Why is April 24 so important for Turkey?
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
20 June 2013 Thursday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 24 April 2012, Tuesday 50 0 0 0
ORHAN KEMAL CENGİZ
o.cengiz@todayszaman.com

Why is April 24 so important for Turkey?

When I started to write this article I saw that the Armenian-Turkish weekly Agos had already run a piece that said all I want to say on this topic.

 I absolutely agree with Agos that recognizing 1915 is not only about the past, but also about the future of this country. It is also about seeking justice for the endless victims of the tragedy. As Agos indicates, the solution lies in dialog between Turks and Armenians -- not in declarations from third party politicians, who only exploit this matter for their political interests. As Agos stated, Turkey is already in the process of confronting its past crimes through the coup and Ergenekon cases. But without recognizing what happened in 1915, this process could never be called complete. I respectfully bow before the Armenian victims who suffered deeply and those who lost their lives in 1915, and I leave the floor to Agos and their meaningful piece:

“The reason why we don’t want to forget the things that happened 97 years ago is not only a matter of paying our tributes to the innocent souls that were lost, but also because of our firm belief in another future… The deeper meaning that lies in the prominent minstrel Hovhannes Tumanyan’s words “Abrek yereğek, payts mez bes çabrek” (Live long children, but don’t live like us), refers to the responsibility of building a peaceful future. Attaining a firm cognition on how the people, the nature and the civilization were all exterminated in 1915 is a sine qua non for such a responsibility.

“While remembering 1915, we take strength not from our desire for punishment or revenge, but from our wish to collectively get rid of the chains of the past. For what will eventually emancipate us is the truth. They intimidate people by saying, “They call our grandfather murderers!” but those who bear responsibility are not Turks, Muslims or Kurds. For it is not people who commit genocides, but the mindset. Just like the Nazis, the İttihat mentality, did actually sacrifice both the victim and the perpetrator; the ones who lost their lives were gone, but those who remained became sick. What made the successor governments an accomplice to this deep-rooted crime has been the systematic policy of forgetting and denial.

“In fact, we are not any longer debating what happened in 1915 in Turkey. Everyone debating on this subject knows that, in this very dark year and the ensuing years, hundreds of thousands of people were uprooted from their homes and were never able to return, with a great majority of them lying somewhere in some corner of Anatolia or in Syrian deserts without a tombstone. They also know that many people had to convert their religions to be able to survive and sought shelter in Muslim families... Nowadays, these facts are only countered by the obdurate argument, “No one can ever dare to say that we committed genocide!” As if, the use of any other word could lessen all that happened...

“As 2015 drawing near, we witness some efforts that are made to drag Turkey to a more nationalistic ground and we are concerned about it… As long as Turks and Armenians fail to see how the third parties hypocritically exploit this issue and fail to make a collective effort to solve their problems together, we will have to live with all these concerns for a very long time. It’s inevitable.

“Turkey remembers the truths about her republican history, though very late and with strings attached. Turkey is settling her accounts with the coup d’état, massacres and the crimes committed by the state. The Ergenekon trial, the Sept. 12 trial, the Feb. 28 investigation, the inquisition of what happened in Dersim in 1938. Each and every one of those bears historic importance. Should these cases be handled in due process, they all have the potential to take the country on a brand new path. When we take a closer look to these trials and investigations to better understand their significance, we can see that all groups in Turkey -- Turks and Kurds, Muslims and Alevis -- has fallen victim to the practices of the state. Even though each group maintains its tendency to put forward its own victimization, a holistic look into politics indicates that it is the founding ideology that lies beneath the root cause of all these victimhood.

“…Without securing cognition about what happened in 1915, we may get as close to the doorsteps of the new Turkey, but we cannot get through it.”

