Armenian Relocation and Turkish forgetfulness
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
19 May 2013 Sunday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 27 April 2010, Tuesday 0 0 0 0
HASAN KANBOLAT
h.kanbolat@todayszaman.com

Armenian Relocation and Turkish forgetfulness

On April 24 more than 100 people marked the 95th anniversary of the forced migration of Armenians by sitting around a poster that read “This pain is our pain, this sorrow is all of ours,” in İstanbul upon the appeal of 67 intellectuals.
This incident was presented to the world as a first in Turkey. However, this isn’t the first time this kind of event has occurred in Turkey. Just last year on April 24, the Human Rights Association (İHD) was recognized for an activity organized by its İstanbul branch titled “Armenian intellectuals and April 24, 1915: They were arrested, exiled and left without tombstones.”

For years, the only topic on Turkey’s agenda in April has been the Armenian relocation. People are split into those who defend the Armenians and those who oppose them, those who accept it and those who deny it. Is it right to have to choose a side?

Why are the defenders and resisters of the Armenian tragedy forgetting the tragedy of people who comprise nearly 50 percent of the population in Turkey today and who were forced to emigrate to Anatolia during the course of the last 150 years? Aren’t non-Christians allowed to have tragedies? Of course Turkish intellectuals need to be concerned about the pains of their neighbors, but they also need to be concerned with the tragedy that exists within their own country.

Armenians were relocated; they were not deported. That is because they were displaced within the Ottoman territories out of necessity. Due to the conditions of World War I, they were forced to move from Anatolia to the Middle East. They were not deported. However, Turkish and Muslim migrants were deported. So Armenians cannot be said to have been deported.

On Aug. 7, 1982, two terrorists from the Armenian Secret Army for the Liberation of Armenia (ASALA) carried out an attack at Esenboğa Airport. The attack led to the deaths of two security officers and six passengers, two of whom were foreigners, and an additional 72 people were wounded. The Esenboğa attack was the first act by ASALA in Turkey. Attacks carried out by Armenian terrorists against Turkish diplomats started in 1973. During the period between 1973 and 1994, the bodies of Turkish diplomats arrived in coffins covered with Turkish flags from 13 countries and 17 cities (Rome, Marseilles, Lisbon, Burgas, Belgrade, Brussels, Athens, Lyon, Paris, Sydney, Copenhagen, Geneva, Los Angeles, Ottawa, Boston, Vienna and Tehran.) What did we do to commemorate the memory of the martyrs killed by Armenian terrorists at Esenboğa Airport on Aug. 7, 1982? Nothing. There is not even a plaque anywhere in the airport to remember those who were killed. We have not dedicated a corner to them. We have not placed a photo of them anywhere in the airport. Not even a small statute has been erected. No sirens have ever been sounded on Aug. 7 to mark a moment of silence in their memory.

There were continuous forced migrations from Crimea, the Balkans and the North and South Caucasus to Anatolian territories after the annexation of Crimea in 1783, the Caucasus-Russian War in 1864, the 93 War (1877-1878), the Balkan War (1912-13), World War I (1914-18) and during the republican era. These forced migrations shaped Turkey’s demographics, economy, history and cultural formation. Turkish society -- which is unaware of the events of 1783, 1864, the 93 War and 1913 -- knows those of 1915 because of the Armenian genocide claims.

More than half the people of the Turkish Republic are the children and grandchildren of people who were subjected to ethnic cleansing, genocide and deportation.

Nations and groups that were subjected to such merciless campaigns and subsequently had to migrate to Turkey in the last 150 years include Adiges, Wubihs, Karaçay-Balkars and Kosaks; Abkhazs from the northwest Caucasus; Chechens, Dagestanis and Ossetians from the northeast Caucasus; Karabakhs, Azeris, Ahıskans, Terekemes, Kalpaks, Acaras and Georgians from the South Caucasus; Crimean Tatars, Ukrainians and Belarusians from north of the Black Sea; Balkan Turks, Albanians, Bosnians, Pomaks, Ulahs, Torbeşs and Macedonians from the Balkans; Arabs and Jews from Spain; Turks from Crete, Rhodes and other Aegean islands; Cypriot Turks from Cyprus; Turks, Palestinians and Kurds from the Middle East; Uzbeks, Kyrgyz, Kazakhs and Tajiks from Central Asia; and Uighurs from the Far East.

In fact, Anatolia has become the home of those migrants subjected to injustice and deportation in their native lands.

So why does Turkey fail to address these facts?

Why does it fail to erect a monument in remembrance of those who were murdered in these vicious events? Why does it not make any attempt to do this?

Even if the public’s memory is poor, the state and intellectuals need to have a much sharper memory. Intellectuals, whether they accept or refuse to apologize to the Armenians, should be aware of the pains their ancestors suffered.

Armenians are close neighbors of Turkey. They are like part of a family that has been divided due to disagreements. For this reason, the acts of terrorist organizations and radicals cannot be attributed to the Armenian people. However, we should remember that not only Armenians but also Turks have suffered in the last century.

Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
13 May 2013
Understanding Reyhanlı via my family
6 May 2013
Afghanization of Syria; Pakistanization of the ME, Central Asia and EU
29 April 2013
Putin's Kyrgyzstan visits
22 April 2013
Will the US give Central Asia to Russia as a gift?
15 April 2013
Impressions from Washington, D.C.
8 April 2013
PM Erdoğan to head off to Kyrgyzstan, Mongolia
1 April 2013
Spring festivals
25 March 2013
What will happen in Uzbekistan?
18 March 2013
The new pope and the alliance of civilizations
11 March 2013
Encouraging the growth and development of Turkish think tanks
4 March 2013
After Barzani's visit to Moscow
25 February 2013
Alliance of Civilizations in Vienna
18 February 2013
Prime Minister Erdoğan and Turkish think tanks
11 February 2013
Muslim Brotherhood back in Iraq
4 February 2013
DHKP/C in a pot of honey
28 January 2013
Israel
21 January 2013
A presidential era of music
14 January 2013
Turkey's African initiative
7 January 2013
Moscow-backed Iranian plan announced in Damascus
31 December 2012
What can we expect to happen in Turkey and its environs in 2013?
24 December 2012
Post-Jalal Talabani era
17 December 2012
Attempts by Syrian Turkmens to unite and organize
10 December 2012
Underrated visit to Ankara by Turkmen of Arbil
3 December 2012
The ÜDİK dimension of Turkish-Russian relations
26 November 2012
Barzani to Moscow, Putin to Ankara
19 November 2012
Syrian Circassians have begun to arrive in Turkey
12 November 2012
Moldova’s Gagauz people and identity issues
5 November 2012
Positive steps in Turkish-Moldovan relations
29 October 2012
Mavi Marmara trial to begin on Nov. 6
22 October 2012
Turkey’s revised Syria policy
15 October 2012
War lobbies
8 October 2012
Turkey and Syria: Is war necessary?
1 October 2012
Yannis’s Mytilene
25 September 2012
Putin’s visit to Bishkek: Central Asia, the US, China and Turkey
17 September 2012
Future concerns of the Iraqi Turkmen people
10 September 2012
Observations on Syria from Hatay’s Vakıflı village
3 September 2012
Reflections and perceptions of Russia and Russians in Turkish
27 August 2012
Why little girls don’t collect napkins anymore
13 August 2012
Observations on Syria from Hatay-Samandağı
6 August 2012
Spending time with the Free Syrian Army in Hatay’s Reyhanlı district
30 July 2012
Observations on Syria at Cilvegözü border gate
24 July 2012
The way foreignness is perceived in Turkish
23 July 2012
Uneventful days on Reyhanlı-Idlib border
22 July 2012
Looking at Syria from Hatay-Reyhanlı
16 July 2012
Prime Minister Erdoğan in Moscow
15 July 2012
Iraqi Circassians
9 July 2012
Looking at the geopolitics of the Black Sea from Trabzon
25 June 2012
BSEC Summit in İstanbul
18 June 2012
Talking with Taqi al-Mawla about relations between Turkey and Iraq
11 June 2012
RISS and Rostov-on-Don
6 June 2012
First open conference in history of MİT
4 June 2012
Kyrgyz prime minister’s delayed visit to Turkey
3 June 2012
Turkey’s Somalia strategy
28 May 2012
Second International Somalia Conference: end of transitional phase
25 May 2012
Are Russian tourists being discouraged from visiting Turkey?
21 May 2012
Growing importance of energy between Ankara and Arbil
16 May 2012
Prime Minister Erdoğan heads for Kazakhstan
14 May 2012
Turks need new strategies
7 May 2012
The results of the Greek and Armenian elections and Turkey
4 May 2012
Looking from Mosul to Turkey
1 May 2012
Al Nujaifi: Turkey is Mosul’s gate to the world
30 April 2012
Investing in Mosul means investing in the future
27 April 2012
Al Nujaifi: Turkey is Mosul's gate to the world
23 April 2012
Syrian Kurds and Turkey
20 April 2012
Syria: Towards a manageable chaos
16 April 2012
The safe zone discussion in the Syrian issue
11 April 2012
Turkey and political transformation in Middle East
9 April 2012
Syrian Kurds
2 April 2012
The future of Syria in the aftermath of Baghdad and İstanbul meetings
26 March 2012
Syrian Circassians
26 March 2012
Syrian Circassians
19 March 2012
Syrian Turkmen
12 March 2012
Analysis of placards at Khojaly commemorations
5 March 2012
Baku’s view of the Middle East and Turkey
2 March 2012
Turkmen president’s visit to Turkey
23 February 2012
Understanding Syria from Syria: Assad has six months left
20 February 2012
We discussed the Middle East at the Valdai forum
13 February 2012
Reasons for Russia’s current Syria policy and the likelihood of change
6 February 2012
Possibility of Israeli attack on Iran on the rise
30 January 2012
Maliki’s new steps that escalate tension
27 January 2012
Turkey and Russia: heading towards strong multi-dimensional and multi-directional cooperation
23 January 2012
Davutoğlu in Moscow: new era in Turkish-Russian relations
20 January 2012
Attack on Turkish embassy in Baghdad: from tension to crisis
17 January 2012
Only a step toward democracy in Kazakhstan
10 January 2012
Saudi Arabia’s new generation visits Ankara
9 January 2012
Kyrgyzstan’s new President Atambayev to visit Ankara
6 January 2012
Behind the scenes of Uludere
2 January 2012
Turkey is being forced into isolation
26 December 2011
Turkish citizenship for Armenian diaspora
28 November 2011
The future of Kazakhstan for Turkey
20 November 2011
Turkmenistan marks 20th anniversary of its independence
14 November 2011
Kyrgyzstan chooses stability: Atambayev elected president
1 November 2011
Scenarios of transition from Turkish republic to Kurdish republic (2)
24 October 2011
Turkey-Azerbaijan High Level Strategic Cooperation Council
21 October 2011
Scenarios of transition from Turkish Republic to Kurdish Republic (1)
17 October 2011
Cooperation Council of Turkic Speaking States summit
10 October 2011
Quiet developments in Turkish-Vietnamese relations
3 October 2011
Economic relations between Turkey and Syria
26 September 2011
Turkish-Ukrainian relations on the 20th anniversary of Ukrainian independence
23 September 2011
Turkey-Uzbekistan relations on the 20th anniversary of Uzbekistan's independence
...