Flow of history and the new Middle Eastern order
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
21 May 2013 Tuesday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 13 September 2011, Tuesday 0 0 0 0
BÜLENT KENEŞ
b.kenes@todayszaman.com

Flow of history and the new Middle Eastern order

It appears that the year 2011 will be etched into world history as a watershed of equal or even greater importance than the years 1979 and 1989. Recalling the developments that occurred in and around 1979, when the strategic conditions of the bipolar Cold War era were at their peak, I can safely assert that the Middle East, as the arena for the rough and tumble between the Western and Eastern blocs, suffered from serious chaos and confusion at that time.

In 1977, Pakistan saw a coup that reinforced the pro-American group in this strategic country. The US managed to pull Pakistan to its own side with no strings attached, but in 1979, it suffered from an unexpected defeat in Iran, where the people led by Grand Ayatollah Khomeini overthrew the pro-Israeli and pro-American shah's regime and established a theocratic revolutionary regime hostile to these countries.

While the initial repercussions of the Iranian revolution were being felt, Iran's new enemy Israel and former Soviet ally Egypt on March 26, 1979 signed, with the US as facilitator, the Camp David agreement, which came to be seen as one of the most important pillars of the new order in the Middle East. The Soviets' response to this move was harsh, as they invaded Afghanistan, a country located on the eastern end of the Middle East that has long borders with Iran and Pakistan, in December.

As an effective response to revolution-exporting Iran and the Soviet expansion, the US gave the green light for a military coup in Turkey on Sept. 12, 1980, just as it had three years before in Pakistan. In other words, as a measure for protecting Western interests from Communists and Islamists, the democratically elected governments in Pakistan and Turkey were overthrown and these countries were left to the mercy of unlawful coup generals. This order continued for a long time with small cosmetic changes.

Many countries and regions quickly adapted to the world order established after the tearing down of the Berlin Wall in 1989 and the collapse of the Communist bloc, but the Middle East was isolated from these winds of democratic change. The distorted regional order created in the antidemocratic conditions of the Cold War era remained untouched in the Middle East while the rest of the world was trying to replace the Cold War era system with organizations required by the new world order starting in 1989.

The West was trumpeting democratic values and liberalism based on a free-market economy all across the globe, but it was quite happy with the lack of fundamental rights and freedoms in the Middle East. Western powers even stood against all popular democratic moves in the region, fearing that a transition to democracy would inevitably unfetter religious people. The incidents of 1990 in Algeria and Tunisia and what happened in Turkey in 1997 strongly support our case. The hegemons of the unipolar new world order played a critical role in maintaining the Cold War order in the Middle East, while the rest of the world enjoyed the liberating climate of the post-Cold War era.

Starting in 2002, Turkey struggled to get rid of the straitjacket that was forced on it during the Cold War era and reinforced with the postmodern coup of Feb. 28, while, in the current year, the people of the Middle East and North Africa revolted, demanding democracy and freedoms, extending their struggle across a vast stretch of land and destroying the despotic regimes in the region one-by-one.

Clearly, it is the Cold War order that is being annihilated alongside these despotic regimes. An archaic order that has been kept alive just to ensure the security of Israel and offer immunity to its illegitimate occupations and deeds is now collapsing with great noise. It is not just the Zine al-Abidine Ben Ali, Hosni Mubarak, Muammar Gaddafi and Bashar al-Assad regimes that are falling. It is the entire Western-made Middle Eastern order that is tumbling down. The Camp David order that only sought to reinforce the security of Israel at all costs is waning.

Clearly, those who are concerned about this collapse can do little about it. If you do not have a realistic plan for completely eliminating the peoples of Tunisia, Egypt, Libya, Syria, Palestine and many more countries, you have every reason to wait for these peoples' demands for democracy and freedom to establish their own orders in their respective countries before erecting the pillars of the new regional order in the Middle East. It is for this reason that the truly wise regimes should act according to the Zeitgeist, or the spirit of the times, and refrain from resisting this tremendous change and the flow of history.

Neither Assad nor any other dictator will be able to hold on much longer in the face of this great trend of change that recently ousted Mubarak, Gaddafi, and Ben Ali. Israel will also be swept up in these winds of transformation if it fails to fathom the process reshaping the Arab World and keeps its anachronistic stance. What Israel should do in the face of this historic turning point is to not stand as an obstacle to the fulfillment of regional peoples' demands and expectations concerning democracy and freedoms.

Given the traditional Jewish brilliance and widely acclaimed Israeli strategic genius, one expects Israel to make its national interests compatible with the expectations of peoples in the region. Otherwise, it will become a greater challenge for the Tel Aviv administration to find support in averting tensions similar to the one recently experienced at its embassy building in Cairo. Zeitgeist and the flow of history will have no mercy to spare on those who try to swim upstream. If they stubbornly go against this flow, they may triumph in fleeting victories in the short run, but they will be violently driven toward catastrophic and greater defeats.

In this perspective, Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan's historic visits to Egypt, Tunisia, and Libya, are regarded as an important step suited to the spirit of the times and the flow of history. The formation of a new order in the Middle East replacing illegitimate dictators with popular democracies is imminent and Erdoğan's tour should be seen as a bold step by a leader who has internalized this reality. We are going through a period of transition during which those who make their plans fully aware of the current situation in a Middle East constantly being shaped by new developments will win and those who persistently turn a blind eye and deaf ear to them will lose.

Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
19 May 2013
We make peace with ourselves as we integrate with the world
14 May 2013
Mr. Erdoğan goes to Washington
12 May 2013
Do we know this language? To what extent?
9 May 2013
Religious and sectarian wars in the Middle East
7 May 2013
5 years ago, 40 years after
30 April 2013
Concrete civilization
25 April 2013
The way to cope with radicalism, extremism
23 April 2013
Can Turkey overcome its bad luck in EU membership process?
21 April 2013
Fear of radicalism in Syria: the self-fulfilling prophecy
18 April 2013
Why is the GYV statement on press freedom significant?
16 April 2013
Role of NGOs in democratization, demilitarization, conflict resolution (2)
14 April 2013
Role of NGOs in democratization, demilitarization, conflict resolution (1)
11 April 2013
Turkey and Azerbaijan on converging paths
2 April 2013
Choreography of the settlement process
28 March 2013
Germany running the neo-Nazi and racist gauntlet
26 March 2013
The New Middle East
21 March 2013
Glad tidings for a colorful spring, and concerns
19 March 2013
Borders and limits
14 March 2013
The effect of ‘soft power' on Turkey's rapid development
10 March 2013
There is no Kurdish issue in Turkey!
7 March 2013
What's the situation in the talks with the PKK?
5 March 2013
Öcalan invests in the post-İmralı era
22 January 2013
What does the aborted attack against the İzmit church tell us?
20 January 2013
İshak Alaton's letter to TÜSİAD
17 January 2013
Theses on PKK members assassinated in Paris
15 January 2013
World's most famous Turkish brand: Today's Zaman
10 January 2013
Risks facing İmralı process
8 January 2013
But which PKK?
6 January 2013
Hope and caution necessary in talks with PKK
3 January 2013
Not funny in the least!
1 January 2013
Demirel, psychological warfare and media
30 December 2012
Assessment of a year
27 December 2012
Cyprus under siege: analysis
25 December 2012
Cyprus under siege: predictions
23 December 2012
Cyprus under siege: observations
20 December 2012
Yearning for unchecked and unbalanced power
16 December 2012
Ergenekon alive and operational
11 December 2012
Is Turkey's EU membership declining in importance?
9 December 2012
Alienation of Turkey's Kurds
6 December 2012
Egypt, Morsi and democracy
2 December 2012
The coup commission's praiseworthy performance
29 November 2012
'Not enough, but yes' to elimination of school uniforms
27 November 2012
History, art and power
22 November 2012
The other side of the coin: Hamas
20 November 2012
Israeli aggression and 'new circumstances in the Mideast'
18 November 2012
Israel's right to kill!
15 November 2012
Israel's right to self-defense!
13 November 2012
A massacre that is becoming ordinary in the insensitive eyes of the world
11 November 2012
Turkey's place: the East or the West?
8 November 2012
‘Can Turkey shoulder the responsibility of being a model country?'
6 November 2012
The choice of the US people and the world
4 November 2012
Rising Anatolia
30 October 2012
Through patience, it seems, our republic is evolving into a democracy
11 October 2012
Why are we angry at our EU snapshot?
9 October 2012
Civilian supervision of military a must, but how to do it?
4 October 2012
We must stop seeing Azerbaijan purely as a source of oil and natural gas
2 October 2012
Has Turkey already abandoned its EU vision?
30 September 2012
AKP congress and R2P from Davutoğlu's perspective
27 September 2012
Who is the real hero that stopped the Balyoz coup?
25 September 2012
Quo vadis Turkey?
23 September 2012
Balyoz verdict and the future of coup culture
20 September 2012
Democracy, tolerance and forbearance
18 September 2012
The prep courses debate and Erdoğan's real intentions
16 September 2012
Muhammad, Jesus and Moses are our revered values
13 September 2012
Is it freedom of expression or a hate crime?
6 September 2012
I have good news for newspapers!
4 September 2012
Speaking out in hard times
30 August 2012
Media's 'Kony's and child abuse
28 August 2012
Can Morsi's historic Iran visit be seen as a sign of a shift of axis?
9 August 2012
Cold War with Iran
5 August 2012
Has the coup threat been averted yet?
2 August 2012
Ibn Khaldun’s lessons on politics for leaders
31 July 2012
Nizam al-Mülk’s advice for today’s leaders
29 July 2012
Afghanistanization risk in Syria
26 July 2012
Islam, Islamic and Islamism
24 July 2012
Arakan: a big massacre witnessed by the insensitive world
22 July 2012
When will Ankara change its thesis about the downed F-4?
19 July 2012
‘Assad struck at the heart’
15 July 2012
Rule of the executive
12 July 2012
All Muslims, like Turks, don’t see contradiction between democracy and Islam
10 July 2012
Turks prioritize economy or democracy?
5 July 2012
Is Iran's nuclear program peaceful?
1 July 2012
Clutching at straws with Syria
28 June 2012
One correct and one wrong move
24 June 2012
Turkish-Syrian tension and Abant platform
21 June 2012
Kurds’ PKK issue
19 June 2012
The PKK issue must be settled once and for all
17 June 2012
Syrian deadlock’s blow to Egypt
14 June 2012
A rift between the Hizmet movement and the AKP?
12 June 2012
First year of AKP’s third term
5 June 2012
Focus is on serving humanity, not only promoting Turkish
3 June 2012
Those who are not part of the solution to the Syrian crisis are part of the problem
31 May 2012
PM gives glad tidings to subversive generals!
29 May 2012
Red suitcase, honorable commander(s) and others
27 May 2012
What befell Niyazi-i Misri in the past is happening to Fethullah Gülen now
22 May 2012
The role of civil society in Turkey's democratization
20 May 2012
If democracy had ever come, it wouldn't have gone away!
15 May 2012
How has resource-low South Korea ended up the world’s 13th-largest economy?
13 May 2012
Yes to presidential system if...
10 May 2012
Erdoğan, military coups and public opinion
...