COMMENTS
Mr. so called Adam Orman, you should use your turkish name cause it is obvious you are not an Adam, no anglosaxson would ever write such things you did. English language is one of the largest languages of written evidences and documents proving the Armenian Genocide. You know why Armenians refuse th...
Ararat Araratian
If Armenians and Turks have any evidence to prove their claims and counter-claims, they both separately or together should open a case at an internationally recognized, unbiased, independent court of law, or set up an inquiry of unbiased, honest and independent experts to put an end to this hundred-...
adam orman
All i have to say- Wake up Turkey. Remember, the lies and denials will not lead you anywhere. ONLY THE TRUTH WILL SET YOU FREE...
John K.
Sandokan you are pathetic! Open your horizon and your brain if you have some, it is our history you are not the only turk on this planet! If you feel admitting the truth is a complex that is your problem ! You are the one who has complexes and people like you are the cause for which some consider u...
Nazim
necati, your comment makes gives me pain from laughing at your puny assessment of our situation at the Diaspora. It seems you have -6 million knowledge about the Armenian Diaspora, and on the other hand speaking of glue, what is the picture of Kemal Ataturk doing in every room, class, hall and place...
Gary
And of course Mr. Cengiz, I have never before heard it put this way. It brings a new light into the importance of resolving this conflict and disagreement about the events of 1915. Thank you for your article. What we do with the past has great significance for the future. The truth does set us free....
Achon
Thank you [Mine Ozcelik Bagrationi, 25 April 2012 , 16:46] for your courage and honesty. I hope you are a telltale sign of what the future of Armenian and Turkish relations will be. Justice is important, but along with that, peace as well. Even as a second generation Armenian in America hearing my ...
Achonig
When the Armenian Genocide of 1915 took place in Western Armenian, today's Eastern Anatolia, there was no Azerbaijan. I wonder what all these Azerbaijanis or Turks disguised as Azerbaijanis are doing here posting on a topic that has nothing to do with their fictions and their fictitious country. It ...
Ararat
20% of the Turkish population of Kurds knows very well the Armenian Genocide. Another 30% of Turkish population is of mixed Armenian and Turkish blood and is the direct result of the Armenian Genocide but most are afraid to admit this publically. So 50% of the population of Turkey already knows the ...
Uncle Billy
The Westerners (and their Armenian friends) are the only ones who can tell the right version of the history. Their capability is superior to that of the Turks, who are barbarians and have no capacity in such matters. That’s what you’re telling us Mr. Cengiz. Without being aware of it, you’re spreadi...
Sandokhan
What does Mr. Cengiz have to say about the deportations of over 350,000 Azeri Turkish MAJORITY from Armenia in 1988? What does he have to say about over 45,000 Azeri Turks and over 1,000,000 refugees as a result of illegal Armenian occupation of Karabakh, Azerbaijan? ASALA terrorism? Dashnak terrori...
Ayten
"Agos" is a foreign-funded newspaper that is an enemy of Turkey tollerated by another enemy of Turkey called AKP. Agos and Armenian terrorists should instead focus on the fact that until 1955 so-called "armenia" had a MAJORITY AZERI TURKISH population until they were subject to a real genocide by R...
Ayhan
Dear Avery If you are right the Colombia and Mexico parliaments wouldn't accept the Khocali genocide so Armenia should man up and admit it.So that they will become a civilised nation. Mine Ozcelikian How did you calculate your 1.5 victims? Can you please provide a breakdown of your figure?
satrap
Dear [satrap , 25 April 2012 , 12:57] When the Government of Azerbaijan recognizes the Sumgait Genocide of Armenians, the Kirovabad Genocide of Armenians, the Baku Genocide of Armenians, the Maragha Massacre of Armenians, the War Crime Bombardment and Massacre of Stepanakert civilians, Operation Kol...
Avery
One needs pages and pages to write all the massacres and Genocides that the Turkish people have committed throughout centuries. The Armenian Genocide is unique because it started in the late 1800s (Hamidian massacres), intensified in early 1900s with the Young Turks, officially suppressed under Atat...
Uncle Billy
The so-called gen_ocide lie is used as a glue to keep 6 million ermenians scattered all over the world together to prevent being vaporized...
necati
