The European Article 301 in the making
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
18 May 2013 Saturday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Diplomacy 07 February 2007, Wednesday 0 0 0 0
SELÇUK GÜLTAŞLI
s.gultasli@todayszaman.com

The European Article 301 in the making

It was almost shocking what Time magazine did this week by publishing a full page ad about "a compelling documentary on the Armenian genocide" combined  with a 98-minute DVD on the "genocide," both paid for by the weekly magazine. The amount is huge when you consider that 550,000 copies are distributed weekly throughout Europe.
The Armenian lobby gleefully declared that the magazine came to this decision as a way apologize for the mistaken distribution of a CD made by the Ankara Chamber of Commerce two years ago that claimed no genocide occurred. As Time has not returned our emails, we only know this due to the statement from the lobby. Since the weekly hasn't denied this, we shall assume it is true.

The timing of the magazine's decision is interesting and wise. There are several initiatives around the world by the Armenian lobby that would be detrimental to Turkey's interests if approved. While the law penalizing the deniers of the Armenian "genocide" is awaiting vote in the French Senate, the US Congress is preparing to vote on a bill that would recognize the tragedy of 1915 as a genocide. Time's "free" support for the Armenian cause, coming in the wake of Hrant Dink's murder, also coincides with the EU term president Germany's initiative to legislate a pan-EU law that will criminalize the deniers of not only genocide, but also war crimes and crimes against humanity.

Germany issued a statement on Jan. 29 outlining its position on the matter. The scope of the draft is non-specific and open to proposals from member countries. Germans have recommitted themselves to revive the negotiations on the framework decision to combat racism and xenophobia that was first proposed two years ago by the Luxembourg presidency. However, because the scope of the draft is so wide, many acts can be criminalized that should be considered under the banner of freedom of speech.

The draft also creates a large vacuum for member countries to get involved. It says: "Pursuant to the draft, member states have the possibility of making criminal liability dependent upon the determination by a national or international court that a concrete historic event constituted genocide, a crime against humanity, or a war crime." Considering the efforts of the Armenian lobby both in France and Belgium to get laws issued to penalize the deniers of the "genocide," Turkey should be worried. Though it is too early to say, it could pave the way for a EU-wide law that would penalize deniers of the Armenian "genocide" and make it equal to the Holocaust. The Armenian lobby has invested a lot in the German proposal and they already declare that in the event of the approval of the German proposal, Turkey would have to change its mind on 1915 if it wants to be a member of the EU.

The European Article 301 is looming on the horizon.

Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
15 July 2009
Baykal knows better than Olli Rehn
1 July 2009
What’s the matter with Rehn?
21 April 2009
Saylan, Aykurt and European Union
13 January 2009
Expect this from the children of the Holocaust
18 November 2008
Vecdi Gönül and the faint-hearted republic
28 February 2007
Has the Bosnia verdict ‘closed a chapter’ in history?
21 February 2007
Babacan and the confusion over the EU
7 February 2007
The European Article 301 in the making
31 January 2007
The old Erdoğan and the new Erdoğan
24 January 2007
301 is an embarrassment
1 January 2007
800,000 Turks become EU citizens
26 December 2006
Europe's Test on Islam
22 December 2006
Christian Democrats Object Report on Women Rights
21 December 2006
Greeks Block Finland, only one Chapter to be Opened
19 December 2006
Backed by France, Greek Cypriots Support Opening one Chapter
19 December 2006
'People Biting Dogs' and our Relationship with Europe
18 December 2006
EU Could Use Armenian Genocide Against Turkey
16 December 2006
EU Agrees to Slow down Enlargement
15 December 2006
EU Leaders Discuss Enlargement
14 December 2006
US Support for Student Exchange Disappoints Greek Cypriots
13 December 2006
[NEWS ANALYSIS]
Another EU Classic for Turkey: Constructivist Ambiguity
13 December 2006
Finland Insists on Opening one more Chapter
12 December 2006
Eight Chapters Frozen in Negotiations, EU Train Still on Track
12 December 2006
The Government did the Right Thing
11 December 2006
EU Seeks Compromise
9 December 2006
Draft Text Fits Commission’s Recommendation
7 December 2006
No Further Deadline Offers
6 December 2006
Battle of Cyprus in San Diego
6 December 2006
Loving Turks and Crises
4 December 2006
Germany-France Insistent on Deadline
30 November 2006
Earlier EU Decision Good for Turkey
30 November 2006
NATO Summit Declares Bigger, Stronger Rapid Reaction Force
30 November 2006
Rehn: No Train Wreck, Pace will Slow
29 November 2006
Anger over Afghanistan at NATO Summit
29 November 2006
Report on Professor Yayla
28 November 2006
[NEWS ANALYSIS]
Rehn has Seen the Cyprus Reality; Hope Other Leaders Do!
28 November 2006
Afghanistan and Security Occupy NATO's Riga Agenda
25 November 2006
Finland to Remove Maras from Cyprus Plan
24 November 2006
Headscarf Ban Causes Discrimination-EP
21 November 2006
EU's Turkey Decision Set for Dec. 11
21 November 2006
British Deputies Launch Campaign Against French Armenian Bill
18 November 2006
EU Leader Calls on Europe to Face its Past Sins
17 November 2006
We Shouldn't Contribute to Rehn's Isolation
15 November 2006
Washington to Austria: Breaking EU Negotiations not an Option
14 November 2006
Austria Asks for Pause in Turkey's EU Negotiations
14 November 2006
Hopes for Finnish Plan Fading
9 November 2006
[NEWS ANALYSIS] -- Crisis Deferred for One Month
9 November 2006
Brussels Insistent on Freedom of Speech, Opening Ports to Cyprus
9 November 2006
EU Progress Report Confirmed by all, Including Greek Cyprus
8 November 2006
Hope of Postponement in Cyprus Deadlock
8 November 2006
Finnish Plan was an Immoral Proposal
2 November 2006
[INTERVIEW]

