Turkey’s rise to the occasion
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
21 May 2013 Tuesday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 26 February 2011, Saturday 0 0 0 0
ABDULLAH BOZKURT
a.bozkurt@todayszaman.com

Turkey’s rise to the occasion

I do not believe you can successfully use the Turkish template or replicate the Anatolian model in Middle Eastern and North African countries, where anti-government protests are spreading rapidly and taking down authoritarian leaders who have failed to live up to the expectations of their people.

There is simply a wide array of differences among Turkey and these countries, ranging from economy, social class, culture and history. Even when Turks ruled many of these countries for centuries during the reign of the vast Ottoman Empire, they did not disrupt the local characteristics of these nations, leaving them to enjoy great autonomy and independence from any interference. If the Ottomans had done what colonial powers like the French and British did in these countries, we would hear many of them speaking Turkish today instead of French and English.

That being said, Turkey can certainly be an inspiration for a lot of people in these countries and can rise to the occasion to help these troubled regimes make the transition as smoothly as possible. The men and women on the Arab streets look to Turkey and feel close affection for what Turkey represents today. The increasing popularity of Turkish soap operas across the region is a testament to that fact. If the new and existing regimes in the region are in a desperate search for a boost to their legitimacies, Turkey could assist them in building a platform for channeling the aspirations and expectations of people to reflect better governance and transparency.

There is no doubt that any change must come from within and a strong sense of local ownership is needed to sustain the democratic change in these countries. Besides, Turkey has a lot of shortcomings of its own and needs to pursue a vigorous reform agenda to better align itself with democratic ideals, fundamental rights and the rule of law. Nevertheless it has come so far with many bitter experiences in the troubled past and learned a lot about how to play out the reforms without disturbing the fundamentals of the state and always averting the risk of a “failed state” syndrome.

Over time, a strong middle class has flourished in Turkey, helping remove huge income disparities between the rich and poor. A relatively competitive educational system has given hope to citizens of the lower and middle classes, creating access opportunities for their children. Although thwarted by military interruptions and stymied by chronic problems in the functioning of democratic institutions in the past, the country has been able to stand on its own two feet, always taking two steps forward when it was forced to take one back. In the last decade, the stability and huge reform drive, aided by the EU process, helped the country secure a place in the prestigious G20 major economies club and increased its clout in the region and the world.

Consequently, there are a lot of best practices Turkey can enthusiastically share with countries in the Middle East and North Africa using a “soft power” position that is more convincing than many others. The people in the region by and large welcome Turkish suggestions and do not have deep-rooted reservations and doubts about Turkey’s motives. One of our reporters accompanying Turkish Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoğlu during a trip to Tunisia last week told me how the Jasmine revolutionaries in Kasbah Square were cheering twice as loud for Turkish reporters.

He also recalled the sharp contrast in terms of the security outlook between the French Embassy and Turkish Embassy in Tunisia, saying the former was heavily fortified with barbed wire and sandbags while the latter was pretty much open to the public. “Out of respect for Turkey, Tunisians were saluting the Turkish Embassy when they passed by the embassy building,” he said. The same stories can be found in many other trouble spots in the region. During the mass evacuations from Libya for example, both the government forces and rebels were extending protection to Turkish expats. In the Darfur region of Sudan where I visited with State Minister Faruk Çelik last month, I heard stories that most people were seeking treatment at Turkish-run medical centers because they did not trust to the ones run by Westerners. The rumors, albeit unsubstantiated, of medical experiments by doctors from the West were widespread among the Sudanese there, making the jobs of the aid workers from Western countries more difficult.

If you are looking a niche for a competitive edge in the markets of these countries, Turkey certainly has one than can be employed with ease. There is strong backing for such initiatives from the Turkish public as they can closely relate to the difficulties encountered by people in the Arab world. Surely Turkey cannot remain indifferent to developments in the region, but it should play its cards very carefully and patiently to avoid the very risk that it may blow back in the face of Turks if pressed too hard. The transition in the troubled countries will take a longer time than many anticipate and, as such, Turks should be patient and keep a low profile, letting the locals lead and avoiding pitfalls along the way.

Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
20 May 2013
Iran exploiting Shiites and destroying Iraq
17 May 2013
EU's stake in Turkey's judicial council
13 May 2013
What to expect from Obama-Erdoğan meeting
10 May 2013
How Turkey's deputy PM saved the Israeli-Turkish deal
6 May 2013
ECtHR, freedom of assembly and May Day in Turkey
3 May 2013
Get out of jail free card for bid-rigging in Turkey
29 April 2013
PKK's venomous mouthpiece targets US, Gülen
26 April 2013
Iran's clandestine operations in Turkey
22 April 2013
Turkey deserves 2020 Olympics Games
19 April 2013
Concerns over Turkey's new petroleum law
15 April 2013
French socialist's unfair report on Turkey
12 April 2013
Turkey should tread carefully on Palestine issue
8 April 2013
US-Russian deal to impact Turkey's role in Central Asia
5 April 2013
Legal woes for Turkish energy firms in Iraq
1 April 2013
Turkish railways and EU
29 March 2013
Turkey, Cyprus and ENI fallout
25 March 2013
Apology and Middle East politics
22 March 2013
Terrorism toll on Turkey
18 March 2013
Turkey, world trade and top WTO post
15 March 2013
UNHCR's Guterres on the Syrian refugee crisis
11 March 2013
Why Sweden is going strategic with Turkey
8 March 2013
Competition as Turkey goes nuclear
4 March 2013
Zionism debated by Turkey, US and Israel
1 March 2013
Energy plays in Turkey's ties with US and Iraq
25 February 2013
Why is Jordan special for Turkey?
22 February 2013
Iran plays al-Qaeda figure to pit Turkey against US
18 February 2013
Violence and freedom of expression in Turkey
15 February 2013
France courts better ties with Turkey
11 February 2013
US Ambassador Ricciardone's blunder
8 February 2013
Why is Turkey sending its navy to Somalia?
4 February 2013
US response to embassy attack
1 February 2013
Engaging in Africa without challenging others
21 January 2013
Steps to align Turkey with ECtHR
18 January 2013
Whistleblower reveals foreign policy blunders in Turkey
14 January 2013
Turkey and hydrocarbons in Iraq
11 January 2013
The PKK bookkeeper and cover-up
7 January 2013
Turkey's security deals with partner nations
4 January 2013
DPG's challenge to secret US-Iran talks on Afghanistan
31 December 2012
US secret talks with Iran over Afghanistan
28 December 2012
New tool to promote trade
24 December 2012
Sudan and South Sudan: indispensable partners for Turkey
21 December 2012
Failure of new constitution in Turkey
17 December 2012
Turkey tightens vise on tax havens
14 December 2012
Turkey to help secure Af-Pak border
10 December 2012
Turkey, Hungary should do more
7 December 2012
Last act for Assad
3 December 2012
Turkey's golden story with Iran
30 November 2012
Connecting Turks and Emiratis
26 November 2012
Israel's legal woes in Palestine
23 November 2012
Turkey's new plan on Cyprus property disputes
19 November 2012
Turkey should arm the opposition in Syria
16 November 2012
Turkey's high hopes for Africa
12 November 2012
Turkey, Brunei offer promising partnership
9 November 2012
Turkey slacking on combating terrorism financing
5 November 2012
Fouling up press freedom in Turkey
2 November 2012
Rapprochement with Israel unlikely
29 October 2012
Phone call that disrupted Turkey's ties with Iraq
22 October 2012
Future of Afghanistan and Turkey's role
18 October 2012
De-coupling fears for Turkey-Russia ties over Syria
15 October 2012
Iran to turn ECO into paper organization
12 October 2012
The pro-war lobby rallies in Turkey
8 October 2012
EU ‘regress report' 2012
5 October 2012
New mandate needed for diplomats, not military
1 October 2012
Elections and a swelling budget in Turkey
28 September 2012
Convention speech and Erdoğan's dream
24 September 2012
Iran prime culprit for slashed hajj quotas
21 September 2012
Role of Iran and Syria in THKP/C terrorism against Turkey
17 September 2012
Early warning for Muslim bashing
14 September 2012
Campaign to repatriate stolen Turkish artifacts
9 September 2012
Iran's terror and trade war against Turkey
7 September 2012
Turkey hails Egypt's comeback
3 September 2012
Turkey's management of Syrian refugee crisis
31 August 2012
Germany playing dangerous game with Muslims
27 August 2012
Turkey's Myanmar policy
24 August 2012
Prosecuting Syrians in Turkish courts
17 August 2012
Wait on Syria, push for Kandil
13 August 2012
New page in Syria
10 August 2012
Countering Iran's threat
6 August 2012
Iran Spring and Turkey
3 August 2012
Turkey to shape Syrian army in post-Assad era
30 July 2012
The new CHP vigor for Turkish politics
27 July 2012
Turkey's play with Syrian Kurds
6 July 2012
Scorecard for Turkey's AK Party since election victory
2 July 2012
Turkey and Arab anxiety
29 June 2012
Iran, Syria to target Turkish troops in Lebanon
25 June 2012
Is Turkey itching for war with Syria?
22 June 2012
Sledgehammer case and ECtHR
18 June 2012
EU presidency of Greek Cyprus: Coming of age or falling from grace
15 June 2012
Neutered Ombudsman Law
11 June 2012
Profiling Erdoğan through the eyes of a confidant
8 June 2012
Whistleblowers and secret recordings in Turkey
4 June 2012
Cost of Syrian crisis to Turkish economy
1 June 2012
THY and union zealots
28 May 2012
The legacy of the Mexican presidency of the G-20
25 May 2012
Turkey and Mexico: Distant yet so close
21 May 2012
İşbank and the CHP
18 May 2012
Erbakan's legacy and gas deal with Iran
14 May 2012
EU-Turkey fundamentals: How strong are they?
11 May 2012
Germany must come clean on neo-Nazi murders
7 May 2012
Davutoğlu's record on parliamentary queries
...
Bloggers