Genocide it Was, and Genocide has continued to this day against our Armenian citizens. We need to muster some courage and accept responsibility for the deaths of 1.5 million of our Christian citizens. Thank you for All courageous and righteous Turks, who all biases aside have come forward and cried...
Mine Ozcelik Bagrationi
Until when Turkey will shoot its own feet?
VTiger
Beware of the Troll! If you've spent any time in chat rooms, bulletin boards or posting on Zaman you may have already come across one of these troublesome creatures. Often suffering from a mutant strain of compulsive posting disorder, a troll's basic mission in life is to mischievously manufacture i...
Sebouh
Gerneral sherman! Your history is all invented. First the word Genocide was created by Raphael Lemkin to define what happened to the Armenians and the jews, the one who created the juridical word of Genocide say so . Who are you to say it was not? Second, The number of the victims has nothing to do ...
Ararat Araratian
Truly speaking, The Armenians are ones who primarily massacred and wiped out all the Muslims from the territory, while at same time assisting the invading Russians to defeat the Ottoman army and liberate Constantinople. A dream that was only dashed by the brave Ottoman soldiers. Had this dream been...
Nageyec
Dear Armenians When is Armenia going to recognise the Khocali Genocide and pay reparations?
satrap
Your comments are so true my ancesters left Armenia in those horrible years. The Turksish government needs to accept and come forward for the genocide that happened to those poor people. Time to learn and move forward.
Henriette
armenian genocide claims really so absurdity. then RUSSİA admits his crimes against Cream tatars, Mesheti turks, circassians which stalin deports them from their nativelands. if you want genocide then first of all start near future look In khojaly, kharabakh occupations.
azer
Hey guys, Have you ever read this pieces about 1915 incidents by the first Prime Minister of Armenia Hovhannes Katchaznouni titled "An Armenian Manifesto Circa 1923: Dashnagtzoutiun Has Nothing to Do Anymore" Here is the link
Can Bonomo
Which Turkish PM will have the courage?
VTiger
SickSherman, the fact that others have committed atrocities and genocides doesn't alter the fact of the Armenian genocide! See if you can focus on the subject. You very much sound like an Armenian determined to discredit the Turkish nation. Shame on you!
Ilknur
Another year went by and things have not changed much in regards to Turkey’s recognition of her government’s actions in the years surrounding 1915. What is precious here is the time that is being lost. I cannot imagine a world that will last more than a century which will have people that will deny ...
Ananias
@generalsherman, for once keep quiet and listen to fellow Turks who want to build a meaningful future, and unmask the truth about this subject, instead of your blanket ignorance and racist uttering, try to learn something from your fellow honest citizens.
Qb4
Generalissimo Sherman, you are again showing you utter idiotic behavior. Do you read what you write? I do not think so because you would be laughing so hard on yourself that you would not be able to submit your writing. As for Bernard Lewis who you keep quoting continuously, he is one of those profe...
Uncle Billy
Dear Orhan, thank you for this piece. I do believe that Turks and Armenians can live side by side in peace and harmony, recognition of the Genocide will help build a solid bridge between the two nations. denial of the past will only poison the future. let us build a better world through understandi...
marty
Are we yet walking in the wilderness and no exit from it.?
yet where
As an Armenian i dream of that day when Turkey will finally look to its History as it really was and wonder about how they sacrified an important portion of the population of those blessed lands in Anatolia. To see Turks and Armenians as they were before that dammned date of 1915 that started with t...
Ararat Araratian
I'm not sure I understand the logic in making a whole country liable for unfortunate circumstances. Can we agree that crimes were committed on both sides and remember all those that have perished rather than take a one sided approach? Another hundred years will pass and no one will agree.
Aydin
Turks are the same turks (at least for Armenians... they are same as in 1915 same as today..the tragedy of our nation is that we believe that this turks are changes this is new turks and we should talk.. NO NEVER...they will do the same if there will be a chance...one thing is clear: We will get bac...
Marine
Well said! Let's not forget to thank Today's Zaman for publishing this very significant and meaningful extract. Turkey is making progress in facing up to its past -though not as fast as some of us would like! Thank you all at Today's Zaman ..... I am very grateful to you.
