in Iraq means a safe haven for terrorists in the north of the country, and Turkish citizens pay for that vacuum with their lives. No government in Ankara can close its eyes and ears to developments in Baghdad. If Iraq is in fact disintegrating, it is obvious that Turkey should strive for a stable democracy at its southern border. If that country shall be Kurdistan, Turkey will support that country to include Kirkuk in its territory. Alternatively, Turkey will look forward to forging a Kurdish-Sunni Arab confederation that will include the districts of Kirkuk, Ninawa, Al-Anbar, Salah al-Din, Diyala and Baghdad. Only such a confederation can assure a stable country to the south of Turkey and only such a confederation can obstruct Iranian access to the Mediterranean through Syria and Lebanon.

The fear of losing control over that access is my explanation of Maliki's anti-Turkish remarks.

COMMENTS
After beeing rejected from Europe, Turkey became for a while a model to the arab world, but now Ankara is loosing all it's political appeal. Too much political errors, too many interferences in Syria, putting oil on fire, in Iraq, their complicity silence regarding the Bahrein revolution, all has p...
Adnan al Muteyri
For such an insightful column, Today's Zaman should have used a map of what the author sketches in the conclusion. Mr Balci is spot on with all the suspense of analysis held on till the very last line.
Naveed Ahmad
Let Iraqi's keep killing each other(sorry iraqi people!), they are good at it, for a little longer than anticipated, so we don't have to do anything. Then clear picture "ta-da " Al-Maliki can take the blame for himself, while not much country man left so he can rule with persian iron fist.
fist
Click here to read all user comments
Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
15 May 2013
Erdoğan and regional American policies
8 May 2013
Time to rethink Ilısu
1 May 2013
Violent May Day in İstanbul
17 April 2013
Remembering the Prophet
10 April 2013
Silivri battles become Silivri Carnival
3 April 2013
A pool of wise men!
29 March 2013
Turkey: a friend of Israel for the sake of Palestine
27 February 2013
What will we do without the PKK and Ergenekon?
20 February 2013
Suicide bombers
13 February 2013
Peace-of-no-other-choice: Blue Peace
6 February 2013
Job description: Commander to lead a coup
30 January 2013
The new Cabinet and the Ministry of Health
23 January 2013
Israel's newcomers' parliament
2 January 2013
Three charts of the Ergenekon organization
19 December 2012
Explanations and solutions based on one man will eventually fail
12 December 2012
The change of conditions in the Middle East
21 November 2012
Gaza Operation could hit Arab Spring
7 November 2012
Obama's second term, America's last chance
31 October 2012
First battle of the war of presidency
10 October 2012
New religiosity
3 October 2012
The place of parliamentarians is in Parliament
19 September 2012
Winning the war on terror
12 September 2012
A presidential system for Turkey
5 September 2012
Iranian spies in Turkey
29 August 2012
Education? Leave it scruffy!
22 August 2012
A bomb at the mountain exit gates
15 August 2012
Kidnapping a parliamentarian
8 August 2012
Turkey is Europe's cellphone-speaking champ
1 August 2012
Hashimoto’s disease and politics
25 July 2012
University entrance exams and falling off roofs
18 July 2012
AK Party's problematic hierarchy of norms
11 July 2012
Higgs boson and foreign policy
4 July 2012
A caveat: Turkish endism
13 June 2012
The prime minister in boxing gloves
6 June 2012
Change at home, change in the world
2 May 2012
Facing realities of 4+4+4 education reform
25 April 2012
The Turkish-Iraqi battle of words
18 April 2012
The coup trials: justice or revenge?
11 April 2012
Dragged into Syria
4 April 2012
Why I support 4+4 and have reservations about the third 4
28 March 2012
Why did I visit the Wailing Wall?
21 March 2012
Nevruz celebrations and playing to deadlocks
14 March 2012
A new world map drawn on Syrian divisions
29 February 2012
12 years of compulsory education
11 January 2012
Where should the former chief of General Staff be judged?
4 January 2012
Internal diversity of the new Turkish right
14 December 2011
D-forum of the Alliance of Civilizations
7 December 2011
Political ambition detection toolkit for students of Turkish politics
30 November 2011
Arab fall in İstanbul
23 November 2011
Surplus of seeing and uniqueness of ‘the I’
16 November 2011
What if the constitution is not changed?
9 November 2011
Feast of Proximity
2 November 2011
Turkey’s economic surge and its role in the Middle East
27 October 2011
Said Nursi’s relevance to current age
28 September 2011
Back to the constitution
14 September 2011
The New Middle East: Turkey replaces Israel
7 September 2011
The future of Turkish-Israeli relations
24 August 2011
Self criticism in the army is good
17 August 2011
Israel's obsession with Erdoğan
3 August 2011
Resignation of the commanders: a soldierly comment
27 July 2011
The era of dialogue will never be over
20 July 2011
Democratization of the military’s anti-terrorist activities
13 July 2011
Israel has no need to beg for reconciliation with Turkey, an apology is enough
29 June 2011
Do they want Erdoğan to become a sultan?
22 June 2011
A new government, please
15 June 2011
Did the people really say anything?
8 June 2011
A request for post-election victory balcony speech
25 May 2011
Anatomy of video blackmailing
18 May 2011
Election time moral norms
11 May 2011
Amazing readiness to believe lies
4 May 2011
An election campaign without a constitution
27 April 2011
Canal İstanbul and other crazy projects of the Prime Minister
14 April 2011
Vicious cycle of quotations and freedom of expression
7 April 2011
June 12 election and party politics
31 March 2011
Marching towards elections
24 March 2011
I vote for TÜSİAD’s constitution
17 March 2011
Poor candidates
3 March 2011
Campaign to win hearts and minds of Arab world
24 February 2011
Caught unprepared
17 February 2011
Need for good judges and prosecutors
10 February 2011
Does Turkey need an Egypt shaped on the Turkish model?
27 January 2011
Speaking Turkish in English
20 January 2011
What Sarksyan and Papoulias have both forgotten
13 January 2011
The greatest threat
23 December 2010
Heteroglossia and dictatorship
16 December 2010
Ottoman Commonwealth of Nations?
9 December 2010
Use of excessive force against protestors
2 December 2010
Wikigeeks
25 November 2010
Three generals suspended; three times hip hip hurray!
11 November 2010
A harmonious world and President Gül
4 November 2010
Turkish membership in the EU
28 October 2010
A new opening with Turkish Review
14 October 2010
The resignations in the HSYK
7 October 2010
Davutoğlu’s dream came true at İstanbul Şehir University
30 September 2010
The first adjustment law on its way
23 September 2010
Turkey, Israel and the PKK
16 September 2010
‘Yes’ vote is transformative
9 September 2010
A personal suffering from the referendum campaign
2 September 2010
Seeing the greater picture of the referendum
26 August 2010
Meeting with Öcalan
...