Egypt is becoming Turkey
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
22 May 2013 Wednesday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 22 April 2012, Sunday 9 0 0 0
CUMALİ ÖNAL
c.onal@todayszaman.com

Egypt is becoming Turkey

The events of the past two weeks are reminiscent of the events in Turkey’s recent past.

The army and the judiciary are intervening in the country’s politics and the fault lines between liberals, conservatives and secularists are growing deeper. They cannot agree on what should be drafted into a new constitution. It is unknown whether the parliamentary system or semi-presidential system will be preferred. The economy has hit rock-bottom. All fields from health to education and from tourism to culture are being threatened with this imminent economic crisis.

Egypt is facing the same problems, only more dangerous, that Turkey has been struggling with for many years and is only now taking steps towards resolving.

In order to deal with these problems Egypt needs a Turgut Özal or a Recep Tayyip Erdoğan. In the 1980s Özal introduced Turkey to the ways of achievement and following this path, in the 2000s Erdoğan took important steps towards resuscitating a shrinking economy and cementing political stability in Turkey.

The common features of both leaders are that they are both pious, charismatic and have the typological profile of “man of the people.” They embraced all groups within society and did not exclude anyone. Their attitudes weren’t based on their prejudices. They didn’t commit to the West or the East by conducting a one-dimensional foreign policy. They didn’t chase utopias. Improvement of the country was the core object of their program.

Egypt urgently needs such a leader who bears these characteristics. Is there such a leader bearing these qualities among the existing candidates? It is really hard to answer this question. What we do know is that the country needs a leader with a particular profile who can lead his government and gain the confidence of the people.

This leader has a very specific set of attributes. First of all, he needs to be from a religious background but not use religion as a reference in his discourse. He needs to try to keep an equal distance from all groups and not scare anyone. He must also not be from among the politicians of the old generation. He must have spent all his life in a political struggle. He must have been exposed to the oppression of the regime for years, but held his ground. He must use cautious language in his economic discourse. He must not have a reactionary attitude toward sensitive issues such as banking, interest, commercial relations with the West and tourism. He must try to take the existing balances (constituents) in the country into consideration and not take anyone on. In international affairs he must persistently avoid discourse that may drag the country into problems.

It is already clear who this person is.

For Egypt to overcome the deadlock it is facing, it should try to get through the constitution-drafting process and presidential elections without causing a bigger crisis. In the end, the ruling powers should consider the interests of the country superior to their interests. No doubt the efforts of the army, which directly intervened in the constitution-drafting process and in determining the presidential candidates, to keep its power will severely harm the country.

When Turkey began to limit the power of the army, the country began to make economic, political and diplomatic progress. For years the Turkish Army introduced itself as the ultimate guardian of stability and solidarity in the country. It moved under the assumption that Turkey would be ruined if it took a back seat. Now we are witnessing the Egyptian army’s attempt at spreading the same type of idea.

The intervention of the Egyptian army, whose main responsibility is to defend the country, in politics will always cause deep rifts among the public. It should avoid political intervention. Similarly, the Muslim Brotherhood should also act sensibly. As seen in the process of assigning the 100 members to the Constituent Assembly who will draft the constitution, the Muslim Brotherhood should keep in mind all constituents within the country. Or else unnecessary tension occurs in the country. In a country where the majority of people have not yet voted or cannot fully appreciate the value of the ballot box, the Muslim Brotherhood should be aware of the extent to which gained votes reflect democracy.

Undoubtedly, the biggest danger awaiting the leaders who will govern Egypt is the economic problem. Egypt’s current situation is like or may even be worse than the situation of Turkey during its 2001 economic crisis.

The majority of the people are very poor, and can’t survive without subsidies from the state. Exports and investments are too low for a giant country with a population of 90 million. Healthcare and educational services are about to cease. Municipalities are on the verge of bankruptcy. The amount of a retirement pension is almost the same as the cost of a rich person’s meal, and the same can be said about workers’ wages.

In short, any government that will assume the duty of ruling the country will lie on a bed of nails. And for this government to be successful, political tensions should end as soon as possible.

