|  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
May 26, 2012
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 20 February 2012, Monday 23 0 2 0
MÜMTAZER TÜRKÖNE
m.turkone@todayszaman.com

Mother tongue

Today is International Mother Language Day. For 12 years, people have been marking Feb. 21 as a day to promote linguistic and cultural diversity. The purpose is to raise awareness that there are communities with diverse mother tongues living in countries across the world and that these communities have rights concerning their native languages. This day is particularly meaningful for Turkey.

Turkey’s main political problem is the Kurdish issue as it affects every area ranging from daily politics to the country’s regional relations. For instance, the most recent state crisis, which lasted two weeks, was based on disputes concerning the Kurdish issue. The Kurdish issue is the mother of many other problems, and the Kurdish issue itself is a Kurdish language issue. In other words, today, i.e., International Mother Language Day, is particularly important for Turkey.

The mother tongue of Kurds living in Turkey falls into the Indo-Iranian language group. While the Sorani language is spoken widely in northern Iraq and western Iran, Kurds in Turkey predominantly speak Kurmanji with a much smaller number speaking Zazaki. Except for their mother tongue, Kurds and Turks have intermingled both culturally and historically. Kurds and Turks are loyal to Sunni Islam and nomadic values that date back to thousands of years ago. They lived together without any problem in the same country for 50 years. The only difference between them is their mother tongues. This difference was not a serious problem until the establishment of the republic, more specifically until the coup generals of the Sept. 12, 1980 coup passed, as a parting shot, a bill to ban the use of Kurdish language.

The republic, established in 1923, tried to assimilate Kurds into the nation-state of Turkey. Language was the sole tool that could be used for assimilation. The Turkish language was supported while the Kurdish language was discouraged, and on Nov. 6, 1983, the coup generals passed a bill to ban it altogether. This bill defined the use of the Kurdish language in all sorts of public communication as a crime. The Kurdistan Workers’ Party’s (PKK) started to launch terrorist attacks in 1984 citing this law as a reason. The ban on the Kurdish language became the central theme of the Kurdish issue. The Kurdish armed rebellion sought popular support against this ban and it was considerably successful. Although the said law was abolished eight years after it was passed, the Kurdish issue had fed on the Kurdish language ban and became politicized.

The state launching a Kurdish language TV channel called TRT 6 in early 2009 was a turning point in the mother tongue issue. Although the ban on the Kurdish language continued in many areas, the official state TV channel’s broadcasts in Kurdish brought about big change. The use of the Kurdish issue became acceptable. The public authorities started allowing Kurds to give Kurdish names to their children. Restoring the names of geographical locations to their original Kurdish designations came to be accepted as normal. There was no problem related to the use of the Kurdish language. Yet, using Kurdish in education is still one of the hottest debates in politics and represents a major cleavage.

One of the most biting debates in the process of drafting a new constitution is the position of Kurdish with respect to Turkish as an official language. The most effective cure to this problem is to accept Kurdish being used in education. The new constitution should ensure this or at least should not impose any ban on this matter. The problem concerning education in Kurdish can be solved with a bilingual education model as is the case elsewhere around the world. However, except for the pro-Kurdish Peace and Democracy Party (BDP), no one is warm to this solution and this applies even to the ruling Justice and Development Party (AK Party). Education in the Kurdish language is a red line for many parties.

A prominent AK Party politician Bülent Arınç said the Kurdish language is not a language of a civilization, which was interpreted as the AK Party’s stance on education in the Kurdish language. What would happen if constitutional guarantees were introduced for the right to education in Kurdish? There would probably not be serious demand for being taught in Kurdish, but it would certainly solve the problem. Kurdish is undoubtedly a language of a civilization, but it is not a language of economy.

Today is International Mother Language Day. Turkey continues to suffer from its most significant problem without being aware of this day.

