Is this why you remain silent?
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
18 June 2013 Tuesday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 05 February 2012, Sunday 6 0 0 0
EKREM DUMANLI
e.dumanli@todayszaman.com

Is this why you remain silent?

It is said about 17,000 unsolved murders were committed during the 1990s. For many years, the Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK) has been creating propaganda out of these murders.

It has argued over the years and told the Kurdish youth that groups or individuals acting on behalf of the state had committed brutal murders in the region. This propaganda had remained influential up until the decision by the state to reopen the files on the unsolved murders. The rule of law was observed, and prosecutors in Diyarbakır started reviewing the cold cases, most of which have not been investigated for years. All unsolved murders were included in the review process. Complainants petitioned the courts. People implicated in these murders started to answer before the law. For instance, Col. Cemal Temizöz, whose name most frequently pops up in the discussion on the unsolved murders, was removed from office; he is now being tried as a suspect. He still remains in custody.

Eyewitnesses, informants, state officials, the relatives of the victims of unsolved murders… Everyone is now telling what they know about these murders. It should be noted, however, that some of the eyewitnesses have withdrawn their previous statements, but the justice mechanism is still operating. In conjunction with the statements, excavations were started; bodies were exhumed.

Amid all these developments, the circles close to the PKK, which has focused on the unsolved murders for so many years, chose to remain silent during this process. The pro-PKK political party [Peace and Democracy Party (BDP)], which uses every opportunity to put on a media show in support of the terrorist group, did not even budge to interfere in the proceedings of this case. Aside from a few symbolic statements, the supporters of the terrorist organization did not make any substantial moves regarding the process.

Based on this general outlook, I drew the conclusion that the supporters of the PKK were not sincere in their actions. Turns out I was wrong. They were actually considering one aspect of the issue that none of us recalled, and this is why they were staying silent. It became evident that not all of these 17,000 unsolved murders were committed by individuals who argued they were acting on behalf of the state. How am I drawing this conclusion? It is quite simple.

According to a recent report published in the press, the prosecutors who were investigating the unsolved murders concluded that some of these heinous crimes were committed by the PKK. The judicial authorities, who held that nearly 8,000 murders were committed by this organization, are reviewing all the cases. The files actually reveal strong evidence of and information on the members of the organization who were executed because they were trying to escape, the militants who were declared agents of the state and others who were killed just because they were observing their religious duties and practices. And these arguments are not based on some suspicions. The judiciary, which reviewed all of the evidence and allegations, has acquired concrete and reliable evidence and accounts of eyewitnesses.

In fact, the execution of undesirable militants within the PKK was no secret at all. This practice has been known of for years. For instance, the PKK murdered Hikmet Fidan, former deputy chair of the People's Democracy Party (HADEP), to send a message. Even very close friends of his did not attend his funeral. Leyla Zana and Orhan Doğan, who paid a visit to his relatives to offer their condolences, refrained from condemning the murder. Kurdish intellectual Orhan Miroğlu, provides a sufficient amount of evidence of how the PKK put pressure upon the people of the region. And in fact, the people did understand the silence of the Kurds. All were aware that the PKK, relying on Stalinist methods and measures, was acting brutally against the people of the region. And there was no visible actor or power that proved to have the ability to address the PKK's brutality.

Now, this is changing; the state is identifying the suspects within the state and taking them to the courts. The state officials of the time are now being held accountable for what they did in the 1990s. Something new has emerged during this process: The murders committed within the PKK are also being investigated. This means that those who remained silent during the probe into unsolved murders in the region knew they would be put on the line in the future as well. What does the execution of 8,000 militants mean? Is there any more brutal organization in the world? Is it possible to believe that such an organization would bring and promote democracy, peace and freedom?

The Quran puts this eloquently: He who kills one man kills all men. Regardless of whether or not the murders were committed on behalf of the state or the PKK, prosecution of the unsolved murders, identification of the suspects, conviction of the culprits and proper legal action would renew confidence and trust in justice; and this will also offer some condolence to the relatives of the victims. The brotherhood of peoples could be realized by such an action; and only in this way could lasting peace be achieved; only in this way could a democratic and free future be attained.