COMMENTS
Friends of Turks, The Egyptian military has consistently fired live ammunition on their own people. They own up to 10% of the Egyptian economy. Does the Turkish military attack Turkish civilians? No. AKP took over military hierarchy without a SINGLE incident of violence. How do you have the nerve...
semsi
To Cristoph: As much as I would hope Egypt, Iraq and Syria are becoming like Iran, (the most succesful anti-imperialist state on earth), I think the opposite is true. Unfortunately, they will most probably become puppet states serving western imperialism.
Özcan
Egypt is in a much worse position than Turkey in 2001, not least because its political culture is emerging from six decades of authoritarian rule and its religious culture - both Muslim and Christian - is increasingly shaped by fundamentalism (rather than Sufism), which hardly encourages stability. ...
Zlatan
Around 40% of the population is not able to read and write. Their situation is way way worse than Turkey's 10 years ago. And they will not have the support of EU like Turkey has had for the last 10 years, which has been the engine of the reforms. So I can not see how the the two countries can be com...
Not similar
Egypt is going through a really hard and confusing time. I hope that SCAF is not orchestrating events. I worry most about the working man, he just wants to make a living. If they can get through this process, I think they will be alright, but it is going to be a really long journey,
Sue Coon
Egypt becoming a Turky , and Turky becoming a chicken ,no that is miracle..
Kurdo
Egypt is becoming Iran, as is Iraq and soon...Syria.
Christoph
Turkey may have faced difficulties but the situation in Egypt is entirely different. Turkish people by nature are extremely hardworking, patriotic and devoted to certain goals. In Egypt almost fifty percent of the population is sufi oriented.They prefer to meditate rather than work. Even the skilled...
Ahmed m Ibrahim
Turkey was in a MUCH worse position in 2001 than Egypt is today. There was a huge earthquake in 1999, the finances collapsed completely in 2001, 60 years of Secularist rule had divided the country along ethnic and religious lines, there was widespread torture, corruption, daily disappearances, assas...
Friend of Turks
Click here to read all user comments
Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
19 May 2013
Why is Turkey not getting involved in Syria?
12 May 2013
What is Israel pursuing in Syria?
5 May 2013
When a terrorist becomes seen as a freedom fighter
28 April 2013
Can Turkey solve the Palestinian problem?
21 April 2013
Why would Turkey pursue a policy harmful to Egypt?
14 April 2013
Egypt on Turkey’s path
7 April 2013
Should Egypt fear Iran?
31 March 2013
Why did Israel apologize to Turkey?
24 March 2013
Streets no solution in Egypt
17 March 2013
If Muslim Brotherhood nominates liberals in parliamentary elections
10 March 2013
Could a military coup be on the horizon for Egypt?
3 March 2013
How will Egypt get out of this crisis?
17 February 2013
An Islamic Nations Security Council
10 February 2013
Has al-Qaeda been defeated in Mali?
20 January 2013
Why are Russia, Iran and China silent on Mali?
13 January 2013
New Egypt means new opportunity for Palestine
6 January 2013
Now is the real test for Morsi
30 December 2012
Does Turkey belong to Europe or the Middle East?
23 December 2012
Egyptian opposition, Turkish opposition
16 December 2012
How to read historic referendum in Egypt?
9 December 2012
Are you a supporter or opponent of Morsi?
2 December 2012
The greatest risk for Egypt: polarization
25 November 2012
Israel’s art of killing
18 November 2012
Israel likes hazy weather
11 November 2012
New closing hours for shops to change Egyptian lifestyle
4 November 2012
Qatari Emir’s Gaza show
14 October 2012
A search for alternatives to the Muslim Brotherhood
30 September 2012
Morsi and the AK Party experience
23 September 2012
Can Turkey and Egypt rebuild the Middle East?
16 September 2012
Hidden messages in the events in Libya
9 September 2012
Is Turkey losing its influence in the Middle East?
2 September 2012
Iran is trying to seduce Egypt
26 August 2012
Will Israel pursue same policy in Syria as Ethiopia’s in Somalia?
19 August 2012
Good things happen in the Middle East, too
12 August 2012
Sinai Peninsula a great test for Mursi
5 August 2012
Why do Arabs remain silent on the Kurdish issue?
29 July 2012
Does the Arab community admire Iran?
22 July 2012
Turkey: tired of high-pitched foreign policy
15 July 2012
What will Morsi do about Syria?
8 July 2012
Why should Mursi make his first visit one to Turkey?
1 July 2012
Why are the West and Israel afraid of Morsi?
24 June 2012
Egypt’s doubters
17 June 2012
Erdoğan 2002, Mursi 2012
10 June 2012
Does the Erdoğan government want Mursi to win?
3 June 2012
Egyptian voters made the most challenging choice
27 May 2012
Critical months for Egypt
20 May 2012
Is Amr Moussa really the favorite presidential candidate?
13 May 2012
Economy key for AK Party’s success, but what about for Egyptian leaders?
6 May 2012
Is Egypt aware of the danger?
29 April 2012
Egypt and the example of Turkey (1)
22 April 2012
Egypt is becoming Turkey
15 April 2012
A bitter lesson for the Muslim Brotherhood
8 April 2012
Is Khairat al-Shater Egypt’s Erdoğan?
1 April 2012
Muslim Brotherhood should seek consensus
25 March 2012
If those dealing with the crisis aren’t sincere…
18 March 2012
By launching rockets, Palestinians fall into Israel’s trap
11 March 2012
Critical three months for transition to democracy in Egypt
4 March 2012
If Syria becomes like Libya, the ME region will be singed
19 February 2012
Qatar: Impossible to understand
12 February 2012
US, Israel will not attack Iran
5 February 2012
Will the people of Egypt become divided like the people of Turkey?
29 January 2012
Will Egypt be able to achieve what Turkey achieved in 2002?
22 January 2012
The greatest danger facing Egypt: Economic crisis
15 January 2012
Leader wanted for Middle East, now!
8 January 2012
What will the West do about the Muslim Brotherhood now?
1 January 2012
Is Assad any different from Gaddafi or Mubarak?
25 December 2011
What will the Middle East be like in the next 10 years?
18 December 2011
Christians accepted in Egypt
11 December 2011
Why the insistence on calling the Arab Spring the Arab Fall?
4 December 2011
Is Turkey running out of steam in the Middle East?
27 November 2011
Egypt is going to the polls on a knife’s edge
20 November 2011
Is Turkish military source of inspiration for Egyptian army?
13 November 2011
Will the Syrian crisis be able to awaken sleeping giant Arab Union?
6 November 2011
Muslim Brotherhood did not understand Erdoğan’s message on secularism
...