COMMENTS
@necati: I guess now you're getting it. I am not surprised by your reactions; a person who is raised with (quite possibly) lies and propaganda. If you have access, you might also want to check Herodotus, I didn't read his writings myself but I know that he mentions kurdish people.
liberalist
First of all, The "kurdish" ethnic group and kurdish nationalism are a recent invention. Read Christopher Dickey's "bordering on insanity". The "Kurds" in Turkey, Iraq, Syria, and Iran are all genetically dissimiliar and liguistically incoherent. The reality is that they are iranic offshouts who hav...
necati
i cant believe these kurds trying to make a history in internet. here is my source : "Though some Kurdish intellectuals claim that their people are descended from the Medes, there is no evidence to permit such a connection across the considerable gap in time between the political dominance of the ...
necati
@GeneralSherman, i did study linguistics and what I have written so far about languages is based upon the knowledge I got from the linguistics courses. As for your point of Europeanness, can you show me a sentence that shows I linked the idea of Europeanness with language or race. I am not professi...
semira
@generalsherman: Kurds are known to belong to aryan race not Semitic. But they were under heavy influence of Assyriac culture, which occupied todays southeastern Anatolia and then collided with Armenian culture 1000s of years before. Assyriac, Armenian and Kurdish people had preserved their culture ...
liberalist
Hulya, I am responding to your comment. I think you misunderstood the writer. The writer said Kurdish is not the language of economy, which is a fact. This is not say Kurdish does not have potential to be the language of economy. I am for the promotion of Kurdish language. Why can't we be like Switz...
Fatima Gulen
semira, of course, kurdish is part of the Indo-Iranian language family. That is a subgroup of your so-called "Indo-European" language family. It is important to make such distinctions. Because, for example, it means that kurdish is far closer to Hindi or East Bengali than English or other Europea...
GeneralSherman
Peter Lodenius, then you also have no idea what you're talking about. The "kurds" in Turkiye, iraq, syria, and iran are all genetically dissimiliar and liguistically incoherent. The reality is that they are iranic offshouts from india who have always lived on other people's land. Even then the kurd...
GeneralSherman
sacmali yabanci, the name of the country is Turkiye. Get that through your thick skull. It's not "kurdia".
GeneralSherman
@necati: You have no idea on what you are talking about. As an example, just check out Medes empire from google or wikipedia. You'll see how old and rich Kurdish culture is...
liberalist
I always remember Turkish politicians have tried to relate Kurdish problem in the eastern part of Turkey with economy. Now, we are told that Kurdish is not a language of economy. Then, somebody comes and plans to build a reservoir in replacement of Hasankeyf as we also have been told we have hardshi...
semira
just a reminder, i guess you probably forgot, Mr Turkone. Kurdish is not a part of Indo-Iranian language group as there is not any such language group. Kurdish is part of Indo-European language family/group. Kurdish is a close language relative of Persian, and distant one of English or other Europea...
semira
i would like to ask a simple question. "Can Turkish people in Germany have an education in goverment schools via their mother tongue or are they learning German??" For the people who have never ever been in Turkey, it is easy to say their superstition. In Turkey, when you applied to open an ethnic...
Emre
"The only difference between [Turks and Kurds]is their mother tongues." This statement reveals the writer's complete and utter lack of knowledge of the huge cultural and social differences between the two peoples. The Turkish personality, aspirations, interests, motivations, I could go on,is about a...
Azad
I stronggly support my Finland-Swedish compatriot Carl. Education in your own language is a basic requirement for good citizenship.
Peter Lodenius
Mr Editor please publish this comment for sake of objectivity and freedom of speech: "Only if Turkish politicians read about Kurdish history then they will not utter such racist none-sense. The Kurds had built civilizations and contributed innumerably in many ways. Kurdish is older than Turkish. The...
David Palch
Mr Turkone, Do you speak Kurdish? OR What do you know about Kurdish language?..How can you say Kurdish is not a language of a economy? What do you base your arguement on while saying it is not a language of economy? As far as we know Kurdish history dates back at least to 3000 AD..No one can say th...
Hülya Erdemli
As a Swedish-speaking Finn, i.e. a native of Finland speaking Swedish as his mother tongue, I strongly support the right of Kurds and other minorities in Turkey to be educated in their mother tongue. This is an identity constituent and thus a basic key to effective learning and citizenship. I and my...
Carl
English Domination The internationalization of the Internet should not be surprising, considering that 92% of the world’s population speaks a primary language other than English. As technology enables more and more people to connect with each other, so must the policies about the platforms for comm...
Banish English
Sheer nonsense and baseless claims blended with a tad of logic and reason! "They lived together without any problems ..... for 50 years." So, the Dersim massacre wasn't a problem?! The only difference is their language? Really? How about religion? Yezidi, Alevi and Christian Kurds don't count, do ...
Baran
Kurds were never able to set up a civilisation , always lived under the control of other nations. So Bülent Arınç is right.
necati
Yes you are right. We may as well be living on another planet.... kemalia?
tehlikeli yabanci
If only Mister Bulent Arench ( Bulend a Kurdish word means loft) New Kurdish, he would change his name to Yuksek Arench ,Abu Jahhal( father of ignorant) was Muhamed peace be on him, arch enemy, In turkey we keep bumping in one Abu Jahel after another ,what a luck.. If Kurdish not a language of C...
Esfandyar
Click here to read all user comments
Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
20 February 2012
Mother tongue
19 February 2012
Who holds power?
13 February 2012
Special authority
12 February 2012
The Kurdish issue has divided the state
6 February 2012
Can negotiations with Öcalan be resumed?
5 February 2012
CHP will be divided into two parts
29 January 2012
Anti-militarization
23 January 2012
Who is directing Turkey?
22 January 2012
Hrant Dink 5 years later
16 January 2012
May 19 celebrations
Weather
City>>
ISTANBUL
Today Sun Mon
14C°
21C°
15C°
23C°
16C°
24C°