Fearless, Self-Assertive Armenian Lobby in Europe
by
Selcuk Gultasli

29 October 2006
EU Progress Report Stresses Local Dialogue
28 October 2006
Is Turkey's EU Bid Becoming a Mirage?
21 October 2006
EU Waits for Turkey Progress Report to Take Stance
21 October 2006
US Urges France to Promote Discussion
18 October 2006
OSCE Reacts to France's Armenian Bill
18 October 2006
Pamuk's Task
13 October 2006
EU Screening Process Ends, Crises Loom
13 October 2006
Brussels Concerned; ‘Decision Foolish&un-European’
12 October 2006
In Brussels, Talat Says Finnish Plan 'Dangerous'
11 October 2006
'Genocide' Bars the European Turkish Community
11 October 2006
Paris Hears Warning from EU Commission
10 October 2006
Circassians Ask European Parliament to Hear 'Historic Tragedies'
5 October 2006
Finnish Cyprus Plan too Vague
4 October 2006
The First Year of Negotiations Didn't Give much Hope
3 October 2006
Some Criteria are Better than Others...
29 September 2006
Bendit to Barroso: Cut the Jabber
27 September 2006
[BRUSSELS] European Parliament Report in the ‘Winter Months’
19 September 2006
Hans Blix: US Took No Lessons from Iraq
18 September 2006
All the Pope's Men
16 September 2006
Greek Cypriots Insist They will Veto Turkey
15 September 2006
Pope's Remarks on Islam Anger Muslims
12 September 2006
Turkey Forewarned European Parliament
12 September 2006
While Entering Another Season of Crisis
11 September 2006
'Bush Took Advantage of Terror Attacks at Home and Abroad'
11 September 2006
First Time Headscarf Ban in EU Report
8 August 2006
A Friendly Conversation Between Osman of Mardin and a Belgian Professor
3 August 2006
We are All Lebanese Today
1 August 2006
'A Terrorist Government has Seized Israel'
29 July 2006
EU Support for Turkey Increases in Europe but Decreases in Turkey
27 July 2006
Belgian Jewish Leader: Israel Committing War Crimes
26 July 2006
This Time the EU Astounded (!)
12 July 2006
Turkey has her own ‘Turkish’ Public too
11 July 2006
Financial Aid Bill Approved in ‘Unexpected Meeting’
8 July 2006
Greek Cypriots Uncomfortable with the Turkish Names on the Commission
6 July 2006
Did Anybody Die in Luxembourg that Night?
4 July 2006
EU was Indifferent to our Destruction; it has Moral Responsibilities for Membership
4 July 2006
Finland and Turkey can Resolve Cyprus Problem
28 June 2006
Direct Trade with TRNC is Difficult Matter
27 June 2006
Headscarf and European Union
24 June 2006
Leigh: No EU Member Wants a Cyprus Crisis
22 June 2006
Swift Decision in Semdinli Case Result of New Counter-terrorism Act
17 June 2006
[BRUSSELS] Is Europe Becoming Introverted?
17 June 2006
[NEWS ANALYSIS] -- Crisis Explodes Early
15 June 2006
EU may Toughen Language of Turkish Paragraph at the Summit Conclusions
14 June 2006
'Lest Someone See, Turkey's Accession will Occur at Night'
14 June 2006
Plassnik Creates Tension in EU Meeting
13 June 2006
[NEWS ANALYSIS]

Turkey has just Begun its Long Journey

13 June 2006
Become a Minority and be Saved!
...