Baran
An insightful and deeply human analysis. Revenge and punishment have never been able to redeem any victim in the world, either at a collective or an individual level. They rather perpetuate a hellish situation. Deep historical traumas can be transcended only through sincere and unbiased dialogue,un...
anastasia
Sorry, nobody believes armenian propaganda especially considering that the proponents of it (French, Russians/Slavs, Americans, English/other Germanics, Israelis, Armenians, and Greeks)are guilty of infinitely worse genocides against the native peoples of the Americas including the Native Americans,...
GeneralSherman
Genocides are only commited by christian imperialists including the French genocide in Algeria, the US, British, French, Spanish, etc. genocide of the Native Ameicans, the British, French, Spanish, etc. genocide of the Americas as a whole including Central America, the Caribbean, and South America, ...
GeneralSherman
As long as there couragious writers who are allowed to publish articles like the above,we can after 9 decades see the light in the tunel .
Gaidzag
One of the biggest obstacles Turkey is facing today dealing with the 1915 events is the Turkish Prime Minister Erdogan. The laws he put in place and incredibly self-serving, self-righteous and delusional statements he has made over the years have made matters even worse. What can Armenians expect fr...
Ararat
I doubt that Turkish government honestly wants to investigate its past. If there is a will to do so, any act of racism should be charged as criminal act, then it will be much easier to make debates about what had happened in 1915. As long as there is no law against racism, it will not be possible to...
Armen
Orhan jan i thank you as a armenian to turkish is my first time thnking to any turkish man orhan GOD BLASSE YOU
Ara
Mr. Orhan Kemal When are you going to write a piece regarding the Khocali genocide which has been recognised by Colombia today. We also expect you to put pressure on Armenia with regards to the Khocali genocide recognition. I believe that Armenia will recognise the khocali genocide but the people in...
satrap
Well written piece by Agos and keep up the good work Mr Cengiz. We must face our role in this tragedy where an entire people were driven away from their homeland and many of them lost their lives in the process.
Baris
24April has no meaning for Turkey because it is a lie fabricated by armenian losers. IF it were real, they would look for justice at the authorised court. Lie loser=24april
necati
very well said. the recognition of the acts of 1915 as genocide separate from the incidents of World War I is good for the people of both nations.
Nayiri
I have lost all hope that Turkey or turks will see the truth as it is.. For them it is bargaining the best price for a tomato or eggplant in a Turkish bazaar. The blood of millions of Armenians is not worth the price of a single cow inside Turkey. Realistically speaking, we will stay enemies forever...
Mani
Very nice indeed; but as long as Turkey blockades Armenia and intervenes in third party issues, then all bets are off, and recognition will be sought in order to damage Turkey's standing as it damages Armenia. Respect is a pre-condition to reconciliation, and respect cannot take place without recip...
Jack Kalpakian
Turkey is not ready to confront the events of 1915. I had hoped that under the AKP party things would change enough for that history to be debated openly and honestly, but the official denial and coverup continues. I see little evidence that will change anytime soon. April 24, 2015 will soon be here...
Christoph
Click here to read all user comments
Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
18 June 2013
How did an international conspiracy manipulate Gezi Park events?
13 June 2013
Democracy at stake
11 June 2013
How Erdoğan sees all this
6 June 2013
What did prime minister's hometown tell us?
4 June 2013
Can the damage Erdoğan caused be repaired?
31 May 2013
Alevis' feeling of otherness deepens
28 May 2013
‘Satanic Verses,' Fazıl Say and Sevan Nişanyan
23 May 2013
Some citizens more equal than others
21 May 2013
Religious freedom problems in Turkey in 2012 and forever
16 May 2013
Who are the owners of places of worship in Turkey?
14 May 2013
How and why was the terrorist attack in Reyhanlı censored?
9 May 2013
The day after the PKK's withdrawal
7 May 2013
When will official reaction to 1915 change?
2 May 2013
Peace or democracy?
30 April 2013
Rumi, Buddha and remarks of Tokyo governor
25 April 2013
April 24 and Turkey's time tunnel
23 April 2013
An Armenian lady, Hrant and April 24
18 April 2013