COMMENTS
So, it's now 2 mln? Where do you pull your figures from?
S
Dario First of all, its not 2 million, its not evene 1 million and last thing, we didnt even do genocide. And as long you don´t have evidence that türks killed Armenians, then shut up please.
kadir
dario, did you ever wonder what role the Kurds played in the Armenian massacres?
Baris
I wouldn't for a second accept that the past turkish regimes not have tried with every consievable force and terror to silent kurdish people, idnetity and eradical kurdish culture; that said PKK was created as a communist party and a communist party have no nationality which is why some of the found...
bingo
Let me start and say well done on your article. There is no doubt that some of the crimes were committed by The PKK. However, you are over exaggerating. You should start from the beginning and ask why kurds have carried arms . You should tell me why my father and I were thrown out from the offic...
No Kurdish name ? he should a turkish name
how about the 2 million armenians that Turks killed?
dario
Click here to read all user comments
Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
16 June 2013
The key to security and peace
9 June 2013
Fuel-flame equation
3 June 2013
Show some prudence, please!
26 May 2013
Either brotherhood or backbiting
19 May 2013
How can Turkey become a global power?
17 May 2013
How will Obama-Erdoğan talks affect Syria?
12 May 2013
Go tell your father
5 May 2013
Who will undermine the settlement process?
28 April 2013
The lousy media, again!
21 April 2013
Hatred of mosques and prep schools
7 April 2013
For the sake of a cat
31 March 2013
What is this harshness for?
24 March 2013
Danger bells
10 March 2013
Support for the process along with aphorisms
3 March 2013
Was this what you called the language of peace?
28 February 2013
A deep operation
24 February 2013
Have you ever seen a regretful junta member?
17 February 2013
Some decency please!
10 February 2013
Well, why are you pushing that much?
3 February 2013
Dancing in the claws of terrorism
27 January 2013
Spy
20 January 2013
On death
13 January 2013
Finding a solution through a minefield
30 December 2012
Hey guys, take it easy
23 December 2012
It is not possible to live with so many questions
16 December 2012
By denying Ergenekon, media becomes irrelevant
9 December 2012
For a freer Turkey
2 December 2012
Grief or patience?
25 November 2012
Choosing a coup among the coups
18 November 2012
Are you Gandhi or Stalin?
11 November 2012
Toward conscientious journalism
21 October 2012
Heterodox perspective on negotiations with PKK
14 October 2012
The ‘X day' coup perpetrators were waiting for
7 October 2012
To fight or to quarrel?
30 September 2012
End of political administrations
23 September 2012
Was it necessary?
16 September 2012
Global operation
9 September 2012
Terror news, censorship and the government
2 September 2012
To wage a total war against terror
26 August 2012
This time you are caught red-handed, matryoshka
12 August 2012
'Something you can never forget'
5 August 2012
You will not be able to satisfy your desires
22 July 2012
Between frenzy and paradise
15 July 2012
Our downed jet and communication mishaps
8 July 2012
Getting it when you lose
1 July 2012
The unbearable burden of being in the same boat
17 June 2012
New era that started in Arena
10 June 2012
It is not about Article 250, it is all about egalitarian democracy
3 June 2012
Those who avoid applause!
27 May 2012
When a call for fairness and reason finds acceptance
20 May 2012
Virtual madness
13 May 2012
Danger on the horizon
6 May 2012
Who fired the first shot?
29 April 2012
Violence
22 April 2012
Look at what International Herald Tribune is doing
15 April 2012
The Turkey abroad that I (we) admire
8 April 2012
Four military officers I knew in the coup
1 April 2012
Syria-Iran, a hard trial
25 March 2012
Slippers!
18 March 2012
Why are you avoiding the Gladio prosecutor?
11 March 2012
Hard to tell, but it is true
4 March 2012
To be able to confront coups
19 February 2012
Society, not community!
12 February 2012
Beware!
5 February 2012
Is this why you remain silent?
29 January 2012
The time has come
22 January 2012
Can one be pro-Dink and pro-Ergenekon at the same time?
15 January 2012
They failed again
8 January 2012
To be held accountable
1 January 2012
Never in the new year!
25 December 2011
Bells are ringing for Europe
18 December 2011
Militant
11 December 2011
God forbid!
4 December 2011
Global Ergenekon
27 November 2011
Surviving the Dersim discussion
20 November 2011
Codes of Dersim
13 November 2011
Kurdish insurgency
23 October 2011
The end of outlawed PKK will be like that of Gaddafi
16 October 2011
Are your artistic horizons so restricted?
2 October 2011
End of the road approaching
18 September 2011
For Turkey to do well in the Middle East
11 September 2011
The end of an empire built on fear
4 September 2011
Traffic fatalities soured the Eid
14 August 2011
Do not disrupt our peace
7 August 2011
Suffering for Muslims on the horizon
31 July 2011
The new era in civilian-military relations
24 July 2011
The price of being spoiled
17 July 2011
What the murderers of soldiers want?
10 July 2011
Turkey's test with football
3 July 2011
Damage control after elections
26 June 2011
Knowingly hitting a wall
19 June 2011
One language equals 7 bln people
12 June 2011
A new page
5 June 2011
Nothing will remain confidential
29 May 2011
Still much to be done
22 May 2011
How do the media’s genes transform?
15 May 2011
Those who want to sabotage the elections
8 May 2011
Time to counter global lies
1 May 2011
Politics in the barracks
25 April 2011
A lesson for everyone before history
...
Bloggers