|  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
May 26, 2012
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 12 February 2012, Sunday 9 0 4 0
GÖKHAN BACIK
g.bacik@todayszaman.com

Partition of Syria among the Great Powers: The solution?

The Syrian crisis is now in deadlock, with little hope of a solution. This deadlock is not only an aspect of the inner struggles of Syrian domestic politics.

Rather, it is the Great Powers -- the US, Russia and China -- and two regional powers, Turkey and Iran, that find themselves unable to agree on a joint agenda for resolving the Syrian situation. The Syrian crisis is more than just a bloody struggle between the Assad regime and the opposition. Therefore, the defusing of the crisis entails the need for compromise between the Great Powers.

History has seen many similar stalemates between the Great Powers, which have prolonged national impasses. It is habitual in world politics that some lands become the hub of the Great Powers' competing interests. As they rarely want to go to war against one another over much smaller states, the Great Powers prefer to establish their zones of influence on these territories. For instance, Poland was in this situation in the late 18th century because of the conflicting interests it represented for Russia and Prussia. In another famous example, the Anglo-Russian Agreement of 1907 created zones of influence in Iran: A Russian zone, a British zone and a neutral zone. Of course, the most ambitious example is the post-World War II partitioning of Europe by the Great Powers at Yalta. Partition here does not necessarily mean the physical partitioning of a state; mostly, it takes the form of the creation of various zones of influence of the Great Powers.

The Syrian case is a typical example of a struggle between the Great Powers to secure their own interests in a territory. The Russians and Iranians are themselves not happy about the horrendous acts taking place under Assad, but their own interests in Syria force them to stand with the regime. Thus, so long as they are persuaded that their interests are secure, reminding them of the humanitarian tragedy unfolding in the cities of Syria will not be sufficient to do the job of halting it. This is a sad but familiar phenomenon in world politics. Thus, to set progress in motion, the international community must first persuade Russia, China and Iran that action is necessary. This can best be achieved by guaranteeing their long-term interests in Syria. In other words, those countries should be given concrete guarantees that a regime change in Syria will not mean the total loss of their established interests there. Both Moscow and Tehran should be persuaded to believe that they will retain their interests in the region, even if the present regime in Damascus is overthrown. Today, both Iran and Russia are of the firm view that regime change will be detrimental to their interests in the Middle East.

The terminology of competition between the Great Powers is not sympathetic. However, the killing of innocent people, including children, obliges the international community to revisit all sorts of potential solutions and strategies. If it is not possible to move forward without the consent of Russia and China, the critical mission should be to persuade them. The international community, represented by an international conference on Syria, can easily offer China and Russia guarantees for the preservation of their long term interests in Syria. Meanwhile, regional countries like Turkey can play a serious role with regard to Iran's position in this process.

COMMENTS
Avery, I don’t blame you, it is a very complicated issue. Even the experts cannot predict how the events in the ME will fan out and how the Kurds will fare in all of this. Kurds are split between 4 countries and are/were oppressed in every single one of them. There is a tendency to believe, as you d...
Baris
Partitioning countries is not a solution- its a weakness in secular ideological logic. Incidently, why didn't America partition during its civil war- it would have saved 100s of 1000s of lives? It didnt partition because foreign powers avoided taking sides, allowing the federal govt to eventu...
abu kamel
Always been a supporter of peaceful resolution of Syrian or Bahraini crises. Having read what you wrote and what is out there on TV channels on either side of the divide, we are all talking in thin air. Persuading Iran, China and Russia which has its only military base in region, are nearly impossib...
Naveed Ahmad
[Baris] You are correct. My understanding of Kurds is limited. However, recently Kurdish MPs, presumably elected by Kurds, are openly stating that self rule is no longer sufficient: they want independence. Given the history of violent suppression of Kurds by the Turkish State up until recently, it i...
Avery
Avery, I think your understanding of the Kurds of Turkey is rather limited. You'll find that it is the PKK which has been figting Turkey, not the Kurds. There is a difference. Most of the Kurds in Turkey do not support the PKK, they are willing to remain as citizens of Turkey. This is easily seen by...
Baris
[Sherman]your wonky turkish perspective makes it impossible for you to understand anything, basic or slightly, just slightly, above basic. Your Denialist bot software mass populating posts under every article is ignored by super majority: human beings learn very quickly to recognize and ignore jun...
Avery
Avery, your wonky armenian perspective makes it impossible for you to understand a few basic things. 1. "partition Turkiye"? What are you japing about you armenian monkey? I have a better idea, let's partition armenia among Turkiye, Iran, Azerbaycan, and Georgia. It's more historically accurate...
GeneralSherman
Well, if the solution is to partition Syria, why not also Turkey ? Kurds have been fighting the Turkish State for what 30 years ? And how many people have been killed ? 30-40 thousand ? If Turkey did not give sanctuary to the so called Free Syrian Army, it would be gone in a few weeks. It has sustai...
Avery
At least the Arab League has acted more influential compared with the OIC.
Rowan
Click here to read all user comments
Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
12 February 2012
Partition of Syria among the Great Powers: The solution?
5 February 2012
Iran's suicide
29 January 2012
Turkey and Iran: Neither enemies nor friends
22 January 2012
Maliki against Turkey
15 January 2012
The US and Turkish democracy
8 January 2012
Is the Sunni-Shiite split a myth?
1 January 2012
Turkey's limits
25 December 2011
Turkey and France: Hitting true and false notes
18 December 2011
Turkey and the Shiite Muslims
11 December 2011
Turkey reads the EU incorrectly
Weather
City>>
ISTANBUL
Today Sun Mon
14C°
21C°
15C°
23C°
16C°
24C°