Wise people's contribution to peace process
16 April 2013
What is wrong with Fazıl Say's punishment?
11 April 2013
How do Turkish laws produce terrorists?
9 April 2013
Truth and reconciliation commissions are necessary in Turkey
4 April 2013
What should wise people do for the peace process?
3 April 2013
Why can we not make fundamental improvements for non-Muslims?
28 March 2013
Murder of an Armenian Turkish soldier accidentally on purpose
26 March 2013
What is Turkey's roadmap for the Kurdish question?
21 March 2013
Real injustice in Ergenekon and Balyoz cases
19 March 2013
What did the Hasan Cemal case show us?
14 March 2013
Turkey, Israel and jujitsu lessons
12 March 2013
Secrecy in the investigation of attacks on Armenian women
7 March 2013
The peace process and freedom of the press
5 March 2013
Does an Armenian murderer eliminate the hate crimes presumption?
28 February 2013
Culture of lynching: dealing with hate crimes
26 February 2013
Öcalan's letters
21 February 2013
Turkey in mirror of European Court of Human Rights
19 February 2013
Victory and defeat
12 February 2013
What is wrong and right in criticisms against American ambassador
7 February 2013
Turkey's judiciary problem
5 February 2013
Hrant and Talat Pasha
31 January 2013
Genocide through the eyes of a child
29 January 2013
The Halki Theological School and the SCO
28 January 2013
‘I wish I wasn't Armenian'
22 January 2013
Why were the lawyers arrested?
17 January 2013
Is the Hrant Dink murder being resolved?
15 January 2013
Aren't the murders of Armenian women hate crimes?
10 January 2013
Atrocities in Syria committed by all sides
8 January 2013
A country of speed readers
7 January 2013
How can we achieve peace?
1 January 2013
The prime minister’s lawsuits will backfire
27 December 2012
Uludere massacre one year later
25 December 2012
Why was the commemoration for the Maraş massacre banned?
20 December 2012
How the Uludere massacre alienated Kurds from Turkey
18 December 2012
What can propaganda achieve?
13 December 2012
Praising Hrant Dink's murder
11 December 2012
Special Warfare and Christians
6 December 2012
Hrant, embarrassment, a disaster
4 December 2012
Déjà vu -- removing immunity of Kurdish MPs?
29 November 2012
Revealing too much: info belonging to Armenian groups online
28 November 2012
Turkey and Germany’s past atrocities
22 November 2012
Can Germany be a model for Turkey in confrontation with past atrocities?
20 November 2012
Hunger strikers did not die, but handicapped for life
15 November 2012
İstanbul and Constantinople
8 November 2012
Polar bears, Bedouins and poor Turkish politics
6 November 2012
Hunger strikes and a vicious circle
1 November 2012
1915: heroes and murderers
30 October 2012
The price of no criticism for the government
23 October 2012
Do not interfere with Kemalists’ mourning
18 October 2012
Armenians and a Turk in a Lebanese restaurant
16 October 2012
Restorative guilt and the Kurdish question
12 October 2012
Linking women’s stories in Turkey and Armenia
11 October 2012
1915 and terrorists on mountains
4 October 2012
The price for denial of the events of 1915
2 October 2012
How can Turkey bring an end to violence in Kurdish question
27 September 2012
Why are they so successful in seeing problematic aspects in coup cases?
20 September 2012
How Alevi victims became criminal offenders
18 September 2012
Islamophobia and hate speech in Turkey
13 September 2012
Criticizing Israel and insulting the Prophet
11 September 2012
Owen, Cemal and 1915
6 September 2012
How missionaries were linked to the PKK
4 September 2012
Will justice be served in Malatya massacre case?
30 August 2012
Campaign against violence
28 August 2012
Has the dispossessing of non-Muslims ended?
23 August 2012
Was Atatürk an Armenian?
21 August 2012
Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar!
16 August 2012
Zero tolerance for freedom of expression
14 August 2012
PKK, kidnapping and absolute impunity for the PKK
9 August 2012
Is there any ‘legal' place of worship for Alevis in Turkey?
7 August 2012
The government as an advocate of military coups
19 July 2012
The future of the deep state
17 July 2012
One basketball for all non-Muslims
12 July 2012
How was a monastery robbed in Turkey?
10 July 2012
Halki Seminary, cemevi in Parliament
3 July 2012
Who ordered the murder of Christians?
28 June 2012
From the September 1955 pogroms to a campaign against missionaries
26 June 2012
Recognizing the victimhood of the slain Christians
21 June 2012
What does the PKK really want?
19 June 2012
Prison SOS
14 June 2012
Let’s send all Kurds to prison
12 June 2012
From stone throwing children to child soldiers
7 June 2012
What do Islamist feminists say about abortion?
5 June 2012
Nationalists, muslims and the Kurdish question
...
Bloggers