Syria is stuck
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
21 May 2013 Tuesday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 15 November 2011, Tuesday 0 0 0 0
BERİL DEDEOĞLU
b.dedeoglu@todayszaman.com

Syria is stuck

The balance (or imbalance) between the Sunni and Shiite populations in Syria once helped to consolidate existing regimes all over the Middle East.

Syria’s regime was also a factor demonstrating which country in the region was cooperating with which great power. When Iran was a close ally of the West, Syria was supported by the Eastern Bloc. In those times, Iran, Iraq, Turkey, Lebanon and Israel were all in the same camp. Then, Iran abandoned its Western allies and a bloody process ensued to re-establish the balance. In those years, the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) came into existence, Israel’s relations with Syria deteriorated, civil war in Lebanon intensified, and Iraq suffered a great deal and was literally occupied in the end.

Today, we have witnessed the long-term consequences of what took place decades ago. However, today’s world is quite different from back then and it is harder to force people to live under a regime they dislike. Moreover, today’s alliances are multifaceted. For example, Turkey is an ally with the West, but it is closer to Barack Obama’s US as it struggles with the France-Germany-Great Britain axis and tries to be on good terms with Russia. Israel opposes Obama’s policies and is actually serving Russia’s interests. Iran is trying to assure Russia’s partnership, not by using its antagonism with the US but via friendship with China. Many European countries are attempting to forge their own alliances and some of them are doing everything to win Russia’s.

Because of this complex configuration, it’s not surprising that the Syrian regime is breaking apart. It has had to decide whether or not it accepts the new parameters of foreign relations. In order to facilitate this decision, Turkey advised Syria to cut its ties with Iran. This would also allow Russia and the US to reinforce their cooperation in the region. However, Iran made a counter-proposal to the Syrian leadership: Stay close to Tehran and benefit from the Iran-Russia alliance. The problem is that the Syrian people have accepted Turkey’s proposal while the Syrian regime has opted for Iran’s offer.

Meanwhile, Europe has failed to pull Syria toward the international system, and Russia has preferred to negotiate directly with the West rather than sending its messages through Syria and Iran. The tension between Israel and Iran has surpassed the problems between Syria and Israel, and Turkey’s relations with Syria and Israel have simultaneously deteriorated. All this happened while the US was mounting pressure on Iran. In this context, Syria made a big mistake and tried to play the new game with old rules.

Syria had two choices: either to implement comprehensive political reform, in other words, to put an end to minority rule -- a choice that would mean a regime change, or to resist and try to convince third actors that this resistance is what is good for the region. Here again, the people and the rulers of Syria have made conflicting choices.

Syria’s leaders have chosen to liquidate the opposition and label their actions as terrorism. It has also chosen to intensify its cooperation with Iran and its sponsors. The only way to pull Syria out of this vicious circle was to support a regime change and this is the main reason why Turkey is now supporting the opponents. The regime change in Damascus is also good news for the “doves” in Israel, because Syria’s normalization may provide some security at one of Israel’s borders at least.

The Arab League’s recent decision to suspend Syria’s membership is an important step toward pushing Damascus to reconsider its choices. The Syrian leadership is lonelier than ever and the way is now wide open for all kinds of international interventions.

Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
17 May 2013
A trial in Germany
14 May 2013
The Reyhanlı attack and Europe
10 May 2013
Sounds from Turkey
7 May 2013
Israel's attacks against Syria
3 May 2013
Turbulent politics
30 April 2013
Trusting the European Union
26 April 2013
The peace process and sabotage
23 April 2013
Terrorism, Chechens and beyond
19 April 2013
Turkey: the land of fear and suspicion
16 April 2013
The Middle East and terror
12 April 2013
Peace-building as a challenge
9 April 2013
The Egyptian case
5 April 2013
The United States is in a hurry
2 April 2013
Fires in Germany
29 March 2013
The peace process and the details
26 March 2013
Turkey-Israel: a new process
22 March 2013
Intervening in Syria
19 March 2013
Cyprus-Turkey: a new period?
15 March 2013
Dealing with technical issues
12 March 2013
Upcoming elections in Iran
8 March 2013
After Hugo Chavez
5 March 2013
The global dimension of the leak
1 March 2013
The PKK and global balances
26 February 2013
An actor's choice
22 February 2013
New initiatives on Syria
19 February 2013
A challenging process
15 February 2013
Explosion at the border
12 February 2013
Peace negotiations and global circumstances
8 February 2013
Turkey-EU: a new debate
5 February 2013
Attacking the US Embassy
1 February 2013
Africa: the new chessboard
29 January 2013
Discrimination
25 January 2013
David Cameron and the EU
22 January 2013
Two journalists
18 January 2013
Attacking a university
15 January 2013
France-Turkey: new problems?
11 January 2013
Negotiating with terrorists
4 January 2013
‘We are so different that nobody understands us'
1 January 2013
Turkey-EU: A proposal from Britain?
28 December 2012
The need for transparency
25 December 2012
Student movements
21 December 2012
Risk assessment
18 December 2012
The EU’s Irish presidency
14 December 2012
A new look at Greece
11 December 2012
A new law for universities
7 December 2012
A real risk for Turkey
4 December 2012
Turkey-France: A new period?
30 November 2012
Israel-Turkey: New communication channels
27 November 2012
The Patriot issue
23 November 2012
US and Russia should open a new page
20 November 2012
Israel, Gaza and beyond
16 November 2012
US’s Israel test
13 November 2012
Reforming the United Nations
9 November 2012
US presidential election
6 November 2012
The other aspect of US elections
2 November 2012
The Middle East and nuclear proliferation
30 October 2012
Celebrating the republic
23 October 2012
Dialogue with terrorists
21 October 2012
From crisis to cooperation
16 October 2012
Brainstorming about the Middle East and Nobel
12 October 2012
A festival in Houston
9 October 2012
Terror and Europe
5 October 2012
The prime minister’s speech
2 October 2012
Palestine’s future
28 September 2012
Another way to negotiate?
25 September 2012
Discussing Muslims
21 September 2012
The Middle East quartet
18 September 2012
A movie and a trap
14 September 2012
Time to resuscitate the EU process?
11 September 2012
The presidential race in the US
7 September 2012
War scenarios between Iran and Israel
4 September 2012
Reforming education
31 August 2012
Turkey’s Syria problem
28 August 2012
Forgetting about the EU and beyond
24 August 2012
The global rivalry enters a new phase
21 August 2012
PKK’s strategy based on hatred
17 August 2012
The Syrian civil war
14 August 2012
Kidnapping a deputy
10 August 2012
Iran and Turkey’s role in Syria
7 August 2012
More deaths, alas
3 August 2012
The foreign minister’s visit to Arbil
31 July 2012
Two pieces of news, one option
27 July 2012
Domestic and international politics
24 July 2012
Can Israel intervene in Syria?
20 July 2012
Bloody Wednesday and Syria
17 July 2012
Democracy, constitution and beyond
13 July 2012
Amnesty International’s report on China
10 July 2012
Visiting the patriarchate
6 July 2012
People, governments and Turkey
3 July 2012
The Erdoğan-Zana meeting
29 June 2012
Russia’s weight in the Syrian problem
26 June 2012
Change in eastern Mediterranean balances
22 June 2012
Those who try to bring the past back
19 June 2012
Maliki, Talabani and new problems
15 June 2012
A methodological problem with coup trials
12 June 2012
The new period in France
8 June 2012
The government-opposition summit
5 June 2012
Is there a risk of ‘going back’?
1 June 2012
The richness of plurality, impossibility of uniformity
29 May 2012
Individuals as pillars of democracy
...